Case Information
*1 ~~~ 7~b ... l'1 ·' \ . ~--~\).IN IHE: CouRr oF CRr·m,·,Jffl APPE.flls oF YE.Xfls
~C~Di~E~ UM · .. · . ~©~if\JfitL~~ J\U$ !J ~ &®~I ~fbJ®U~,CU~ · . PE1t1totJ FoR WRr'1'oF (YlfltJdflmus -xe PRdiMiNAR)' SIA1EmE,.lf
1\lcrrtc£ WHEREAS IHE PRt'so,JE~"~ MABr.ns /1£-rr·lr'oJJ urJde~ Ar<f(Jc tJ' 0/, c' c I Po. w r=l5 r,:tEJ iN -(ffr;. t77 1'!1 i/t'S{~r'cT ~ D } .
CouR-( ttl HltRf2.i~ CouN1y; 1~:Xfl>, (')~ J'ulf l 0; d.OI5 ) . [1] ,·~ Ct11l~£ 538931·-rYt ftrJd tHE (~ft( Ct>llf-f 1H~REJ1riE-t?- fldoP-rEd ~({E ~IP( S1A1E'~· Pr<oPo.se:d n·rJdr/J3> oF l===llc~ ArJd co,Jc(us/o,Js oF {ttul · otJ ju.s-r :3 [1] ~o 15 • Fu/C11{E~ 1 W~t'c.U tflt; P&iSotJrit:;.'!; 0ix1«~ ~ - 0 f I s ftE(<E{~ l (jf -{flc/kd (o TH~<: t'NS'"( "'"'I i)o CcJ (11 ~~ ( mfV-\CI f!P1tt.p
FoR 1Hr. Cou~~ R£\l(EW o HouJE.\/E.{(, 'ft-1£. Pr<.\sorJ~~ s tJol' StJ~E. *3 ,' N ;1' _s AS 5 E_((_ y, 'o A1 ~ flN-d i:lt£. Pr<.t(X>~£(2_ SE.EXs
iN c oR f< t.c_ \ fo~ (fir's CouRI''-(.o R~Mtl/\\d l'H~ Pf2oC."e..di19> BfJe.K -,::'D IHE Couf<_:( B£lovJ FoR iJddt-nb,Jfl( p-flc(- F,'l\\dl [4] '9S Md Co~c(uStotJs irJ / Aw o '1Hu~ 1o mtlKE. ('(1od:FtcAu~.J.> ,
]ITO rHE SuPREJYJ£ Cout<--r t-Ills rYllld£ i-r ciEAtZ) uJH~gE TI/E \>~::.PRi\lf11ibtJ oF R•Jftfs: ( (, sucH !HAY it tJEcE.ssAr<.t/y Ah'~ orz, imPflcT> ,11-IE cotJdt'-(tbNs or f<ESif<fi/NI oR fflc.1 oR I~ \)f '\:JE.I'E,.\fto~ J 1H£ H~f!,t/15 ftJ~'f/otJ (£ 1/(E <Wly fhHltlfiSI£
A"E-NuE of t<E.\\Ef, .SEE: ~t.A{Y)r£~ vs(b FAuvER 1 ~ gg f. :?>d M 5lfo c~ood) CtiliJ3: Pf-16.-iSER VSe Ro~u~q~ .s. c,'. 1 '6~'7 '-+1 I U· S .. lf-7 5 (1 97i)
· ~o(l,ES~ 11{~:. Rt:::.ll'r=-F AsSIG/Z..'f 51!>UjHT tllti... fk{>otJEI?-) ,cflA!
