United States v. ComstockUnited States v. Comstock
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Motz
Reversed and remanded by published opinion. Judge MOTZ wrote the opinion, in which Chief Judge TRAXLER and Judge AGEE joined.
OPINION
DIANA GRIBBON MOTZ, Circuit Judge:
In these consolidated cases, we resolve identical constitutional challenges to the civil commitment provision of the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 (the “Act”) —
Invoking the Act, the United States initiated these cases by asking the district court to order the civil commitment of five individuals — Graydon Comstock, Shane Catron, Thomas Matherly, Marvin Vigil, and Markis Revland. The district court refused to do so, finding the Act unconstitutional because (1) it was “not a proper exercise of any power that Congress might constitutionally exercise” and (2) “commitment pursuant to
The Act authorizes civil commitment only if a court finds by “clear and convincing evidence” that a person “has engaged or attempted to engage in sexual violence or child molestation”
and
is “sexually dangerous to others.”
I.
We begin by outlining the relevant statutory provisions of
A.
The statute challenged here permits the Attorney General, his designee, or the Director of the Bureau of Prisons (“BOP”) to certify a person as “sexually dangerous” and ask a federal district court to order that person’s civil commitment.
Prior to the hearing, the court may order an expert psychiatric or psychological examination of the certified person, with the resulting report filed with the court.
For the court to make such a finding, the Government must prove by “clear and convincing evidence” that the certified person “has engaged or attempted to engage in sexually violent conduct or child molestation”
and
is “sexually dangerous to others.”
In the event the court orders civil commitment, the Attorney General must “make all reasonable efforts” to arrange for a State to assume responsibility for the person’s “custody, care, and treatment.”
As long as the Attorney General holds the person pursuant to a
The Act offers a person committed to a federal facility pursuant to
At a discharge hearing, the committed person must be afforded the same rights to counsel, to present evidence, and to subpoena and cross-examine witnesses as afforded him at the commitment hearing. If the court finds by a “preponderance of the evidence” that a committed person is no longer sexually dangerous to others if released unconditionally or if released under a prescribed regimen of treatment, then the court must order the appropriate discharge.
B.
In the consolidated cases before us, the BOP certified Comstock, Vigil, Matherly, Revland, and Catron (collectively the “respondents”) as “sexually dangerous” persons subject to civil commitment under
Comstock, who pled guilty to one count of receiving material involving sexual exploitation of minors by computer in violation of
The cases of Vigil, Matherly, and Rev-land followed a similar course. Vigil had
Matherly had pled guilty to one count of possession of child pornography in violation of
Revland had pled guilty to one count of possessing child pornography in violation of
Catron’s case differs from the others in some respects. The Government had charged Catron with four counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a minor under the age of twelve and one count of abusive sexual conduct. After some pre-trial proceedings involving expert evaluation and psychological therapy, a district court found that Catron suffered from a mental disease or defect, which rendered him incompetent to stand trial on the criminal charges and unable to be restored to competence in the near future. The Government then certified Catron as suffering from a “mental disease or defect” that qualifies for civil confinement under
Although the district court never formally consolidated the five cases, the parties filed substantially identical pleadings in each case, and the court treated the cases in the same manner. In each case, upon receiving the certificate of sexual dangerousness, the district court promptly entered an order to provide each respondent with several procedural protections.
First, the court found each respondent eligible for appointment of counsel at the Government’s expense under § 4247(d) and directed the Federal Public Defender to provide each with representation. Second, the court determined that each respondent could not afford witness fees and so ordered the clerk to issue subpoenas for any witness necessary for an adequate defense and the marshal to serve these subpoenas and pay the appropriate expenses to the subpoenaed witnesses. Third, in each case, the district court ordered two mental health evaluations — one by an expert designated by the respondent and the other by an expert designated by the Government. Finally, the court set the date for a timely hearing in each case to determine whether the respondent was, as the Government certified, a sexually dangerous person subject to civil confinement.
Prior to the scheduled hearing, each respondent moved to dismiss the Government’s petitions for certification, asserting multiple constitutional challenges to
The district court, however, did invalidate the Act on the basis of respondents’ principal constitutional challenges. Thus, the court held that
II.
