Case Information
*1 OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF TEXAS AUSTIN Yf- ,-
il&ul c. MAPut ,o.m 0m*-*L #“’ maoxable J. P. We-
G’Bolon6r of Ag?ioultm
AUtiP, TOXU
tho A& l usb 08 to 19, u&J a alp r o oa la- b. &i~r”rs statian, label t6 red ooataln- *2 Nonoreblo J.E.HoDonald,~
“Third I
9118~0 out-or-•t0te a00d d00w b00 0 00x00- 11111 operating in tb0 or 2-r l 0mit* fitfit ~a000 plurt l eed, end mhlpwnte o r0 wde da0 b out-or-*tote rtor1130d0r0mw l eloewn rm wed, lr ould tble ow tb o rtotuet o r wh ere out-of-*tote
doelo r hoe wed tb o mello, Redlo, Telegrqih bpr Tolephem to.eollolt ordore ror mood, vould thla etieot tin l tetue.m '(0) It *hall bo unlavrul for poreon to 0uI orfor rgp? role, or oxpofie rm I uy em-o- 3e ulturel o r vegoteble l o od ultbln thle 0tot.o: I . . . .
"(2) Not labobd in eooordewo llq lemlngr"
aootion3 oftho Aotpnrarlbe~tho lafarMt1Qntobe given on l ueb l&ml.
uo not0 thet thle ml epplloe, by it0 tome, only to thwe rho cell, 0rr0r ror -10, or 0
turel or?o okble reedrithinthie peiml tetu 0, it suet be etriot t oonetruod vlh plea5 mwnlng or it0 Jurle~~of W27 s euoa there oltod. , krow tb0 r0a- ~k0nioro~uto~~orr0~ituutk~~tht
l wh e eleveewdeinTo~8. %MI plea0 ubn 0 aootrmt OS atie ie W, vithln the wening oi the rule tbet the low the plea0 of eel0 govome, lo .tbo plroe vlmr* tbo loot rot rmeo8my to o-late the 000 t-t 0r 00x0 i0 p0rrm. . . .I 55p0rp~0 ad0 2p. xofr o tlrmt two quemtloq pro0 in. anoth er l teto. A .,t~"&re8& ~&!hii~*eoit.i?b.8 0 eerteln plea0 vltbwt awllSleetlw won0 tb0t @Ode or0 to bsglro~~barrde~e~~hi~ntvltba~#t~~eot
xOnOr8blOJ.P.WonOneld*~3
buyer, end t&et tltlo thou pee&&e, ed tb propwty ie than r%l*G p buJer** rake hveon v Bobbee%~~$?eE~~$@t~~e~~
t&n, wodd be mode, bt ln beep but & & eh&o@a et&t..'
Ye tb0r- enevw your riret tuo ~wetlone Ln the axqptin. Butthie aplalOnle baedlanthe ue~t~0athatt.M wdh8vO n0tbe0n0f~Omdr0rulo+ith&the *tat0 Orhae by wm out-or-&tote #hf lo nottobe o r cud ny
Iav by lebollng lateretete l lonm 0r t&a F odo rel Lou.