1Ndttd Se. (}RftN1'f.d oN. Hfl~f\5. RE.Vt'E:uJ ~~d d1Efl1£~CL rN~ FoRm of CofYirr1ulfl1ibN oF PuNtsHmr=,.lJ r s Not THE. oN IX Rr::\1r::f fo~M of RE-\;E.f AvAr'IASIE iHe:. PR\5~~~ As t~d~ . ir-ldicfl1'~d ev 1Ht. S'{l/1t_ fi,Jcl{l/t Cov{/:(- B~[ow • fu~R- . f='ur<-(H~moRE - 1'ltE. (.oUR~ or tHE=- S(ff(E of '{E·K~5 HAVtf!9 · . oR~itJAf iTuR~·s-dfcll b N oF cRtfr1,',Jfll Ac.:-r,b,J.s SHAH Hflv£ PowER
RFTtz:R CotJvic-(Jb,J {o SLt5P~,Jd ffl~ ~)(ECLffio('\ of SE.tJIEtJc E ArJd PlAcE. IH~ PEf,:.,JdiiNJ' uPotJ A 5ufi=I<\Jt'SEd REh:~flSE [o RE.iiYIPosE SucH SErJTt:t-lc£ utJdER sucH cotJd[11orJ.s A5 If/£ lEgisltrfuRt=- mny Pt<EScR.~£3£ YfltCS ,'tJ RE(Il1fo,.J ·\o YHE Adu\-r *4 . PRoBAli'oN ANd PARol£ lllvJ PuRSuANI -rc {lR.i18ts Ltd.~ 14)
Af\Jd 4~, r ~~ c D c4) P~ sEE: PEiftY" vs0 t'tfur<.morJd) 51~ 5, ul, ad AI ! d-3 (IE'f;. Cf?.tfYI g flffi JCI7 tf)
.N. Fur«Hr=.f?..(Yio((E.J wH~NE\IER lfk cf-{1!1/ENg£ uhi'M~IEI ( A-(1ttcKs IHE CoRE of liPrl?lc-ft>- .- IHE \JAltd,·'f" cF-rf{E CONY,',.luE_d CON~o,J) oR. IHr£ tYlt:tR~ FAc.t of~ I c~ f/N£- n1E~I oR IENjiH Of 5Ek(ErJCE - II Cl-fAIIt.Nj£. HoWri.V£~ - ~~~£'i5 o'f-fH(_ iE!IEJ~ Raile:~ :ousHt ('litiS( f3E 8RollJM-r &y WAy o'f ltAS£115 CoRAJ.s fE!Itrotl . Sift: LEAr'YIER \)5o FflUVER, g.~g F. 3cl Al>tfd.. (3Rd c&. :>..oo()) . . .
IHE s;m-rr=:.'s PRoPos£d f,Nd{~> oF H1c.lllrJd Co"'clu:r'OA\s oF /II~ -~ IN RElAI/~tJ lo A REquESI f=o(2. C/E(Y}E rJcy IN IH£ FoRm ; of·,CorY1fYlu-m11. (oN oF SE"'T'EN C£ 'TI-l u.s BEt~q 1HE: o~(·y Fo~M
of Rt\\Ef AVA NAB I£ /o IHE PR.iSorJeJl Md N'o1 IJ\lfltlfll!£ As ·A - HASE~i$ Rc.rYJe.dy i~ 1f/u5 iftJcol'iS(S[~NC£ wi-rff (YloR£ Re:f~/JIJI
LAS£-IAW REliEF Sol{,9H1 o,J HffBEfl5 ~CI/rE:uJ • s~: ~&'8 F.3d AI 5~~ . s. c.l'. 1 g().f. (Ylof<J£.SoJ By Sd~ Re::h~_flsal ('() 1'~£ Co~dr1rotJ.> 9r- PnRol£ t>oEs No! AI ANy W,AY. AI'!'~R IHE fRpw-1- . E.R,S c.vRR~Y SENI'ErJC.~ of(75) ~E~~ LJHrcH ,EXA7<.EE5 o,.J
AujuS-( 14,~ d..?6'?. lflus .. DflfE oF If,~ flf<~f.SI e~JtN ON Atf9UST r~ I q8'f s
·-;
' :~r:_..~, •I_ -
-sL_q tA!Hf~REA> uNdt.((. /l-IEs r;_ P11R11C.u (fiR ciRcu rr1 Slf1rJcES. tl-1 £ fk1stW Et<..;f<Eia-ro~ SEEf(5 foiL 11/l's CDuf!-:f to Re.mANd tH£ 1-{ABEils fkocE Ed~·~~ rc Tf{£ cotJVtl.f;~ Cout:(-. &low Foe Rdd,ifoNfvl ff/c.[- f=,rJdt'N35 ArJcl co,Jc/ustorJs of /nw lflft( IJf<~ t«l.of<£ . co,Jsls-r~,JI wt-rK ill£ Hf1&ils co~Yq.l"J trJ t<E.\~~~~ --ro '(/+.£
