midpage
171 Conn. App. 530
Conn. App. Ct.
2017

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Victim: a three‑year‑old girl; defendant (her father) visited and was intoxicated on Nov. 21, 2012. Mother briefly left apartment; on return found victim with pants/down and defendant nearby with pants unbuckled. Mother called police.
  • Medical/exam: sexual assault nurse examiner collected swabs; forensic testing found seminal fluid protein (p30) and DNA consistent with defendant or same paternal lineage.
  • Charges and trial: defendant convicted by jury of sexual assault in the first degree (§ 53a‑70(a)(2)), attempted sexual assault in the first degree (§§ 53a‑49 & 53a‑70(a)(2)), risk of injury to a child, and sexual assault in the fourth degree (§ 53a‑73a(a)(1)(A)). One count of risk of injury was dismissed pre‑submission.
  • Procedural posture on appeal: defendant raised (1) double jeopardy claims (challenging convictions for both the greater and lesser offenses), (2) a Batson challenge to a peremptory strike, and (3) a claim that the court abused its discretion by not producing all of the mother’s psychiatric/medical records.
  • Trial court made an in‑camera review of mother’s voluminous mental‑health records, disclosed selected summaries with mother’s consent, and limited defense access; mother’s psychiatric/substance‑abuse history was elicited at trial.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument (State) Defendant's Argument Held
Double jeopardy: conviction for both sexual assault in the first degree and attempted sexual assault in the first degree Two convictions are proper because the charging instruments included both counts Attempt is a lesser‑included offense of the completed sexual assault; convicting both punishes same offense twice Vacated attempt conviction as it is a lesser‑included offense of the completed first‑degree sexual assault (remand for resentencing)
Double jeopardy: convictions for sexual assault in the first degree and fourth degree Statutes criminalize different elements (intercourse v. sexual contact with intent for gratification/degradation) Both arise from same act and legislature intended parallel/overlapping protection for under‑13 victims Rejected; convictions can stand together because each crime requires an element the other does not (
no double jeopardy violation)
Batson challenge to prosecution’s peremptory strike of venireperson M.B. Peremptory strike was race/ethnicity neutral and supported by voir dire answers (confusion, articulation, concerns about judgment) Strike was pretextual and discriminatorily targeted a Brazilian/ethnic minority juror Rejected; trial court’s factual finding that the prosecutor’s reason was race‑neutral was supported by record and not clearly erroneous
Disclosure of mother’s psychiatric/medical records Trial court’s in‑camera review and limited disclosure satisfied defense’s confrontation rights; summaries given were sufficient Court abused discretion by not producing more records that could impeach mother’s credibility/perception Rejected; appellate in‑camera review found records largely duplicative, trial court did not abuse discretion; any error would be harmless given overwhelming evidence (including DNA)

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Golding, 213 Conn. 233 (establishes four‑part test for unpreserved constitutional claims)
  • Blockburger v. United States, 284 U.S. 299 (1932) (double jeopardy statutory‑elements test)
  • State v. Polanco, 308 Conn. 242 (remedy: vacate lesser‑included conviction when convicted of both greater and lesser offenses)
  • Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986) (peremptory strikes based on race violate Equal Protection; three‑step Batson framework)
  • State v. Esposito, 192 Conn. 166 (procedures for in‑camera review and disclosure of confidential psychiatric records for confrontation/impeachment)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Carlos P.
Court Name: Connecticut Appellate Court
Date Published: Mar 14, 2017
Citations: 171 Conn. App. 530; 157 A.3d 723; 2017 Conn. App. LEXIS 70; AC39616
Docket Number: AC39616
Court Abbreviation: Conn. App. Ct.
Log In