521+39,f0s0th0r0~dle0ue010ia0rthe r*tofe 0Ute to oxorolee it0 p01100 pver In 0 aann0r t&et lwldontelly efioote lntoretet* Okra., cad in 0 rleld elroedy pertly eovarod by Fadoral la&eution.) Your third quoetloa lo beeod upoa 8 au0 in vialob t&w
out-Or-&tot@ wd doelm l ollolte,~ ;~it~we;q~ be eblp ped
by him into 20x00, 0 oltb r by ueno o r 0 l eloemea, nil, W -0, br t. U-R& 7 We kllevm th , la l lth8r oeeo th e l o od lo _ E%SZ?Z Mtbla th e l Uto of hxae uithlk the YuII a of th e Tome Bud Lev. W hoa a l eod de&r la 8aotW &tote wee redio, r0l, inat8nae. u meum oi peotlvo buyme uithinthe Stat. oiiexee,hi order0 for rood thea, vltbla the uaalti8 of tble Aat, bo offore
Ue l eed r0l’ l eio rlthln tibia .eteto, aot,rltheWadlag thet tlte
b+mtod An euah other Wth And tb e&me meem- olloltetloue b p l a&uun,mell, In t& wee of Ualtod ~Btetee va Bodga, 25 Pod. Cu. wt tbrmng @a, it tf00 had thet, war 0ti mowal mw tb bueiruee 0f0 reteildahr laintaricut;lng llquar~ee l SSOe perewutio h ellee l jZZlo& puwhmor. poreoatokoow BJ olloltetl0n p0rLl g ofgrlprorele;gp~~~a~tlt&e “Itmyk dau\rJ 0i Uy prrtioaler aor8l ed- r vortlewante fir tha proee.” 29 Warda aad ?lmaeoe 3!& la whloh tb8 eoeetlw hew We bow fooad a0 Two0 wee a0 fitdihwitt r0r krt9rt3 w be km &a-. But vo find uge OW ltioalntho0pbi0a0ftbB~ ~OurtOf&WlIUO lnt wee 0S *ire Cer ba a Uo r ke *a J. 0. B ulc c p & CO., l9 9 c *4 Boaorebla J. E. NoDoneld, pega
a. v. 929. 2het oeae celled for 8 deolelon of Wm qmetion ehlpper or rortllinr8, hlpplng it0 whothor ee out-of-*tats poduot into Arkeneee on ordore token by 8 eelsemen in &keneee, eubjeot to hle prinolpel'e aoepteme in the other eteto, eiuet comply vlth en Wf.OneO8 l tMM,e mquirlng 0tay per8aa vim &old or offered for eelc ury fertllleer in the &&eta or Arkeneee to file 8 guerenteed enely-ele vlth the &tote aeeB$eeloner or ul~urere y ataaato lt tqe ee pcovlded by the tetute. x0-
. 2h0 opm.on.0rtha 00winthot0800 i.8 eo epplloe r 1s to the Smote preeontod Is your third queetlon, that we teke the liberty or quotiag from it at length; “It 16 lneletod thet the eboun trmoectlm
in the reoord doe8 sot conetitute an ‘offer for 8alo b t&c etate of Arkaneae~ within the ilieenlng It lo oXeIx+d thet there worde of the tatutel are deelgwd to prerent a poreon or corporetfon rrola pleolng rertlllcere in hle *tore or v8rthoufse ln thle eteto end thmvlng open the doore to the publla and thue e%poelng the fect:licero r0c aelr.
The nrjorlty or the oourt, howwr, thie lo ‘think too nerrou Q N8trlated 0 areeAi.ng to be given to th4 vorde *offer rw eele in the *tat* or Arken-
If thle hed been the purpoee of the IagLe- c%e deubtleee it would have ueed the wmde
'keep io r l elo,~ lnetsed or *order for &ale.* m0 nfasity or the 00w ore 0r the 0pfdLon th0t the uoaxb ‘orfor ror eeler aould bo glwn a broador moenln& or oouree, wo thLz& that, Jf
a per&an or oarporatlon hould keep fertilizera in hle *tore end expoee them ror re2e in the
*tot* or &mu, tm.e eat vould aonetltute en orra for l elo. In oth er vo rdm, w think the rertillrer rYteriele aould he oficrred for' overt act cf oll~~tet ifm. Ue mole vlthout w r-eel ouuelly l uw that proof ton&lqg to ehw cay owmt or trditidu0l 8ele vithh orror or thh f8rrtlllro~e for th0 *tot0 or krkaaeu ea croolltitutod *tote or Arkan- ‘offerla8 r0r **lo* within the the 000 within t& wealag Ia other wrde, eet. w thhk 0th eotwl porrw Or w wl0 0r the r~tiuzrr by ua egont oi the ellm omo prr; tituler pereon ww.a tba *tat0 kaad0ar ooaetl- twd +n ‘0rrw raa, *al* vlthu the etato t rithin the nhlq of the *totut*. In s@tmha& tar. ooa- aluelon we em not umlndfu ofthe1ege1m