CouRY} ft>wt.£2. ·y [0] susfkrJd -r~c. ~Ecun ~orl · of sEAG&tt- ~Hu.> . PlAc..tN3, '(fit. fkJ~o~~P- ufo,J ,q _Sufi:.fl. \ItS Ed {<G._t_E.~S£·'(f> gEJ•rtlfoS£ /E!JI'siAtuR'¥- • St:t:
sucH , St::r-\'(~rJc£ fl5 PRESCRl'gE-d gy Sf({(€- PI=.T-(1"1' \IS. Ll-iuR IYJoNd I > l6 s. ().}, ac( AI ~~ 3 tf_cXJ, Cf<Jfl'I.Rlf. lcrJ~
. ·1He. \)a'S(rZ.lc1 cou(L)~ .c.t~RJ!,~'f FtJ~1~ P/N.dt't-1_9:> t1Nd co,JclustbN
of ft+w iN RE.lA1fb,J fo _ cfE. fY7~cy· ,'rJ 1H6. foR.fYl oF- Com«luTtfT1hA ~e=.iNj 11k- orlly 'fnf<M oF REJtc:F IJVRt'lfii3Fi- To if{£ Fk$¥JE~J · rs IHu> lrJsuFf;'ciENY flrJd Ct4iJrJo1 Bt. SU511J/tJa/IJ _,:;,J Adc1Nt~t.l 1 SEE! E-X Pnt?,:ft s.tJ0 uJ,- t?cc.l<f--r tf 7~>o f'o3 - 5. w [4] ~d (t~~~ cf8«J, flfP. til qs) -- tlor t:>/~Ee-Yfy o~ Po: NT tJDR CorJsfs7trJY wtYil fk.tm1rf.Y. cflst./t~u£ o NoNe./1{£~ ; · lfll> Cou{lf DoES R~l/ltfJ Uu,elsdlc.TtbtJ corJcERr·H~ f11eol£ ... ·~ Rt::-lfl'fEcl rnrt/1~~5 o'
. ·~ li-.
• .. · g.!Jolit~: cJovJ t(J f} D [1] 'FFEf<E,J6 (lt<Efl of 7/1~ lfl~ 115 sEf-foR1H
JfSy f}R;,•cff. t{,o7 5EC, Lf@)J {f/t15 (/k S:frf (6' Sf/!(15. AtJd.-rf{t ~uf/tf qcl./~1- BEloW l-lt1S t=1f2E.Iy (/~e;.d 11/11'( 1(/£ (k,'5o,.JE.f2/1115 ffll1r=d *6 ID !rJdudEO.. Su~'f,'dENI SP!',;c,'rc:,'c F,4cf$ ESYf?-(!A~«It}J --(flit( 111-~ cu~Rer-\--r clfllfYl5 Could ~Jo( Hrtv£ eEE.J fkE.SE!Jirzd PR~Z\h'ous ' -t·y B£ct4US~ rtfE F~c.1ut1{ 0~ lEf]f1l Bflsts FoR- 11/G.. C.tlf<I<Ef·J-r
clf\ir'l1-> u~~\lflil AB>Ic o How£V£/Z.., ,Jo'f!::.L 11-1 ftt9£ ~ · .,
oF 1Hr;. Pt<}5otJ£ R-5 cuRf<t._,jy lfiiB£A> rbt71'1>tJ W iffE.R.E.tt> · ·· 'iHt.. pg,'5orJ£(l_ de M..l r f1f<_1i 'c v/flftE;; ·-co 1'#£ fi>MY /(J iNs ~Ftc.~··~ .5-ft1i£Err1~~y rt1 Pf19~ 0. 0F If,'>·· PE-111/b~ -rll~ti ~rf/t£ tiJ>111-tJ7 lk-rtY- r'o~ ~ itt ljlc.1 /rJc{ud~ 5uf/1c/t.tJ·~ :Jri:c-t'Flc file~ 'f-5111Bit'7/{I"!J 1!/ft1'f!l£ Fl!ctir/1{ {)(L /~fl/ [M9,$. &F 7/1£ Ctli<- R~\ cln;ms wE~£. u.ili/focrr It Df:)ugi uif fl\JIJ,'/IIe[E fttJd -tllv> Pt<E \J~~Yt=d -rffr; Pt<.l~o,J£{<_ F!Lo«< tl~SG.l?:tl'r:J 111££ /rJ5illtl{ c(flt~(Vl.> ,:1\l fit'~ ~~'R.