midpage
Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.
2017
Read the full case

Background

  • Plaintiff Robert Thousand, a DOCCS inmate, sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 alleging a January 27, 2014 assault by officers Corrigan, Jones, and Segovis, and that officers Carpenter, O'Brien, and Scarlotta failed to intervene; he also alleged due-process defects in a subsequent disciplinary rehearing involving defendants Liberty and Prack.
  • Defendants moved for partial summary judgment seeking dismissal of the failure-to-intervene and due-process claims; Magistrate Judge Baxter recommended granting the motion.
  • Thousand conceded his exhausted grievance named only Corrigan and did not mention bystander officers or a failure-to-intervene theory; disciplinary and Inspector General records likewise focused on Corrigan, Jones, and Segovis.
  • The Court reviewed exhaustion under the PLRA and New York’s three-tier grievance process (IGRC → Superintendent → CORC), and considered Ross v. Blake availability principles.
  • Thousand previously litigated identical due-process arguments in an Article 78 petition that the Appellate Division (Third Dept.) denied, and the Appellate Division addressed and rejected the due-process claims he raises here.
  • The Court adopted the magistrate judge’s report, granted partial summary judgment, and dismissed defendants Carpenter, O’Brien, Scarlotta, Liberty, and Prack from the action (also noting alternative grounds of lack of personal involvement for the bystander officers).

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether Thousand exhausted administrative remedies for failure-to-intervene claims against Carpenter, O'Brien, Scarlotta Thousand claimed his grievance and follow-up interview should have put officials on notice of bystander/failure-to-intervene claims and that other forums (disciplinary hearing, IG) alerted officials Defendants argued the exhausted grievance named only Corrigan, gave no notice of other officers' involvement or failure to intervene, so PLRA exhaustion failed Court: No exhaustion; summary judgment granted for those defendants (grievance did not reasonably apprise officials)
Whether due-process/supervisory claims against Liberty and Prack are precluded by collateral estoppel based on Article 78 decision Thousand argued he preserved his federal due-process claims despite the Article 78 outcome and objected to magistrate’s recommendation Defendants argued Appellate Division already decided identical due-process issues in the Article 78 and thus collateral estoppel applies Court: Collateral estoppel applies; Appellate Division actually decided the same issues; summary judgment for Liberty and Prack
Alternative: whether bystander officers were personally involved Thousand implied responsibility of those officers Defendants argued evidence shows Carpenter and Scarlotta were elsewhere and O’Brien could not have intervened Court: On alternative grounds, no personal involvement — summary judgment appropriate

Key Cases Cited

  • Jones v. Bock, 549 U.S. 199 (claims exhaustion is affirmative defense and defendants bear burden)
  • Woodford v. Ngo, 548 U.S. 81 (proper exhaustion requires compliance with procedural rules)
  • Porter v. Nussle, 534 U.S. 516 (PLRA exhaustion requirement applies to all inmate suits about prison life)
  • Ross v. Blake, 136 S. Ct. 1850 (administrative remedies must be "available"; clarified limits on exceptions)
  • Celotex Corp. v. Catrett, 477 U.S. 317 (summary judgment principles; nonmoving party cannot rely solely on pleadings)
  • Giano v. Goord, 380 F.3d 670 (exhaustion applies to money damages; exhaustion standards in Second Circuit)
  • Hemphill v. New York, 380 F.3d 680 (Second Circuit discussion of exhaustion and special circumstances)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Thousand v. Corrigan
Court Name: District Court, N.D. New York
Date Published: Mar 23, 2017
Citations: 2017 WL 1093275; 9:15-cv-01025
Docket Number: 9:15-cv-01025
Court Abbreviation: N.D.N.Y.
Log In