Case Information

*1 <t D, F)ql_p~ A ~eL "COSTA, Ct£fl ~e. RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS t.l:ttP.;T of C.P!IMit-it\L (\PPEAI..S OFio:AS P.o. Sox. tJ-308, CAPITOL ~-rATlOIJ MAR 04 AUSTIN J 1tXM 751 ( t

I~ ~E: ~.LJ\. Mo. WfHiO, :5'11..-DI; \f.c+.".lb. t~2'is'lll·l\ ~ lk -STinG 6-t 100\S: \fs 1\&~Jg,~&~~~~ ~~li-_; -1-k,

7 S -th- 0t.Ac.L t. icl 0 Ll"trid t-u._, .-} o+- lik.r-~y tc< . .d'1~-y lc_l(r~ ').

Oe.cr Mr. Aws+c.:

Ple.c::L fif\cl e.ndu-:sul +k- Applra.,nf'5' Or\sincl Appli(dio/1. For V-!r',t 1"\cnolCci\U.."S, O::dc.rc.tianj &L~icck- G~ Seruice.., ct\C~ Ord.u-. l csk +Le-I- '(6l) ple..cr-e_, ~i\r_, t-L.i') dou.J•'-'(lti- ;,.. .tk. cloode..; (.(.().~{... C:(\d. Drir.c'l +k;l +k., o+-k{\·hon a.f -l-le... Gu<"~ j,...,, ...... (.c).;c.f-e..ly. 1../ov c.'SS'IS'+cnc.e,; ·.n rt.JUeJlced ~--:> r~d-+cr is :re.c.Hy crp~e.cidcd

s~ (1Q\1:_..l y, j\:,\-1CE'f L·HAfllE;'S' IJ(.,._~f\UL #-!7&0713 C.Orvic l'-1 u.,;+ l . 'i5lci FM (., s 2_ k'utc.J.'--( 1~-tc :Y loW? *2 . C.~/\. U0. vJp,- f)O, S<iG.-0'

\f.U.tJ.O. U\.l<6 'llcl.- A '• .#- . § lt.J. TH£ 7STH ~U.OlCIAL ASHLEV C..HMI.£5 &ufll~, 11~133 9

vs. OlSTPliCf c.ouflT of § MAPlk MOP,6F/ELD. "J"UQ&6 Lt~EP,T~ tow,rr~~ Th~AS

§ A. APPl lCAfJTS oP.lG-It.JA.L APP LIGATION FO~ \,JP.,LT oF HANOAM us

TO TI-ft H6!\loAAI3L6 PA5~IOIIJ& 3'U0Gt:

t.DMES IJDv.L A.SHl£'i CltA.fJ..L£5 &J~A6~, f\c.lc.-kr, Pro5<:.n ·,:,+he.., a6ove.., shJ \W. nuiV\6~ tous0 o.{! o.c.+ion c..nd re.-s-pe.c·H1.~1(~ .f:ile.s t\,is O"lsincl AppllccbDfl For Wr:1t- Of Mcndctvtu.S) pui'Sucn+ +u Adicle..; I LOl ~eclion Z> (J) the... IC.li'X\S C.Udv o.f t.r-iM·,I)ol eroc..e.dure_; (:r.cCP); ' P,u(e.., 73. S of the.- \Vtcs flJuk.s. o~ Ap.peJ ldu Proculure. (T.~.A .f'.) : c.r1cl en Orck.r frofVl theJ C.Ow-·+ c.>F C-,r-1 •"l ;,,cl Appeals of~ Te..l{C s f; leJ cJolie.Mb- lJ!t . .lol"' \ H"e.- . abu'-1 e.- re.ft.ru\Ceol u.u.st... I n suppor+ of Htis +~~ Appliccn+ would sl,ow +l,·~~ tour+ +1.-tu blb..Ji ~:

I.

B. RELATOA I. 01 A6Ht..e/ tHAflJLGS &uP,f>eU.." T.O.C-.0.-uc ll(gom, ·,~- an of.fctlckr inCAru..rc-kcl ·,n -the., Te.liCS"

~r+MeJI+ u·f C-l'iMincl ~us+ice... o.ncl is ~nf\~ pro ~c.-, w\,L) c.c.n he.., lDC.c+c.cl c+ +hb Jo h(l 13.. Lc.nncHy "3"r. Ufli+; kc.rf\e.S C.Ou!l+y. 8'1'1 !='M CPll, ke./\ed'f• Totes /&ll~.

I.Ol ~e...ldor ~~ e..{C..us+w. ~rt·,s I"C.Meclius- C..flcl ~c;:r nu ctkr c~uc~ r-oAe.cl~ ct l~w.

