State v. Swanson
266 P.3d 45
| Or. | 2011Background
- Defendant Swanson was charged with reckless driving, a misdemeanor.
- At trial, Swanson requested jury instructions on careless driving as a lesser-included offense.
- The trial court refused; the Court of Appeals affirmed, holding only lesser-included crimes may be considered, not lesser-included violations.
- The Oregon Supreme Court granted review to resolve whether ORS 136.465 permits lesser-included violations.
- ORS 136.465 authorizes conviction of any crime necessarily included in the charged offense, or an attempt to commit such crime.
- Historically, the term 'crime' and related definitions have evolved, and later revisions redefined 'crime' to include only offenses punishable by imprisonment.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether ORS 136.465 covers lesser-included violations | Swanson contends 'crime' includes violations due to historical scope. | State argues ORS 136.465 only allows lesser-included crimes, not violations. | ORS 136.465 applies only to crimes (felonies/misdemeanors), not violations. |
| Effect of 1971–1973 statutory revisions on 'crime' meaning in ORS 136.465 | Defendant asserts 1971/1973 changes do not affect ORS 136.465 outside the Criminal Code. | State argues revisions clarify that 'crime' in ORS 136.465 aligns with the 1971 Code definitions. | The term 'crime' in ORS 136.465 is controlled by the 1971/1973 revisions and excludes violations. |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Gaines, 346 Or. 160 (2009) (statutory interpretation governs legislative intent and subsequent amendments)
- Easton v. Hurita, 290 Or. 689 (1981) (criminal procedure and decriminalization implications)
- Mattila v. Mason, 287 Or. 235 (1979) (procedural protections in decriminalized offenses)
- Brown v. Multnomah County Dist. Ct., 280 Or. 95 (1977) (procedural distinctions for violations vs. crimes)
- State v. Conger, 319 Or. 484 (1994) (reliance on legislative history in statutory interpretation)
- State v. Hitt, 305 Or. 458 (1988) (criminal statute interpretations and definitions)
