41 A.3d 1261
D.C.2012Background
- A.M., a ten-year-old, testified that L.C., a fourteen-year-old, sexually assaulted her at a pool during a summer camp activity.
- L.C. was convicted of first-degree sexual abuse and first-degree child sexual abuse based on A.M.'s testimony.
- Before trial, L.C. moved to exclude A.M.'s out-of-court statements under the report-of-rape exception, arguing it does not apply in bench trials.
- The trial court admitted the statements, finding A.M. credible and corroborated by multiple witnesses (nurse, male counselor, camp director).
- On appeal, L.C. argues the report-of-rape exception does not apply in bench trials; the DC Court of Appeals must decide its applicability in bench trials.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the report-of-rape exception applies in bench trials | L.C. argues no, based on Battle's focus on jurors','prejudices | State argues rule applies to bench trials as society's prejudices; judges are subject to same social assumptions | Yes; rule applies in bench trials to the same extent as jury trials |
Key Cases Cited
- Battle v. United States, 630 A.2d 211 (D.C.1993) (report-of-rape rule survives corroboration abolition; admissibility for purpose of showing a report was made)
- Cullen v. United States, 886 A.2d 870 (D.C.2005) (acknowledges report-of-rape rule in bench trials)
- Mattete v. United States, 902 A.2d 113 (D.C.2006) (implicitly endorsed bench-trial admission under Battle)
- Dyson v. United States, 848 A.2d 603 (D.C.2004) (de novo review of hearsay exceptions; abuse of discretion standard for admissibility)
- Daye v. United States, 733 A.2d 321 (D.C.1999) (prior consistent statements to bolster credibility; exceptions in sex-offense context)
- Duncan v. Louisiana, 313 U.S. 145 (U.S. 1968) (historical jury valued in safeguarding against bias; societal assumptions affect fact-finding)
- Battle v. United States, 630 A.2d 211 (D.C.1993) (reiterates rationale for report-of-rape rule in context of jurors' prejudices)