I. The.. c.c..+ soush+ h be., LDI-IIfk-l\ul iS' Min·,~+u-;cl c,nd ncrl- di:rud-jl){)Cr~ In t\c.+uf'e.... A.r-1--id~ li.D7

GS~(.:..~I ish us +he.. prou.clu.to~ +ur cA cpp I iLc. tl M -Po r- w I' ',t cf- h:::6e..cs- corpu-s- if\ wh lc .. l, ti-le.- . o.ppl;u:f\f- Se-Lk:.s: f'd;cf +r(..)M C1 k!D()Y jud5e..Me.n+ iMposin_s o ~e.nd+l( cJhu- +hen dec{{,. Arl Su. I T. t..L.P. The.. f'Dlt- ck the.- tric.l C.6ur-t ( ~- ·tb rt'Aolve... c.onk-:s-\cd.' tC.d ssue.s, ·if c.rHf· the+ ere., Mctuic I fD en c. pfliu:nf s CDnt:i ne.H.O\t. 1\r{. L01 &L. ·~ (c.) (ol) T.tl.P. The.,., ~urt- Df &in;ncl Arpeak Te..-tcs t!-nrerd en Order ~;ld llcue..Mbu 5, .lDI(.I, wt-,u-e.,/"' He., h;d c.our+ wa~ orde..rc.d. rc.solvL +ke- f-ccf- is-suu a..Q. wk.+ku the.- V--lifnos.s MdwiM ~rcok.s wiU .f·GS·Hfy cs -b +[,~ Affliccnf IAt'lOW\LC.J, crttl ; ~ he, cloGS, whc?J·hec- \!',\ bfiMofly shol.<.IS Appl~c.c.~~+ -ro be.- ac.+ucl !y inAo~+ whe.n cof\slclc.t!d c.Bai ns+ the..- . LVicle.nc.e.... o.f.- 5url+- txjJcrlc- E/,:u..>A.do, q~1 S.W . .J-J. JDJ.,l.OS l"TU:.(J'wt.App. i'1'f(..); Ex jJark Tu ky', IOcr S.w. 3d. 38g, 3£?3 (Tc::..-t.C.r~M.-1\pf . .;2.Dol). \h.t; +riel e.oc.,tr+ wcs rc..sol"e.- t~rJ·,s tJtckr -~ikcl by -1-h;iS brf isot.lt- cncl udu -f.incLr-s-s- d- ~c0+ c"cl CuAdus-icniS o-r \cw. ---rh0 c.l6o sic-kcl. +kc:l- +h;~ Is-sue- wcs -6 be. re .. sol.Je.d ,~.ML,;n liu dcys ~~ ckAc.- c.-~ t{,;s orcJer c. suppiGMUt-kl re.Lorcl &kil 6e.- _.f.orc..J;.rckd -to +l.·,s C.Uurf w·d-t-,·,n 1:20 dcys of' +-hu af'\d Jc~ c.+- +h;s Order.

I I.

C. P,£SPOMOEtJT ;L.o{ Pre...spof\cAUI+. Mc.r-k:. M.oft;f-/dd, ·,n hi~ upc.c.Ay cs jud~e., i.1 the.. 7St.1 'Ju.dicic.l o·;s+r·,c+ ~urt

C>f Libcr-tlf C.-Dull+v Te.'ICS hcs- c M.ll'liS"+c.i-lcl clv.+~ tD ~ol\le.., ConhW ~c.+ 'iSSU(;S', a Cn\1) +ho+ OIL..- nckc-;cl -fu Pte...\c..-lur ^[1] S cunf'·tf)e.Murt pursuc.flt +-o 1\r-+. t\.ol .:s (c.) (d) l.t .. t.P. I\6Sfo()cle .. n1- L.Jc..s- c.lt~o Cl'cl.e.n::.d bY. +~i~- tow-+;(\ c11 Otd.c..r {:;(e..J.. t-.lwe..Mber .s,J.old +o re .. .-s"DI\le.... t~u .f'c.c+ iss-ue.,; cl whdher +he.., lA.Othe .. ss- MclLOliLA. &n:::ok.$ wd I ·kx+i.f~ c:s to +he..-

