Slip Opinion
D. Conn.2015Background
- Plaintiff Leslie Williams, a Connecticut inmate, sues multiple prison officials in their individual capacities under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and related state claims.
- Allegations center on February 7, 2013, when Williams allegedly sent a drawing and poem to Nurse Beaulieu, which was exposed to Deputy Warden Roche, leading to Williams’ placement in segregation.
- Williams alleges punitive and disciplinary consequences: restrictive housing with alleged unconstitutional conditions, denial of property, hygiene items, telephonic access, and limited out-of-cell activity.
- Defendants Ford, Roche, Green, Beaulieu, Carrara, Bundy, and Faneuff move to dismiss various federal and state claims; several claims were previously dismissed in initial review.
- The court classifies Williams’s sixteen claims into federal constitutional (claims 1–8, 15), state constitutional (9, 10, 16), and state tort claims under the FTCA construed as state torts (11–14).
- The court grants in part and denies in part the Defendants’ motion to dismiss, leaving Claim One (retaliation/procedural due process), Claim Three (unconstitutional conditions of confinement by Williams against Green), and Claim Four (excessive punishment against Ford, Roche, and Green) viable, with other claims dismissed or remanded for state-court handling of state-law issues.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claim One viability (retaliation vs. due process) | Williams argues First Amendment retaliation and/or procedural due process violation. | Defendants argue the speech is not protected or the claim lacks retaliation elements; procedural due process claim doubtful. | Retaliation aspect survives; procedural due process viability depends on protected liberty interest |
| Supervisory liability for Claims Three and Four | Williams contends Ford and Roche are liable as supervisors for constitutional violations. | Supervisor liability requires direct participation or policy, etc.; speculative involvement is insufficient for Claim Three. | Dismiss Claim Three against Ford and Roche; preserve Claim Four against Ford and Roche (and Green as involved). |
| Claim Three – unconstitutional conditions of confinement | Conditions in restrictive housing violated Eighth Amendment and penological standards. | No personal involvement by Ford/Roche; conditions attributable to Green; insufficient supervisory basis. | GRANT as to Ford and Roche; denial as to the supervisor liability theory for Claim Three |
| Claim Thirteen – negligence under 4-165 | Ford negligently failed to conduct required checks. | 4-165 bars personal liability; claims should be against the State, not the individual. | GRANTED; Claim Thirteen dismissed |
| Claim Fourteen – false imprisonment | Conditions of confinement amount to false imprisonment. | Confinement itself is legitimate; only conditions are challenged. | GRANTED; false imprisonment claim dismissed |
| Claims Nine, Ten, Twelve – state-law claims and supplemental jurisdiction | State constitutional rights and retaliation claims warrant relief | No clearly established monetary-damages remedy under these Connecticut provisions; should proceed in state court | GRANTED; decline supplemental jurisdiction over nine, ten, twelve; these may proceed in state court |
Key Cases Cited
- Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (U.S. Supreme Court 2009) (plausibility standard; avoid bare legal conclusions)
- Pell v. Procunier, 417 U.S. 817 (U.S. Supreme Court 1974) (prisoners' free-speech interests; balance with penological interests)
- Turner v. Safley, 482 U.S. 78 (U.S. Supreme Court 1987) (reasonableness standard for restrictions on inmate correspondence and speech)
- Johnson v. Goord, 445 F.3d 532 (2d Cir. 2006) (retaliation and procedural-dair handling in prison context)
- Virginia v. Black, 538 U.S. 343 (U.S. Supreme Court 2003) (true threats not protected speech)
- Davis v. Goord, 320 F.3d 346 (2d Cir. 2003) (First Amendment protections for inmate mail/speech)
- Wilkinson v. Austin, 545 U.S. 209 (U.S. Supreme Court 2005) (liberty interests for prisoners; state-law policy creation can create liberty interests)
- Lopez v. Smiley, 375 F. Supp. 2d 19 (D. Conn. 2005) (private right of action under Connecticut Article First, § Four for declaratory/injunctive relief)
- Binette v. Sabo, 710 A.2d 688 (Conn. 1998) (private right of action for money damages under Article First, § Nine)