Before addressing the merits of respondents’ due process contention, we note at the outset the daunting task they face.
First, they challenge the constitutionality of a federal statute. In considering any constitutional attack on a federal statute, a court presumes that Congress has complied with the Constitution. See, e.g., United States v. Morrison, 529 U.S. 598, 607, 120 S.Ct. 1740, 146 L.Ed.2d 658 (2000). Moreover, this “deference to congressional judgment must be afforded even though the claim is,” as it is here, “that a statute Congress has enacted effects a denial of the procedural due process guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment.” Walters v. Nat’l Ass’n of Radiation Survivors, 473 U.S. 305, 319-20, 105 S.Ct. 3180, 87 L.Ed.2d 220 (1985).
Second, respondents mount only a facial challenge to the Act. Although the district court held the clear and convincing evidence standard unconstitutional on its face, courts generally disfavor such facial challenges. Indeed, in
United States v. Salerno,
the Supreme Court stated that a party asserting a facial challenge to a statute “must establish that no set of circumstances exists under which the Act would be valid.” 481 U.S. 739, 745, 107 S.Ct. 2095, 95 L.Ed.2d 697 (1987). In the years since
Salerno,
some members of the Court have expressed reservations about the applicability of this stringent standard.
See City of Chicago v. Morales,
527 U.S. 41, 55 n. 22, 119 S.Ct. 1849, 144 L.Ed.2d 67 (1999) (Stevens, J., with two Justices concurring);
but see Janklow v. Planned Parenthood, Sioux Falls Clinic,
517 U.S. 1174, 1178-79, 116 S.Ct. 1582, 134 L.Ed.2d 679 (1996) (Scalia, J., dissenting from denial of certiorari with two Justices concurring). But at the very least, a facial challenge cannot succeed if a “statute has a ‘plainly legitimate sweep.’ ”
Crawford v. Marion Cnty. Election Bd.,
553 U.S. 181, 202, 128 S.Ct. 1610, 170 L.Ed.2d 574 (2008) (quoting
With these principles in mind, we consider respondents’ due process challenge.
III.
We begin by returning to the statutory language at issue here. The Act requires the Government to prove by clear and convincing evidence that a person sought to be civilly committed (1) has engaged or attempted to engage in sexually violent conduct or child molestation (the “prior bad act finding”), (2) “suffers from a serious mental illness, abnormality, or disorder,” and (3) “as a result . . . would have serious difficulty refraining from sexually violent conduct or child molestation if released.” § 4247(a)(5)-(6).
More than thirty years ago, the Supreme Court held that a state could civilly commit a person without proving “beyond a reasonable doubt” that he suffered from a mental illness and required hospitalization for the protection of himself and others. See Addington v. Texas, 441 U.S. 418, 427-31, 99 S.Ct. 1804, 60 L.Ed.2d 323 (1979). The Court explained that a state did not have to meet such a “heavy” burden of proof because the reasonable doubt standard “historically has been reserved for criminal cases . . . as a critical part of the moral force of the criminal law, and we should hesitate to apply it too broadly or casually in noncriminal cases.” Id. at 428, 99 S.Ct. 1804 (internal quotation omitted). Instead, Addington expressly held that proof by clear and convincing evidence sufficed to justify civil commitment of mentally ill persons. Id. at 432-33, 99 S.Ct. 1804. The Supreme Court has never retreated from these holdings. See Hendricks, 521 U.S. at 357, 117 S.Ct. 2072.
