142 Conn. App. 352
Conn. App. Ct.2013Background
- Defendant Dawn Cassara sought joint custody and incurred substantial attorney’s fees in the custody action against Adrian Marcus.
- Trial court awarded defendant physical custody and final decision-making authority to defendant after an eight-day trial in 2009.
- Court reserved ruling on attorney’s fees until affidavits were exchanged; hearing could be scheduled if requested.
- Defendant filed affidavits detailing fees; plaintiff challenged reasonableness of the amount.
- Defendant moved for attorney’s fees post-judgment; court denied the motion in May 2010; defendant appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the court abused its discretion by not holding an evidentiary hearing | Cassara argues hearing was required to test fee reasonableness | Marcus contends no hearing was necessary; record supports decision | No error; defendant waived hearing by agreement |
| Whether the court abused its discretion in denying any attorney’s fees | Cassara asserts findings show defendant cannot pay alone | Marcus contends financial positions and misconduct do not justify fees | Affirmed; court properly exercised discretion and declined fee award |
Key Cases Cited
- Falls Church Group, Ltd. v. Tyler, Cooper & Alcorn, LLP, 89 Conn. App. 459 (2005) (waiver can bar evidentiary hearing challenges)
- Kaczynski v. Kaczynski, 294 Conn. 121 (2009) (presumption favoring trial court’s correct decision in absence of contrary indications)
- Moasser v. Becker, 121 Conn. App. 593 (2010) (abuse of discretion standard in awarding counsel fees)
- Ramin v. Ramin, 281 Conn. 324 (2007) (need for misconduct finding to justify fee award)
- Lambert v. Donahue, 78 Conn. App. 493 (2003) (consider financial abilities and statutory criteria in §46b-62/§46b-82)
- Fitzgerald v. Fitzgerald, 190 Conn. 26 (1983) (fees not awarded solely due to ability to pay)
- Koizim v. Koizim, 181 Conn. 492 (1980) (supportive of discretionary fee decisions based on financials)
