J. Barth v. 4th Jud. District, OP 22-0072

J. Barth v. 4th Jud. District

OP 22-0072

| Mont. | Feb 22, 2022

Check Treatment

*1 FILED

D ORIGINAL 02/22/2022 02/09/2022 Bowen G enwood CLERK OE THE S REME COURT

STATE OF NTANA Case Number: OP 22-0072 Case Number: OP 22-0072 jo-‘red De-Ce/Idait P(0

FILED) Sctpert'or Coutf-Y ..fa;/ FEB 09 2022 po be*? 99 ;c3() ficr 59 -172„. Bowen Greenwood , 5(Aper Clerk of Suprerne Court State of Montana A 0.1417,..delet)ct tv104 /le: • ..faced Baelik rvoi-:(37) -co r (A.)(;-/' /Id t J-e4e arr 0-C) __Sci Fe rv;c0 c y Co79-/---(0 i. V CakSe 41G-tiber'S D6-21-311 aeld -fetie 0C ievlacriarna DC- 2 I - qiiii dott/. _s e e fq-advvre/ch-C *2 D ORIGINAL

a Mid

0361 1(7'3) De-ce441.4t pebSe SupeC/6( cotv)7Ly jod

_ . .,..,.

po 60X 49q sa peelbc ./tit- 59872

FEB 09 2022

c,,,,....o.A.-,o,-. pl,a,•.•la, Clerk of Supreme Court State of Montana /viso404a. 341)re/bele ratc-i, Iie/e,K1 A4,04-tala Jet,(&1 13.il-t)-1 ."--- caose,uos. 10e- )--i-ilLiciAcia"

pc-2/-371

clgeAchA4

V rvloi;o4 -Po(' 4bOvict pauK:5 Yee c-r Ae7o4faA61 feCpcs-ickirrto

— - bto4'e/ktatr Bet A ," - e

.S

Tin,'S Coalq- -ko er rii: t. pacip(i'S) a S

ii/7

de-re/186yr/ ;5 i e-)ca(Ce(a fed i A superia6r cconl Jai'l ct/id A-i)i l'ilmefaiwe accoutelt ono" hcTS

-1Y IoSeao

dwite) 4644

Doe 1 /. ./2 ,0 2

J4(ed

&OA Po boX gq

54PeCiaal/setr *4 /a/ (I) s Aze:sc 2,0 4 - 1 -.< ) t-I /et 3S - ( 2 ) s e f o r t e e X r e I, i c i ? . ? \/ p i s i e k 4 ( O a & M eg , 7 ) / 41047 .. i n ) 96 - 5 ' 7 ,, 2 . J __q . 2 264 . ( 3 / li p i c / K i a V 7 t li r p ' z o // e k 3 W i f u , S q 36 • ,.. S . c . 1 - / 6o ; / 6 ii & I,

2

4 04 ( 119 ' 6 ) ( 2 - / D u ( > k t 426 ( 43 ) v e t a f p , t i 92 () I S * 19 G ) 203 / 0q S i c l 2a7 S 10 . 6 L Q _L z _ a g ( 5 s + r u m k - v 011 ) \ - i ed s i a l e c e t p2 u i s g3q i 1 , 790 2 93 s z Y 6

i

, 37 L i Q i 2 - , c / I : 5 C 0973 )

2266

( 6 ./ 6 /\ ( 0 ) / 1 / k t i tt e l P e t.f i ' ll o t i e r v C il t y ' ( ~ -( V e )) ; e t i i .I . , ( - 301 S l u () e l s - l e i e S 94 e m e m e V e k 2 f e , 2 0 / 7 0 41b r i p i - v O i w ee ' ) 5 6 : 3 ud s z a ) . 2 . 74 h i e / s oo x i i / 27 L4 t € c 1 . 20 1 ( 14qq ) U , S , ( 200 ) r 37 Š i a - 911 , 41 11 1 7 1 .. d . .. 2 , 0 1 2 / 2 25 u150L . k i . ' 14139 ,, z ( F A L i W ee t o y f ed s q % i 26 ) F l a , t. w ee k f y 4 ) e d s qe , r 7

(

8 - f r i 1 2 3 , 4 ( 1 1822 1 3 00 0 99 0 ( 1 ) 6 - W e V n ; c 4 i C - - t, o f c r ; c 4 J a i t 1 ) 4 , 24 , " i t - y r /. ‘ ? . 9 ' . 4 P q q 4 li n ? , I R O () . ) *5 rooftv7.04/eiy-evju 41774 . j k , 4 . V e l , / a t a y i p 5 4 V 14 . p fr t e / i t () 4 , i 5 ) P i r o l f . 4 . - p e d w A m oy l ® v p i ff)) p p o i p p / vpv . R )- a i o

vv

, ) , ? , ( 4 . 0140 / i yo d r i s u m A iiii r)

vok

w i r O f- v O : C l . i d D V 19 , p30 - 0 . k k / ko w I V + D s / vh c c i v

c

t -- q ( - 3h

)

0d1 4 . 19 1 .. v 2

j

y . i p vo X v ( 1 0 , 99 C I j . (r) r c o r ,. 5 " L g v t e i gd 1 ) 2 ) P 5 9 2 ) ) 0 1 r t , c i *d ¢ - 0 4 ) (

5

)

L

i 4 o ti )

a

l - 6 1 , A a P tl n

1

L 5 , 1 & 404715d V

(

h ) p r- A l p LE a ti . 1 = 4 - ) a po i N 5vd7 , ( r ) 0o s v ii . g ) ( - 1 9 v 0 1 / 55 , 93 - w d (

S

) 0 V 2 ., a ( ., T i f , L ) . w o r i po s - v a . 7 , 1 / 10 , 1 , ) , / 5 . c / V C X ) E & 90 ( - 1 Z - 55 v OG , 5 a ; c i A 0 P w il / 4 . / . 4 19do D p / a w il 5 , 194 , v it p s 9117 317 ,

1

0 / /

s

i l o 0 7 ) \ A /

249

*6 i v \ C A C o

A

z A / e - 5 - t e4 c i m p ) 1 ; 6 ' - 1 - r 6 v - ne6 ff a s E v de w c e . s - t e A c g c aph ; c a ll y ( e / r) o H ead - 1 - e . c ii ` ff r i oe ., y a t a he c t r ; 45 r I ;. s ad / 14 ; 5 s : 61e ;/ - 7 e v i t sz i e r i c e c r y ' a 161 - k t - 1 -r ,: a ( d , m e - 1 - 6 - K oe t i c o y m a y he pa V ed

a

- i - t a4 s en ' 7 ,4 -

I c ; s e c i b ) , t he f i e r s o , w ho t a m e 25 - 31 - 703 . pd s - 11104e / v ) e4 . i - b y m o i 6 ' 0 / 7 - 1 . he - C 6 r

e X c eed , " 1 m o rr ili S - 01 goo c i C a t i 5e , 2 S - 3 / - 705 - po s - t pone i r f r ae r t t i p0 , 7 app ) ; ( 611 -) 1 0 / 7 p c t e l - y • - f e i w ( eq m ; r ed ,

e

/ v i e w be po l & l e d k i k 3 , 4 ' V e t e a pp li t ee t t , o z i _

e

i `- kk e r p cv i ) '' - P O ( ' r ee ; o c i 401 V ( ee c l ;f 29 9 A t i o r Y n I c . app i • ?e t - 66 / 7 s ho ll p r o v e , b y " d r k ) e P a1 9 4 - y e ) 1 --) % e p c a tt Y 5 0 V / 4 p de t y egpe c t s - t o p r o c w r i sc i R l Y p e c i e e d 161 ( i c t i and _ S ho w ;/ ) bu il e tt r e s pee l - t k e ± e M :/ k i a l Y W f pe c - t ed ; s ./ qa t e r ; o tt d4d , i 3 ) e p l o y h a s t a L s e d due 0 1 , V i j e 4e e p l a c k , ( e I i 4ed - t e s t ` m c o y a4d . i v t 5 bee t ) t i v i a t b i e

s

o .

/iv\

*7 c A c o d e s

w

t o l -

s

tt pp ( e5 S ; c 9 / 7 C O 4 P e SS o O V ) C A " e i d / v 1 : 5 SA t ( : 7 A - d e -r e / I d a / 1 - f m a y m o v e t o upp i ( e . g '

e

v i V o4 ce a ( i y C o ti P ez : 0 , -) O r a 4 / 11 , 1 , 5 s ; e 4 : 9 , ' v e A h y - 1 - 14 € c

o

l 0 A t k e s eo w il d

;

# W a g i l 4 VO / U / r t e l P itil / v i c 31 ; 07 ) m u 5 i - b e 4 t i c i 5 - I a t e 5 ) 40 t A ) 01 < 1 5 ( A ) hy - t h e c o r i - P e s , 1 0 . 1 o d , 4 ; s s , 1 0 ) , ; 1 t d o d c i t / 11 / 6110* ( e Y •

( 2 ) T - C

c

tIt e i t r b t e v l s -- i he A l 1 I * a l V a l e - k t l e t ' M O ; / 4 ) - i . r u e i s ok / t h e r P t h e C o f p R e ss ; a4 a z i f il s s t i c 54 G o a 4v c it 4 , 11 A r y )

c o lit e + S il o , C o A d it c - I ; a hea t E e ' t i y ; ' 0 t i t l e m e i r e ' s 04 ) i ha

/

140 + ; 0 / 1 . p i a s e c a1 : 02 / ) e m u 5 * ? C ov e b y O t.

p

i epa i de r o A c e e t i n t e v ; c f m c e

i

he c o m - P e C o4 1 I r e , ; s 9 i c e 6 • C e a4 / 0 , 1 55 ; 19 : 1 ; + y ( 34 '

c

o , W e s S i ' 64

o

r ad f il o ' ss i ' o r) / 1 / A y / 16 - i

s

t i t l o m i t - / • ) bed + 0 t i . v e

1

, 4? 60 , 4e5 S obee , e ( a c t/ 9 / 55 ' e f o / i ; s de t o r m e :f r ed

-

1 - 0 6e a c i t i ; s 5 ; b1

c

; ( c b i tt e i s - I e v i c e c c u f f a t v i d i , 9 - l e k e " A d k - # 1 k - A e c o / ,, P e ‘ § ; ( 1 ,7 a ( ad / 4 ; ss i o n

-

t il e „ , i tt ( y a S 6e64 ) ;. 4 . 5 146 A li g t 0 : 41 t G t r oe i ( ( : e c 4 ; 1 0 1 1 0 ( t h e u t i e , s 3 h + i

v

r e o t o e c o f rr e Z ' ; e1 L / ) o ( e l d i s o : s 5 ; 0 " *8 /v\C A CoSe5 (.9 IT 1)-le moct,;(1A ; Š graMed, line coneesslo") , % a i rovi 51 cl-/- em$

A

0452: (ikt 1.kt ellovat)-7, ell IV 4-64,161) 04' the

ease

c/5-7-2o7(1)(4)(8), TaAlper

cu -On Cica -F;Ty ptnyska ev;de")ce

A pellso Co/v-1/1.1;1-S

0-P-Pe/)ce 0-P iamperi'79 c.)/-6) or -rakri'coil;/-73 phys;ca l eviclece -1-lia+ a/7 c+Vibet I proceed;r9 ©r i'civet:92ot-tyloA '5' peric 11;43 0( cibou-i- -to 17e 1`7)seizeeter/ -AC persb/7

or tee/tiove a/1y

(erard doce,t"ie,t, (3( -611:1 wi'i-11 purpose -to

impa;(

ye/ i'+y ava

-tke o e /vietke% petese:415/ or 445'e aviy (:Orordii doettivie4-1- 0( 11,01 ;+ -to be-ra )5e ai,t4 wi‘11,7 prAinpase --1-0

i-ead afiy peisa,-; wIlo oe /v)ely be erlaged ;/)- flie poceedi'Ay 0.e iinvec-/-8130,40/1., ;

*9 50

1

) 9 A ll , C A ( - - a zcz • 96 - 13 - 302 s upp r e il n , - ,7 o f ' e v i V e A c e ( I ) 74 c l e -r e7 k / a44 - agg r ; e v ed b y c t. 4 t 4 A l e t u i C a l 5ea r de t c od s e : u k i v m a i m o v e M e c o k e ' t - t - e s ap r e5g a - 5 e v i V e l c e cv )) 691 ;/ - 63 o li f e t;f i ed b y J - k t e 6 . 44 1 6114414 / S 11 e

0 ) . T . - c - H i e / 10 - 1 - ; 0 / 7 S - 1 - c i t e S - P a C t t .. ? - o t,

t

a l e ) w ood s _ A d w - * T a t - t he e vs V e A s t e S hou l d be s app r e s 5 C 4 - t e 6ou tf 7 t skc lii l e y ee t e + ) l e m e r , o c t be m o - i t kv i c r t - 4 - t e oe t o v i p ' k u . 5 k ‘ Q a f i r i j c ee

a

+ a i a t e r da t e . ; 1 ) - f i l e c o t A t ' i o N e f S

( 3 ) 1 - e o t k m o - N o t e i l s a r v ii f e c t t il e ' e v i V e t ) c e ; S 40 + ad / v 1 ; 55 ; 14e a l - k r ; a t

4

, * i dg e O i pe o • / ( 1

i

' b i e i k 5 c - f a r a -r- eL V a t i l D e f; It t ) t o b A

i

c ; e l d s o P e v i ' de i c e ( 5 ' ( D ; r eq - , e v i de / l c e ; , 1 - 1 - 1 ( 144 - t - w h i k i t l ap r o li e S , a , . e i d e r , o -r f x r e s e4 A l p on ae a l " , d A ; ‘ , 0 ) a

(

i d k l e i n i ' '

t

u e ' e s - f a b i ; 5 4 2 S , ) - •

.

0 ; 1 , 0 ; , ; , i , ,, , r

,

' *10 AA CA Coo/eS b2olaittirl5(Axgr/) fa /54):Cal-,;o4 -tocketthoat.

(1) A Feed/r-b Ctofiewn'iS at) are/xv.. eAAciet

11 puepo5(2. mi'Vectgi

_Sec-tifbA ;4; p4bia? serval& Per-Orlin' /1 (2/1

e aai -ruActic j -i-he persor,' (13) pa(p6Šely Cceadoe a -Co Ise :AeLpas5;oet it a AeCeSSae io prevent sim efile/yts met5leasziliol t-,Lanock /03. DedaNtaiicei., COS; Or 6vAt'sslo

26-

part' 0.0 +lie -1-(aelSacl-lb/ii wirie.(e +he deciiva-N04) act ot-c(wh'ss;04 -eof,ers

iktioviselictitco whi'ch I's

i'fseg' +he -eaci pow* bei id:spate oe ev;fleAce

- tke+ ePoidi C h deck:M.4in 4tcif, otro/viiisSioe-1 ;5 ev/idgnce aS pd-to a the

tit/1st/0;0/1

.27-16-ko6,De.f-Wise

rcleC

The de-reeielavrt- /nay otifiy io Th e cburi. +o be . dischargez/ 4"(bfri °trees+ 4 ihe sravui 041 -11,1e.

ite

€04

h

-t-Ae ()Nero(' aireSt tatielg aen,ried *11 7(49 uoker) orcke vqrcee,1 0 c boo') Ceduced, I -tC) t4F)0/ 7 skeh a? p 1 i'ecci-;6/ 7„ .5cA-9-, sPanbr,`f y APpectes -tAct+ 1-Aefe, waS 40-1- st1+941;c;e/it

ata -r0( -the armst ardler vacethcf; or )4' :4 salrscankinly appears ar4iouipt -t-kat the ba: tAita -rxect -i-00 ifv,3).-> ha // bee redace, 1/6- b;sfrl,'sso.) 1;cksinoce or peoseca,-,K0').

(I) --Aie Court,t4olyeiVlieleo/) a..t1/1 oc

LL

4.91 ,,f) -fir-theral7ce of...110;00,0 ,rele r a co/ilia:at ;,-i-Pperywri7,1040r i`r7c11(-1-,iie,1 ..b bse ell'.5m;ssed, km,A,)eve.6 -t),-)- cottet,414y40 7'6A/el( ct.. d ;5/v\;55cti a .0 avlipa;tit ;6,96e(vv11/04)., 0 e loci lc4-.11efit p( a cottolt Corliti1/7ed /'/) a Pg./fopia,

-. 6 .,(7breileiler a( ir7c1;d/lie/ri; chargile4i a ,oe ic,,-)y, a(1_)esg good cause I 40$44:50 I il s1.0.44 and .t)ie re,a50E-4 .

®r e Ant'isisci c s"9-14 ).1. a

-ede

eti 4e rev tip3,01 •fine /1/1;414-k‹,

d

*12 r " - -(

.

