Case Information
*1 1 \Itt-.\( \.3\.~\osec-a \") 1\ f\o,'-Ofl ~ LeJ<:v~ \-o '\-::; . -" t .
~ \\~\\s W~\\o? f'\M-~mllS
RECEIVED iN COOAT Of CRIMINAL APPEALS JUN 03 2015 w•, t\,A~,CI(!rk \0~\\ <jr: ~NI~'-A~ ~~ . \\1\\ 'S e_'I)V), •n\J ~"'-~ \-\1\~ t.Y3 Cn'.Jf'-~ V ~~r~~ C\ e ~t.\ ch\'\'S Dl\~te_\fro \',\~ Wt~ ~ Lov-x\-' 0:-i\'-\\~ c£ ~~\\)'t ~ \oo\\, ~eflJt-cl S I~ t) lS' {S.y- tl\ 11 1:) . \\_~\\ \\" \L,S. 1 o ~D 1: \))Cju-\q ~h\\~ tt~'--ltJ\ Y \\.tS'· ()n Lt
"'~ J< \-'\-us ~,\ ,(_\\)t'\ \\:,~l"J \n 't%i) '\"'llU ~~ fO ~:'I 1 bk.. w~ oi"''S,\:s
\\\)ct \0 v~ \qtA:oS ~~)\ \[0Vt 7),) 'i) *2 ·.':.: 'f. '3:" \~'- ~ e x-.~t.~ ~r\~:<) ~~)~ ·\-\\\\ ~\~~\08-() ...
~~~\o' 1-- c ()\.)\\ t> (:1
'{ ( \l M1 fvl\
1
Cnr'~· D"'"''~\
" A p~~"\ ~ ""~~\~ Ccun >t-1 \J\~t\c \- ('
c_ \ e..~Y, · -x~ \-\\~ a~c:\1\\ CA~f\c. ttl - f r-
~~ s (J()c\ e(') \-
"'.'; .,· !"'.
\"'\ e>\-\o~ \·o, L~\)~ \a. \1~~ 't- ~~n ~-otc\' vl\t J ·· I") A\+~!\ i (. ;.'i ~41~:; )fp How ) .. I~,\ .
CG"f\\~"'\ s ( ') ~~~~~ Y
~'\ e \,on .\o l.e/\v~
Dt<l~r- ~~t\n \ ''\) leJ\u~
(_ t:.r·.\' ~' ~ t.. CJ~ ~~'~ v 'c. t. -~ A "'€J\Q\.'l_3 \}rtQ\"tR. \()~"'\ ~.\)· \A~b~oLO lutpu~ va.~R-Baf)" Met
~u~p\iC-n~~\ Me:\ Me.\¥1~\MC:hJ.M ~ *3 ~)~ ~.).)~ '18 Cil&i~f!. '~ ·-----
B'"~_M, ~o~l:Jt~ \-\'-\,\ JP-\~B\-()ii'C _ ),( )( l<\ +\~ \~~ItS CcV-t\
~-~ '"-\-0~ ~ o~ c_,, M \tV I\\ Arre:A-\ ~ X
){.