~-r/f~h/11( Ha&rl-5 Pdt1/0N cti//1/EtJJ'"'!J If,~ otJGo,~ Ct»-kltC:1(o,J trJ CAd$£ -tt !?38?3( -fJ _ Y/lut; su8fl7/7-(€~ t'rJ1'1(~ ~ ye~rz. of.~·.# (Y]o((fESo_) er=-l"}J 1f{£ SiflrJdiiM cgrlr=J<Jo,J f/5 Sc(- Fo(Li/( (};;( fl{Z.Y,Ck If, o sc:c, 4@h c. c, ~ -tl/115 w~ E::N mnKl~ f\ suESE-9U~~1 fi1JB£A-> .. d/{1(/r;_tJy £- io iff£ SfJfYl€. eo~ fufL{/Ir;.{(f(I()((~J -11/e "Ffle-1-f/rJdlr!J> tttJcl catJd(j§loNJ .· vicllotJ ~~ ~ lflW r'N if(/~ f<J;.gfl;d fiR~ UtJ StJB Sf/HJ1t'/1-(r;.d f1Nd c/£tttly ff.tc,.~ r'{l}coRR~Se/. S'£f: Pt'llhltl's Wt2.1(' ttt PIIJ~ (.,. R~sPc:ct'P« lfr;
SEt.: ttiiA&fi\~~ . . ~· )j;Ji iJ/,((~tfk/)}L " :' :'
p{(:5tW£~- f£. \lifo~ Pr<o s~ *7 . VER.r'F(cftiloAl
:t=., Gl'll lfllt<oNc_ Wl-lt'-f£S 11/c.J-:;:t:: I> tt ~8t..f 15, r5El'NJ cuf44)f/y .£8~ &~h/J~d "tt> 1!/E .. r5t'l( C/Efll£k5 ttNf7 of fflr;;.. ;:,J5111'ri'TIO,.JPr{ Dt\Jr's/t>~ H>f2... -Ilk -(t..'IOfls ~£Pf~R=! ..- (Ylf:.r.\1' <'f Cfi(Yl/tJ/f( 1/157/C£ ~ · ~D ~By VER..1'ft ifflt-7 {t/£ ~JOt~ SiltfOJ1hl1'('? tf-~cll//f€31!1/o,J;;. (>r i$ 9/JIYZ£_~
fiR.~ -(f<rJ £ ,4tJd coR.Ptct PuRsunH -(() ~ tJ, S1 c_, SE~, l7lf G ~
'5t9N'Ed aAI 11/£ ¢ t>Ryof ~> d..C>l> o . ::
x: U·7Jfl{(DrJ£- QdJiL G-tu Um<ON£ wHt-tG:ff5:§)f'i15 Bi(( clf-(YI~ u#H' 538lf/S c.--"' q o t s l'titl ~ cr ~tnh/2/(/o i£KAS ·791o·7 *8 FILED Chris Daniel
District Clerk
JUL 2 9 20\5 No. 538931-M
§ IN THE 179TH DISTRICT COURT § OF
GILL JARONE WIDTE,
Applicant § HARRIS COUNTY, T E X A S
'-- ._t - . - • . ..... ~ ~ STATE'S PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW AND ORDER Having reviewed the applicant's Original Application for Writ of Habeas Corpus in the instant proceeding, the· State's answer, as well as all of the documents filed in the applicant's initial habeas proceeding cause number 538931- A, the Court recommends that the instant writ, cause number 538931-M, be dismissed based on the following findings of fact and conclusions of law:
1. The applicant is confined pursuant to the judgment and sent~nce_ of the 179th District Court of Harris County, Texas, in cause number 538931 (the primary case), where the applicant was convicted by the jury on February 12, 1990, for the felony offense of aggravated robbery.