/i . /i ( 4 A c _ t/ 6 - 3 - i oq U ' 0 -r - C c 3 , ( C e ) / 1 de - c ee 0 - e 6 - 1 - e r e ' p r ope r l y . A pe cc on S 4 t i . t i !. ( W , 14 , 5e q - e • - f a ( c e o r :. c . ) - / - e - / - k d e a 1 - - t o a c e - c a r e ago , r 7 ) 5 1 - c t A c T I " ) - t e r . k il l e r - ) o t A C I t o f l ) e M e z il - M O - O l e , P e y ' s o c i 47 - '' a s o t y 2b f y b O i \ e v e J - . )- 47 4 - t he ( 0 / K l a c t ; s ?e c ena l e y - i p p ( ' e v e rr t o i ' - t ee / v ) , v 1 - 74 e 1 )-) e 0 - 7 % e r i p l e y ' s ( 37 ) 1 s t r ' e S i P a C S t o il a r a lli e r - 1 - 0 ' & ; ( 3 1 / 1 5 o r c r i m ; c -) a l 17 ) t e r- en t = 4 c i e u c ) , ' , L A e i - 1 - 7 4 r ed ' pope r - t y i c t ii c ( . -- 1$6 ) a / i c ee c t p l e l g i r e r c i t ( t e ,,, o , ( f e t „ c o / b cx I p ( o l e r - I L y ) a iil eo /I I ( ) > ) -- ) . ) i c pe i 504 ) . s pa c i 5e . s i o A o r ) 7 ) 1 - k e po ŠŠ e . š o v i . a - e a4o l hee w ho i s a f r t e i v i k e r O -r t he pe r o / ) ‘ , l ' A 4 ( v e c il ' op i e - 061 /. 11 ( 3 / 0 ( hou s e ll o r & o r oLe a P pe s nn ( 40 )( vs e P ( o P ee t Y * l e . P e . ( ( 0 , - , he t 5 a ) ega l ‹ f r r t y t o p r o - l e & H o w e v e ) . 5 - T A ¿ pe . 60 . 7 , (( i t S i ' i ' < ' ; . e Q ' ; A - 1 - ) n e 149 ! l o - C P a c e l ' e ) y e t - e , ; S . 46 t 5e 4 E r e ) e ) c r e40 4 ,1 c i A s 6041 l y li c i e / v ) 0 ( 11 y ; 4 1

he ' ' e v e l e c ( c e I S A e c e s e xcy - 1 ( 3 i r ' e v e71 . / - I ll e c 3 / ,t , ii ' , 5 - 1 , c , a A a - r a - r a db l e - C e l e a ,, y , *13 / 11 ( A - C O o i e b / 5 - 3 - »2 14 w e s - / - ; 344 - i t: e (- 1 a a ll e f T i e r f a P e r i c e

o

- f o ft e „ r w o i V i t on , e ea ; e s ) 64 ' j a6 - PA ' a e

O

ne ' ) ae i op l v e0 ; e r t i o r ; s e c t i c h A r - k e c il b Y

?ee

v e 04 r i ?e ‘ t c () ( AA e tt s w , de rr f - f i l o i c t ppee t e s k d v e e one e s i i o ha v e i > 11 / 0 ) v eð . i t e5 V - e ' ab / e ( t A 04 7 - C a t e s e l ' o l v e s 1 ,: g ( 2 t, ` O 44443 - 1 - b e e ck 4 m c l e ,

v i i . 5 6 / 0 , 5 € a t i / e v 4 e A c e ) ; d e i c i a t il . ! ? S . a s

o

ll ege r l 0 - P r e4 s e c AA ¿

5

- 1 ; m o il y c o s e i r ee A ,

0

M i m i " c i t ' d 40 - ; d i c i a S e . cv i y

V

e ' , 6010

ba

k o s s t o r k - m e /I - T s CC ee

bed

a / -) c ) A ? ; S e s a v A li cc h ' 0 , 4

P

r ebab l e c a i R s e a - 4 i a l d i - )

ab

C 3 V e *14 o A S e )( t)el A./ - v i ei e l d e /t A 40 , 1 * A / 161 c o / 1 s ' ~ l ' c i e 11 ) . S e c -r o4 R ; 31 , -r t, 5 04 ) f il e C L c C a s e l . 14 a // C ( / ' / _11 : 4 A I n c i v e t k e c ij k r t p I o s e614 . # / p4 c t he a c a t s e c f c A ppea ( ( 2 . 4 d 4e4 ' end )` 0,1 p € 50 / 1 q / i c t b y c o m e I; c l e i t i a 4 t/ t he i no r t o w a4 9 , 6 1 1 4 5 e a t i e a c c a e c t i k o i c ap , ' ( . 15 * - 110 / 14 - ea c e - 1 - 0 - e c t M e m ee - t aho r eda v i c e f o ha v e p i r o r e c ; e l e : V I/ e y P U b li ? ( A ^[3] ; ± / l e , S , S e5 ^[17] ^[1] ^[111] ^[1] S . behed i ^[0] , 4d ^[0] ,

b y o v ? p ' e m / pa r i , a ) I ll & c a l / 14 - X o C M a i d

;

51 - a c 4

( 3 , ( T ee i e ; 5 - 416e3ed c r) : 91 t o bee m eo f e l " \ r t 4ed i s j e r . - 1 - d b . li m i e A ( A c i A i C c g t he C e t u t 5 - e S - P o ( w kc i e l t he de - c e A d6 m f - M a y 00 - 16 t // 7 - C ou c - f e e / i f A /t i e / W e / i t / 4041 - 6 v 7 cz C o45 - 6 `) - ( 4 . - f l o / i A (- 1 - i c l e 11 S e c f: o / )

k I L V . / v o r e i t c e t - i s ) . ) 00 / be dep c : v ed D ue p t o c e S 1 : W + y j o r p m p t e (-)- y t i on ' t ho w i d ' 0 16 t € p r o c e SS n - P o P

*15 C o A s 4

)

0 > - 7 - C ou f - 0 , 1 A / e v e / i d / I n e f r f r l /tf l oa t a i no t A . ( 4 ) 1 1e ) 1 ) S e6 + ; ( 5 . 4 ) 0 cv l f d ge c hb f l 8 / ( e k 9h + S ed W o r ed t / 0 , R ; _31 / - i - a p r ; v 610 , ; 44 ; v : c 144 , 1 p I; v 6 r y ; s e sc R 4 - i - k A ) t o t k e t A / e / l be l ' A s y o - P a - P f ee S n c ; c + y a r- i d s ha l t no - t b e:7 ► -Cr;/-13ed w i k t hou t - t h e . .. $ ) i o t - t i t t n y 2 - 0 a . c o / v i peo ° 49

,

` A t e i o s S e C i - ; O r l 11 . S ea t r c be S o t AV S e ; z a i e š . 71 - y e peop l e -

S

hq I ? be s e c u r e l ' i n I li e ft r pe r ; 50e13 papee s , k e y ne l Z S 0 1 / b d e f - C e C - 15 + 7 47 9 / 1 1 o l A r ea s o , ? 4 , N e S ea , r dee s o t A c i S e i z a i e c A 00 t A l e t a t v i t f c S ee t r c h y p l a t c e ) a r

s

e z e

?

m o t ) t be ' ep - y ) S ha l t i t s S k e k 9 1 ) 1110144 - po c e t o be c ee k t r c hed o f e t he de sc , ( ;/ -) i ' A i pe

c

e s o f, ( 114 ,/ i y b e s e 1 ` z - 40 1 , c

1

- t h c a t p ,t obah l e

c

au s e ) s uppon t ed c a T h i c e a - P - C r i v i c t i . 104 r egdu C ed

G

o n W e i s , AA ' n4 -) i t . t x ) e y i c i r /t e4 - t - / 1 / 1 07 / - M A q C O S ' i l ± k t; 04 1 il e - I li c k 11 ) s ed ; 07 i V i T h e . e t i t,/ v i e r a . - t i ' 0 / ) 1 > ) -ill C O S - 1 . ) 1 7 1 - 6 ( 1 1 9 0 / ) o c e r i a i > )

(

I s t l k - t: S II . 401

-

ue o 4 ) / 1

•

d i ' sv a r a q e c i a - t a ) e d b i

-

t e eo C ..

P

? ) *16 3oV3 Coi) +0,1-;o77 -

A(4kle V ii) 5ec-7,-;0/) 11

dorytornezeia Co4C+ R•e/lioval arici

(I) kg;sioluee sl-tall create a Ju41? ;a/

-ei've pe6045

Si-a/lc/Girds cryvvvi;s5167c04.5:5-Ii`/).7 othooLiteeliem - -thereto 0-e - 11.00 cvid"p(ov•IVe -rcyr

(asijesic e ai-ia(tey,o/id --/-1430 wi-io cue Ael'Mee Jaels4s 4cr (2? The 643/y7p1:5•50`0,/ .S'Act ;//vesi elie Co/teip/a,',/-risi a/K1 />=Ipiefrlem-,:i)s-1-211`5 geciloA, ,T4 /14ctY moke eeve.

skbpde-9a wii-/-Aeges

chatme415.

(3) ikpc3/1 e see,1/viee41•4/ctIli fC(7(51) t Commiss;( )-The soip(e^e Court /via>/: (11) Re•Crg cv))/ Juš-Hce (3( Ac1,94 -rorci/ccOol)IV -9374J- pef-Por4A6t4ce seri'aus/y ,te-ytegereŠ. u):791 WS c/a-645 cod Is (mot)/ become pee/vicvext; ®r

(3 61645Pirei SoLgpe4d) o cefriove 0.AySt5ttee de jtic e -co.( wi'llioweiti/5cork/14c1. I>) (5-creei, IA); )W14 ciAd pets,Vecil -Po/ him 1-ic Re trfofervt 11; S dt/ti-i`eS,) vbiel'opi 124) ca4645

Judt'da)

ethi?Sarbjateti

.setiptexie caw*

-Ole State or /14443-4<a,

19)6ib/Ykei I /111+empatbk e.

*17 iiave bee77 -1', 17;71 . 5 to ..(e,Alov~ slepir)(7,7-)i`e

tick4:yht

AR3v51 -- o-C . 2(321. on '1)612/ co.ltac-1-ed - tine lawyer ha( or /via/1 tot/1(1 abotd. s-tephot4;e, Acieic/11:9h-7'. - 1 - 6 11 1 C( 2y about Same or Ike -fil:43.c. Ta4/1 qc),/? . g) avec here:. d7) (4/3o/a I,, s-frephovit'e

Ju

c\ fie L a 6p r I s t ) ( 31 4 M 7 ) o t - t a k e a / Y l e t r i o til

f

k 4 " 1 "

E

A - . 1 ) . ( ii ) k , C m A e v o s o k i - * - 1 - 0

R ; \ 9 . h - t c t - P t e r C o lt & _ I - 1 . 661 c - t A e e K a t , t ) / A D . 4 561141* , s t ph e m it uyh e t ) a S k e d w hy s k e

-

1 - 0 - 11 , N e e s a ; 7 li no t t i k t , itt s - 1 - ho t s C l a l - CC ( v I C y e r C U S C , + a l k R eez i l t a t r n i e l k e - 0 ( o : rfr i p / A b i; c . D e - C e t ) c l e r g 06014 : 7 4 ( v ) C i ti e : ( o r i

.

-

t e pkv a . e a s k e v i d e . t o j e - c ) o r a ce , o - ;/ ) k i a ti . s ,

s

o s h e c ouh i t ood f 0 , s o ( 7 , T e . k . e l; ( e - 05 ( 3 / )

ca

s e s , _56 , ^[6] , ,!),put,:b0;e k ) e op f il , ' , ; 7 ( 40 ( 4 . e 3 c / 7 - w e t 5 & l e 4 / 104 t h ,

49

/ v i e s ce a e l f t ^[10] `f l O t ^[7] S b e t b r e . g titt o i • i T h e i 1 - k e r- z i s h e a l/ /

)

01 ' do , $o . S l n e 41156 () e v e r 5ub / y i a ' . . / - 4 , e d

/

v i c - 1 - i ' a i h e 4 ( 1 2 . 5 , S h e

710*

, 3 e - 1 - . e oy a

c

o c t r " , .. . 4 i; 46 t - t e 5 , _

(

D e b t r a p ea l y . ) _ h a 5 po w e r 04 7 t w / I . e Y i n / 1y i e 3 a ti . 714 a - O e 4 . b1 A - 1 '

g

' C e 1 , ‘ l e v ; n l e . " 4 - 4 a c e e l e W ? f l e - 7 ) p i L e t a - 7

c

t S c • C a _ (r a i e x a 1 ` c ( 0 • - 1 - I A L A ) ( 0 - 1 - v ti a , 5 ( 1 " i/t ' ( 7 10 2 k t S 6 7 ' S ce u , / e l ! . w e - 1 - t a ) k a l o t (- + . 6 r z o / - I - 49 . F e t I ii r i - I ' - 16 -- I - ' , s " L e ' a - e D (I C 16 ' 114 ) 1 r) i f--- ? 0 , 51 D

r

c a /l e ^[0] 1 e e t C S O 4 . ' e r) C - f n e • V b e i o , i - - '' , 01 / 0 eec o e i c m - i r — 4 a 0 5 1 t C e k . f 0 r 4 1 i d * I Y S e ) . e ' d e s c l: c ' c ) ( 3 / 1 r e A i )) 01 - / 1 h e ! ' a ( e ) li r A e e • I ! I I a e i . t e C A t e C a ' e , e d ec i __ - 2 e - 07 - 1 c O + A i x e r n i l I d d e l *19 3 ; o f 1 2 a

v

e ( * l e o , - 1 , -- v o ' bu ß pope t aoa r k . T h , ' Š w a s be 1 , -) 1 14 5055 be c a t i 5e c C c o v i l d / 9 ' 60 , A c e r e l s ., „ T he i a , V , Y ; s - t i ' c l ph0 / 7e S a i d e t ha - t t he r a i v e r e5 c K a A

w

a . 0 - be , ? , C e c o ( ded , M e , a6 t e 1 i ' ö c an be pu r l ed • r i beq ---) ii -r _ t ( v ) , i 5 c a t i o t, C o c o f N a ii , 7116 ' e , 1 )- 1 e C cv i v e ( S a t ky l w a c v e - e Y ha r c i 1 - o hea l ' , D epha A l e 544 s k l e w t hu l d ha v e - t h e M v a - l - e d ' A v e5 - 1 - 0 ' jl a t o r

-

f o m e , ' " o l 0 1 / 4 _ s ' e e ,f 4 7e ,, T 11 , ' S s t i V ) h oL c ' f l a t h ' zc i ppeeg t l i e da l e - t oda y ; g 4 2 / 2 7 / 2 ) , 711 ; 5 de r f c S a ;,,, i 6 e v V e 4 : S - t )-- i e a t e ll y . 1 , ` m e y ha v e ,.. - e t i k ed W i ' il t i S f epb w il ' e a - I ' - p i a i ' - pa i c i t -r o , r a t a v - 1 . - 2 / 1104 tf ii 5e I . 5 + ; 1 ) ha v e / 104 k eeee l 4 i be t o i ft an c ( 4 ) ;f )- 1 he t s l ; nee - I li e / 16 . 1 i : J e4 -- i - - t o . C ou r t a - C e t,,I, / 1 -

f - e _ & ,

(

7 e / e l o v i c l R i ck s o k i , k ' c l A c i B ( ‘ ' - 00 1 , e l y 1 , w i ' f i c t m C c o m ( g ., / 1 , -) . s li e g i a r f ed - - i - e103 I i ; l e Jc i dge - i - k i c r i • I. S / 1604 / sky i f ‘

e i s he L Q 101 . 4 , 4 ) 01 0 , , ) e - m a r e ' ) . 14 / 7 4 e a f r i , u 5 l e t e e / v i e c i ep li o v i ; c ,t 1 - l e s f q - i - e C B < O W . a4 , y t w ill e v o s u „- 14 J udge La e s o / 1 A g r eed li l a - 7 ' - , 4e iiii e r pa r t y ha 5 a / v ) e 4 - i a l 4964 ; e o ( d ; s o r de r I s S ue c o , i c e7 i , ,.. 9 - t b c

e

- C e / i g o v - i - t cz / V 40 e x a r i e - G - 0 , 1 -- i t o , n ; D e ( e l goa , i - i - 4 - 0 )( A 1 / 6 - 14 - 20 1 , 4 t A i d i b e t ep t 0 - ed r c ' cc / t i e l - ed a4 / 077 o V e . 44 C A r Y a 0 . 71

s

ee 44 - k i c h m e41 ' ' l a / v i e d () A k i A - i , R 16 T e 1 5 ) . S t e p h a t e 4 - ; a t ) : d o o l o p e l ( c a t - f il e 1 , - 1 ,,, ua 5 1 , , d m a t oo i ' e l c ,. . c - t e tt e , 1 ., 0 ) ,: 0 -- , ; 5 * e l o t 4 - 4 4 e . s i e p A a o 4 ; e _

; 5 t i o - f - e a I k o i s e c f , A i e f i l a ) H e . 6111 - 1 P i c - P e c i < S : t 1 , -- i n ) a l r A _ 2 - 7 , 1 . 0 / % 1 *20 1 ( ok 12 , S k ou t 5 -r i -r e D e - N i -) : ± l o p o . ) a tl e r ti m / k en w i p r e . )-( € . 5 ; a r i a i e s ee / v I c ii e t eg s he ► s ? r oad I ha v e c o ( 11 - 61a - e d . 1 )-- t e ,t i o rr t a A c t J a w y e , ( 1 ba r a ; e i d ha v e bee7 i , * 0 / 14 , c i - kk e he t O r g / 0 c o S ' e c o D i e l S o k i - N - S m

-

. ii - t e S a m c he m 4? X t A ) 4 c - C tt 4o p r o c eed ' P i o t w a S 0 / 1 / 1 // 972 /, S u l y e i a sc i n sc i , ' 4 he W o t il d , v i - 1 - * I k e 5 - 1 - ep i c ( 4 ; l r y - CC / o y c a S e s , z ha , d * L I k J + k i e - . ( b t e abou , - // A i / p r oh ) e / v i s a ( i d 1_ + C ? ' € d l t " C , S i n O W W / v l GO / A / 7 y C o / 1 - r 1 ; ( - 1 s r e i b r i - S C c ee a - f - M e . h - m e i r t S ) , V 9014 u6 l a s , - 20 -- t M e --( ' ( I ' S - 1 - . 1 -- ; f i l e 1 t o l c / k ili en a tt r € 44 ' . . f M e / v ) , . 1 ' P l a c l - i - o a S K 1 -- 7 / s / v 1 - 1 - 0 b - e po s e ) , K en10 1 _ . T w o r)- 1 ' a c o t i - C 1 1 1 6 - / - a - O a r 7 i f y

B

e c au c e s t ep f r o v o ' - e A z i ck

h - i - ha S bee ) i y , r 25 N u l - hpe - - 1 , 41e c ^[4] C p 7 a m e , - o v ? d c l o ili s o A o r ii , A y

.;

2 " ha v e a s ii r e c i a l ; hg E m ) . 5 v ; ( 1 . m e a ) 1 / 6 t c i f e r oa l e c i‘ e - V e4 S e , - 11 ; 5 ' s a O ck l - ho o - f i ne s > ? / 9 -) A v y w k i / v ) e / i i t a A d - f A e / v i en - i - c t/ i e t c 6 / ) sy - , ( t i , t V an