\\~"~\~ Q_o\J'I\\1 \:~n~-\nt.\ C.\e~~ ·f<
l::f.\ \\:\s o®t.tl\\ CApf\q\y, ~
~-e.~pot1c\~n.\
.!"to\\ o f\ \~ \_ <B'\v e ~ 'hliUit- , \() \ «:."t.U '\';._~\17, ~1\1\t-1; f')A,\\"~f' ~'~ - - ~\1\ ~ ~~ "t!~\1.~\~ ~J\OOtd\lte.. .,~, \ {)At'l~\'J A w'"'\ o~ \"\An~~tt4~
'I~ ~t-,Af'l '~c40\a~ \\~\ ~ \\)C* \~8'\f~-'1 te~n~'~ tn\\v!\\sv,\\t._ 1 ~ \1\ Wl\\\(y C~vn\1 ,'\i;_'l;..._~ A\ \~~ E\\rs \){)\\ M\c\te.S') Sl!.\~ 1\S .Po \\cWs
·~~\1\tl ~- \\\\\ j\ \loe,\o8a
~\\\~ \,)('\\ \
\b~") ~'('() 98~
\1\.\<"\\Sv I u~ )''t 173'-f') ~\lu\d \;\1\<t.- -\-o tt.s\)tc...\ s:', .. A\J to;:''\'-'~~~ t'-1<t- \~1"~ Covr\ of' -L'I\1~1\N~\ Ap~~l\\~ ·\-~ \~\\~ t\(( ~ l~ \ ~J\\)~ \<J "~" ~ ~~f\,1\1-oQ...' ..s \JJ t \\- o\Y M 1\ n c\'"-M \-1. ~ ~"'" s\ C... 'l».rn 0 - \-\,.. ""' '!. C clJ_f\ \y D t~ til:. >r ~\~r~ \.0 \.~ otc\~~ \~ Co,.np~\ ~\M W" 1-t/\-lMt~ ~t\\ \\.0") lJt,~of' -\-\"~to~~ Cor pV\) J l* ~ i)(((}~.rtV'ldvrn) 1\nct l\Jpph~f")e~ ~ \~ -\-'-)~ Cov~ cP .•
Cr'M' .v~\ Ar~V\\~ l"' f\((()~a~f)Ct. w ,\-~ ~~)tj o·r Aope.'li tt1~ ~r:.oce.d ur-e ?.3. 'Y -.r ~~ ,S. ~·\"\~ Or) \&-\'->1 ~~ ~Qil ~t.t_'\~\)\ \\ M-\.\~ h.~ ~ b~ ~~.~ WI\\Q.~~ \~ >t'l~ C..o\.),\ o\ c..,lMlrJf\~ Aw~\~. ~(~ ~\.\\cs J:' Co\J\\-\-\f\nc::\k\ d-.C}\5 ~\\t~\,~ \SA"\;~~\'\) "l\\'3 \\.0'( \N"'\ ~0 .. \S \~3~8'~')/t "-"<'~c\ """"-not"'"~u.-,:~ ..-.f)l;l .su~~k~tlt\3 ~·~ "1~ f\~ b'l ~~\t·~ Ott\.
a<t . " l -~· . . \.1.)'\\. \\ '\\) () • ~'
;u • • '• -. :.·
~r\A.~ ·~. \-\'\\\ ~ \\.~\o%\)
'Y..r\ ~~ 1(.. \ i(~A-3 ~~\".\o~
C: c()~\ c:s\: C., \fVllNI\) I A ~pt~\~
c... hn~ \J"n'~\
\\1\~~\~ Cour\\f 1::>\~r·t~\
~ C\e'"' tr\ D\\' (Nfl\c._\\'f"
~~ ~ ~c nae_~·\-
\ ·~\.\)~~ G\A!ltV').3. ~ \J~f'lY\'\9 ....
n (;)\,on ~ l o,\) '(_. \Cl \, ~ 't.. \:-. -;.\. ~"ot~' '"'"~~ PM~<;-, A.~c.cvri.\._\1\'J ~ \e.1.1\~ ~L\\~~ o\' fl.. eet_\\A\~ roc, ll}. · \'!