thet penel l tatuke met be l trlotlJ owetrued. aothvr aardaelrule ora-trwtlan tit0 rind
the lo l latlve into&, end ln dleoowr ob oot Of the l tetuto l hould be oane 2t22 f’
"III th0 QUO 0r st. L., I. n. 69. R. CO. v. mldrap, 93 Ark. 42, 123 9. Y. 778, tb court uldr
"Whle l tetutole 0 penal law, tithe legal ruirlethetewh~levehovldbeaoaet~wd
l trlotly. But thle doea not man thet the word8 or the t8tute hould be o Mrrowautou- elude moo vhi0hthoeevamle intbelr oamon endordinrrrf~a~rtloa,vouid omprvhegd.' 2,
"InStote v. Se~.ll,45&k.387~ th8 oourt rooo@udthat,uUle pen8% Ututoe wotobe
w~~truodetrlotly,new l leooqlpllttedtothe grinoifl0 th0t th0 int0nti028 0r ta s43gbm~~
mwt~ovornthe oonetruotlcmoipenmlee veUu l tetutee era not 0th~ tatut~e, and thet be owetrwd 00 l Wlot 00 to woet th e la- f)p”“l of tha &@.eleture. In 0000 the 0-t to&ion ~~t~~~~~lfi~~~J~tu~~~* W h0 I-U& 0r l trlot hdrpwtetlw a000 not 0~ 00uug in th0 fita atar w00, pm-t t a0 .ud glvlng eeeh it0 ~gp r oW.ek l *Ow, eenottoovort~thleoM. F o r. rm M& tituhe are not to b o 86 o~~truod 00 wo r k M aurdity, w d0r0at tblr purport 0sr tb
~o~~f,the aourt initltutoa far, their on-
%a8 Lrrt08ktiw 0r ram &gieleturo In peee- gziJpg;;~Y~~&$~+~f~ by . . * St. Rep. j32, t folloi.8
"*Ae we wdoretend the t4tut0, lte ooatrol- lag purpoee we to 6wrd the q5rlaultur0l pub2l.a ege3net rpurloum uzb worthleee wmpowde eon- tiase oldee femlllmM3, to rls on rollem a *6 atOtutOry guawnty thOt fortlllserfi &old by th&m
oanteln the ulmaloel lqpodlente, end in tho pm-
portlone, repreeentod, and to furnl8h to buyer0
ahoep end rellablo mene or p~oviqg tho baeptlan
and fraud, m hould rush b o l ttomptea. T h e eoaom- pllehunt of the&e objeote vill greatly aaoto the poepmrlty cad l ua ao~e oS the fig10 ur twel
la&Wry, ud we do not bveltmte to doalero
thay ere l trfotly vithla the pelo of Zagltlnate
pollae reguletlcm.~
"It le obvloua thet, lr the ooaetruotlon to be pleoed upoa the tetuto bJ the tx@t
pbm.irr 8kmuZ.d govern, tha objoat’or f&a et&-
uto would in 0 urge meeeuro be br00tOd. Ii
the mnte or powono or awpoalovaamlallod
without tho tete oould oolb into tho etAto uud
8ollslt order0 troa pePeoxu hwv, aek¶ng tb em-
treat l ubjeat th e ep p r ovel of th e how 0rri00
in onothor eteto, md then hlp tbo r0muun
into the eteto ulthout owpl~'tith *tot0
love ln regerd thermto, it le ovidoat that the etatuto vfwld to 4 greet extent
gqozo;fath, On the other haul, tho ooaetruatloa
tin mejorlt' have plaood upon tb etatute will rreotueto &I 0 p?qpoeo the laglelotulwaed In
puelaglt,andwthlnkvehwa glvon~r8amcue
able reala tke vmde *@for for *ale.@’
It i8 0~ oplnlon that vb0r0 an out-0raat0 *hi l Hd sollolto order0 for l o od ln T~Jc~o, by qdne of 0 ir 0 ee- men, by m@, by redlo, by tolo&troph, or by totiphvne, voh oUaltetloa oonetitutee en offer r0F ulo vltblu tUe tete, llenae vlth the Toxee $ood Law la re rtilnd aa to eny Ma ehlpmen a uda into thle state u 8 neult 0; ordorr Fooured "0
by l uoh m8um. I: ..".
Y31~ i:~! ;y - r: , p&& my&e var;L truly