. - A N i t O e il i s e c ± ; 01 . 2 4 ., /, l udge La r s a f 7 sc o ' d k ) e 6 } 00 ) . , S e r q m e a 11 p6 ! qe_ pe w k e i 7 L o s ee i ' c 1 ac ti d 4 0 s op i r li t c - c o c i f t : i e s 4 c l ee k ji ' v e D eb r a pe ( c i c t / v ) e m o r oo ‹ l o t/ v i s e v i e f i s -- f r ho r t 1 . 00 ( s a i w ood r 10 - 3 - s e4 v 1 I - f r 140 ( 1 - 1 - 1 // k e_ ( 6 & t k i s e - P ( 3 0 . 1 , - 1 ' f i l e . s t o r k e ho s p ; l a / - ii no r- f r i o k / v i -- c . i ' - 1p peo c ee i , D r 5 c a l a - t - ? - ; 0 ; 01 z L i aa 5 -( 7 ) ' t - f ® . T h r o c e ' e & 6 t/ W had a 300 v , e v k il e r . V o o do a i $e . l a w , f i e a I 5 o s a t ' d 1 , 1 a p e ,, i r o k i v - f k i a . - h r i _L T w e , ( 5 # ` , 0 1 a 616 1 , ; - ) , V c s l y / 7 ' e ; * t i o a 5

• 0 ( 1 Y a • # r i L v I P T A , A ^[7] . ^[1] . :/ ^[41] e , . n ^[1] ) *21 5

,

4 ' ) 2

V

o l o t - t; c 7 ) a /t/t c 4 q6 - I 5 - 213 )( sc e A c tf c o c f e s ) . ( 101 A ; 1 h , ' S s f a t e , m e4 ( . ( t/ ) tt S ed a - f - I c a e t ) a a : 051

be

./ v t e . ( ee M C A c ode s A c t i c ii o ) . ./ v e t y - rr i ' o t ) / l a s b ee n pe S t p c m ed f l l t o v e .. r , L i t / 00 ,.; -) r l h s , - T h ; 3 I ' s & V o l o v f i c / 1 a / 4 / Z 4 2 , .: 4 - - 3 ) . - 703 6 t 7 ill A d t c 4 ' : v - :; --

,,,,

) / - 705 : ( 5e e - , ft i ( C / 1 c ode s ) ,. 7 ' ^ t ) 50 / 14 ,

,

s pe ,,. ed y - t ( 6 : 0_ . ii

R

i : g l ed s ha v e 17een v i b ) a - t ed a il de ( - t he A / 1 071 - 1 - a /t a C o s , ` ' - f e i t - 1 - - ; 0 , - - ) A r f : c i e n 3 e c f; c 5 / 1 2 . / . A . on e

1 a 1 - A e i nea r ;/ - ) g . s J ad3e , 1 c 14 - 50 / 1 - i - o k i 1 3 ( N r i c t/ l y L

w

a i d i e l s . 46 po ll a ll f il e K - r f a l H ea K . f e c ad s f i f i a - t - 11 ; 10 / A - 461 / 0 bou l - , W il C r t -- t he Y a ii e P u ili > j

A

I ' s pe f, , N , 0 - c c 1 / 7 a l 5011 e A c e i , - 1 ' a 4 i - C - C 6 r e7? : 1 - . 61 A ( . - 1 - ., ^[7] ^[6] ( / 56 - 11 -) e . 5 C A / w 44 - 461 / i ; ' ea k t h C e c o ( VS ha V e po f i c e 5 - 0 - 1 - e l v i m t / I / ^[7] - t i ge , S O b y pu 1 11 ,f ) , 3 - t k e5e

-r

e c o ( d_ c i j ill e & O l e . ho c C O 0 l a - l - o v f i A il c n - q6 - 13 - li o a4 c / 10_1e q o ill ) m f g . E , ( s ee 0 , - i , - v ; b1 A . po pen ) . T h? ,,. c ou rr . s / l e v e l a S k e r i P o r

j

o l i ne r a ( l d ge v e ( o v i c e

o

r O V e A s e s p i t e s i b t an# + 0 d i v i c il t 1 , 6 - I i - d i c e 6 e / 6 - / 3 - 2 / 0 ) - t i ,,, , ) 02 )- ii ( c oo , n m .. 44 - b : & ii < D A , bo r e ) k - f l e i : ' < ^[7] - ^[4] , e1 , ^[14] Q / Z O . c e '' t - _

...

, . .. - i be y m T h ' s ; s s e + - f o r + ( ad 0 (-) 1 / e2 . 0 2 . ( i eed

t

k e i 3 .. - , 1 4 - 1 , p e 7 11 ,, e . C o A C A " v 7 ; A t/t il e . - - t - m e x L A .. ) ; /f r i f eq cy t

r

P l ea s e - H I

-

t o p v l e , . i cc o l p r o v e t m * e A L ` t , ,, ,

S

o m e i n . k ? I be c a c t ü9 : 4 - /; ( 3 7 ,, :I i , A ., 4 AS ;/ #1 a d s 4 T e ' r e4 +

ss

i c t 4 - e l I L AS H b c ; 4 1 f. a & t he w ; e csc i pe?

.

s o t O e l l ' e li t i l e ' s e / v e c t - f ' o r . 0 - P C i ' c e r ( A l a ) S c i i d . , r • e 4 i ; i - c e 1 , ? 0 b h e ) p c 0

m

e ( 13 - t k ;f i q I n e k e i c - P I C li t l e c c ii p a r t 5 ( s e e & o f f

L

A } e ' c i n rr s a r i c 4 - 6 1 0 , - 1 - 4 q 0 - i t l f *22 fr Ok f: T h e a t ( li - š c e1 ) ph0 , 4 , ck i l r . - / i N t y - p - S ii ; e1 . - P r e W e o

ill

e , op c , 1?6 ,, c & o rr , v t a i de . A 44 ) - 1 - 1 ) 31 ) e - e c { i s e S i - w i v -

e / O s c t ba c i - - t ha t i n egh t. o - P r o t c ee 6 - o c e S a i d - t he v e k ii ` de w a s i / v i / v I e s ill a t e l y de sc ebed ( . 4 ) l ' ii f ) e c ego c ) • -r e ' s - i V a ll ' o r i M I 5 C e k t i d 4o -r il a v e

he

i pp , e r 7ed e c a t 6e . 911 e s - i d i go f , A - t y p ) a - t e

A

w l , . ' i . e s ( a l e ( ' a il li ne o - C ' c e t s

. ge r t - t o m y hou , ( e .

(

s e e9 / 1 c a l l l o ) , H e 6 ( 150 S a i ' d - t h a * ./ v t y d a d t e og 41 - 47 ' 0 t k e hou s ' e -) ' oge s t t A e k n ; - ( ' e be / 11 - 1 ) nen c o l ' d he w e / r t l ' , 140 - ii ne hda . r e , t 4 ) ; 111 m y c i ao? ,

0

7 0 f r o k iil t o . ' 1 P a k 6 r . s a .;, 1 : 1 + o l d ' t he A 4 - N / N a t i

u t ) l ed a k 7 ; 4 - ? € 111011 . p r + t A k A 5 . i r- - ) i M e hou5e , " , 1 - N ne y C ou l d s o i .: e7 . 51de a4 c 119 t e# ; 4 ' , M e s e

s t o r f e ,,, y l e f ) i - c m A c t ÷ I r t A c e a i - a i I ,, X - 16 I S * l e / 14 t lil k I C : 014 . 1 c 1 A c 2 , 1 2 S a t e C k i du i d - . 2 - d t ' d e l o f 6e A , V e a k ili T e o r i i n i e , T he o4 ; c e r ' s C o d tt e - t ed a bu ll ea s odo i c t i ,/ e s ea r c h cv 7 d . s e ; • 2u t r e . 1 ( * s ee M o r t c

• v / v eo ' s s , 20 ii 7 /t 4 . - r 1 2 51396 / 1 10 4 - k . )) . 1 - H 3 D , 3d q - 35 - ) . f i f:; i e3 cc ue + ha s T ' t i r - f li e r h e l d ) a c i d - P e A k i v r t ' s

16

: 9111 10 p r o ' v e kcy ; s a c e li ded ¿ o l de r + ii e e , x pe w ded

p

f i v o t cy 6 1 3 h 1 oode ( A (- f k l e . 8 ) 5e c ii ' d - i o o v I c i )) .

(

A J ) , 1 6 - 7 - o l e t pe r i - p t r e 04 ) i A - tI r e A ckv , d s A o l r ea sc oab i e j e v e / q W I ' ? ' ^[7] ^[1] po i ; C e " l a v e a v a l ; c 1 / 7 ) . ) e k 1 h c a s : s 1 0

a c l • . 5 - a r c a I C a ( '

v

o 1 da e 0 ,f ' e - k i ` c i e ii e c p t v ) / 0 6 1 ii i c >

I

a be a ® r a e f A l a e l C t i s o ( S e e - s i ck i r e e x e e l • k 1 : 4q v D ; s r ; c . c o w l 0 9 2 4 1 70 A e l c y r k . / 94 196 7 , 2 2 4 P . . 2 P 62 , 2a4 , 6 )( A : c c a & o v g *23 70;" IZ /KV " r + i c i e li 6 s - e c . r i a , " 7 7 a t k e M g9 / 1 / 10 A l a / I c i C on s - i - 89u - i/ 0 / 7 „ W h I t c h ; S 4e r il - - 8 c a 1 - k 1 A \ r i ' ; c i e n ) s e c han 0 o f t he 197 z . / v f o e - q - c v i c L C aea f e ' s -fr a t e b / 1 ) E - T k e p C OU P + 61 ) 50 h a S i c . ) 43 r ec og / A ; ze d il ( 701 - f - - T h e p C o - i - e d ; c 3 , -) a go e t/ ss * t AA tf r d . s o tI c t W e S v a t c h e S and • S o ' zk ee s p l ed y e ' s ; a t " : 0 ,7 . . " e w e i e t a il c l ' s , C a t L s t i t t a t i b i n i ppbe , S da , a li pepp l e e tt i d 1 - 14e i ' e ho f r i e s a /l az i e ff ec t s ) w i ' 1170 / 0 1 - r e s aa - t o a i e l - i l e , ( CC : A - 1 ; 7 ) c l ) c c od t t e l ; s ; p1 v o l v ed . - 1 1 m ; s 19e . 1 1 / 1 . 9 . S e t, ' d t h e 0 - c - C ; ce f ' s , V ook i f ec ii M e r ou liii A m e r / VA I e4 - 7L a r e? d : T he / 1 , 10 / 29 1 - 617 7 a c o , 5 - 6 - 1 - 0 - 61 - 1 ,,f rr - f - ; c ) e P i ge r - f l i c i h9 a t e i d s e c ii ' c o A M e i c i ae / v u t s + be 5opp ( e s S e c i a tt i e r / vc il - q6 - 13 - 302 . ( s ee . )- 1 , 161 a i de s ) . i : k e S a i i ' c d c 2 i gov e - a - f ) ( c ee &V I o t A c i bo i

e i v u li c I P . 0 - A du /t 14 ; p ) e - C c t i ge a k eee • m ee i t abou l W il e y * X S o l/ dn T he y - t he A l po r ee Q ( * 0 F ue s - a v i A g 4600 . - w ha t * , -- 24pp f e l e c i ; e ' A ili ' - f k o m - i - x r ead i ! ii m e m y 113 k r / ' s N r e p ; r e c t by r v t;t a f kk t . T h e s / m a i k e s a ll M e s k t i t/t i m i r l i k ,t he h - e ( ' t a t e o r t c do - I - _ I 7 i v o l t i v r t a i r Y m c i / 1 / 1 --( bLe b v i c i r / d i m 4 16 - / 3 - 3o / ( S ee m e A c o d e SAA il y c i tt e p i b c e s S - C ; 3 ha v e c ~ . 6 S © I v e / 2

Lo c i ( a be -- t i n c - C c i t d - - t ee / r t h A / li e A de t r f r o v i c l / 1 - 10 - t a t ‘ a ( c o s H i r ed1 ( 3 / 1 A e - 1 - 1? l e 11 . ,, S e c - 1 - 1 ` o , - ) - 17 A ) S o ( S ee A l : C a / i c i a V A r : z o t l a . _ 3 V 1 U . 54 1 . 34 , 1 6 S o C 1 16 O . 2 ) 16 1 . E d , 2 c l 6 9 1 / ( 1966 ) . a T h e ; 4 v 4 ; r y - I s

L A g - iil e , ( 4 - t h e O a r / 10 , - 75 5 - r ea s o c l - i t h l y C o A v e X o i b a 56 15 ' pe d ' # ( 1 5 f e l p i 7 1 ' s -r ee t k ; i - ed b y A i t ?o o d a c - 11 / w a S S o , o ' d f e - 7 ( 1 , , )( 1 c f _ d oe - t h V E a S a / l ) ¿ N I V , S . / c i , / 03 . ) d c i . r + . 2 P 74 T h e . I . gd . / e i "

*24 8 , 0 C 12 . ) 64 ‘ 0989 ) p T he pah ` c e - 1 - 001 ‹ A i y p M cv l e , be c k 5e .

I

sc t i ' d 1 - 1 , l eee w ag a r e c o r d ; ( 79 o - e t, oho i t he4ppe4e ( 1 ,

.

T he y 1 .t ) ; II t i o - i - y e w ; • - i • ( A , V 1 - 12 i v t e „ o r ob r a ; i ) a .

Loa

(r o v - T + - P ® 46 l ' - i -- , M e s t a l t 60 d ii v i r i m o y e r ; s

d

c ,t o s 1 - 4 k e S o vv w f i na ' 71 " A C 6 4 ( v i t ' / - 761 . ) de - ee y l c i a r t ha5 a ( - 0715 - 0 ( 41 - ; 0 (-- 4 ./ 16 : g - t t o ob l a ;t 1 e X a t 1 W o r Y e v ,t o l ee l c e a il c i e l e ii ! o t 1 04 ' t h t ' s 63 P -r t I s a v ; o1a - F ; on c C d e t t e . p r i Y e s S " ( s ee V a c t e v ß e i s a r de ) / 9 9 8 A i rr

/

52 ) 11 / 6 , 2 S 9 , 01 - 1044 . 57 ) % 2 P ., c f 6 • 71 ) , . r .,

.

) S o

c

d i - I ii en c il . c oe7 i r t e s t a - t e o r r i v i y l a w y e r i - ® ob t a ii n V c i e f, c A 7 I d o il t d i b 4 2 ( b yv i / v ii ' S . s ou k t c a ,t, -) . - t y J a ; )

S

M o t 4 ) ; ( 19 c i e - t e r- f i V e 1 q , 16 (-) k a S oe - 8 t.t xv i - N i e l / v i y . c e v i p k i c t e ss c ode , s o l e l e c ou w

l

d v i e 1 c e o c o ?4 i a s li e , e1 A i , m e de + ee - H v e 71 - 1e / e ) a S i c e ll A il Y

/

v ) c r k he r ( D eb i b t pea % ) - P o ( i ' l % ( s ee i e t A ( 6 - a i ' v e X v s M t e , _2o i t,/,, 07 - ) 89 , i v ) 6 ) 375 M o i o r l , 996 ) 329 po3d 3 7 76 ) . " , - ;I ii a ll ( 6 ' m i ena / c a s e s F 101 , -- y e p r o S e c t 6 ; c o

h

o t 5 ! d e l i - e s - l e t 1 p 1 1 5 % ed d i dd y - k o - p p v i t i c i e - r o t h e

. de - C 4 , 75e o v ) Y e k r e4 I pa i n y e A r o r o V ea C k e r i e ll - e v ; de , i c e ; e l i ' . 7 ' ,

p

b sc e ss i )( m ' ,I i k e i e ho C bee v ii

a

vs ' o / a - / - ; 07 - ‘ 04? f k e pee / 14 ; 507 / e “ s e 5 f o ( ' c t e r t t e k A v i c i t 6 - 1 - 102 . ( 6 ) C 5e € C A : C O : 16 S ) , 04 1 ; ( e l r g c t i C r I c t i o t A ) > I s / vk A de e t/ - 4 . ( e 5 e / 7 1 k e d - f i n e N ba b i e c o t i t c e A -r- C i V e m ` l - -- C a s o y t o p m c i o s I x A l : 5 k a d t il e peo , , s e c t A t i o li ; A l e - e ; 1 1 ( 7 s C a . ( g e S 0 - C - ( i c e ( '

e s t S ( A t l i " , 0 ( A - 3 - P o l i s - r 7 ) " t O w

i

l i o ( p V l i e o i A l o t q 5 - 7 ® 2 . 0 3 ( ) )( B ) ( 5ee , , , t 1 c # c o d e s ) , H P C 6 A ( . o . n . ged - il e l p C I O - A l : k g i ) e i h i t ' a d v g r i 1 0 r A f i r *25 c

i

o c i ; i d ; -(- c ' e r e c i -- S i c r t e m e A r t S , o ( l e 7 0 l e Š l oe y ho S , C a m d o tt - t w k e4 71 / 11 ' i c e s a - 1 - ; #4 - t e i t v i t e w ed c t ga l e r) , c - c - C : C e f i x ii eh - ( ae li y pa l a l e c . )-( ) A - 0 % s S i z a l t v e m . ; A + A e K o ba k e ( a u5e A O ' ; c i ao ' - 17 ( s ee A c eda v il ) , A l I 04? - H i e c f , e . - ( S . a i f i c i a / v r a ' ss ; oe f i s a : r e p2 ( * c 5 - c t k l e aq40 ) e t Y . . c a r li r cv , , v t c 4 - 26 - / - / 01 ( s e t ? m a - f C o v i e S ) . m y a il ii ' , S ' ; O n 5 t i e v e ( A r t ac k ; i ' 77 oe K o b o W e . c au f A 5e A f " -( 5 ; 4 06 1 . V - 1 , - - i nn e y 4 ) s c 71 e v e -r

•

s a i d o v l y ili t i g abo l e t i 4 t, oha l 4 - i > il e ; # - A e4p R e A N G A i e r t e i ' -) . - ha ppo i c . L ; c i a t 1 - C - 11 - l e r e bee f ) , 4 , 4 ( yq ... ko fr t e o f 41 , ' i ce ,. ,. , : - . 11 Š o • Q t -- , 44 , 1 - a l s a * , ;. C ' I ll ea .. ) , t i oa c ,. , a u i e op c 4 r op - y r ; S ca l ed , -r k ., - ,, s ,,.; s - c e ' t ' , v ; o ' i a - W a , -) o c D e r e f l ce c t _9 : a s . , 15 - 1 - oede r i / v I c r e t 27 k l ( 1

