People of Michigan v. Joseph James Chandler
331031
| Mich. Ct. App. | Jul 20, 2017Background
- Joseph Chandler pleaded guilty to manufacture of methamphetamine, maintaining a meth lab, and possession of methamphetamine; sentenced to concurrent terms (two 6–30 year terms and 35 days).
- Offenses occurred April 2012; arraigned July 2014; posted bond and was released.
- Chandler was arrested on unrelated charges in another county on March 23, 2015, remained incarcerated there, and later pleaded guilty in that other case.
- His bond in the present (Cass County) case was revoked on June 9, 2015; sentencing in the Cass County case occurred July 10, 2015.
- Trial court awarded 35 days’ jail credit (3 days from July 11–14, 2014, and 32 days from June 9–July 10, 2015) but denied credit for the March 23–June 9 period because that incarceration was for unrelated charges. Defendant did not object at sentencing.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether defendant was entitled to presentence jail credit for time incarcerated on unrelated charges (Mar 23–Jun 9, 2015) | People: credit limited to time jailed "for the offense of which he is convicted"; unrelated incarceration not creditable | Chandler: sought credit for entire period of pre-sentencing incarceration, including time jailed on unrelated charges | Court held no; credit only for time jailed because of inability to post bond on the convicted offense; unrelated incarceration not creditable |
| Whether trial counsel was ineffective for failing to object to jail-credit calculation | People: counsel not ineffective where objection would be meritless and record shows timely bond revocation | Chandler: counsel should have objected to secure additional jail credit | Court held no ineffective assistance; failure to object would have been meritless and record lacks evidence counsel knew earlier about the other-county incarceration |
Key Cases Cited
- People v Meshell, 265 Mich. App. 616 (court reviews unpreserved sentencing errors for plain error)
- People v Adkins, 433 Mich. 732 (credit only for presentence jail time served because defendant was denied or unable to furnish bond for the offense of conviction)
- People v Givans, 227 Mich. App. 113 (defendant not entitled to credit for incarceration on another offense)
- People v Prieskorn, 424 Mich. 327 (delay in charging does not entitle defendant to credit for unrelated incarceration)
- People v Waclawski, 286 Mich. App. 634 (no credit for time jailed in another state for unrelated offense despite extradition delay)
- People v Rodriguez, 212 Mich. App. 351 (counsel not ineffective for failing to raise meritless objections)