2. The court assessed the applicant's punishment, enhanced by two (2) prior convictions, at seventy-five (75) years confinement in the Texas Department of Criminal Justice- Correctional Institutions Division (TDCJ CID).
3. The Fourteenth Court of Appeals affirmed the applicant's conviction in the primary case on February 14, 1991. White v. State, No. 14-90-00152-CR (Tex. App. - Houston [14th Dist.] 1991, pet. refd) (mem. op., not designated for publication). The Court of Criminal Appeals refused the applicant's petition for discretionary review on May 15, 1991.
/ -, 4. The Court finds that there are no controverted, previously unresolved facts material to the legality of the applicant's confinement which require an evidentiary hearing and recommends that the instant writ, cause number 538931-M, be dismissed because the applicant has failed to include sufficient specific facts establishing that the current claims could not have been presented previously because the factual or legal basis for the claim was unavailable; or that, by a preponderance of the evidence, but for a violation of the United States Constitution, no rational juror could have found the applicant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. TEX. CRJM. PROC. CODE ANN. art. 11.07 § 4 (a) (West 2013).
5. Further, a request for a commutation of his sentence is not available as a habeas remedy. Executive clemency is exclusively a prerogative of the Governor under the Texas Constitution. See TEX. CONST. art. 4, §ll(b); State ex rei. Pettit v. Thurmond, 516 S.W. 2d 119, 121 (Tex. Crim. App. 1974) (citing Ex parte Giles, 502 S.W.2d 774 (Tex. Crim. App. 1973)). Accor9ingly, it is recommended to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals that the instant application be dismissed. Alternatively, the court recommends that the applicant's ground for relief in cause number 538931-M, be denied because the relief requested is not the proper basis upon which habeas corpus relief can be granted.
ORDER THE CLERK IS ORDERED to prepare a transcript of all papers in cause number 538931-M and transmit same to the Court of Criminal Appeals as provided by TEX. CRIM. PROC. CODE ANN. art. 11.07 § 3. The transcript shall include certified copies of the following documents:
1. The application for writ of habeas corpus;
2. The State's answer;
3. The Court's order;
,. -
''
4. The indictment, judgment and sentence, plea papers, and docket sheets in cause number 538931 (unless they have been sent to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals pursuant to a post-conviction writ of habeas corpus order); and
5. The State's and the applicant's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions ofLaw (if any).
THE CLERK is further ORDERED to send a copy of this order to the applicant, Gill Jarone White, #538415 - Bill Clements Unit, 9601 SPUR 591, Amarillo, TX 79107, and to counsel for the State, Baldwin Chin, Assistant District Attorney, Harris County District Attorney's Office, 1201 Franklin, Suite 600, Houston, Texas 77002.
By the following signature, the Court adopts the State's Proposed Findings of
Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order in Cause Number 538931-M. / AUG 0 3 Z0\5 Signed - - - - - - - - ' 2015.
.. ···
. \ ' ' -!' ._ • ., .., .•
No. 538931-M IN THE 179THDISTRICTCOURT EX PARTE § § OF
GILL JARONE WHITE,
Applicant § HARRIS COUNTY, T E X A S
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned counsel certifies that I have served a copy of the "State's Proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Order" in cause number 538931-M to the applicant on July 29,2015, by mail as follows:
GILL JARONE WHITE
# 538415 -Bill Clements Unit
9601 SPUR 591
Amarillo, Texas 79107
Bl}ldwin Chin
Msistant District Attorney Harris County, Texas 1201 Franklin, Suite 600 Houston, Texas 77002 (713) 755-6657
Texas Bar ID #00783823 Prepared By: ?/.· ' . ··-. . . . . . . ~ ; . ~ ~ .. Joshua Vincent-Intern :"'· \ ' ~ . ' ' ·-
-:;. '· •• , • • t t, - . . . .., . • . • ' ... .. ~- -~