CITY OF HAPEVILLE Et Al. v. GRADY MEMORIAL HOSPITAL CORPORATION
328 Ga. App. 332
Ga. Ct. App.2014Background
- Grady Memorial Hospital sued the City of Hapeville and its Police Department seeking $81,694.74 for medical treatment provided to four prisoners in the City's custody.
- The City moved to dismiss, asserting sovereign immunity from suit.
- The trial court denied the motion, finding OCGA § 42-5-2 waived sovereign immunity for medical providers seeking payment, aligning with Cherokee County v. North Cobb Surgical Assoc. and Macon-Bibb County precedent.
- The City appealed the denial of its immunity defense.
- The Court of Appeals reviewed the denial de novo and assumed the City had custody of the prisoners when treatment was rendered.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether OCGA § 42-5-2 waives sovereign immunity for municipal jailers so a medical provider may sue for payment | Grady: § 42-5-2 creates a statutory duty to pay medical expenses and thus an express waiver permitting a money-judgment suit | City: Municipalities are treated differently for immunity; § 42-5-2 waivers recognized for State/counties do not necessarily apply to municipal corporations | The court held § 42-5-2 covers inmates to whom OCGA § 42-4-1 et seq. applies and concludes the legislative waiver extends to municipal jailers; denial of City's motion affirmed |
Key Cases Cited
- Cherokee County v. North Cobb Surgical Assoc., 221 Ga. App. 496 (discussing county liability under OCGA § 42-5-2)
- Macon-Bibb County Hosp. Auth. v. Houston County, 207 Ga. App. 530 (holding legislature's enactment of OCGA § 42-5-2 waived county sovereign immunity for medical expenses)
- Ga. Dept. of Natural Resources v. Center for a Sustainable Coast, Inc., 294 Ga. 593 (statutory waivers of sovereign immunity must create a specific right to a money judgment)
- City of Atlanta v. Mitcham, 325 Ga. App. 481 (discussing municipal immunity framework under OCGA § 36-33-1)