- / 006 a f i d bo t h q o i c e i s

-

a N r e 360 ' HY Q - C " T A / v i p e ( 14 e4 ) / ( 11 " , 0 r- C ab c ; c a - t; 773 . P h ys i ' ea t e v i V ee i c e i t l e4 t / S - 7 - . 207 ( 00q )( 13 ) ( s ee • i tI C A . c ode s ) T i ne m L t 3e z ne t/ e f S c t E T C i t e f d "

c f( . ^[7] , , ^[1] ( 1 e / x / r o e tf. i e 1 - 1

b

t i - e A l o t e e v i de n c e 5 050 , > ) 15 - , . A /I: k e b c i l i c e d - H i e r t o A l e s a c t - t. A i ) - 14 -) e l a w c od c o ( I s illi t 411077 -r i gh l k S

v i l a l e c t i ' 04 , 15 c t. r e c a t .t i > ii - t h e d ; s /f r k - 1 - _ c a v i - t o p ( o C ee c i o r i c i e r a A r G S - l ea k e a c / au & w h i d r) i s

t i c ' ,,/ a r o c ' i n ' c c a e ' . 1 . : v ' e ) ' 04 S C

t

a / 1 ) e ) S . - b i - t t d ^[10] A A r - e / / E l e - W I

u

. .. .. , n e i a c e , l e i - f e c L i k l e s u P t e e . r i ` c l ' o r i A nn4 - # . / . ^[1] c A - ^[1] : Q C ou r 4 1 / e _ t l y *26 l O o f l . I M e o , ,,,. ) r y pa C i b i e I l e / b i e c i r ( s ee S I - n i t y l k V 6e v - b ' l - e d 5 . - k " f e5 j e - / a u s ' , ( 13 1 1 : d ge / g 93 S i d ; v 2 ‘ 0 ;, - 163 ) 37 L i 5d , . 2d 5 - 6 ( ) 97 ) , il na s o r e f --- i r e t e / r i t I ' s de l - a i l n I - l ' > - 23 " v i e 01 , s e i t 0 - , ( ' pe i o l y ab / e c e tt 45 S Le t ) ? ( 1 : 6 ) / 1 ; s a V e l a l a t ; a t, ( n i , t e - c ' ou r f i e i A m e r i s m e A t ( s ee ij a k / v I cx - k . e I ) 1 2 0 ; - / - 1 ( 0 , 4e e v c ; c t y 0 - c J a i 1 l e t 1 44 ;, c q e l , a t / v o ill - 9 4 / 9 ‘ u / 1 : - / - e Q / . c - f vc i e s

. S a p ( e / w i e c o l A t e - 1 - . / v i a i c h 2 1 ) 2 o / 1 ) , A s t e r i e ( t ed l ' on c n i o s e cc a cc p ( e i r t a i c l e f i f eo r t; a1 C a t i v i t o i a t e

i -- K i e c o t A M I A r ti e 4 c f A il e m itl e 4 - 041 y W i e / - 1 i ' I s - P eeee c i e5 ) b t i t ' a i s o w hen ; -- h r o li o t o S , ) - A l e V i e t o - P l ega l p t bee s t, M e f o tt e t h ?4 , 4 - 2e , i ( V i /t e A t p r oh i b i t ) : go v e mm e t h - o r-r i ' c l o ) s , W o m de t m 4 - ge v a . r ee456 , 1 a t 9 s e , p - f r peaòab l e c a t t 5e a il ð w he i e l ega 1 pee3 c 7 S P I A 5 go cv e - C - o r boae li t d i t i ha C < 1 0 , e ( - 0 - 1111 / -)

-- t - o . e 0 ,, c a k e , c e ( 5 / v i A ) 37 s , ( 1 - . 9 N 1 ; -)- C an A o s r e x 9 - ; i 5 P b t, ; 5h ( i . de * c li l i c e . - ' 5 - P a tt r - li n A d A t i q A c i m e , 4 Y e o c k , > v z . V i e e n / 9 S e e . + / n e t - i - " - n - i c e ccy t s - / - ) V - 4 A - 60 / 01 peoe c l Ì o a

e V e7 ) ‘ pp / y c . 4 - e l e i - t he S l ae l o c " i ego t/ p c o c e s 5 " , (-) a C r i ` m ii c i ) 1 C - e l . ( ' . e e A 166 ' 0 117 ' V o ) ; v , e6 6 l o u , S 266 ) 27 z 1 ) 1 / 4 / S Z - t S o 1 , 2? L E 990 s a ) I. 1 5 ) c e t 19 7 L i P c i t . 2 o t 312 ) 85 ( 1 , ' , L W , q ) 30 ) 2 . 6 F l a , k , w e e k l y f ed . 5 976 : ) , 24 F / a , L . W ee k / y k o l S Q 7 7 ) . C O ( 10 46 10 7 ) a il d ? t o y e r f b ( K . e I 44 7

. . .. . I c e - t i ne t e e t yc - t; 4 11 . 1 1 ; n i f i n t I o w e v e n , - , 5 4 - 49a c f i t 1 P . s t i n *27 ii

01

- ; ha v e an t s ,; 3n ,; -- N c e v ? c e ,, T h e y , r eq w ' r e I k e r i ne po k , 10 , L f i t o t, be c - V e

e

c i 04 ' - i - e r , M e s e c o t/ c l - I - f e ' a r ( - S ee ' K ea - t - i ' 76 v s i p l ea c c t F 75 i - v l o - 1 - , a ll eg i .. 2 t l i 92 1 1 F l o ( ) 2 , 97 i 1300 ( 19 K ) ,

--

" : - . 7 r P po cee d ec / f o ' i i c r ; c t ) o t 47 / w eee

c

o ti v ; c l e s 1 ) 1 , 4 caa l d ca pp ea ff o t A d r)- 14 D ccee - t

w

ou l d v eaca l e - 111 1 e ( 7073 , V c 1 ; 0 / 2 . 1 - 10 w e v e ( ; v a C a l ; ( 5 - n i e C o / I v i ? - f r i b i u u6 k / 7 / 4 0 7 ' C ho v ? e - r h e - c a C t t ha i ' Z " , ,,: ' - v i r l C 0 / 6 - 1 -- ;

- f; o4a1 3 ) 115 W c ee 1 © s v

e

j o k i c t

I

' l 1 k e a C r . o441196 , ,, , ' _61 i k i o i v e .., - / - a S ' il ) 4 , J 6 t 17 1 - ) 1 ( c u lli t i t k , -- C i aL S cvk i c d - 1e45 - 1 . cv i e op P eaL5 / 11 , 16 . ( 1 ) t i qe ane . aed v ; ( 71 , : f t il . - 8 - i e r ho r i b . T he s q - c r t e , ( ./ - K : r e

c oe i s t V - k i c i 0 ee o e 1 , 4 s S 6 ' e i r ( v i ed

*

Le i a -

m

o w ' , c

1

- t e ; ee s + a , V

V

. c - 1 -

I

' e t .. 5 g , m ee ii - , 3 6

3 t

i eo ( I 9o0 ) , J a , i e a m o v e s e ( 064 - 6

e

x e r t ° s e s m pe i ea v ; S o r ? ,

i e o i s e m e f i li m ee i tt o t , e , o1 , J ' a - t i n , P c A v r i t k ee

a

*28 0 * i )

(

3 ) sk i p / e k e - e -r o , ii be 4 , 72 s e / 1 - P t o

/

14 ' e l s

t

a l e ho s 1 - t - a l I - 1e - y e c bu r i t i r t il ^[1] ^[1] ^[1] ( ^[16] ^[1] ^[1] . t e s . c r o m a 11 3 c a e c 1 ( 5 ( A a ( ge a - C - C i C e c 3a k e r w e ' f - i - T 11 , e C c ( 1 67 -- i e s s l e w ' 1 ° r ? - 11 - 7 , 1 5 p o p e ( a r k / I t e t r / v i : r i o t i r ha C e A l p i o y / v I e t r i " - ; 71 1 / S i 7 l ge1 ) 7e j u t e I a r s o c -) - R o , r ( 4 )) 1 W u I / ( 41 ` s -

o / i k C e e a / 7 ck e x h ' o r i

H

, c l e01 , S e c t i o t )

A

. / o v e : -

c

li ' S / 1 " t i ' SS a k : v e C aa sc 4 - k > 4e , C S /t i c A Y 6 - 13 - ' 01 ( 0 , DC - 21 - 371 , D c - 21 - 4 0 C P - o t r j e e i v i ; k e bab i t c o Log " t h ASS aahL w t e i t h ( A / e c i P O 4 / 4 - -- . 213 )(( > 2 / ) v - v t I e f e5 ./ . . r o c # ,; 0 (- % 04 ) o r

-

7 - 0 , 4pe r ;/ ) ( 4 2 , 1 )-

d

e v ; c e Y . 6 - 6 - 10 6

,

a7 c / R o

J

a r ed ea

---

I M P O / ?4 , 0 R / r

p

r o s e / P e l Y 2 1 0 4 e f

FILED

*29 11/03/2021 Shidey Faust

CLERK

Missoula County District Court

STATE OF MONTANA

By:1 aim Driscoll

DC-32-2021-0000371-IN

^[1] Fourth Judicial District Larson, John W 14.00 Missoula County Courthouse Missoula, Montana 59802 ^[2] Telephone: (406) 258-4780 ^[3] ^[4] MONTANA FOURTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT ,MISSOULA COUNTY ^[5]

Dept. No. 3

STATE OF MONTANA,

Cause No. DC-21-371 Plaintiff,

OMNIBUS

HEARING and MEMORANDUM JARED GLENN BARTH, Defendant, The Prosecutor and the Defendant's counsel, by signing this memorandum, acknowledge that they have both read the omnibus hearing tatute, MCA 46-13-110, and are now prepared to discuskany pretrial matters in add‘tion to and including those matters listed in MCA 46-13-110. Our discussion of add subsequent agreement on these pretrial matters is summarized by this memoranduiln.

I. DISCOVERY

In compliance with MCA 46-15-322, the State shall immediately and on 1. a continuing basis: a. Disclose the names, addresses and statern9nts of the State's witnesses (including experts) that the State may call as witnesses in their case-in chief.

b. Disclose and make available for inspection ll physical or documentary evidence in the State's posses ion that the State may use at trial or which was obtained from or be onged to the

, Defendant. c. Disclose all oral, written or recorded statem+ts made by Defendant to investigating officers or to third persons. ^[1]

OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM

*30 d. Disclose all exculpatory evidence known to the State, including ^[2] evidence that would tend to reduce the Deiendant's potential sentence. ^[3] 2. In compliance with MCA 46-15-323, the Defendant shall, 30 days after arraignment, and on a continuing basis: a. Disclose the names, addresses and statements of the Defendant's witnesses (including experts) that the Deferdant may call in their case-in-chief.

b. Disclose and make available for inspection all physical or documentary evidence in the Defendant's pbssession that may be used at trial.

3. Initial discovery shall be completed by complete and on-going. Discovery disputes shall be raised no later than twenty-one (21) days prior to trial (or at the tirne of the final pre-trial, li/hichever is earlier);

11. CO-DEFENDANT(S)

The Defendant states that there is not a co- defendant in this case. The name(s)/cause number(s) of the co- defendant(s) is/are

Co-Defendant is represented by Co-Defendant is represented by

111. FITNESS TO PROCEED

The Defendant's fitness to proceed is at issue: ( )Yies (\iNo. If yes: a. A psychiatric examination of the Defendant skall be conducted by

(the State Hosp.ital) Name of Psychiatrist: Further orders:

OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM ^[2]

IV.

*31 INFORMANT, AND SURVEILLANCE INFORMANT: The State declares that a confidential informant was involved ( )Yes (X)No. If yes: The Informant will be called as a witness: ( )Yes ( )No The State has disclosed the informant's identity: ( )Yes ( )No The State will disclose the Informant's identity by: ELECTRONIC SURVEILLANCE: The State declares there has been

electronic surveillance of the Defendant or his premises: (X)Yes ( )No. lf yes: All material obtained by electronic surveillance has been supplied to the Defendant. DVD of body camera, in car video, audio recordings and photos.

V. SUPPRESSION MOTIONS

1. The Defendant moves, pursuant to MCA 46-13-302, to suppress physical evidence: ( )Yes ( ) No. lf yes: The Defendant's statement of facts and brief filed 1I?y: The State's brief filed by: ^[1] The Defendant's reply brief filed by: 2. The Defendant moves, pursuant to MCA 46-13-301, to suppress

Defendant's admission or confession: ( )Yes ( ) No lf yes: 'heofy\ie The Defendant's brief filed by: The State's brief filed by: Defendant's reply brief by:

(NOTE: The motions will be deemed submitted without a hearing unless a Request for Hearing is submitted prior to the end of the briefing period.) ^[3] OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM

VI. OTHER CRIMES, WRONGS OR ACTS/TRANSACTION EVIDENCE

*32 The State intends to introduce evidence of other primes, wrongs, or acts, or transaction evidence pursuant to Rule 404, M.R.E.: (. )Yes (X)No If yes, the State declares that all such evidence h s been disclosed to counsel for Defendant through the normal discovery pr cess. 1. The Defendant may file a brief opposing the use of any such evidence by: 2. The State's response brief due on: 3. The Defendant's reply brief due on:

(NOTE: The motions will be deemed submitted without a hearing unless a- Request for Hearing is submitted prior to the end of the :friefing period. If and only if such evidence is discovered later, the exclusion of the evidence may be addressed in a motion in limine)

VII AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES

The Defendant is aware of the time limits imposed by MCA 46-15-323 in which Defendant may assert certain defenses. 1. The Defendant will assert an affirrnative defense: ( )Yes (-tNo If yes, the affirmative defense is: 2. The Defendant will introduce evidence of good &laracter: ( )Yes (4No 3. The names and addresses of all witnesses to be called in support of

any affirmative defense or good character, together with all written reports or statements made by them shall be furnished to the State by:

4. The State shall furnish the Defendant with the names and addresses of all witnesses the Statd intends to call, to rebut the Defenqant's affirmative defense or good character, by: OMNIBUS FIEARING MEMORANDUM ^[4]

VIII MOTIONS BY THE STATE

*33 The State has pretrial motions: ( )Yes (X)No lf yes: These motions are: (a) (b) The State's brief filed by: The Defendant's brief filed by: The State's repiy brief filed by:

(NOTE: The motions will be deemed submitted without a hearing unless a Request for Hearing is submitted prior to the end of the briefing period.)

IX. MOTIONS BY THE DEFENDANT

The Defendant has pretrial motions: ( )Yes ONo lf yes These motions are: fiR5IeNe,

The Defendant's brief filed by: i. State's response filed by: The Defendant's reply brief filed by:

(NOTE: The motions will be deemed submitted without a hearing unless a request for Hearing is submitted prior to the end of the Oriefing period.)

X. PERSISTENT FELONY OFFENDER

Pursuant to MCA 46-13-108, the State will give nolice, by separate pleading, if the State seeks to have the Defendant senter ced as a Persistent Felony Offender. ^[5] OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM

XI. MENTAL DISEASE OR DISORDER ISSUE

*34 Except for good cause shown concerning fitness Ito proceed, any mental disease or disorder issue shall be disclosed and discussed at the time of the signing of this omnibus form.

Neither party has a mental disease or disdrocler issue concerning the Defendant and no examination pursuant to MCA 46-14-201 will be requested or conducted.

Yes, the State Defendant has a mental disease or disorder issue. This issue shall be brought to the Court s attention by a motion at the time of the Omnibus hearing so that an examination pursuant to MCA 46- 14-201 can be ordered.

xII. TRIAL PROCEDURE 1 Expected length of trial is: 2 days. 2. The Court will draw a panel consisting of 65 prospective jurors.

The State waives any right to be present at t e drawing and agrees that the panel may be drawn from those indiyiduals who have returned their juror questionnaires: ( x )Yes ( )No. Defendant/waives any right to be present at the drawing: ( )Yes (ANo. Defendant agrees that the panel may be drawn /from those individuals who have returned their juror questionnaires: (.4Yes ( )No.

3. AII motions in limine shall be filed and fully briefed not later than 30 days prior to trial unless upon good cause shrwn (or at the time of the final pre-trial, whichever is earlier).

4. All standard jury instructions shall be filed prior to voir dire. Additional instructions will be submitted on a howing of good cause.

5. Appropriate Disposition Date: OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM ^[6] ^[1] *35 ( N o t e : A ft e r t h i s da t e no p l ea ba r ga i n s w ill be a cc ep t ed , b y t he C ou r t, no r w ill an y p l ea s ba r ga i n s be a ll o w ed t o be f il ed a ft e r t h i s da t e . ) ^[2]

X

I L APP O I N T M E N T O F C O UN SE L ^[3] A s t he c ou r t - appo i n t ed c oun s e l f o r t he D e f endan t, I a ck no w l edge t ha t t h i s ^[4] appo i n t m en t i n c l ude s t he t r i a l o f t h i s m a tt e r i n D i s t r i c t C eu r t, po s t - t r i a l m o t i on s , s en t en c i ng and , ab s en t s pe c i f i c pe r m i ss i on t o w i t hd r a w an appea l t o t he ^[5] M on t ana S up r e m e C ou r t i f t he D e f endan t e l e c t s t o appea l and I do no t dee m s u c h an appea l t o be f r i v o l ou s . I n t he e v en t t he D e f endn t w i s he s t o p r o c eed ^[6] w i t h an appea l I be li e v e ha s no m e r i t, I w ill p r o c eed pu r s uan t t o t he p r o v i s i on s o f ^[46] - ^[8103] ( ^[2] ) , M C A . If t he D e f endan t e l e c t s no t t o appea l , t he D e f endan t and I w ill s i gn a w r i t t e n n o t i c e o f " E l e c t i on N o t t o A pp e a l " a n d I w il l f i l e t h e " E l e c t i o n N o t t o A ppea l " w i t h t he C ou r t.

X

III. S T I P U L A T I O N O F E N T R Y

I

C oun s e l f o r t he S t a t e and f o r t he D e f endan t ha v e r e v i e w ed t h i s O m n i bu s H ea r i ng M e m o r andu m and he r eb y s t i pu l a t e t o i t s 8n t r y b y t he C ou r t.