~-I *3 ~ppl·,ccn.fs inooCULC£.;1 end. j~ he- cloc;S, w~e:~cr his b+IMo(\\{ -::.lnow:s Appl;cdl.j.. 6 &.._; cdu.cUy i~1·nou:.n+ wkn (0{\l:>ick.ftd ~in~+- H~ C>.Ji~ 6-t 5ui l+. t:Jr l'c,f~ c~·w/loio) 'Jt-fl 6.w . .;{cJ . .2a.l.2o~ Crw. &i 1'1. Arp· i<1'1~): EX jJ~r lr: Td~t) I O'i s.w. &:;( sf58-J 3~3 . ~ T<...~ .. t..r eM . J\pp· 2.oo..u_. ~lrte..., -\-1'1~;\ w_u.rt i...::L~ -l-6 r6::nJ l\Le.- +ki:o Is-sue- WI+L,, 1\ CJc) do..p cJ -1-k., de,\u ck 1-t,_,~ Dcck.r c.flol e.A-Ic.r .p_,t"d, nss- 0~ -h:.c.J· cf'lol COI\c-lt.;sibns- o~ lew. ·ne..- suppkMul·tc.l IU.llc-ck w~ -to bv ~rWcroleJ. 1-o -\-l;,s C'_uu-r+ c..s,\i,;.') I~ do.ys af +k., de~ ot- +k·,s on:kr. To d.ck- -1-k -h-ID( c.our4 L.c:s- Aai- eovtpl ;d wAL, +L,·,s occkr. Marl t-'\C'f be..- SU'IJe.d Mo.re...{:idcl , -:f~)e.-• ·, +k. 1$-f(., 0'-"didcl Oio--\-ri<:J Lo(....rt ()k l):J(.r+'-/ tDuf'l·hf \e..ICCS, a.+ hi~ plc.c.e.. at bu:sifle.os c.+ t"'X:S &.M Hou-s--1-an s+. ~oDI"'l 3ol.\, Gibu-h,.T~s rlSTS.

III.

D. VI()L.AIION oF AP,TIC.LE I. 0"7 'T. C.C.P. \::l~ -t'c.:tns -h. re.::so\ut:.; H'\<U c.on.te.s-~cd 3.0/ The.., ill~:rponde.J\·t violc-kcl AM. ll.o·7 6e..G.3 LLl CJ) T.t.L.P. ~cd- ' 1 ssue.;s- +\,c.+ a.re.... Mc-kric-1 b +k- ~dc.-1-o;s- c.ol'l:.f'·,ne..r-llc..n+. end ~lf .,P.,;\i~ --b e..'1-k-• _.{:;,,ctn5s ·In +ka... Dr&..u- ~rDM -\-Le..., L~ Of of .fcc+ enol condu-s-ion~ 6~ lew w·,.~L,in llv +;~-'~e., fRELc)be.c) &in;(tcl Appwls o.f \e...'£Cs. .f.::ded b.f ~elo.-lor c.n Oe.co--~.bcA

:S.o~ Motron s ~r GvidUl+ic.r-y ~+uv·,ns end -&.nc.L, Wc..rrc.n+ ~cvv loe...e.n 1'7, :LD/Y end Jcr-tucry I~ J-.ots. 'Tl-Je-Sl:- 1"'\.o·Hons -w~ sc.n-1- -1o Go"l\C &. ~n::.wn,o·,s--k--ictt-Le..r-~ ~ibu-ty Cou.n.fy Toms Cnd s"'e..- -fde.cl ~ +ku c6ve., rcA.~c.ed ttu~ of\d 6r~lt+ +kM -\-o +~ c.+-kn-hon cJ +k illf..IJ"fbnckot, Mcrk. H.ot-ckield. ""Sr...dcu, ·,n -1-k, ·1-s: 1h 0w:,L ... ;cl 0~-s tciL..t tw.+ ~ L.ibe.ri·y C.Cu.n·h.t luc.s. ·The... (Z,e_opof'lok.n+ wc:s- c\ ~ or-des-eel b.[ -\\.vtc.v.rl- 6-\tv\i nol Apped(J 6·f Te..v:cu- re...:sdve.. +lis- kc..+ issue.-. C.opics c-9 ~ Arrf•u.(\~ ~ M.o-1-lo,"~ .for e..'-lidcfl.iicry hc.ar·ir15 end ~e.nch wcrrctrl- ccn be... ~nJ ~n k c.l'1otr-iGt C..le.rt...."S' supplo·'(...tJc.l reLol'cl in~ a~ve... r-c...krUlced c.c.usc.

3.03 To olc-k... PJc..lc+or hc!5' rttiUiec.l no, ~fb~ truM ~u:;~ resc.rcJ..ins flt~pondVtt:S du.+y ttl f!Je...b.\or~ c.ppl;cc\-iof\ ..fbr wri-t of ~6o c.orpui5 +kA etc, fJI.de.rlc.\ to rt.oblue.., & -fe.c..-1- ·,~sue..-s- it'\ \escil-ly ut fldc.kr's wnrinc..M.Urt c..nc.\ no ·finoL".ss o-f -kd- cnot condu:s.ion-:s- ot lew

+ht; he v e_.. han nc do by P,e.;s rolc.:'l-1-.

