History
  • No items yet
midpage
State v. Keaira Brown
300 Kan. 542
| Kan. | 2014
Read the full case

Background

  • Brown, age 13 at the time of the crimes, was tried as an adult after a district court waived juvenile jurisdiction and authorized adult prosecution.
  • She was convicted of first-degree felony murder and attempted aggravated robbery with a hard 20 life sentence for murder and a concurrent shorter sentence for the related offense.
  • The State sought and obtained authorization to prosecute Brown as an adult under the Revised Kansas Juvenile Justice Code, including eight factors for waiver.
  • Evidence at waiver included crime details, prior uncharged incidents, juvenile facility records, and testimony from various witnesses and experts.
  • The defense challenged the waiver ruling, the jury instruction on felony murder, the sufficiency of evidence, prosecutorial conduct, and the constitutionality of the harsh sentence for a juvenile.
  • The Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s waiver and the convictions, and upheld the mandatory hard 20 life sentence as constitutional under Miller and related precedents.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Waiver decision: proper application of eight factors Brown argues district court abused discretion; lack of substantial evidence State contends factors supported waiver No abuse; factors supported waiver
Felony murder instruction: flight from aggravated robbery allowed Instruction misstated law Instruction was legally correct and factually appropriate Instruction not error
Sufficiency of evidence for attempted aggravated robbery No attempt evidence; taking occurred with death Evidence showed attempt despite fatal taking Sufficient evidence of attempted aggravated robbery
Prosecutorial misconduct in closing Prosecutor improperly portrayed Brown's testimony as untruthful Misconduct isolated and not reversible given overwhelming evidence Mitigated; no reversible prejudice
Mandatory hard 20 life sentence for juvenile offender Sentence unconstitutional as applied to juveniles under 18 Miller does not render hard 20 life unconstitutional here Constitutional as applied; parole eligibility after 20 years under Kansas law

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Bailey, 292 Kan. 449 (2011) (factual review and standard for waiver decisions)
  • In re D.D.M., 291 Kan. 883 (2011) (abuse of discretion standard for waiver factors; substantial evidence requirement clarified)
  • State v. Griffin, 279 Kan. 634 (2005) (flight from attempting to commit an inherently dangerous felony included in felony murder instruction)
  • State v. Cheffen, 297 Kan. 689 (2013) (felony murder not alternate means doctrine; off-grid offenses clarified)
  • State v. Ward, 292 Kan. 541 (2011) (prosecutorial misconduct standard and harmlessness analysis)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Keaira Brown
Court Name: Supreme Court of Kansas
Date Published: Aug 15, 2014
Citation: 300 Kan. 542
Docket Number: 106111
Court Abbreviation: Kan.