Respondent appeals from a final order reducing the real estate tax assessment on petitioner’s real property in the City of Syracuse from $258,800 to $180,000. The plot is
It is apparent that the property had to be sold to settle the estate of the previous owner. The proof of the facts and circumstances of the sale does not warrant the giving of great weight to the amount paid, as evidence of the value of the property. Petitioner’s expert estimated the reconstruction cost of the building at $318,200 and the present depreciated value at $127,304, notwithstanding the repairs and improvements which had been made to the property at a cost of $250,000 only five years prior to the assessment date. Respondent-appellant’s expert estimated reconstruction cost at $332,658.24 and the present depreciated value at $259,473.43. The land was appraised by petitioner’s expert at $153,000 and by respondent-
Property in the City of Syracuse was assessed at 60% of its value. The land assessment of $194,800 indicated a full land value of $324,667. Special Term found the full value of the land to be $200,000 and the full value of the land and building to be $300,000. Considering the sale of the property to petitioner in 1955 for $295,000, the recent rehabilitation of the building at a cost of $250,000, the reconstruction cost of the building, the location of the land, the frontage of two streets and the value of the land, we find that the value of petitioner’s real property on the assessment date was $400,000, which, assessed at 60%, requires that the assessment of the property be reduced from $258,800 to $240,000. (Of. Real Property Tax Law, § 502, subd. 3.)
Williams, P. J., Bastow, Goldman, Halpern and Henry, JJ., concur.
Final order unanimously modified by fixing the assessed valuation of the real property at $240,000 and as modified affirmed, without costs of this appeal to any party. Certain findings of fact disapproved and reversed and new findings made.