Respondents concede that
Addington
governs the second and third prerequisites to civil commitment under the Act, and so the Government need only offer clear and convincing evidence to prove them. Respondents insist, however, that to establish the prior bad act finding, the Government must offer proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Because
Respondents rest their argument entirely on In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358, 90 S.Ct. 1068, 25 L.Ed.2d 368 (1970), which the Supreme Court decided nine years before Addington and which neither involved nor discussed civil commitment proceedings. At issue in Winship was a New York statute that defined a juvenile delinquent as a youth who “does any act which, if done by an adult, would constitute a crime.” Id. at 359, 90 S.Ct. 1068. Win-ship addressed whether juveniles in such delinquency hearings, like adults in criminal trials, “are constitutionally entitled to proof beyond a reasonable doubt when they are charged with violation of a criminal law.” Id. at 365, 90 S.Ct. 1068 (emphasis added). The Court concluded that juveniles were so entitled, because “ ‘[a] proceeding where the issue is whether the child will be found to be ‘delinquent’ and subjected to the loss of his liberty for years is comparable in seriousness to a felony prosecution.’ ” Id. at 366, 90 S.Ct. 1068 (quoting In re Gault, 387 U.S. 1, 36, 87 S.Ct. 1428, 18 L.Ed.2d 527 (1967)).
Respondents maintain that
A.
First, contrary to respondents’ contention, neither the Act nor its regulations require a “prior criminal act finding.”
Nothing in the Act requires that the finding of past conduct constitute criminal behavior. By its terms, the Act mandates a finding that a person “has engaged or attempted to engage in sexually violent conduct or child molestation.” The Act does not define the terms “sexually violent conduct” and “child molestation,” which are broad enough to encompass noncriminal conduct such as unlawful, tortious conduct.
The regulations promulgated pursuant to the Act also do not limit “sexually violent conduct” or “child molestation” to criminal activity. They define “sexually violent conduct” to “include[ ] any unlawful conduct of a sexual nature with another person.”
In sum, respondents misread the Act and its regulations; they require a finding of a prior bad act — not a finding of a “prior criminal act.”
B.
Moreover, even if civil commitment did rest in part on the commission of a prior criminal act, respondents’ arguments fail. For Addington establishes that the purpose and structure of the commitment process render it unlike any criminal prosecution. Thus, respondents misunderstand Winship and Addington and ignore the Addington Court’s painstaking explanation of the limited scope and force of its holding in Winship.
Indeed,
Addington
expressly rejected respondents’ view that the “rationale of the
Winship
holding . . . applies with equal force to a civil commitment proceeding.”
Addington,
441 U.S. at 427, 99 S.Ct. 1804. Rather
Addington
held that a civil commitment proceeding, unlike the juvenile delinquency hearings in
Winship,
“can in no sense be equated to a criminal prosecution.”
Id.
at 427-28, 99 S.Ct. 1804.
Addington
characterized Winship’s unusual expansion of the criminal burden of proof
By contrast, in a civil commitment proceeding, “state power is not exercised in a punitive sense.” Id. at 428, 99 S.Ct. 1804. While the stigma inflicted by a finding of juvenile delinquency is “by definition bottomed on a finding that the accused committed a crime,” Winship, 397 U.S. at 374, 90 S.Ct. 1068 (Harlan, J., concurring), civil commitment is not “bottomed” on a finding that a person committed any crime. Accordingly, Addington found that civil commitment simply does not impose either the stigma attendant to criminal culpability or the loss of liberty associated with a criminal sentence, and therefore does not require the criminal law burden of proof.
Addington also forecloses respondents’ contention that the delinquency hearings at issue in Winship implicate “the exact concerns” at issue in civil commitment proceedings. Appellees’ Br. at 58-60. Rather, Addington stressed that civil commitment proceedings involve very different concerns. In a juvenile delinquency hearing (as in an adult criminal trial) the “basic issue” turns on “whether the individual in fact committed a criminal act.” Addington, 441 U.S. at 427-29, 99 S.Ct. 1804. Resolving this single “straightforward factual question” determines whether to confine a juvenile and whether to imprison an adult and so warranted the “heavy” reasonable doubt standard. Id. at 428-29, 99 S.Ct. 1804.
In civil commitment proceedings, “[tjhere may be factual issues to resolve,” but in this context, unlike criminal or delinquency proceedings, these factual issues “represent only the beginning of the inquiry.” Id. at 429, 99 S.Ct. 1804 (emphasis added). A court, in civil commitment proceedings, must go beyond the “beginning of the inquiry” and also determine if a person is “mentally ill,” dangerous, and “in need of confined therapy.” Id. at 429-31, 99 S.Ct. 1804. When making these determinations, which “turn[] on the meaning of the facts which must be interpreted” by experts, Addington held the “strict, criminal standard” of proof “unnecessary.” Id.