.__-
~ S:.,.s'f)e_~ ', ' ., ·. '.•
c)~\~ '. C'-.r\-\~\ ~\~ o\ ~~f\J\t ~ \\ "'"'-~ f\nc\ (0'9W oS' \-"'\~ n()nun hA~ -be.tr) ._r~n\c ~~ -.l ~\ ~ i ~C) \5 ~~ \.), S. r1A\ \ ·h~ ~ "'n~ 'tf\nl ~\ - ~,~\tt~\ C..\~r-~
~\' \~~R.\~ C.O\J"\1 \flo~ \r-f\n't,),!\) i \io\.1~ \Qr) ) \"t 1/~Q ~ y -~~ ~- ).(.l.Q )bi?[OB'CJ t. \\t \) (\ l \
j .. \.~9. ') Ft"'' cr~a
'"""·"\'sv~ U ~, \~tA~ 773'13 .~ '\\.\.1_\YI ~o~\1\~ \\t \\ .~ \\o~\o&o i
Tf\ \-\L \ e_"'j.f\·S ~~\tt\o~
C cuR. t. o \;) C.\'- lf'l lfvA\ (.\,~\~ \)~i"\\(...\ · \\1\~q_\S Ccv'1,~'f
\:),~\'to.\'-'\- C. \e~"" - 1: () \~\S oW,\ of\\
c)\ei\~,\~ ,
h ·t 'So fO ndt.!'\ \ 'Y.. ~ll..\F\1') \)o'--'0\"~ \:\\\\ )il: \'o~\.og-o "e.~~R. \\c_.\,n~ ~to St<.. '-" \~~ ·~~\ ~
C}\\l.~~ Wo~d \,"'~ \o .~\\~ -\-~U or~·\VA-l A. pp\tCAtLC() ro~ uJt'-\- ot' flAnQA.f1V\:) ~vt3VJ\·f't\ \a \e:~~ ~~e._~ ~ A ppe__)}"'~~ ~'t>C.t~ut~ :·" f)).,'-\(b)~)~) Aid\~. S . A\sCJ \~iAEi (Gcl~ ~~ Gr-tMc~! fr·o~ A':\ :l.. ~\ \<e'CI\:S C.ci~<- a\' C"M Q,oc M'< \\.<Y) Stc <> (c.') . Ac\u::J ~m S e_ l Ar>.Q tV'\ CI\\Ce.-~t~Q\ hf)O l-.)a Ca~~e ~ AU.f\\ \\b'~ ~~\\\o~ \t.~\.Jlt.~ \ 1\f) 'C'tcep'hon \::; \ "t "'\ «... )\. r p ~ ~ <:> c "\ , :> '{'c.,.\t..uu::S b cop 1 u \J/\d e ,.-\,\ \~ '\. 3 (c.,) t..l\cA .1\\\ow \o ~t-~c.e.x:.c\. . ~~)J\'1\ "'£)o~)f\~ ·\\\\\ *" \'o~l06'0 A't"l fH~~~\-\~ \J)Cl\tC-~A\-c:e\ \"'
L th~ \e.~~~ U\:fN\n~\ ~ L':-U"\t\Vt\\ Q\.t~\tc:~, ~\\\~ \Jn\~ V"'l \\v n\'>~ t \k I \ \:.XI\~ .110<\ Kll.?. be.-1 ~ ~ 0o \\cu.) ',
~~\~'\ ~"5\~~ ;\:\\.\\ ~\b~to~G '£\ \ \'~ \)~~.\
\. \:, tt'l ~'"' ~ i~
\~~"'t\~v~\\ e... \ e~AS II ~'-t I) \ht\f\toQ.. h~ ~~\-H\\-\~e~ A\' H:i-1\e~\~~ .tVl-0 hAs no ~eR.. ~_r·1e..dy f\t \f\w . '\nt_ I\~ C.CM~e..\\e..Q \:~ rtt~,\ %-\-e:.~tA \ n,Ct c'\t:.SL.\~\rLon.J\fty f\tCJ)\d.\~ ~ ~ ~·\)\\~ .'l'3,,y~)~)~) ,\\\ *6 .. . , ~
C u~~ f>A5~) I
\.Ur,\ o~ "~A~cf~~~l· .. {:ccn\,~~e_c:\) (c~r1 · 1 ~<r~)
P<\~e..~ .....
