State v. Keaira Brown
300 Kan. 542
| Kan. | 2014Background
- Brown, age 13 at the time of the crimes, was tried as an adult after a district court waived juvenile jurisdiction and authorized adult prosecution.
- She was convicted of first-degree felony murder and attempted aggravated robbery with a hard 20 life sentence for murder and a concurrent shorter sentence for the related offense.
- The State sought and obtained authorization to prosecute Brown as an adult under the Revised Kansas Juvenile Justice Code, including eight factors for waiver.
- Evidence at waiver included crime details, prior uncharged incidents, juvenile facility records, and testimony from various witnesses and experts.
- The defense challenged the waiver ruling, the jury instruction on felony murder, the sufficiency of evidence, prosecutorial conduct, and the constitutionality of the harsh sentence for a juvenile.
- The Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s waiver and the convictions, and upheld the mandatory hard 20 life sentence as constitutional under Miller and related precedents.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waiver decision: proper application of eight factors | Brown argues district court abused discretion; lack of substantial evidence | State contends factors supported waiver | No abuse; factors supported waiver |
| Felony murder instruction: flight from aggravated robbery allowed | Instruction misstated law | Instruction was legally correct and factually appropriate | Instruction not error |
| Sufficiency of evidence for attempted aggravated robbery | No attempt evidence; taking occurred with death | Evidence showed attempt despite fatal taking | Sufficient evidence of attempted aggravated robbery |
| Prosecutorial misconduct in closing | Prosecutor improperly portrayed Brown's testimony as untruthful | Misconduct isolated and not reversible given overwhelming evidence | Mitigated; no reversible prejudice |
| Mandatory hard 20 life sentence for juvenile offender | Sentence unconstitutional as applied to juveniles under 18 | Miller does not render hard 20 life unconstitutional here | Constitutional as applied; parole eligibility after 20 years under Kansas law |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Bailey, 292 Kan. 449 (2011) (factual review and standard for waiver decisions)
- In re D.D.M., 291 Kan. 883 (2011) (abuse of discretion standard for waiver factors; substantial evidence requirement clarified)
- State v. Griffin, 279 Kan. 634 (2005) (flight from attempting to commit an inherently dangerous felony included in felony murder instruction)
- State v. Cheffen, 297 Kan. 689 (2013) (felony murder not alternate means doctrine; off-grid offenses clarified)
- State v. Ward, 292 Kan. 541 (2011) (prosecutorial misconduct standard and harmlessness analysis)
