United States v. TomesUnited States v. Tomes
- Reporters:
- Before:
- Nalbandian, McKeague, Griffin
OPINION
NALBANDIAN, Circuit Judge. After pleading guilty in 2018 to federal drug and firearms charges, John Tomes Jr. was sentenced to twenty years in prison. Now, just a few years later, he asks for a reduced sentence and immediate release. His vehicle is a motion for compassionate release under
I.
John Tomes Jr. has a colorful criminal past. His most recent run-in with the law landed him in federal prison after he got caught up in a drug distribution and money laundering scheme in Louisville. After a grand jury indicted Tomes on drug, firearm, and money laundering charges, Tomes pled guilty. Following this plea, the district court sentenced Tomes to twenty years in prison. But after serving just a small fraction of his sentence, Tomes moved for compassionate release. He says the presence of COVID-19 in prisons, coupled with his increased susceptibility to serious illness from the virus because of chronic asthma, constitutes an “extraordinary and compelling reason” for release. He also says the law has changed since his sentencing, and he would receive a shorter sentence today than he received a few years ago.
The district court ordered the government to respond to Tomes‘s motion. But “after complete review” of the motion and its accompanying briefing, the court denied the motion. (R. 250, Order at 1, PageID # 1758.) It said that
II.
We review a district court‘s denial of a compassionate release motion for abuse of discretion. United States v. Ruffin, 978 F.3d 1000, 1005 (6th Cir. 2020). A district court‘s consideration of a compassionate release motion embraces three criteria: extraordinary and compelling reasons for release; the
A.
“The passage of the First Step Act in 2018 expanded access to compassionate release by allowing inmates to bring compassionate-release motions on their own behalf.” Elias, 984 F.3d at 518. A district court deciding a defendant‘s motion for compassionate release must do three things before granting the motion. It must determine that “extraordinary and compelling reasons warrant such a reduction.”
At first blush, this framework seems simple enough. But one snag has beleaguered courts since the passage of the First Step Act. Before the Act‘s passage in 2018, only the Director of the Bureau of Prisons could move a district court to modify a defendant‘s sentence. Id. at 1003. Now, though, the Act allows for defendants themselves to do so. Id. at 1003–04. Yet the Act still prompts district courts to consider “applicable policy statements issued by the Sentencing Commission.”
We have grappled with this issue in a series of recent cases. See Ruffin, 978 F.3d at 1006; Jones, 980 F.3d at 1101; Elias, 984 F.3d at 519. And in Elias, we concluded that ”
This all matters here because in denying Tomes‘s motion, the district court believed that “USSG § 1B1.13 limits the ‘extraordinary and compelling reasons’ for compassionate release to” the four categories in the guideline‘s application notes. (R. 250, Order at 1, PageID # 1758.) That is no longer true. We have now held that
That is not to say, however, that the court‘s error requires reversal. We have reversed a district court‘s denial of a defendant‘s compassionate release motion when the court‘s reliance on
But even if a district court wrongly constrains itself to
This all flows from the statutory scheme. Before a district court can grant a defendant‘s motion for compassionate release, it must find that the defendant satisfies all three of
We do so here. The district court denied Tomes‘s motion “after complete review” of the motion and other briefing the court ordered. (R. 250, Order at 1, PageID # 1758.) The court noted that it had “considered each of the
We spot no abuse of discretion in the court‘s doing so. Tomes and his associates dealt in large quantities of various drugs, including methamphetamine, heroin, cocaine, and marijuana. And Tomes did so while armed, despite his status as a felon. Likewise, Tomes laundered tens of thousands of dollars, fruits of his illegal trade. So releasing Tomes after he served just a few years of a twenty-year sentence would not “reflect the seriousness of the offense.”
Tomes‘s arguments to the contrary are unpersuasive. He says he has chronic asthma, which increases his risk of serious illness from COVID-19. But Tomes “did not provide any records in [his] motion to support that [he] has” chronic asthma. Elias, 984 F.3d at 520. All he provided were a couple of letters from his parents. So the “district court could have denied [Tomes‘s] motion for compassionate release on this basis.” Id. Likewise, Tomes‘s contention that the BOP cannot handle COVID-19 outbreaks does not persuade us either. See Elias, 984 F.3d at 521 (“It was not an abuse of discretion for the district court to conclude that speculation that COVID-19 could spread to FPC Alderson was insufficient to justify Elias‘s release.“).
One last point. Tomes says he should receive compassionate release because if he were sentenced today for the same crime, he would not have gotten the sentence he did. The district court noted that
Tomes‘s argument fails. The First Step Act explicitly says that the amendment to which Tomes refers—§ 401—applies “only where ‘a sentence for the offense has not been imposed as of [the] date of [the Act‘s] enactment.” United States v. Wiseman, 932 F.3d 411, 417 (6th Cir. 2019) (quoting First Step Act of 2018, Pub. L. No. 115-391, § 401(c), 132 Stat. 5221). The district court sentenced Tomes on June 7, 2018. The First Step Act‘s effective date is December 21, 2018. Wiseman, 932 F.3d at 417. Tomes‘s sentence had therefore been imposed as of the Act‘s enactment, making § 401 inapplicable. Id.; see also United States v. Richardson, 948 F.3d 733, 748 (6th Cir. 2018) (“Congress has, in essence, drawn a line in the sand. Defendants sentenced after December 21, 2018, may benefit from Congress‘s amendment to § [841(b)(1)(A)], but defendants sentenced before that date cannot.“). And we will not render § 401(c) useless by using
III.
We AFFIRM the district court‘s denial of Tomes‘s motion for compassionate release.