D A T E D t h i s 3 1 - d da y o f I\ k ^[2021] . / s / B r i tt an y L . W illi a m s B R I TT A N Y L . W I LL I A M S A tt o r ne y f o r S t a t e o f I/I on t ana

a

O

r - S t eph n i e M c K n i gh t A tt o r ne y f o r D e f endan t

/

( 7 7 / - F e V i e bd c d J A R E D G L E NN BA R T H ^[11] ^[1] ^[3] ) ^[1] D e f endan t S O O RD E R E D : D a t ed :

D

I S T R I C T J UD G E

E l e c t r on i c a l l y S i gn ed B y :

O

M N I B U S H EA R I N G M E M O R A NDU M H on . J udge J ohn W . La r s a W ed , N o v ^[03] ^[2021] ^[01] : ^[52] : ^[32] P M

F

*36 I LE D ^[11] / ^[03] / ^[2021] S h i r l e y F au s t

C

L E R K M i ss ou l a C oun t y D i s t r i c t C ou r t

S

T A T E O F M O N T A N A B y : M i c he ll e V i ppe r m an DC - ^[32] - ^[2021] - ^[0000414] - I N

1 F ou r t h J ud i c i a l D i s t r i c t La r s on , J ohn W ^[21] . ^[00] M i ss ou l a C oun t y C ou r t hou s e M i ss ou l a , M on t ana ^[59802] T e l ephone : ( ^[406] ) ^[258] - ^[4780] ^[3] ^[4] M O N T A N A F O UR T H J UD I C I A L D I S T R I C T . C O UR T ? M I SS O U L A C O UN T Y

• ^[5] D ep t. N o . ^[3] ^[1] S T A T E O F M O N T A N A , C au s e N o . DC - ^[21] - ^[414] ^[6] P l a i n t i ff,

O

M N I B U S H E A R I NG an d ^[7]

M

E M O R ANDU M J A R E D G L E NN BA R T H , ^[8] D e f endan t, ^[9] ^[10] T he P r o s e c u t o r and t he D e f endan t ' s c oun s e l , b y s i gn i ng t h i s m e m o r andu m , a ck no w l edge t ha t t he y ha v e bo t h r ead t he o m n i bu s hea r i ng s t a t u t e , M C A ^[46] - ^[13] - ^[110] , and a r e no w p r epa r ed t o d i sc u ss an y p r e t r i a l m a tt e r s i n add i t i on t o and i n c l ud i ng ^[11] t ho s e m a tt e r s li s t ed i n M C A ^[46] - ^[13] - ^[110] . O u r d i sc u ss i on o f and s ub s equen t ag r ee m en t on t he s e p r e t r i a l m a tt e r s i s s u mm a r i z ed b y t h i s m e m o r andu m . ^[12] I . D I S C OV E R Y ^[13] ^[1] I n c o m p li an c e w i t h M C A ^[46] - ^[15] - ^[322] , t he S t a t e s ha ll i mm ed i a t e l y and on ^[1] ^[4] a c on t i nu i ng ba s i s : ^[15] a . D i s c l o s e t h e na m e s , ad d r e ss e s an d s t a t e m e n t s o f t h e S t a t e ' s w i t ne ss e s ( i n c l ud i ng e x pe r t s ) t ha t t he S t a t e ' m a y c a l l a s w i t ne ss e s i n ^[16] t he i r c a s e - i n c h i e f. ^[17] b . D i sc l o s e and m a k e a v a il ab l e f o r i n s pe c t i on è ll ph ys i c a l o r do c u m en t a r y e v i den c e i n t he S t a t e ' s po ss e ss i on t ha t t he S t a t e m a y ^[18] u s e a t t r i a l o r w h i c h w a s ob t a i ned f r o m o r be l onged t o t he D e f e n d a n t. ^[19] c . D i sc l o s e a ll o r a l , w r i t t e n o r r e c o r de d s t a t e m en t s m ade b y D e f endan t ^[20] t o i n v e s t i ga t i ng o ff i c e r s o r t o t h i r d pe r s o n s . ^[1] O M N I B U S H EA R I N G M E M O R A NDU M ^[1] *37 d. Disclose all exculpatory evidence known to the State, including evidence that would tend to reduce the Defendant's potential ^[2] sentence. ^[3] In compliance with MCA 46-15-323, the Defendant shall, 30 days after 2. arraignment, and on a continuing basis: a. Disclose the names, addresses and statements of the Defendant's witnesses (including experts) that the Defendant may call in their case-in-chief.

b. Disclose and make available for inspection all physical or documentary evidence in the Defendant's possession that rnay be used at trial.

Initial discovery shall be completed by complete and on-going. Discovery disputes shall be raised no later than twenty-one (21) days prior to trial (or at the time of the final pre-trial, whichever is earlier);

II. CO-DEFENDANT(S)

is vi is not a co- The Defendant states that there defendant in this case. The name(s)/cause number(s) of the co- defendant(s) is/are

Co-Defendant is represented by Co-Defendant is represented by

III. FITNESS TO PROCEED,

The Defendant's fitness to proceed is at issue: ( )Yes No. If yes: a. A psychiatric examination of the Defendant Shall be conducted by

(the State Hospital) Name of Psychiatrist:

b. Further orders: ^[2]

OMNIBUS HEARING

MEMORANDUM

VI. OTHER CRIMES, WRONGS OR ACTS/TRANSACTION EVIDENCE

*38 The State intends to introduce evidence of other crimes, wrongs, or acts, or transaction evidence pursuant to Rule 404, M.R.E.: ( )Yes (X)No lf yes, the State declares that all such evidence has been disclosed to counsel for Defendant through the normal discovery process. 1. The Defendant may file a brief opposing the use of any such evidence by: 2. The State's response brief due on: 3. The Defendant's reply brief due on:

(NOTE: The motions will be deemed submitted without a hearing unless a Request for Hearing is submitted prior to the end of the briefing period. if and only if such evidence is discovered later, the exclusion,of the evidence may be addressed in a motion in Iimine)

VII AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES

The Defendant is aware of the time limits imposed by MCA 46-15-323 in which Defendant may assert certain defenses. 1. The Defendant will assert an affirmative defen'se: ( Yes ( )No If yes, the affirmative defense is: TA,0a16,9 Ibe. 2. The Defendant will introduce evidence of good character: (JiYes ( )No 3. The names and addresses of all witnesses to be called in support of

any affirmative defense or good character, together with all written reports or statements made by them shall be furnished to the State by: "210 4n

4. The State shall furnish the Defendant with the names and addresses of all witnesses the State intends to call, to rebut the Defendant's affirmative defense or good character, by: 1(-1 daqi- pt'r- --/z)

OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM

^[4] *39 I V . I N F O R M AN T , AND S U R V E I LL AN C E I N F O R M A N T : T he S t a t e de c l a r e s t ha t a c on f i den t i a l i n f o r m an t w a s i n v o l v ed ( ) Y e s ( X ) N o . If y e s : T he I n f o r m an t w ill be c a ll ed a s a w i t ne ss : ( ) Y e s ( ) N o T he S t a t e ha s d i sc l o s ed t he i n f o r m an t ' s i den t i t y : ( ) Y e s ( ) N o T he S t a t e w ill d i sc l o s e t he I n f o r m an t ' s i den t i t y b y : E L E C T R O N I C S UR VE I LL A NC E : T he S t a t e de c l r e s t he r e ha s been

e l e c t r on i c s u r v e ill an c e o f t h e D e f endan t o r h i s p r e m i s e s : ( X ) Y e s ( ) N o . If y e s : A ll m a t e r i a l ob t a i ned b y e l e c t r on i c s u r v e il l an c e h a s b ee h s upp li ed t o t he D e f endan t. D V D o f bod y c a m e r a v i deo , i n c a r v i deo , aud i o r e c o r d i ng s and pho t o s .

I N VES T I G A T I VE S U BP O E N A : T he S t a t e de c l a r e s t ha t an i n v e s t i ga t i v e s ubpoena ha s been e x e c u t ed : ( ) Y e s ( X ) N o A ll m a t e r i a l ob t a i ned b y t he i n v e s t i ga t i v e s ubpoena ha s been s upp li ed t o t he D e f endan t ( ) Y e s ( ) N o . V . S U PP R E SS I ON M O T I ON S ^[1] . T he D e f endan t m o v e s , pu r s uan t t o M C A ^[46113] - ^[302] , t o s upp r e ss ph ys i c a l e v i den c e : ( ) Y e s ( ) N o . If y e s : T he D e f endan t ' s s t a t e m en t o f f a c t s and b r i e f f il ed b y : T he S t a t e ' s b r i e f f il ed b y : T he D e f e nda n t ' s r e p l y b r i e f f i l e d b y : ^[2] . T he D e f endan t m o v e s , pu r s uan t t o M C A ^[46] - ^[13] - ^[301] , t o s upp r e ss

s

T i N e i D e f endan t ' s ad m i ss i on o r c on f e ss i on : ( ) Y e s ( ) N o If y e s : ^[17] ^[18] T he D e f endan t ' s b r i e f f il ed b y :

T he S t a t e ' s b r i e f f il ed b y : ^[19] D e f endan t ' s r ep l y b r i e f b y : ^[2] ^[0] ( N O T E : T he m o t i on s w i ll be dee m e d s u b m i tt ed w i t h ou t a h e a r i ng u n l e s s a

R eque s t f o r H ea r i ng i s s ub m i tt ed p r i o r t o t he end o f t he b r i e f i ng pe r i od . ) O M N I B U S H EA R I N G M E M O R A NDU M ^[3]

V

*40 III M O T I O N S BY T H E S T A T E T he S t a t e ha s p r e t r i a l m o t i on s : ( ) Y e s ( X ) N o If y e s : T he s e m o t i on s a r e : ( a ) ( b ) T he S t a t e ' s b r i e f f il ed b y : T he D e f endan t ' s b r i e f f il ed b y : T he S t a t e ' s r ep l y b r i e f f il ed b y :

( N O T E : T he m o t i on s w ill be dee m ed s ub m i tt ed w i t hou t! a hea r i ng un l e ss a R eque s t f o r H ea r i ng i s s ub m i tt ed p r i o r t o t he end o f t he b r i e f i ng pe r i od . )

I X . M O T I O N S BY T H E D E F E N I A N T T he D e f endan t ha s p r e t r i a l m o t i on s : ( ) Y e s ( ) N o If y e S : 6e s e r v t - T he s e m o t i on s a r e : T he D e f endan t ' s b r i e f f il e d b y : S t a t e ' s r e s pon s e f il ed b y : T he D e f endan t ' s r ep l y b r i e f f il e d b y :

( N O T E : T he m o t i on s w ill be dee m ed s ub m i tt ed w i t hou t a hea r i ng un l e ss a r eque s t f o r H ea r i ng i s s ub m i tt ed p r i o r t o t he end o f t he b r i e f i ng pe r i od . )

X . PE R S I S T E N T F E L O N Y O FF E ND E R P u r s uan t t o M C A ^[46] - ^[13] - ^[10] ^[8] , t he S t a t e w ill g i v e no t i c e , b y s epa r a t e ^[18] p l ead i ng , i f t he S t a t e s ee ks t o ha v e t he D e f endan t s en t en c ed a s a P e r s i s t en t ^[19] F e l on y O ff ende r . ^[20]

O

M N I B U S H EA R I N G M E M O R A NDU M ^[5]

XI. MENTAL DISEASE OR DISORDER ISSUE

*41 Except for good cause shown concerning fitness to proceed, any mental disease or disorder issue shall be disclosed and discussed at the time of the signing of this omnibus form.

J Neither party has a mental disease or disorder issue concerning the Defendant and no examination pursuant to MCA 46-14-201 will be requested or conducted. Defendant has a mental disease or

Yes, the State disorder issue. This issue shall be brought to the Court's attention by a motion at the time of the Omnibus hearing so that an examination pursuant to MCA 46- 14-201 can be ordered.

XII. TRIAL PROCEDURE I

1 Expected length of trial is: 3 days. The Court will draw a panel consisting of 65 prospective jurors. The State waives any right to be present at the drawing and agrees that the panel may be drawn from those individuals who have returned their juror questionnaires: ( x )Yes ( )No. Defendant/ waives any right to be present at the drawing: ( )Yes MNo. Defendant agrees that the panel may be drawn from those individuals who have returned their juror questionnaires: (4Yes ( )No.

3. All motions in limine shall be filed and fully briefed not later than 30 days prior to trial unless upon good cause shown (or at the time of the final pre-trial, whichever is earlier).

4. All standard jury instructions shall be filed prior to voir dire. Additional instructions will be submitted on a showing of good cause.

5. Appropriate Disposition Date: OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM ^[6] *42 (Note: After this date no plea bargains will be accepted by the Court, nor will any pleas bargains be allowed to be filed after this date.)

XII. APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL

As the court-appointed counsel for the Defendant, I acknowledge that this appointment includes the trial of this matter in District Court, post-trial motions, sentencing and, absent specific permission to withdraw, an appeal to the Montana Supreme Court if the Defendant elects to appeal and I do not deem such an appeal to be frivolous. In the event the Defendant wishes to proceed with an appeal I believe has no merit, I will proceed pur'suant to the provisions of 46-8103(2), MCA. If the Defendant elects not to appeal, the Defendant and I will sign a written notice of "Election Not to Appeal" and I will file the "Election Not to Appeal" with the Court.

XIII. STIPULATION OF ENTRY

Counsel for the State and for the Defendant have reviewed this Omnibus Hearing Memorandum and hereby stipulate to its entry by the Court.

DATED this ji,2r61 day of NNernI0e-r- 2021. /s/ Brittany L. Williams

BRITTANIY L. WILLIAMS

Attorney for State of Montana Stepharfie McKnight Attorney for Defendant

tdim Ne/y-

12,eaetua

JARED GLENN BARTH • /1/.31.Qi Defendant

SO ORDERED:

Dated:

DISTRICT JUDGE

Electronically Signed By: OMNIBUS HEARING MEMORANDUM Hon. Judge John W. Larson ^[7] Wed, Nov 03 2021 01:50:02 PM *43 OfficerID: MC\sgorr, Narrative

SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION:

On 07/15/2021 at approximately 1800 hours, I received an email request from MCSO Detective Diebert #448 to clarify the seizure of the knife involved in this incident. Deputy Baker conducted the majority of the interview with Jared Barth, I asked him a few questions to help better understand the events on Futurity Drive. One of the questions I asked Jared, pertained to the alleged knife involved. I asked Jared about the knife and he was informed the other party, Mr. Bobko accused him of pulling a knife on him and demanding money. Jared immediately became upset with the question and asked Deputies if he was being accused of a crime. Deputy Baker and I explained we were merely inquiring about a "knife," asking if one was involved, if he carried one, and its current location. Jared openly admitted he owned a knife, and pulled a knife during the altercation with Mr. Bobko. Jared then was asked to produce the knife, to either prove or disprove its relevance in this case. It was my understanding, Mr. Bobko saw and described the knife to Deputy Baker. Jared tried to sway the conversation off topic but would eventually „ 6rle 6711.(-C admit he stored the knife inside the house. Jared told Deputies multiple times to "qg 4 i,8 -fro./44 ,gtt the knife," and "'t is inside, I'll go get it for ou." This was not an option for officer

CoP safety concerns. There were mul ip e amily members present during this time, including his father David. I had spoken to David when I arrived and took a statement from him, so I requested he assist me in securing the knife for evidence. I explained the knife would be beneficial for the case and David agreed by saying, "I don't have any use for it here." David began walking inside the home and I asked if it would be okay if I came inside with him and he said, "yes." I requested to enter the residence for officer safety concerns. Deputies had not been Ace j

_Tel ar

inside the residence during the interaction up to this point, as Jared was interviewed A ada outside on the porch. Additionally, Jared and David consented to allowing Deputies vi

/-114a set•th0 take possession of the knife and I felt it was not safe for me to allow David to come Y back out of the house with a weapon. I followed David inside and he went into a room just off the main open living room. The room was on the left side of the short hallway. I did not ask David who's room he was going into or where he planned on looking for the knife. David went directly to this room and turned on the light, then opened the top dresser drawer and handed me the knife. From my prior conversation with David, he told me Jared resided with him in the house. I presumed based on the above statement, along with Jared admitting to having, pulling, and then placing the knife epacjaier le that fhp_rojaLand dresser belonged to Jared. The knife was seized and obtained through verbal consent. It was taken to Deputy Baker and turned over to his custody.lg cgAby

c lite to which I hea cuared..answer wjajjejleguty.aakera ipjWafflmetive, "it's rpy knife."

64 Key. /len,/ /el 11-1:5 fe rad' Page: 7 of 15 *44 After the identification of the knife, l completed a property receipt for the seizure of the weapon used in the commission of the charged crimes. Jared's attention was very quickly changed to another topic, he began yelling and screaming about being laizlyaEmej.“Nuesting an ambu*Np, @ad he inac additional statements w ich he exhibited during the entire contact.

'patcvoital aboul sAW49 END OF REPORT titApet -t- S. GORR #451 07/15/2021 iqici bet'49-fai5elycterci5e331 emu' I ACCV a/) ambulet/ree? (A.J1441

a 're ik; e a QV/WO/74 / ecog.'d S-telleme4kP

cAThy (epoci? Page: 8 of 15 *45 6.6,(e 11 y5 te t)0,(7 - OfficerID: MC\sgorr, Narrative

SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION:

On 07/1412021 at approxiinately 2244 hours, I was dispatched to 9301 Futurity Drive, Missoula, NIT., regarding a disturbance. Dispatch advised there was an open 911 line with lots of screaming, one person was yelling "he has a knife," and "I am being robbed." It was unknown if someone was stabbed and in need of medical attention. I assisted Deputy Baker #442 and f tpLKopp9s#420. While responding to the location, informationwas relayed the suspect left the area ^[1] _, (110/ e Carl toward HWY 93 N, "WYE." T he sitmest uelaige was described.as a Ford,..Ranger,rx1

,(efiwat6 s; g.Q....2 ygjaWW, 1/ re or ir in color pisiggNxith a toomriEwtraajlievWAsiejuallears #912Gwy. It should be noted, Deputy Baker relayed he passed a similar vehicle when 4/0. 1 90',/epm arriving on scene and it failed to stop.

