23 Cal.App.5th 959
Cal. Ct. App.2018Background
- Andrew Berg was arrested for public intoxication and booked into Monterey County Jail; nearly 48 hours after booking a deputy found a plastic-wrapped bindle of methamphetamine between his buttocks during a visual strip search.
- Defendant was charged with felony possession of a controlled substance in jail (Pen. Code § 4573.6(a)).
- Defense sought to admit evidence (and an expert) that Berg was voluntarily intoxicated at time of arrest ~48 hours earlier to impeach his knowledge of possessing the drugs.
- Prosecutor moved to exclude that evidence under Evidence Code §§ 350, 352; the trial court granted the motion and also denied a requested instruction about the opportunity to relinquish contraband.
- Jury convicted; court imposed the low term of two years (abstract erroneously stated middle term), and appellant appealed challenging the exclusion of intoxication evidence.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether voluntary-intoxication evidence was admissible to negate knowledge for §4573.6 (possession-in-jail) | The People argued §29.4 bars voluntary-intoxication evidence for general intent crimes like §4573.6 | Berg argued intoxication was relevant to whether he knew he possessed the contraband when booked and thus could negate the knowledge element | Exclusion affirmed: §4573.6 is a general intent offense and §29.4(a) bars voluntary-intoxication evidence to negate knowledge except for required specific-intent crimes (or express malice in murder) |
| Whether trial court abused its discretion under Evid. Code §§350/352 by excluding intoxication evidence and related expert testimony | The People argued any probative value was minimal given the ~48-hour gap and would be outweighed by confusion and time consumption | Berg argued temporal gap did not render intoxication irrelevant because it could show he lacked awareness when he entered the jail and had no opportunity to purge contraband | No abuse of discretion: temporal separation reduced probative value and §29.4 foreclosed using voluntary intoxication to negate general intent; any potential prejudice was not established |
Key Cases Cited
- People v. Low, 49 Cal.4th 372 (discusses §4573 and knowledge element in possession-into-jail context)
- People v. Hood, 1 Cal.3d 444 (historical framework distinguishing specific vs general intent for intoxication admissibility)
- People v. Atkins, 25 Cal.4th 76 (confirms Hood framework on intoxication evidence)
- People v. Mendoza, 18 Cal.4th 1114 (discusses statutory treatment of intoxication evidence)
- People v. Whitfield, 7 Cal.4th 437 (addressed intoxication admissibility in implied-malice murder; later abrogated by statute)
- People v. Reyes, 52 Cal.App.4th 975 (appellate case holding intoxication evidence admissible to challenge knowledge element; court here disagreed with Reyes)
- Montana v. Egelhoff, 518 U.S. 37 (U.S. Supreme Court: upholds exclusion of voluntary-intoxication evidence against due process challenge)
- People v. Soto, 4 Cal.5th 968 (approves legislative policy excluding voluntary-intoxication evidence for certain mental-state proof)