midpage
Projects
Sign in to see your projects.
280 P.3d 959
Okla.
2012
Read the full case

Background

  • Oklahoma amended §34.70(B)(5) to require 2,000 dues-paying state employees for voluntary payroll deductions; prior law set 1,000.
  • Corrections Association, with ~1,900 members, sued to block termination of deductions and preserve status quo.
  • Federal district court dismissed federal claims for lack of standing and declined supplemental state claims.
  • The Tenth Circuit certified questions to Oklahoma, asking severability of the 2,000-member requirement under OK law.
  • Oklahoma Supreme Court held the 2,000-member date is severable if unconstitutional, leaving the rest of the statute intact.
  • If severed, the remainder would still authorize voluntary payroll deductions for associations and related purposes.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Can the numerosity requirement be severed under Oklahoma law? Corrections Association. Jackson/Administrator. Yes, severable under 75 O.S.2011 § 11a.
Would severance restore the prior 1,000-member threshold or eliminate the language entirely? Advisory depends on severance. Statute would be rewritten if severed. Advisory only; the issue largely moot.
Does severance alter the statute’s primary purpose or its operational meaning? Severance preserves express payroll deductions. Removal changes legislative design. The balance can stand; severed provision not essential.

Key Cases Cited

  • Leavitt v. Jane, 518 U.S. 137 (1996) (standard severability framework from federal constitution)
  • In re Harris, 49 P.3d 710 (Okla. 2002) (procedural guidance on factual bounds of certification)
  • Liddell v. Heavner, 180 P.3d 1191 (Okla. 2008) (state constitutional due process discussions)
  • Conaghan v. Riverfield Country Day School, 163 P.3d 557 (Okla. 2007) (severability and statutory interpretation principles)
  • Wilson v. Fallin, 262 P.3d 741 (Okla. 2011) (constitutional questions in Oklahoma Supreme Court context)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Oklahoma Corrections Professional Ass'n v. Jackson
Court Name: Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Date Published: Jun 12, 2012
Citations: 280 P.3d 959; 2012 OK 53; 193 L.R.R.M. (BNA) 2916; 2012 WL 2107978; 2012 Okla. LEXIS 56; No. 110,349
Docket Number: No. 110,349
Court Abbreviation: Okla.
Log In