)1Coe..$ 1101 set y The suspect was later identified as Jared Barth, M, DOB: 10-31-1989, by searching a -1 at) a) local history with Mr. Barth's cell phone which was provided by the victim.jbegari Ore (2,/ .11 /eft pheckirtg.theAearbyluck st.osLandilikLnot locate the suspect vehicle: I responded to the scene to assist Deputy Baker.

eVial to Ally /40P6C INITIAL STATEMENT MIKHAIL BOBKO: I briefly spoke to the victim, Mikhail Bobko. I learned Mr. Bobko had a business transaction with Mr. Barth involving the sale of wheels.fMr. Bobko agreed to meet Mr. P arth out Jjie13isigmLgto discuss "balancing issues," with the wheels and or refunding Mr. Barth for the vehicle parts. Mr. Bobko told me Mr. Barth demanded to be compensated for taking the wheels into "Tire Rama," for balancing which cost him an additional $45.00. When Mr. Bobko refused to repay the amount for balancing the wheels at Tire Rama, Mr. Barth pulled a knife on him and demanded money... hims If bv nuttina his hands uo and with a han held e • i ilmhead. Mr. Bobko said he then immediately called 911 and left an open line while fighting with Mr. Barth.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION:

A short time later, Dispatch advised Mr. Barth had called in claiming he was "robbed and struck with a Dewalt battery," Mr. Barth wished to report the crimes and wanted to prosecute Mr. Bobko. Mr. Barth was currently at his father's address 1337 S 4th St. W Missoula, MT. NIPD Officers responded to the location and stood by with Mr. Barth until Deputies arrived.

w s narked out hIlLo• ntotketegidence. The truck contained tires and wheels in the truck bed. The truck matched the AbOve description with the Oregon registration plate. Jared's father,,DavicLBarth.was present outside the home when Deputy Baker and I

Page: 9 of 15 *46 k c wei 5 f'16-t- aud‘ure c2e #15‘ e arrived to interview Jared. David told me he was aware of the vehicle parts transaction between Mr. Bobko and his son. He said Jared was not satisfied with the ihee-tt,',1_, balancing of the wheels. He also said he was sold seats that did not fit his vehicle.

*Glat- /) it.9 h+ David was aware Jared was meeting with Mr. Bobko to try and resolve the issue. 44 V/ X Ceebta David told me after Jared met with Mr. Bobko he called him upset but he was not aware a disturbance involving a knife had occurred. He told me Jared went there to request repayment for having the wheels balanced by another auto mechanic. Laskeg cloOS

. red was kno a a as no ut C> say cop tbejay_piyeL.1 Kate. insicklbelLOrlie to ntamgaariliiiriA, ),f4p L1, -t

s

aiteatkito ItSWAX5MGETriM—A7S-P":4-h tiQicee He described Jared as being very paranoid and was distrustful of the government. 1-410 Jared was known to believe "the FBI," were following him. David said Jared had approached a feniale on the street and accused her of being a FBI agent following him around. David said Jared was in need of a mental evaluation and needed to start taking pills.

ADDITIONAL STATEMENT FROM MIKHAIL BOBKO:

Mr. Bobko told me he agreed to meet with Jared during the night, as he had been unavailable and out of town prior to this date. Mr. Bobko said, Jared came to his business demanding repayment for the wheel balancing.11 10. IctpAme=be refused to Ray the balan,pirm.amount but had offered fqlrfifund to the parts, Mr. Bobko said after telling Jared he was not going to pay him, Jared pulled a knife out at him and said, "give me my money." Mr. Bobko said Jared approached him with the knife and he raised his hands up for protection and hit Jared with the flashlight. M14.2kko_fpg n?etenextgamar_etaLIy money. I asked Mr. Bobko how Jared lost his shirt clueing the altercation and he said he did not know but thought Jared ripped it off and began wrapping it around his arm. He also told me during the altercation, Jared chLolved his cell phone so lei ced it Li fmv.jm qpApir_ounding his business, ,,a,,..m a d tl Mr. Bobko feared retaliation from Jared and his family. I explained the criminal

(A)6

process with him and encouraged him to reach out to a victim advocate, along with A i

C

I the civil aspect of the sale/repair with the vehicle parts. Mr. Bobko said he would call 46/2e.C4- the NICSO if Jared returned to his business and caused a disturbance. • <hdaq Peir 6,62 ,6K a AY-1/4/6DEPUTY ACTIONS: I assisted with collecting evidence from David Barth. pavic1 allpytelime_tagiter his tesidep.csand I walked with him tkainAlgonlwhere he went directly to a top dresser

7ve,Ve4 drawer and produced a black folding knife. David believed this was Jared's knife, this was later confirmed with Jaredli his statements, "yeah that's my knife." octgok° I completed a property receipt for the knife and cell phone. A photocopy of the Tike Page: 10 of 15 *47 1,0G1 do yoti ph000py

es, atc-1- cc;

fkeA solve aci(? Rama receipt was obtained and then returne.d.faih.Q1 razily. I then went to Mr. Bobko's residence and pTovided him with a victim's notice form and clarified some of his statement's, see above.

WATCHGUARD VIDEO:

My in-car and body worn cameras were downloaded and saved as evidence. For further information refer to Deputy Baker's original report. END OF REPORT S. GORR #451 07/15/2021

Page: 11 of 15 *48 OfficerID: MC\mbaker, Narrative On 07-14-21, at approximately 2244 hours, l was dispatched to the area of Futurity Drive and Train Bridge Loop for a subject who called 911 and was yelling "He has a knife!". It should be noted I responded to the area with my emergency lights activated. l was driving southbound on Highway 10 from the Wye and noted a vehicle pull off Futurity Drive and proceed northbound on Highway 10. As I passed that vehicle, l noted it was a red Ford Ranger with a lumber rack. After pulling onto Futurity Drive, cl_i_221c1 s_als.pilatILI to‘, ai ktirowncolor Ford Ratim Dispatch then advised me the vi'ctirrisaid the suspect was still on scene. Due to the report of the suspect still being on scene and the danger posed if they were, l did not pursue the matching vehicle. Upon my arrival, l contacted Mikhail "Mike" Bobko. On my initial contact with Mike, he appeared distressed and out of breath. Mike was speaking erratically due to his level of excitement and it took a few minutes for him to regain his breath. j'Vlike was holdin.g_a yellow and black flashlight and a cell phone. Below is a summary of my interview with Mike. Mike owns an auto parts yard at 9301 Futurity Drive. Recently, Mike sold multiple auto parts to a subject whose name he did not remember. He later said he believed the subject was named "Jay" or "Joe". Mike said he communicated with the subject through phone calls and texts. Mike provided me with the phone number he used to contact this subject. Mike provided a phone number of Dispatch advised me we have history with a subject owning that number identified as Jared Barth. Mike told me he installed wheels on Jared's vehicle and sold him some other miscellaneous parts. Jared contacted Mike after the sale and was upset because the vehicle was not driving right and wanted to return the parts. Mike said he was not in Missoula when Jared wanted to meet up and Mike would have to text Jarejt9 let m know when he was available. Mike and Jared agreed to meet up at 7s- 31----- usiness on Futurity that evening. iv'irke-giTiVecT;;;;;; rational and calm when they first met. Mike agreed to take bad._,..s d...give Jared a reb.11-WArjkihathmaisl. Jared then brought up that the vehicle was pulling to right after mike installed the parts. Jared told Mike he had to go to TireRama and have the

, tires serviced for $45. Jared wanted Mike to reimburse him for the cost associated from TireRama. Mike told Jared no and Jared became angry with him. Jared pulled out a knife and yelled "Give me the money!". Mike said Jared was holding the knife out in front of him in his right hand and advanced

,ree0thoward Mike. Mike described the blade as a folding knife with a blade length of approximately six sele tt) inches. Mike said Jared made a stabbing motion toward him with the knife. Milv....asultelatlightap

ttgizatuUarecLlaaclthe-klaite_42 zawpiii4aLtiLt z.pj192101dzsas9110:atrlairo-....2is.2.52 eCI AYpil\-. which nextenm he ,iropped Ittasr2Ske,bitto. Mike was able to pick up the cell phone and Jared yelled to give ti§ v er 5., ‘csi o..• back the phonelgike said he threw the phone over the tenc910wlis almarlaosiza t_on favritLIaimpzelatayirom Jare4;1;mpApil0 yva,s, hilby.,„targd„LuttlApte...tiws in the back vtile.,13,e 4.1e1 5 1101( ran but did not believe Ja4ed cut him iiiiii the knife. • said he called 91_ 14.1,,d crd ictapte.,e,,lazed,L,q,alm.

‘St. Told qii 41104' t C le ovilik CO/1 Zike said he.a .gAtrgcLon the head at least once by Jared but was not cut. Mike...pointed to a sot on /teE Mike 0 A _ -,....., , cli'd 46-t the left side of his head above the temple. 1..noted a small amount a redness and minorswelling in the re,14/1E(129jrjacitca. I also o:Tserved minor abrasion to Mike's left tricep and multiple spots on his back. 04,6:C fi n e i f? r

.0 ,tev 91i A -Cr' Mike declined any medical attention. l took photos of Mike's injuries which were included with this re Pori coold z teivto c

s

:to'?" aed j0 A C Cif a4d c -the el 0 fl e Page: 12 of 15 *49 report.thjol ht.c fiec21pylor proximately 15 feet inside rollin a P to,Mike,s_b_usiness.ltsga. hone had a crackesLici;egn and, would not turn on. While speaking with Mike, dispatch advised me they received a call from Jared who advised he was at his parent's house at 1337 S 4th Street W in Missoula. Jared told dispatch he wanted to report being robbed. While enroute to speak with Jared, dispatch further advised Missoula City PD was standing by at the residence with Jared waiting for my arrival. Upon my arrival to 1337 S 4th Street W, I located Jared seated on the steps of the residence with two Missoula PD officers standing next to him. Below is a summary of my interview with Jared. Jared said he purchased multiple car parts from Mike and Mike was supposed to mount and balance rims for $45. Jared got the vehicle back to his residence and noticed the vehicle was not acting right. Jared took the vehicle into TireRama and had the tires balanced. Jared said a seat he bought from Mike also was not compatible with his pickup. On 07-14-21 at 1500 hours, Jared called Mike and Mike said he was out of town. Jared called Mike again at 2000 hours and Mike's son answered and told Jared Mike was in Seely Lake and would call him back. Mike called Jared back around 2100 hours and Jared went to the business on Futurity to meet with Mike. I asked Jared what his intention was to meet with Mike. Jared told me he wanted to get his money back. Jared said he was on the phone with his dad initially but hung up in order to record Mike with the phone. jgred b__ e told Mice that l .1,ared said Mike immediatel hit him in the head with the flashli ht Mike was holding. I asked Jared if Mike said anything to Jared prior to hitting him. Jared said no and that Mike immediately hit him. Jared also said Mike took Jared's shirt at some point during the fight. asl l (ec at Mike and he said because Mike told him he would not give him his money back. Jai-ed said Mike took the cellphone and ran away from him. Jared said he yelled, "he's robbing me". Jared said he ran to his truck a and left. Jared said he passed a police vehicle with it's emergency lights on. I asked Jared if he attempted toe 46d to stop or flag down the vehicle. Jared said no because he did not want to "cause a scene in the middle of the road". ta11<ed arsd if he attemoted to defend himsPlf in anv wav after Mike" hit him ared paused nd said, "I think I've just explained everything sir." I explained to Jared the importance of the question ^[1]

d and he said he already told the story two or three times, and it was not changing keevec Wended himself b I asked Jared where the knife was. JALliskeZs,d rec tut f question and sai I, "Ts in the house". I asked Jared what happened with the knife. Jared began to av ask if I had a recording of the inci ent. I got Jared back on track by asking what happened with the knife ict4

Futurity. Jared said he pulled it out to defend himself. When I attempted to clarify when he pulled

. ?lit the knife, Jared just said "I don't know" multiple times. toriA l -

C,O C.0 /1/6VV

Deputy Gorr asked Jared if he called 911 and Jared said no because Mike took his phone. Deputg_Gorr asked if Mike called 911 and Jared said yes. When Deputy Gorr attempted to ask further questions, 56ti l V i ‘p h-; 5 Jared did not respond to the questions and began saying it was an armed robbery and he could have a

concussion or memory loss after being assaulted. ,repeti+ Page: 13 of 15 *50 , ,to I asked Jared if we could see the knife to obtain any evidence or match the description of the knife. Caa 1E2E1 jaLan witl about neecthrlaisttplaile.2 askedJared again and he avoided pa l:T(7, 7. answering my questions regarding the knife. At this point, l instructed Jared to stand and placed him under arrest in handcuffs. Jared did not resist me placing him in handcuffs but began yelling for his family to "call the district attorney and raise all kinds of fuss". l placed Jared in the backseat of my patrol vehicle. l read Jared his Miranda Rights and asked if he understood them. Jared stared at me and did not answer. I asked Jared if he understood

/4/v Ve- them and he said he was not, "No sir, l wasn't listening." l read Jared his rights a second time and he said „.....7s-tate,c4 ever he understood them. c11,2.14.1.ared l had his cell phone and_asled Tultiple_tirne5 jfi co& open it to vieW ;1-- Act la tbsaltoi„,,, 5, ie claim gqs_tecsgslAcl. Ja.ced said only if we view 1 ppssible sipsgSheAollezmcicad and I ould eed to view it later after char in it. Jared refused to

frac lecoo give me permissibn Pr a code to the'phchie. l noted a brack shirt on the seat of 'Jared's l asked sc e Jared what shirt he was wearing and he said it Was a black shirt with a Santa Cruz logo. l asked Jared if he knew where his shirt was and he said Mike stole it. When l told Jared his shirt was in his truck, he ) staited laughing and said Mike took it off his back and stole his phone. l askedkred why Mike steal ive it to me and put Jared's Shirt back in his truck. Jared said he didn't khow. When /Jared's hone the asked why Mike wbuld call 911, Jare said Mike hit him then tried to play the victim. Prior to leaving, l spoke with David Barth, who advised he was Jared's father. David told me he Was speaking with Jared on the phone while the confrontation with Mike occurred. David remembered hearing Mike say, "why didn't you bring it to me?" and Jared replied, "you told me to take care of it". David said the argument sounded like it was becoming more heated and then disconnected. David said he did not hear anything else over the phone. Jared was arrested and transported to Missoula County Detention Center. Jared was booked on AsSault with a weapon and robbery. Due to the phone allegedly containing a video of the incident, the phone and the knife were collected as evidence.pivictsholyenae422pyj n TireRamaspiert_op. 07-13-21 for $40. l took a photo of the receipt and returned it to David. Deputy Gorr lateu.e._-inler_vjewed Mike. Please see his supplemental report for further. It should be noted my body and car cameras were activated during this incident. Please see those recordings for further. PLease forward to the County Attorney's office for review.

Page: 14 of 15 *51 MONTANA DISTRICT COURT MISSOULA COUNTY MINUTE ENTRY Date: 11/19/2021 01:30 PM Hearing Type: Evidentiary Presiding Judge: John W Larson Case Number: DC-32-2021-0000371-IN State of Montana vs. Jared Glenn Barth Department: Courtroom: 3 Charge(s): Criminal Mischief Pecuniary Loss More Than $1,500 Appearances: Prosecution Attorney, Brittany Williams. Attorney Stephanie McKnight appears with Defendant, Jared Glenn Barth, who appears from the Missoula County Detention Center. Also present were Jennifer Wells; Court Reporter and Michelle Vipperman; Court Clerk. Dr. Scolatti was sworn and testified. The Defendant advised that he wants a new attorney. The Court advised that there is a form to fill out and submit to the public defender's office. The Defendant advised that he would like to represent himself. The Court advised that Ms. McKnight remains as his counsel, for the Defendant to go through the proper procedure to request new counsel, and should the Defendant be found fit to proceed the Court will provide a Waiver regarding self-representation. Ms. McKnight reserved on a Gallagher hearing outside the presence of the. State. The Court stayed further proceedings until the State Hospital prepares an evaluation. *52 7/16/2021 2:26:27 PM

Print Date/Time: i i Date/Time User Action Description MachineID 07/15/2021 00:43 JMachado Call Cleared Close Call CAD5 :31 07/15/2021 00:43 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 420 Available CADS :30 07/15/2021 00:43 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 442 Available CAD5 :26 07/15/2021 00:23 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 451 rerouted to call 57 CADS :51 07/15/2021 00:23 JMachado Call Stack Call placed on unit 451's stack CAD5 :51 07/15/2021 00:16 JMachado Narrative Added tape req submitted CAD5 :40 07/15/2021 00:14 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 442 At Jail CAD5 :16 Unit 420 At Jail CAD5 07/15/2021 00:14 JMachado Unit Status Action :16 Unit Location Unit 451 Secondary Location Updated: a6 CAD5 07/15/2021 00:14 JMachado :08 Narrative Added req 911 tapes-451 CADS 07/15/2021 00:13 JMachado :34 07/15/2021 00:10 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 420 Enroute Jail CADS :10 7/15/2021 00:10 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 442 Enroute Jail CADS :10 Unit Location Unit 420 Secondary Location Updated: Jail CADS 7/15/2021 00:10 JMachado :10 Unit Location Unit 442 Secondary Location Updated: Jail CAD5 7/15/2021 00:10 JMachado, :10 Unit Status Action Unit C127 Available CAD2 '07/15/2021 00:03 TMay :12 Unit Status Action Unit C398 Available CAD2 07/15/2021 00:03 TMay :07 CAD5 Narrative Added 10-15 -451 7/15/202 00:00 JMachado :48 CAD5 07/14/2021 23:37 JMachado Unit Location Unit 451 Secondary Location: 1337 s 4th st w :12 Unit 420 Secondary Location Updated: 1337 s 4th st w CAD5 07/14/2021 23:37 JMachado Unit Location :12 Unit 442 Secondary Location Updated: 1337 s 4th st w CAD5 07/14/2021 23:37 JMachado Unit Location :12 Unit Status Action Unit 451 Off Scene CADS 07/14/2021 23:36 JMachado :59 Narrative cAdded 10-12 W/ JARED C398 CAD2 07/14/2021 23:36 TMay :32 Unit Status Action Unit C127 Off Scene CAD2 07/14/2021 23:25 TMay :14 Unit C127 Secondary Location Updated: 1337 s 4th CAD2 07/14/2021 23:25 TMay Unit Location :14 Vehicle Deleted: LicenseNumber - 486515b; License St CAD3 07/14/2021 23:24 LWilson Vehicle Deleted

ate - Montana; Role - Plate Inquiry; Plate Type - Pa :41 ssenger Car; CADS 07/14/2021 23:24 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 442 Off Scene :28 Unit 420 Off Scene CAD5 Unit Status Action 07/14/2021 23:24 JMachado :28

s . 07/14/2021 23:24 JMachado Unit Location Unit ^[420] Secondary Location: er ^[1337] s4th st w CAD5 :28 07/14/2021 23:24 JMachado Unit Location Unit ^[442] Secondary Location: er ^[1337] s4th st w

ba t ne v e r , c fr c A :42 07/14/2021 23:20 TMay

Unit Status Action Unit C398 Dispatched

CAD2

:18 ee l P O r t 07/14/2021 23:20 TMay Unit Status Action Unit C127 Dispatched

CAD2

:18 07/14/2021 23:20 TMay

. Incident Created Added Incident Number, ORI: MT0320100, Number: 2021- :18 ^[00028472] 07/14/2021 23:20 TMay Unit Location Unit C398 Secondary Location: Secondary Location Cle CAD2 :18 ared 07/14/2021 23:20 TMay Unit Location Unit C127 Secondary Location: Secondary Location Cle CAD2 :18 ared 07/14/2021 23:18 ALechleitner Narrative Added 2c front light will be on, req 10-5