3.(Jt./ As i c..le.c.r _f;ro,.., +lv ~dc.br . ..s Koflons end +k, Ork kmf"l -\k, brt c( &;n;r'bl AQ~6:2.\ ~ c..~

Te.Yc.s, ~e.-;s-pondul-1- ~s ken_ ~cch:d I~ pLA· on nD+iw +l,d ~dc+or ~uJ:.s -\br ~u_ls~ue.s of ·tee.,+ Mc-kricl -6 . ~dc-lor:-s- c.on-F~Ilc.Mc..n+ -\u be.. r-c.sol\le.cl and -hnc:Ln_s~ o.f -h-\- end C..oYid_L.i·:s-·ion:s ot lew be.,; _Mcd.e.-. ·-rk_s~ cc..·Huns c('(.; ~u;l'e.OI la~ H-e_; C...o .. u+ o.(:. C..r·,M;nc../ Appcd s Tt.l{t:.S"'. to ~c..+ of\ ~t-lo-br ~ \f.tt·it o~ \....obu,s- corpu.~ _ ~e-lc\-or ~s ~urte.. wdl o..~v ~U.lft..M(.{\+ or olollsct-ioflS i~fbSW LAflbl\ hM by +Ltu TC.t...r. \n c..on+rd 'be.:..;ond -k. Ple..ld-ors (~.Unrts, ~-GS'?='f\J.c.n+ hcs wholly k'cda.l. +t. c_ov--p\y w;+k Ad, Scc..3(<:..)(c{) I. tL. \ l?,~:s (bflole..'l~ . ol-'\ple-k-ly ~'j1101Y.J. end ol>s~cro.Jd Ml vrck.r ffon tk- C_o_.r+ o9- C..r~r-;,,--p/ !S cwns ill Iced fc.;fl,-, en~ ~c~ c.ls-b ~c.·,(ecJ. ~t) c~d P-.e...lc.+ur Appuh~ le.I(CSJ +k pru-b-slof\cl cflcA CDt'H·'\6n C~J.Aitusy c:R- eny wr-A·kJI re..spon~ts .-\u l.ri,~S Ko·-h"oAS" uttd ~us+s. "3.o5 '"The., !'Ole., & -~ tf'\icl ecurt icr -k, l'"'eJ..)b\\te..- c.on-k.s-\-ed -fe.c..t i'5"SUC:>, if- cny·, -thJ.. oi'U fv'\c.\-c.r1d -6 C.f'\ ofpl;cexn-Vs c..o<lfin<.tvtU\+ end. e.J\1-c.r-- ~1\olincs- e-9 -~ed- e-nd c.ondi.As-;o(\s 0t lew_ Ar+ _5cc.. 11.0/ Ct.), Ccl) T.~.t.P. P,csp::.rdc.n-1-- Cf\ rvlini~kl'rcl otu+ie.~S") ord..tr +- G s- lew .:l ~-td:c... + \,.;, Aepccls ft-u,'S' Te....cc.-s-l c() tk it!{')(!( ^[1] 6f- .CrotV\ leMA -~ &if- ( r:.n ot iS' ic.lc~ :cr)\J \/ s tk; pc-cc.ecJu. rt:A *4 TV.

t. ¥fiA.~Ef1 foP. P1ate.F

WAUJeFOP->5) Pi2J6flliSBS t.D~v\06~00, ~eu\TbPh f.\S\1L6Y l-Hi\~Lf:S lSv.f,~ICU ... Vro~:L-1 ~~c.c-kCu.ll~ ~uu\;~ .{:-; ndi~ +~+ · ~pt>ndCI'I+ JiJ Aat rc.sol\IL; ~hu ft:~t ·r~W<'.J en~ 01-k.r .t'~ondi·1)o ·6 .G- -kef- c.rJ. o.. ~tu'\iunS" IGLJ cs- orJe.rc~ ~y -\-k., Court 6{:- C.c (l·')·,f'C.\ A.~p::.ds we+~ if\ -\-~ 1--iK~ r~>c.l'-'(~ ~1.( lew, &:.id ~rtkr c~ol +kl flldalor 'orov_sl..t -tk·,~ lJiJ<Jfal1 In 5ocxJ fcitk crd.. lt,cs- 5u6~+w-bdi~Jre.vct/ccL ~e/tofe.r prc-'tS fur Oil or-du- cLru+in~ P1Grfbnc.kf\+ -k reso\~e,; -t-\.,e.; 'jssue.-. ·fu . bj wcy o(\ e.vidcnhcry lr-cc-rln5 enol ~nh:r ~;t\j_;":S;s- 6t: .fcc+ cr1o\ conc.lu:co~·s.oe c.v J,rec..f-c.d .n ArL Cc) (JI Tt..c.P. c.nJ. -tle..- ortkr .fruM {le._. ~r+ o~ &,M,•-c\ Ap(h--is &~ Tc...u-s-. ~e.s(XcH\ .. \t~ ~loMik-kJ. ~;

