Appellant, J. Arthur Ewing, individually as life beneficiary under exercise of power of appointment, and Fidelity-Philadelphia Trust Company and J. Arthur Ewing, substituted trustees for Emma M. Ewing under the will of William S. Duling, deceased, filed their appeal wherein they objected to the calculation of the life interest of J. Arthur Ewing brought into existence by the exercise of the power of appointment of his wife, who was the preceding life beneficiary of the trust.
A stipulation of facts agreed to by counsel was filed October 15, 1941, which eliminates the questions of calculation of the tax and as to values. The stipulation provides that if the tax is due at all it is in the sum of $3,207.01.
This leaves only two questions for the consideration of the court: First, as to whether the original appraisement is res adjudicata and precludes any subsequent appraisement at this time; and second, whether the tax is payable out of the income or principal.
The first contention requires very little discussion. Granting the authenticity of all the cases cited by appellant in his very able brief, they are not decisive of this question. He goes to great lengths of research to show that once an appraisement is made by the Commonwealth, both as to valuations, deductions, and all other incidents of an appraisement, and the time for an appeal goes by, neither the Commonwealth nor the taxable person or persons can appeal. From this he argues that because immediately after the
As to the second question, we agree with appellant Ewing that, all taxes having been directed by the will to be paid out of the corpus of the residue and this corpus forming one third of the original corpus of the residue, the payment of the tax assessed against his life interest as well as all other taxes including the tax on the daughter’s life interest (were that taxable) is payable out of the principal of the corpus of the trust. Of course the tax on the daughter’s estate, having been only two percent, has heretofore been paid. The tax being due from the corpus, the same will be awarded therefrom in the adjudication upon the trustees’ account which is now pending.
The stipulation of facts agreed to by counsel having fixed the amount of the tax on the life interest of appellant, J. Arthur Ewing, the same will be awarded to the register of wills in the sum of $3,207.01 in the adjudication upon the trustees’ account aforesaid.
And now, January 23, 1942, the appeal is dismissed with directions to the register to proceed in accordance with this opinion.