Respondents additionally err in contending that
Winship
requires us to overlook
The statute challenged here offers the same sort of professional review and opportunity for correction of an erroneous commitment, similarly reducing the need for the rigorous reasonable doubt standard. For example,
In sum, respondents misread
IV.
Perhaps most surprising, respondents offer no justification for disregarding precedent. The closest they come to doing so is to note that the civil commitment statute challenged in
Addington,
unlike
A.
Thus, in
Kansas v. Hendricks,
the Court flatly rejected the contention that a civil commitment statute “established criminal [rather than civil] proceedings” because it was “predicated upon
past conduct
for which [the petitioner] has already been convicted and forced to serve a prison sentence.” 521 U.S. at 361, 117 S.Ct. 2072 (emphasis added).
Hendricks
concluded that because the challenged statute was civil, not criminal, in nature, it did not violate the double jeopardy and
ex post facto
prohibitions of the Constitution.
Id.
at 369-71, 117 S.Ct. 2072. Of course,
Hendricks
did not directly resolve respondents’ burden of proof claim. But in reaching its holding, the
Hendricks
Court noted that it had “consistently upheld . . . involuntary commitment statutes provided the confinement takes place pursuant to proper procedures and evidentiary standards” — and then cited
Addington. Id.
at 357, 117 S.Ct. 2072.
4
Moreover, the logic
Hendricks
explained that the Kansas civil commitment statute withstood constitutional challenge because, although it required “evidence of past sexually violent behavior,” it did not seek to
“affix culpability
for prior criminal conduct.”
Id.
at 357, 362, 117 S.Ct. 2072 (emphasis added). Rather, the statute simply “used” evidence of prior criminal conduct “solely for evidentiary purposes, either to demonstrate that a ‘mental abnormality’ exists or to support a finding of future dangerousness.”
Id.
at 362, 117 S.Ct. 2072. Exactly the same conclusions must be drawn with respect to the civil commitment scheme at issue here. The Act similarly does not seek to “affix culpability for prior” acts. Instead, it simply “uses” prior acts “solely for evidentiary purposes” to support a finding of a person’s mental abnormality or future dangerousness or both.
Id.; see
Moreover, this very rationale — the basis for Hendricks rejection of the double jeopardy and ex post facto challenges — mirrors the rationale Addington employed in rejecting a challenge to the clear and convincing standard of proof. Addington recognized that civil commitment statutes may require factual findings but held that such findings represent just “the beginning of the inquiry” as evidence of future dangerousness or mental illness and thus need only be proven by clear and convincing evidence. Addington, 441 U.S. at 429, 99 S.Ct. 1804. Hendricks followed that same reasoning, explaining that evidence of a prior criminal act in a civil commitment proceeding may represent an “important indicator of future violent tendencies.” Hendricks, 521 U.S. at 358, 117 S.Ct. 2072 (internal quotation marks omitted). 5
Moreover, while the statute approved in
Hendricks
requires proof of evidence of past criminal activity,
B.
Finally, we note that no Supreme Court precedent lends support to the contrary view.
Rather, in 1993, the Court specifically reiterated that the civil nature of a civil commitment proceeding warrants application of the clear and convincing standard. Heller v. Doe, 509 U.S. 312, 113 S.Ct. 2637, 125 L.Ed.2d 257 (1993). Noting that “[t]he procedures required before the government acts often depend on the nature and extent of the burden or deprivation to be imposed,” the Court looked to the significant differences between Winship and Addington to illustrate this point. Id. at 325, 113 S.Ct. 2637. Because “confinement in prison is punitive and hence more onerous than confinement in a mental hospital,” Winship held that “the Due Process Clause subjects the former to proof beyond a reasonable doubt” while Addington requires “in the latter case only clear and convincing evidence.” Id.