(1S,l:jt..E'{ C..HA!!,Lf6 ~P,P.ELL# l:l<D0"13J ~\o..-kr frc ~ ~"'"' B, tcn(\c<U'f -sr. Uttl+, FK f.!.3l... ~eel y, 1" c.)(O S' 18\ I<} *5 TH£ STI\IE- C>F Tfl(l\'5

COUt-JT\1 oF Ll f£"Plf~ V.

t. AFFiDAVIT. ( Q£c.cAP,ATioJJ) M~ nc.Mt'..l hr A~h\<>f 01ncrlcs- ~~,-n-Jl, 1"1"( clck.., of 6·lr+~ ·1') o\ _: l'6-Z5'1, r'\\.f "tnMc.h:"' ·lcknti.t'\/;115 Ol.AMtJU' is llLoDlS3. i eM prcs-m~ly ·,ncc.rcc.nJd c+ +~ ~l.rt ~- C..Onf\e.Uy "Jr. u(\·,+ In kcrf\ts tc~f\·ty, kure.cJ'(, re.-l(CS ~pfi FM 10"62 l-8\l'l.

\ o\e.c..lc('(., L.ndc.r pc..ncl~ o.t {Xf'jur~ t\nJ· -\-\.-e.., ..\6~oinS i~ · .trLAv enol corru.k dc.y e+ b'le.L.v.kd o1\ ft-.e.., 2oiS".

VI.

6-. C€PlTiflCATE Of S6PiVIC€ tcr-1-ify +k-1- c hu.~ corrc.d c.up~ -H.v d:c)\[0 A~p lil.c·H on for- \J r'i oR

j her-c:bL[ \.VC:S Scr·\iecA 6(\ Mc.-k Morc..~lc.ld ~- .b~ rtc.c.; n~ c.. cop~ -+k u.s. Mcru:knus Mci I aolct~~scd -b: C.Ow+ 6-'i n;nd 11ppec-ls- P.u. Bo\C 12.30'is , C..Cpi--61 .S-\-dion, Av~·t' 1 rh Tc_xcr 1<5711 on +h10 +-k~ d ~ c./ 2o\~. &£~;&~ · Alo~ ASt\LE8 C.,\\f\~lts Bu~~BU. l7t;o/3j ~Mel 'v Un;t SCfj fM fo3l.. ~G:J.y, T~)CcS 18f\ft *6 t-Ci.A. tJo. WI,-~S'iCQ-0 f '"\r. e.+. t.Lt.. cJ.a U'"lll.r A .. '

As'i-lt6'{ CJtA.rz .. t.~ 8UP.AELL "* ,,G,o-m § l~ THE. ?S'TH '3LtOtctAl.. § vs. OlS\fliGr C.CuRr oF § MAP1k f\10fl6FI8LQ. 0UD66 Ll e,E.ta,T'I tout..\.\~ 1t~AS § 0 (L, C>E. ~-

Dfl +~·.-s 0-cj cu.t"\L 6f\ -\1J be.- ke..c1cA .\--~ &.~oin5 ~nldur s PI??'' ccAiuf\ for '-Jr·,.t bf McAJcMU~ C.f'ld ;+ cppt:.ct'$' tb +k be-+ tk+- Scl"\l:J ~k~t .. ...\d be..: G-~A.NTeO

IllS THGf2J6F~P15 O~OEfkO 1~ +k juc:A5v ~c\l ·,~t-~tcoltictd~ 1"'6::.-d\jc_., +lvb-i- i\',L.l<:J c.nd l.n.tcr .(>,."'l i~ s- J' .f£:c..+ crd c.onc..IL.':s tt.JIIS lew . ;n +k cb:::,\.lu rc..-~crcl c.cv.~v. en .-\-l..,i:r t k.,_ c1c'-{ o.+:

5l&N.£ - - - - - - ' ']_{) \S"