CAD6

:40 07/14/2021 23:17 ALechleitner

Narrative Added 2c is jared barth

CAD6

:45 07/14/2021 23:17 ALechleitner

Narrative Added 2c says there was also a theft of his shirt, cellpho CAD6 :2 ^[1] ne, and used parts 07/ 14/2 ^[021] 23:17 AL ech le itn er Narr ative A d d ed 2c wants officer contact, says this is all recorded, CAD6 :01 wants to press charges 07/14/2021 23:16 ALechleitner Narrative Added 2c is at his father's house ^[1337] s 4th st w

CAD6

:41 07/14/2021 23:16 ALechleitner Narrative Added 2c is req medical, now refusing

:59 07/14/2021 23:14 TMay

Link Calls Calls: ^[41]

CAD2

:36 ^[0] ^[7] / ^[1] ^[4] / ^[2] ^[0] ^[21] ^[2] 3:13 LWilson

Narrative Added will ^[352] ^[8] th st -c398

CAD3

:00 07/14/2021 23:12 LWilson Narrative Added s has been helping dad w/ construction in that area- CAD3 :56 c398 07/14/2021 23:12 LWilson Narrative Added last contact with m on 7/12/2021 at 1623 1/2 s 8th s CAD3 :08 t w - dad's address right in that area-c398 07/14/2021 23:10 JMachado Person Added Person Added: Last Name-- mikhail; First Name - bobk CAD5 :25 o; Role - Inquiry; DOB Sex - M; 07/14/2021 23:10 JMachado Unit Status Action Unit 451 On Scene CAD5 :04 07/14/2021 23:09 JMachado Person Added Person Added: Last Name - m; Role - Inquiry; CADS :52 07/14/2021 23:09 JMachado Person Added Person Added: Last Name - bobko; First Name - mikhai CAD5 :24 1; Role - Inquiry; DOB - Sex - M; DL Sta

te - MT; 07/14/2021 23:08 JMachado Narrative Added JagaLLSL.r.—j.ared for robber in red ran er w roof rac CAD5 :53 k -420 07/14/2021 23:07 JMachado Person Updated Person Barth, Jared Updated: Name Changed from barth CAD5 :32 , jared to Barth, Jared GlennAddress Added - 1000 W

7TH AVE C; Contact Phone Added - (406) DOB Added - 1989-10-31; Sex Added - M; Race Added - Whi te; Ethnicity Added - Non-Hispanic; Hair Color Added - Blonde; Eye Color Added - Blue; Driver License Ad ded - 1012519894131; DL State Added - MT; SSN Added -filliMPliftapHeight Added - 5'7"; Weight Added - 175 .0;

RF1, FT1. 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson Unit Status Action Unit ^[361] Stand-By Missoula Rural Fire Stati

CAD3

:00 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson Unit Status Action Unit ^[361] Stand By

CAD3

:00 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson Unit Status Action Unit ^[321] Stand-By Missoula Rural Fire Stati

C AD ^[3] :0 ^[0] 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson

Unit Status Action Unit ^[321] Stand By

CAD3

:00 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson

Unit Status Action Unit ^[878] Stand-By Frenchtown Fire Station ^[7]

CAD3

:00 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson

Unit Status Action Unit ^[878] Stand By

:00 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson

Unit Recommendation Recommendation completed for units: 361, 321, 878, M CAD3 :00 ESI 1, RF 1, F T ^[1] . ^[0] ^[7] /1 ^[4] / ^[2] ^[0] ^[21] 22:47 L W i l so n Incident Created Added Incident Number, ORI: ^[04012] , Number: 2021- z :00 ^[00000456] 07/14/2021 22:47 LWilson Incident Created Added Incident Number, ORI: MESI , Number: 2021- :00 ^[00006451] 07/14/2021 22:46 ALechleitner Ca11 Updated Additional Location Info auto parts Added CAD6 :58 07/14/2021 22:46 ALechleitner Narrative Added m should still be on sc CAD6 :48 07/14/2021 22:46 ALechleitner Narrative Added CAD6 :41 07/14/2021 22:46 Autum Eggers - E2 Person Updated Person Bobko, Mike Updated: Name Changed from bobko, CAD4 :39 mike to Bobko, Mike MAddress Added - 9301 FUTURITY

DR, Missoula; Contact Phone Added - (406) DOB Added - Sex Added M; Race Added - White;

07/14/2021 22:46 system user - New W Alerts Retrieval Alerts Were Successfully Gathered For Global Subject NWPSCADPROD :39 orld Systems Named: (Bobko, Mike) 07/14/2021 22:46 LWilson Unit Recommendation Recommendation viewed for units : 361, 321, 878, MES CAD3 :39 RF1, FT1 07/14/2021 22:46 LWilson Call Type Fire Call Type Changed From Choose Call Type CAD3

AiikTc soi'd he dðrd :36 -> To Call Type: MedicaL Standby ALS, Status: In Pro gress, Priority: High 07/14/2021 22:46 ALechleitner Narrative Added neg desc of susp, only 1 m -, CAD6 "Of to$014/ whige 1`11t :32 07/14/2021 22:46 LWilson Agency Context Adde Fire Call Type Added. Call Type: Choose Call Type CAD3 45C111 iboice1/9 :32 d/Updated >, Status: In Progress, Priority: High 07/14/2021 22:46 ALechleitner Narrative Added c saying c ran away, unk how hes hurt CAD6 :21 hx of number is mike bobko 07/14/2021 22:46 LWilson Narrative Added CAD3 CAD6 71,,, e 5614 :16 07/14/2021 22:46 ALechleitner Narrative Added the knife" unk if stabbed :13 07/14/2021 22:46 LWilson Person Added Person Added: Last Name - bobko; First Name - mike; CAD3 Role - Inquiry; :10 07/14/2021 22:45 ALechleitner Location Cross streets updated, TRAIN BRIDGE LOOP / TRAIN BR CAD6 IDGE LOOP :56 07/14/2021 22:45 ALechleitner Location Call Location Changed from 6903 TRAIN BRIDGE LOOP, M CAD6 issoula to 9301 FUTURITY DR, Missoula :55 07/14/2021 22:45 system user - New W Alerts Retrieval Alerts Were Successfully Gathered For Location At Ad NWPSCADPROD dress 9301 FUTURITY DR :55 orld Systems 07/14/2021 22:45 ALechleitner Narrative Added several voices heard, one yelling "Im being robbed" CAD6 :38 07/14/2021 22:45 Autum Eggers - E2 Unit Location Unit 451 Secondary Location: Secondary Location Clea CAD4 red :31 07/14/2021 22:45 Autum Eggers - E2 Unit Status Action Unit 451 Dispatched CAD4 :31 07/14/2021 22:45 ALechleitner Narrative Added m keeps yelling help, so do others CAD6 :24 07/14/2021 22:45 ALechleitner 'Narrative Added caller just yelling, others yelling, lots of muffled CAD6 sounds :13 07/14/2021 22:45 Autum Eggers - E2 Incident Created Added Incident Number, ORI: MT0320000, Number: 2021- ^[00011947] :06 Unit Status Action Unit 442 rerouted from call 28 CAD4 07/14/2021 22:45 Autum Eggers - E2 :06

ev t; ke Scud Unit Status Action Unit 420 rerouted from call 28 CAD4 07/14/2021 22:45 Autum Eggers - E2 :06 11 can_hardly hear " siomeone yelling he has a kni CAD6 07/14/2021 22:44 ALechleitner Narrative Added 111:s i-obJ covi fe" :59 Call Ready for Disp Call marked ready for dispatch CAD4 07/14/2021 22:44 Autum Eggers - E2

‘/Olk halal 1Y hear e co jf).5 atch :56 Narrative Added m has a knife CAD6 07/14/2021 22:44 ALechleitner

kie ii(2400et # (A.4' ?6-1 nted *56 :45 07/14/2021 22:44 ALechleitner Agency Context Adde Police Call Type Added. Call Type: Disturbance, Stat CAD6 :41

d/Updated us: In Progress, Priority: High 07/14/2021 22:44 ALechleitner Lo cati on Call Location Changed from 46.940231-114.12671 to ^[69] CAD6 :39 ^[03] TRAIN BRIDGE LOOP, Missoula 07/14/2021 22:44 system user - New W Alerts Retrieval Alerts Were Su cce ssfu lly Ga th ere d For L oc at i on At Ad N WP SC AD PR OD :39 orld Systems dress ^[6903] TRAIN BRIDGE LOOP 07/14/2021 22:44 ALechleitner Location Cross streets u p d a t ed , FUTURITY DR / FUTURITY DR

CAD6

:39 07/14/2021 22:44 ALechleitner

Location Call Location Changed from 46.895741-114.09303 to ^[46] CAD6 :33 .940231-114.12671, Source: RapidSOS (07/14/2021 22:4 4:07)

STATE OF MONTANA

STATE OF MONTANA, Dept. Plaintiff, Cause No. -vs- MANS No. 3200G2101183

JARED GLENN BARTH,

AFFIDAVIT OF PROBABLE CAUSE Defendant.

STATE OF MONTANA

)

: SS

County of Missoula ) BRITTANY L. WILLIAMS, Deputy County Attorney, Montana, being first duly sworn upon oath, deposes and says: I have read the law enforcement reports regarding the investigation of JARED GLENN BARTH for allegedly committing the offense of: COUNT I: ROBBERY, a felony, in violation of § 45-5-401, MCA. I believe that the facts as set forth in the law enforcement reports, if

true, constitute sufficient probable cause to justiN the filingAt!IlEhar:95. Those facts are as follows:

On or about the 14th day of July, 2021, Missoula County Sheriffs *58 Deputies responded to a disturbance in the area of Futurity Drive and Train Bridge Loop, in Missoula County. Deputy Baker responded and spoke with Mikhail "Mike" Bobko. Mike appeared distressed and was out of breath. Mike stated he owns an auto parts yard at 9301 Futurity Drive and had recently sold part to an individual who was named "Joe" or "Jay." Mike stated he had communicated with the individual via call and text and Mike provided the number for the individual.

Deputy Baker was advised by dispatch that the phone number was associated with Jared Barth, the above-named Defendant. Mike informed Deputy Baker that he had installed wheels on the Defendant's vehicle and he had sold the Defendant a few other parts for the Defendant's vehicle. The Defendant contacted Mike because he was upset that his vehicle was not driving right and he wanted a refund on the parts.

Mike set up a time to meet with the Defendant. Mike stated the Defendant was initially calm and rational and Mike agreed to take back the parts he provided and give the Defendant a refund. The Defendant then

asked for $45 for having his tires serviced at Tire Rama. Mike informed the Defendant that he would not cover that cost and the Defendant became angry.

The Defendant then pulled a knife on Mike and yelled "give me the *59 money!" Mike stated the Defendant was holding the knife in his right hand and that the Defendant made a stabbing motion towards him and advanced towards Mike. Mike described the knife as approximately 6 inches and a folding style knife.

Mike stated he swung a flashliaht toward the bancrthat the Defendant wa.5 taldinglie knife jn.Mike further stated the Defendant was holding his cellphone in his left hand and that he dropped his phone. Mike picked up the phone and the Defendant began yelling for his phone, at which time Mike threw the phone and began running away from the Defendant. Mike stated the Defendant struck him several times in the back as he was running .

DATED this 16th day of July, 2021. /s/ Brittany L. Williams

BRITTANY L. WILLIAMS

Deputy County Attorney

SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me, a Justice of the Peace, in and for the State of Montana, County of Missoula. Electronically Signed By: Hon. Judge Alex Beal Fri, Jul 16 2021 11:04:07 AM o r k no w i ng l y pu tt i ng M i k ha il B ob k o , i n f ea r o f i mm ed i a t e bod il y i n j u r y , t o w i t: b r and i s h i ng a k n i f e and m a k i ng a s t abb i ng m o t i on , w h il e s t a t i ng " g i v e m e t he m one y . "

D A T E D t h i s 15 t h da y o f J u l y , 2021 . *60 / s / B r i tt an v L . W illi a m s B R I T T A N Y L . W I LL I A M S D epu t y C oun t y A tt o r ne y

C O M P L A I N T 21 - 2 068 W I LL I S H I N TZ , M i ss ou l a C oun t y S he r i ff s O ff i c e KE L A N L A R S O N , M i ss ou l a C oun t y S he r i ff s O ff i c e 45 - 5 - 401 - R obbe r y ^[610] N . W oody M i ss ou l a , M T ^[59802] F : ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5141] T : ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5140]

M ON T ANA S T A TE P U B L I C J a il L i ne : ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5197] T o ll F r ee : ( ^[866] ) ^[395] - ^[8883]

D

E F E ND E R

J u l y ^[23] , ^[2021] T o a pp l y on li n e o r f o r m o r e i n f o r m a ti on , s ee ou r " C li e n t s " p a g e

J a r e d G l e nn B a r t h a t: www . pub li c d e f e nd e r . m t . gov M i ss ou l a C oun t y D e t e n ti on F ac ilit y ^[2340] M u ll a n R o a d *61 M i ss ou l a , M T ^[59808] R E : S t a t e o f M on t a n a v . J a r e d G l e nn B a r t h C a u s e N o . D C - ^[21] - ^[414] W e h a v e r e c e i v e d yo u r c a s e i n f o r m a ti o n f r o m t h e F ou r t h J u d i c i a l D i s t r i c t C ou r t , M i ss ou l a C oun t y , M on t a n a . Y ou M U S T no w do t h e f o ll o w i ng : E M a k e a n a ppo i n t m e n t w it h you r a tt o r n e y t o d i s c u ss you r ca s e . E P r ov i d e you r a tt o r n e y w it h a li s t o f a ny p o t e n ti a l w it n e ss e s i n you r ca s e . E K ee p u s upd a t e d w it h you r c u rr e n t m a ili ng a dd r e ss , e m a il a nd phon e nu m b e r . E S t a y i n c on t ac t w it h you r a tt o r n e y a s o f t e n a s you r r e l ea s e c ond iti on s r e qu i r e .

I M P O R T AN T I N F O R M A T I ON A B OU T YOU R C A S E : • A ss i gn e d A tt o r n e y : K e lli S . S a t h e r , ^[610] N . W oody M i ss ou l a , M T ^[59802] , ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5140] . • ^[163133] i s you r P ub li c D e f e nd e r I D r e qu i r e d t o acce ss you r ca s e i n f o r m a ti on on li n e on t h e P ub li c

D e f e n d e r C li e n t P o r t a l l o ca t e d on ou r w e b s it e a t h u p s : / / p u b l i c d e f e n d e r . ; n t . g o v / c l i e n t s . • N e x t C ou r t D a t e : J u l y ^[26] , ^[2] ^[02] ^[1] a t ^[9] : ^[00] a m i n ^[4] t h D i s t r i c t , M i ss ou l a , D e p t ^[4] . Y ou r a pp ea r a n ce a t t h i s h ea r i ng i s r e qu i r e d . If you f a il t o a pp ea r a t you r h ea r i ng , a w a rr a n t m a y b e i ss u e d f o r you r a rr e s t a nd you m a y l o s e you r r i g h t t o a j u r y t r i a l .

• D o N o t S p ea k W it h A nyon e A bou t Y ou r C a s e : T h i s i n c l ud e s t a l k i ng t o o t h e r i n m a t e s , l a w e n f o r ce m e n t , w it n e ss e s a nd f a m il y o r fr i e nd s , po s t s on s o c i a l m e d i a , s p ea k i ng on t h e t e l e phon e o r w r iti ng t o a nyon e o t h e r t h a n you r a tt o r n e y . T e l e phon e ca ll s a t t h e j a il a r e r ec o r d e d a nd m on it o r e d . A ny t h i ng you s a y w ill b e u s e d - a g a i n s t you .

• ' b i s c ov e r y / E v i d e n ce : O u r o ff i ce w ill r e qu e s t a c opy o f a ll e v i d e n ce i n you r ca s e ca ll e d " D i s c ov e r y " ( e . g . po li ce r e po r t , w it n e ss / v i c ti m s t a t e m e n t s , v i d e o s ) fr o m t h e p r o s ec u ti ng a tt o r n e y a nd L a a y t a k e _ a _ f e w y f ee l . P l ea s e m a k e a n a pp o i n t m e n t w it h you r a tt o r n e y t o r e v i e w t h i s i n f o r m a ti on .