Similarly, in 1986, the Court declined to introduce criminal procedures into a civil commitment proceeding. See Allen v. Illinois, 478 U.S. 364, 106 S.Ct. 2988, 92 L.Ed.2d 296 (1986). Allen found a reduced need for such safeguards when the government treats and incapacitates sexually dangerous persons for nonpunitive purposes. Id. at 372-73, 106 S.Ct. 2988.
Perhaps most striking, in the forty years since it issued
Winship,
the Supreme Court has not once held that the criminal standard of proof applies in
any
civil commitment proceeding — or indeed any kind of civil proceeding — other than juvenile delinquency hearings. Indeed,
Addington
itself noted that the Court has not required use of the criminal law standard even “to protect particularly important individual interests.”
Addington,
441 U.S. at 424, 99 S.Ct. 1804 (citing
Woodby v. INS,
385 U.S. 276, 285, 87 S.Ct. 483, 17 L.Ed.2d 362 (1966) (deportation);
Chaunt v. United States,
364 U.S. 350, 353, 81 S.Ct. 147, 5 L.Ed.2d 120 (1960) (denaturalization);
Schneidemian v. United States,
320 U.S. 118, 125, 63 S.Ct. 1333, 87 L.Ed. 1796 (1943) (same)). In each of these cases, the Court instead applied a variation of the “clear and convincing” standard mandated by
V.
For all of these reasons, we cannot conclude that respondents have met their heavy burden of demonstrating that the “clear and convincing evidence” standard mandated by
REVERSED AND REMANDED
Notes
. In a short footnote in their supplemental brief, respondents urge us to “adopt” the view that
. Two observations further support our conclusion: The Act applies to persons “against whom all criminal charges have been dismissed” for reasons of a mental illness or incompetence to stand trial — persons like respondent Catron.
. At the conclusion of its analysis, the Adding-ton Court considered respondents’ sole remaining argument — that the practice in some states of adopting the criminal law standard in civil commitment proceedings provides “important” support for the view that the Due Process Clause requires this standard. Appellees’ Br. at 65. The Court quickly disposed of this contention, explaining that any pattern among the states of adopting “the criminal law standard gives no assurance that the more stringent standard of proof is needed.” Addington, 441 U.S. at 431, 99 S.Ct. 1804. It concluded that the standard of proof must only “meet the constitutional minimum,” which, of course, the Court held to be the “clear and convincing evidence” standard. Id.
. As a matter of state law, the statute at issue in Hendricks required application of some criminal procedures to the civil commitment proceedings, including proof beyond a reasonable doubt that an individual was a sexually violent predator. Hendricks, 521 U.S. at 352-53, 117 S.Ct. 2072. The Supreme Court, however, did not regard these criminal procedures as important to its decision to uphold the Kansas statute. Rather, as noted above, the Court cited Addington, 441 U.S. at 426-27, 99 S.Ct. 1804, as an example of an “involuntary commitment statute” that contained constitutionally adequate “procedures and evidentiary standards.” Hendricks, 521 U.S. at 357, 117 S.Ct. 2072. Moreover, the Hendricks Court followed this citation by outlining at some length the procedures it did find significant in the Kansas statute, never mentioning any criminal procedures or evidentiary standards. See Hendricks, 521 U.S. at 357-59, 117 S.Ct. 2072. Furthermore, the Court expressly rejected the view that the use of criminal procedures converted a civil proceeding into a criminal prosecution in which the Constitution required heightened criminal law protections. Id. at 362, 364-65, 117 S.Ct. 2072 (citing Allen v. Illinois, 478 U.S. 364, 371-72, 106 S.Ct. 2988, 92 L.Ed.2d 296 (1986)).
. Respondents themselves concede this point — that evidence of a prior bad act serves an evidentiary purpose — but contend that the “uncertainty of the science underlying” the sexual dangerousness finding in
. To be sure,
Addington
observed that “there is a serious question as to whether the state could ever prove beyond a reasonable doubt that an individual is . . . likely to be dangerous.”
Id.
at 429, 99 S.Ct. 1804. The district court attempted to distinguish
Addington
on this ground, reasoning that because the prior bad act finding in