midpage
256 P.3d 987
N.M. Ct. App.
2011

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Two consolidated cases involve property tax refund claims for 2007 in Albuquerque, NM.
  • First installment due date on November 10, 2007; delinquency date set as December 10, 2007.
  • Taxpayers paid installments and filed refunds in February 2008, within 60 days after due date per statute.
  • Assessor moved to dismiss as untimely; district court denied; stipulated judgments allowed appeal.
  • Issue: whether the 60-day filing window begins on the due date or the delinquency date.
  • Court held the window begins on the due date, reversing the district court.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
When does the 60-day deadline begin? Taxpayers: begins on delinquency date; favors public convenience Assessor: begins on due date as written in statute Deadline begins on the due date; untimely otherwise
Does common usage of 'due' alter its meaning in the statute? Taxpayers: 'due' means when payment is expected, not the delinquency date Assessor: statutory language controls; 'due' and 'delinquent' are distinct Plain reading controls; ordinary usage does not alter the statute
Do practical consequences render the statute unconstitutional? Taxpayers: time frame too short and unconstitutional as a due process issue Assessor: time frame reasonable given notice and options to challenge valuation Sixty-day period is constitutional as a statute of repose

Key Cases Cited

  • Sonic Indus. v. State, 140 N.M. 212, 141 P.3d 1266 (2006) (statutory interpretation governed by plain language and intent)
  • Terry v. N.M. State Highway Comm'n, 98 N.M. 119, 645 P.2d 1375 (1982) (due process depends on reasonableness of the time limit)
  • Garcia v. La Farge, 119 N.M. 532, 893 P.2d 428 (1995) (statutes of repose begin before accrual of the cause of action)
  • Tafoya v. N.M. State Police Bd., 81 N.M. 710, 472 P.2d 973 (1970) (ordinary meaning rule for ambiguous terms; contextual limits)
  • Muse v. Muse, 145 N.M. 451, 200 P.3d 104 (2009) (counsel arguments alone are not evidence)
  • Pub. Serv. Co. v. N.M. Pub. Util. Comm'n, 128 N.M. 309, 992 P.2d 860 (1999) (statutory interpretation guided by legislative intent)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Chan v. Montoya
Court Name: New Mexico Court of Appeals
Date Published: Apr 1, 2011
Citations: 256 P.3d 987; 2011 NMCA 072; 150 N.M. 44; 150 N.M. 24; 2011 WL 2848143; 29,142, 29,760; 32,990
Docket Number: 29,142, 29,760; 32,990
Court Abbreviation: N.M. Ct. App.
Log In