Roberts v. Roberts
19 A.3d 277
| Del. | 2011Background
- Husband and Wife married August 12, 1989; they have a 14-year-old adopted daughter.
- They separated around April 1, 2008; cross-consent PFAs were entered restricting contact in May 2008.
- Husband filed for divorce January 16, 2009; a prior decree was vacated due to timeliness concerns.
- Husband completed an April 2009 PEP (basic course) that did not include a DV component; Wife had not filed a Certificate of Completion as of December 11, 2009.
- Family Court Commissioner granted the divorce after noting the PEP issue and finding potential, but not necessary, linkage to DV education; August 2009 Wife Certificate still not filed.
- Court ultimately affirmed the divorce decree, holding that 1507(h) did not require a pre-decree DV-Pep completion and that Husband’s April 2009 PEP sufficed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether 1507(h) requires a DV-component PEP. | Wife: DV history mandates DV PEP for Husband. | Husband: no demonstrable DV history; no DV PEP required. | No demonstrable DV history; April 2009 PEP sufficed. |
| Whether completing a PEP is a condition precedent to entry of the divorce decree. | Wife: PEP completion must occur before decree. | Husband: PEP completion not required before decree; waiver possible. | PEP completion is not a strict condition precedent to entry of a divorce decree. |
| Whether the court erred in not requiring pre-decree DV-Pep completion despite possible DV history. | Wife contends error in not imposing DV-education. | Husband: not required given no demonstrable DV history. | Court did not err; no demonstrable DV history. |
Key Cases Cited
- Solis v. Tea, 468 A.2d 1276 (Del. 1983) (standard of review and statutory interpretation guidance referenced by court)
- Forrester v. Forrester, 953 A.2d 175 (Del.2008) (properly applying statutory provisions; review standards)
- Jones v. Lang, 591 A.2d 185 (Del.1991) (abuse of discretion and standard of review principles)
- Villarroel v. Villarroel, 562 A.2d 1180 (Del.1989) (family court jurisdiction and ancillary proceedings)