W e p r o v i d e e f f e c t i v e p r o f e ss i o na l l e g a l s e r v i c e s w i t h e q u a l a c c e ss t o qu a l i t y c li e n t - c en t e r e d r e p r e s e n t a t i o n . ^[610] N . W oody M i ss ou l a , M T ^[59802]

M

O N T A N A S T A T E T : ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5140]

P

U B L I C •••• = ••• F : ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5141] •

D

E F E ND E R T o11 F r ee : ( ^[866] ) ^[395] - ^[8883] J a il L i n e : ( ^[406] ) ^[523] - ^[5197]

O c t ob e r ^[21] , ^[2021] *62 J a r e d G l e nn B a r t h ^[2340] M u ll a n R o a d M i ss ou l a , M T ^[59808] R E : ^[10] / ^[15] / ^[2021] C o m p l a i n t I nvo l v i ng S t e ph a n i e M c K n i gh t D ea r M r . B a r t h : I a m w r iti ng i n r e l a ti on t o you r w r itt e n c o m p l a i n t r e g a r d i ng S t e ph a n i e M c K n i gh t , r ece i v e d i n ou r o ff i ce on ^[10] / ^[15] / ^[2021] . A f t e r r e v i e w i ng you r c o m p l a i n t , I h a v e a g a i n c on s u lt e d w it h M s . M c K n i gh t ' s s up e r v i s o r , R ee d M a nd e l ko , r e g a r d i ng t h e i ss u e s you r a i s e d . M s . M c K n i gh t i s a n e x ce ll e n t a tt o r n e y a nd i s w o r k i ng h a r d t o p r e p a r e you r d e f e n s e . I ' m s o rr y t h e r e w a s a m i s c o mm un i ca ti on r e g a r d i ng D r . S c o l a tti ' s ti m i ng , bu t p l ea s e k ee p c o mm un i ca ti ng a nd w o r k i ng w it h M s . M c K n i gh t s o t h a t s h e ca n p r ov i d e you t h e b e s t , m o s t e ff ec ti v e r e p r e s e n t a ti on . A s I s a i d b e f o r e , M s . M c K n i gh t w ill c on ti nu e t o c on s u lt w it h you r e g a r d i ng t h e d i s c ov e r y i n you r ca s e s a nd a ny m e r it o r i ou s m o ti on s t h a t m i gh t b e f il e d . S i n ce r e l y , K o a n M e r ce r R e g i on a l D e p u t y P u b li c D e f e nd e r O ff i ce o f t h e M on t a n a P ub li c D e f e nd e r C c : S t e ph a n i e M c K n i gh t

610 N. Woody Missoula, MT 59802

MONTANA STATE T: (406) 523-5140 PUBLIC F: (406) 523-5141 bEFENDER

Toll Free: (866) 395-8883 Jail Line: (406) 523-5140

*63 September 28, 2021 Jared Glenn Barth Missoula County Detention Center RE: State of Montana v. Jared Barth

Cause No: DC-21-414 Dear Mr. Barth: . I got your message regarding Ms. McKnight. She has sent your reports from both your cases. I understand you gave away the discovery in your first case to a family member. We are happy to send you a new copy in that case. Additionally, Ms. Mcknight says she hasn't received a message from you on her phone recently. Be sure to leave a voicemail for her if you don't reach her when you call. I assure you she is working for you and your case. Should you have questions, please be sure to call your attomey Stephanie McKnight at (406) 523-5140.

/ Sincerely, Reed Mandelko Office of State Public Defender

We provide effective professional legal services with equal access to quality client-centered representation. publicdefender.mt.gov 610 N. Woody

MONTANA STATE

Missoula, MT 59802 PUBLIC

DEFENDER

T: (406) 523-5140

F: (406) 523-5141

To11 Free: (866) 395-8883 Jail Line: (406) 523-5140

*64 October 06, 2021 Jared Glenn Barth 2340 Mullan Road Missoula, MT 59808 RE.• 10/5/2021 Complaint Involving Stephanie McKnight Dear Mr. Barth: I am writing in relation to your written complaint regarding Stephanie McKnight, received in our office on 10/5/2021. After ensuring Ms. McKnight had a chance to review and consider your complaint, I reviewed your case file and consulted with Ms. McKnight's supervisor, Reed Mandelko, regarding the issues raised in your complaint. Mr. Mandelko and I agree that Ms. McKnight is providing you effective assistance of counsel and that assignment of a new attorney is not warranted at this time. Our office has sent you your discovery paperwork and will make it available to whomever you direct. Ms. McKnight will continue to consult with you regarding the motions to be filed in your case, but she is ethically required to use her professional judgment to only file those motions that she believes to be of potential merit and use in your case. I kinow your current situation is frustrating, but I urge you to continue to work with Ms. McKnight so that she can provide you the best defense possible in your case. Sincerely, Koan Mercer Regional Deputy Public Defender Office of the Montana Public Defender Cc: Stephanie McKnight

(eb po (c) Th-e y 4.6 1 ted_ hey- - why 'She__ Jekgye *65 a..40 1 e Scr . 14, ,1 `.; ieft_6_0‘,4 _ 9 I % 617 r- t e l e C a ti ( 4 , L _ S i ) e s ee / A . i d / 11 1 ( A , + . t )- T e . J 4 , 0 AA S e r 507 gd , y 6 L p ec w o e k s h e ( . 0 c / i i 40 - 7 L / 00 . k _ L v , v e . az i v w . _ , : k . a D ' o r ee n . S . € 7 : ,. : . : 5 1q . 7 . e ... A ° 77 1 : 1 : _d r a i L A ‘ k it 3 ) 1 e - -

- r e e kv i c i o y e • ee a

y4

Q c A / P ti e i c

_

C ee

•

e g . 7 4 . o a f - P a r v ; _ f it a s . 31 - 1 t

yu

fr _ ! ; , _o_ ' 1 . / 17 - 1 - 6 4 , 79 , 5 -f a . 47 - 4 ° s i n e . f . / A - P _ e _ c 4_1 ` K d 65 . , 57 , 6 , 6 / i c e 5 4 , c 6u . // 5 0 L i . i s ) 5 ' ;

,

(07) .[P__,.._c()_.;:th,__y -t,"713 *66 hel° Job, i kat/6_ bte71

LA):11

_as kihj, Me ,,(t S-efict Ale ,44 y Tve_adafic .3Pie sa/Q( ba'J 3 wec Ks cv9c3 __(>0{.)

ari.,s.i1341..ev 41:

,reles.5€

_pacte:_e•cuiert

ke(S

-c®r kx9.1-4-r Vne

g to-eeks _SAe

tA)ör/LIQ/ co/L-1.e 11/2 -91 blet ha _5 7)0/- Yet 1-

beeA

ot -Ce

7'16 _ 41_0 %2S,

do/i-e so„ qi5c3 tieIC 6t-0-c..CW --717c ke-03,(c 1,1av,--azta.y_sferl be4 t . Azi_0116/2Y, /v)-e 1,.a./YA .hoive Vie4t .

pm )-e

61.4 k 7E0 yo az_ cv" th nre S J a r ed B a r t h N o t e s R u ss e ll La F oun t a i n / S t ephan i e M c K n i f i r , h t S ep t e r nbe r ^[30] , ^[2021] M e n t a l S t a t u s E x a m i na t i on and B eha v i o r a l O b s e i v a t i on s : J a r ed B a r t h i s a t h i r t y - one ( ^[31] ) y ea r- o l d , engaged , C au c a s i an m a l e . M r . B a r t h w a s c li n i c a ll y i n t e r v i e w ed and p syc ho l og i c a ll y a ss e ss ed f o r app r o x i m a t e l y an hou r a t t he M i s s ou l a C oun t y *67 D e t en t i on F a c ili t y . F o r t he e x a m i na t i o r i M r . B a r t h w a s d r e ss ed i n t he t r ad i t i ona l o r ange j a il j u m p s u i t. H i s h y g i ene and g r oo m i ng w e r e adequa t e . H e d i d no t e x h i b i t an y unu s ua l beha v i o r s , m anne r i s m s , ph ys i c a l c ha r a c t e r i s t i cs , o r s pee c h pa tt e r n s . M r . B a r t h w a s c o r d i a l and c oope r a t i v e du r i ng - t he a ss e ss m en t. H e pa r t i c i pa t ed i n a ll a s pe c t s o f t he a ss e ss m en t. D u r i ng t he e v a l ua t i on , M r . B a r t h d i s p l a y ed an app r op r i a t e r ange o f a f f e c t , d e m o n s t r a t i n g a f u ll b an d o f e m o t i on s d u r i ng t h e i n t e r v i e w . T he e m o t i on e x pe r i en c ed appea r ed t o be c ong r uen t w i t h t he s i t ua t i on s d i sc u ss ed . H i s de m eano r w a s t y p i c a ll y r e l a x ed and c ongen i a l . M r . B a r t h ' s v e r ba l beha v i o r appea r ed t o de m on s t r a t e c and i d , s pon t aneou s , and open c o mm un i c a t i on . O v e r a ll , M r . B a r t h ' s a tt i t ude and de m eano r t h r oughou t t he e v a l ua t i on p r o c e ss s ee m ed t o be open , f r an k , and r e s pon s i v e . M r . B a r t h w a s o r i en t ed t o pe r s on , p l a c e , and t i m e . H e c o rr e c t l y i den t i f i ed t he c i t y , c oun t y , s t a t e and l o c a t i on w he r e he w a s a t. A dd i t i ona ll y , he k ne w h i s age , t he y ea r , s ea s on , m on t h da y o f t he w ee k and da t e . ' H i s gene r a l .f und o f i n f o r m a t i on w a s i n t a c t. H e w a s ab l e t o i den t i f y t he c u rr en t p r e s i den t, f i r s t p r e s i den t, c ap i t a l o f M on t ana , nu m be r o f da ys i n a m on t h

N d appa r en t d i s t u r ban c e s w e r e no t ed i n h i s a tt en t i on and ho w m an y n i ck e l s a r e i n a and c on c en t r a t i on du r i ng t he i n t e r v i e w . T he r e w e r e no i nd i c a t i on s o f o r gan i c i m pa i r m en t, i n t e ll e c t ua l d i s ab ili t y , o r p syc ho s e s . M r . B a r t h ' s i n t e ll e c t ua l ab ili t y w a s e s t i m a t ed t o be a v e r age . E x e c u t i v e f un c t i on i ng p r ob l e m s no t e v i den c ed b y poo r p l ann i ng and o r gan i z a t i on . A dd i t i ona ll y , h i s j udg m en t, r ea s on i ng and i n s i gh t appea r ed t o be adequa t e . A b s t r a c t i ng t h i n k i ng w a s i n t a c t a s M r . B a r t h w a s ab l e t o c o rr e c t l y i den t i f y f ou r ( ^[4] ) o f f ou r ( ^[4] ) s i m il a r i t i e s and t w o ( ^[2] ) o f t h r ee ( ^[3] ) c o mm on s a y i ng s : A ud i t o r y c o m p r ehen s i on w a s i n t a c t w i t h no appa r en t d i ff i c u l t i e s . H i s t hough t c on t en t w a s app r op r i a t e f o r t he s i t ua t i on . M r . B a r t h ' s m e m o r y p r o c e ss e s w e r e i n t a c t f o r i m r ned i a t e , s h o r t - t e r m , an d r e m o t e e v e n t s . M r . B a r t h ' s t hough t s w e r e c ohe r en t, and he e x p r e ss ed h i s i dea s i n a c on s i s t en t an d r a t i ona l m a n ne r . T he r e w e r e no h i s t o r i c a l o r c u rr en t i nd i c a t i on s o f de l u s i on s o r ha ll u c i na t i on s . M r . B a r t h ' s c li n i c a i p r e s en t a t i on an d pe r s ona l h i s t o r y doe s no t s ugge s t t he p r e s en c e o f an y m ood d i s o r de r . M r . B a r t h d i d no t e x p r e ss an y ho m i c i da l o r s u i c i da l i dea t i on , p l an s , ge s t u r e s , o r pa s t beha v i o r s . U nde r s t and i ng o f Lega l S i t ua t i on : U t ili z i ng t he C o m pe t en cy t o S t and T r i a l G u i de li ne s , de v e l oped b y t he G r oup f o r t he A d v an c e m en t o f P syc h i a t r y , ba s ed on ' he D u sky v . U n i t ed S t a t e s ( ^[1960] ) s t and a r d s and c r i t e r i a f o r c o m pe t en c y o u t l i n e d i n W e i t e r v . S e tt l e ( ^[1961] ) . . M r . B a r t h po ss e ss e s t he f o ll o w i ng p s y c ho l ega l ab ili t i e s :

s ^[1] *68 . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o be ab l e t o unde r s t and h i s c u rr en t l ega l s i t ua t i on . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o unde r s t and t he c ha r ge s aga i n s t h i m . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o unde r s t and t he f a c t s r e l e v an t t o t he c a s e . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o d i sc l o s e pe r t i nen t f a c t s s u rr ound i ng t he a ll eged ' o ff en s e . W hen a sk ed t he c ha r ge s aga i n s t h i m , M r . B a r t h w a s ab l e t o g i v e a de t a il ed a cc oun t o f t he a ll eged r obbe r y . H e s t a t ed he w a s i nno c en t o f t he c ha r ge s . ^[2] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o unde r s t and t he l ega l i ss ue s and p r o c edu r e s i n h i s *69 c a s e . ^[3] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o unde r s t and l ega l de f en s e s a v a il ab l e i n h i s beha l f. ^[4] .. M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o unde r s t and t he d i s po s i t i on s , p l ea s , end pena l t i e s

po ss i b l e , no r doe s he de m on s t r a t e an ab ili t y t o app r a i s e t he li k e l y ou t c o m e s . ^[5] . M r . B a r t h ha s a good unde r s t and i ng o f t he r o l e s o f de f en s e c oun s e l , p r o s e c u t i ng a tt o r ne y and j udge . M r . B a r t h r e l a t ed : D e f en s e A tt o r ne y : " S t ephan i e , t he y a r e s uppo s ed t o l oo k a t a ll t he e v i den c e , w ha t l t o l d t he m , f o r m u l a t e a c a s e , f o r m u l a t e a de f en s e t o he l p m e . " P r o s e c u t i ng / C oun t y A tt o r ne y : ^[1] don ' t k no w t he n a m e . T he y a r e f o r m u l a t i ng a c a s e aga i n s t m e . T r y i ng t o c on v i c t m e o f w ha t e v e r c r i m e i s a ll eged . " J udge : " La r s on . H e l oo ks o v e r t he c a s e . H e hea r s t he de f en s e and p l a i n t i ff s a r gu m en t s and he c on c l ude s and m a k e s a j udg m en t o f gu il t y o r no t gu il t y and i f gu il t y p r onoun c e s a s en t en c e . ^[6] . H i s ab ili t y t o a ss i s t i n h i s de f en s e i s adequa t e . H e w an t s h i s a tt o r ne ys t o do m o r e and doe s no t r ea ll y t r u s t t he m . H e de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o c o m p r ehend i n s t r u c t i on s and ad v i c e f r o m h i s a tt o r ne y ; he de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o m a k e de c i s i on s a ft e r r e c e i v i ng ad v i c e f r o m h i s a tt o r ne y and he de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o m a i n t a i n a c o ll abo r a t i v e ee l a t i on s h i p w i t h h i s a tt o r ne y . ^[7] . M r . B a r t h d e m on s t r a t e s an ab i li t y t o t e s t i f y r e l e v an t l y a n d b e c r o s s - e x a m i ne d i f ne c e ss a T y . ^[8] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o t o l e r a t e s t r e ss a t t he t r i a l and w h il e a w a i t i ng t r i a l ^[9] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o u nd e r s t an d t he d i s po s i t i on s , p l ea s , and pena l t i e s

po ss i b l e . ^[10] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o i den t i f y w i t ne ss e s .. ^[11] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an a b il i t y t o f o ll o w t e s t i m on y f o r c on t r ad i c t i on s o r e rr o r s . ^[12] . M r . B a r t h de m on s t r a t e s an ab ili t y t o p r o t e c t h i m s e l f and t o u t ili z e t he l ega l s a f egua r d s

a v a il ab l e t o h i m . Respectfully, Michael J. Scolatti, Ph.D. Licensed Clinical Psychologist OPD Mental Health Consultant

*70 F o r m ^[10] ( ^[4] )

C

E R T I F I C A TE O F S E R V I C E I ce r ti f y t h a t I f il e d t h i s ^[0] P e titi on ^[0] M o ti on

P

s hpo r v : s e y c o , l + r o N I ' O t h e r ^[1] . ,, J . ( t ' t *71 [ N a m e o f do c u m en t] w it h t h e C l e r k o f t h e M on t a n a S up r e m e C ou r t a nd . t h a t I h a v e m a il e d o r h a nd d e li v e r e d a c opy t o eac h a tt o r n e y o f r ec o r d a nd a ny o t h e r p a r t y no t r e p r e s e n t e d by c o un s e l a s f o ll o w s :

" S a f b a 7 t y L . // a / I- 1 747

f

o ( 75g c 4 . ' " P , ' A e

%

ov a , / I T Y 8 c : D . [ A dd r e ss ] C oun s e l f o r . ^[5] - ^[0] ' F e a A l ^[0] / 1104q [ O t h e r p a r t y r e p r e s o ti ng h i m s e l f o r h e r s e l f]

P c \ k a V S a P e ( ; 0 ( . / 11 T 5 ? 72 [ A dd r e ss ]

d a y o f f ee b ( ^[4] ^[0] ( y , ^[20] ^[42] DA TE D t h i s . ( I VA 41 ^[12] 544# P [ s i gn a t u r e ] i G 1 ( e c i B A ( - 0 1 [ P r i n t n a m e ] © M on t a n a S up r e m e C ou r t F o r m 10 ( 4 ) C E R T I F I C A TE O F S E R V I C E I ce r ti f y t h a t I f il e d t h i s ^[0] P e titi on ^[0] M o ti on ^[0] O t h e r t e x it 0 - c S C 4 F , ' 41 / 1 / 1 . 2 ( X ( 0 / -r t i o

*72 , [ N a m e o f do c u m e n t ] w it h t h e C l e r k o f t h e M on t a n a S up r e m e C ou r t a nd t h a t I h a v e m a il e d o r h a nd d e li v e r e d a c opy t o eac h a tt o r n e y o f r ec o r d a nd a ny o t h e r p a r t y no t r e p r e s e n t e d by c oun s e l a s f o ll o w s :

A l - ko r A e y - e , - e r a [ N i t ^[8] i e f op I ng2 i n j e g o

e l e / ^[1] C A , m y 5 - 9620 [ A dd r e ss ] - ^[1] C oun s e l f o r ^[546] ti e o c " • \ 0 , - 4 - 6 . 4 a L

t.

(

ð - ee < I G a r t - A , [ O t h e r p a r t y r e p r i . ^[5] e i g i ng h it n s e l f o r h e r s e l f] ko M ( s

o

r ee • i c r / 14 - 70 - . 6 c l u z [ A dd r e ss ] DA TE D t h i s 2_ d a y o f r e6a t e t r y , ^[202] Z . /