History
  • No items yet
midpage
155 A.3d 881
Me.
2017
Read the full case

Background

  • Ames, jailed on an unrelated probation-violation arrest, was interviewed in the county jail visitation room by two plainclothes, unarmed detectives about a reported restaurant burglary; the interview was recorded.
  • The detectives told Ames the questioning was voluntary, that he could stop and return to his cell at any time, and that the subject did not concern his probation matter.
  • Ames denied involvement for about fifteen minutes, then confessed after detectives suggested cooperation could affect outcomes; no Miranda warnings were given.
  • Ames moved to suppress the statements as the product of custodial interrogation; the suppression court denied the motion.
  • Ames entered a conditional guilty plea reserving the right to appeal the suppression ruling; the court affirmed the denial on appeal and affirmed the conviction and sentence.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether Ames was "in custody" for Miranda purposes during the jail interview Ames: incarceration + detectives' questioning created custodial coercion so Miranda warnings were required State: interview circumstances (plainclothes, unarmed officers; room layout; told free to leave; brief, conversational interview) show no custody Court: Not custodial under totality; Miranda not required

Key Cases Cited

  • Howes v. Fields, 565 U.S. 499 (prisoner interrogation not categorically custodial; totality test applies)
  • State v. Ntim, 76 A.3d 370 (Me. 2013) (standard of review for suppression findings)
  • State v. Bryant, 97 A.3d 595 (Me. 2014) (factors for custodial interrogation analysis)
  • State v. Kittredge, 97 A.3d 106 (Me. 2014) (consideration of officer appearance, number present, and interrogation length)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Ames
Court Name: Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Date Published: Feb 7, 2017
Citations: 155 A.3d 881; 2017 ME 27; Docket: And-16-172
Docket Number: Docket: And-16-172
Court Abbreviation: Me.
Log In