L\) ~~ o.~~\"~'-~ c:.\~,x ~"'-"\\ ~~w'\t~ ~\sa\"~\~~~~"" >t'-1~ ittc.>tc:\
0\o~) \'H\r\S:M~\\-ecl, \-~ \-\,IL ~ Ccur-\ o~ <2..\lni.u~\ ~ppeA\~., Af'ton~ "~ ~\\,.e_r- ~~,\~l"'l~r"-1~ ~"P~'~ 0'\ S\..lpp\~J"l~f\\--J_ ~~, AA~ ~\~?o ~ \': c:\ ~ r) tl ~r1,3J o-..\' ~d- ~ or co ~ \ v l ; tJ'l cr~ ) "01 " . ~~ ~-~ \,1 ~ .;_~.,_, pM\-1 : ( o':.~·~~;M~ ~~ c\uch<\ ')
5) o~ ~""~ \~\ ~\ Q~ \\o~ ¥,liE. ~t~1~\ C~ A~?\;CJ\\lt>~ b"J \-~~
S~f\\~ o\'"' ~().st CC)f)u\<:\'tor\ A~~\\~\~ol") ·\b~ wt~\- o\''hf\~~el..l~ .;» ;?' Co\" ~u ~ u'lc:\es ,A~\c.\~ \\ -~~ [1] \-~~ o.;~\ \~c.\<. c\~,)\. sh..f\\\ ~o~uJt\r--cl ./' ., ~«. u.n\\- \'~(.:.t.>\d \o -\-\.{\~ (~\.l\\ (Co\J~ (i<f'c_~,I'1H\Jf\) ApptA\~) unlt . .U'
d~~\"'\.~\ CC)\Jt\ · hA~ \e.t.l~\)~d An ~._,\~~{o'"' o.\' \\CY'l~ ·~eM '.\-'-1~ c~\.)rt OQ Cnl'l\tvl\\ AppCJ\\~ ~\)\~\JM\ \~ ~Ul~ 73.~S. (t.W·~~~~\I'l-OI~) l \,""~ ~tl\f"1~ ~C\ ~~~a\u\u.1r'\ ~\' C.'"'M~ ~f\1Sr~ A\~a \\~\'<.. '1~. S .,1-n · Ae\?\'c"\'CL,'"") s\P\\rc.~ 'f> u1 rAtt ' ..
\}J,\~u, \~ OA~~ t'ta~ \~e_ m\~ cR \t~~t0 ~0 ¥1'<- .w\~CA\t()f\
\:,"'\ ~e. ~"\ ~::. / t'lt . con v ; d ; :_s c c. \l t~ ~h.,\\ t e::.~::>l\l~ i \wu -\-h"\ \-"'~ c~u"\ h~ \-Hv,rc)~ QtS;_)NA\td ·\or tes~\\.A~l'on.
A~ l"\~\;on \'o, ei\~l)s\on ~ \<:> 'h<L \'.)ed ·," ~~ C'o\l~"-\ o~ Ct\<"\"N~\ App~\.3 be\'Q"\:. ~~~ e-y p\""\,·~() o~ ~~ \~0 -dA/ p«l)cc\.
~0 ~'I o·\) un\\ cY\'\\·~ \\l\~~1\S eGt-j>\.1..!. An \A AnSw~~ ~,\~Q\ i tn- A tott ) . iiut"''\~ [1] r's UfOf"') wlt\~~ ~,,~~-t ~~ s~<:.f) OG()~ t~c\~-~\ 't~c\\1~~ c\1\\~ I I ._) co;\ J~l\1\1' ~1..3 e.r bee') ~ ,~~ c~\J ';:\- \:\\ e, l ('1 ,,v~) 1\(]~t.t\'-~ . ~"c\ \-\." ~ b~vJI o() n · ~~nsa ~ b'l ~eS\)<lna~\ :0..:» Wfmcc\ h1 s\1\\'-\~ ~el\\m- UJ<:J\A\c\ M\l'C. t ~t.\\:Q~G \\C)\\'-l:~ b't Cc:>\J~'\ Q\> c_,,n\tv~\ Ari>~\s or cb~~~\~c:l \\' ct~<l'1e.cl n~t~~l\t~to- ~~~\re~·
~e..s~cnd~f"\\ C..Y'\,\~ ~~"''~\~ '~ h\5 CJ\QAc.,\'1 AS \:J,~\~H~.\ ~\e..t\~ c\' \-\!\~~\~ C..cu"\1 )\e.l~~ h~S A. ()\\~\3\e~l/\\ dU\\1 m \e..C.\~0~ ~\\Q \\\~ A\\ ~".~~ '~ \<l J\ C.S\f"'\\()A \ ~tocetd \-~ Af'IQ ~e.~~~h A\\ au\\~~ ~e."\J\\1'\\£)~ \h.)''\~\.1\f\{'\~ ~~ \A,U) \c.,c._'{l At\~.~\) \C..C..~ .. \\.()~ Sec:. -:1(~) 1\1\Q \'1. ~\.t'e3 o~ App~)\'-'\-~ ~toc.e.c\0'~ ·. '13. ~ Al)c\
/3,S n~n+\~()Q:~ t!'\ +'-'\~ W~\t,
~·~1\\-~~ hAS of) ~ t\Jt~-~A\ a c.c_f\S s i t)f'\ s \"' c\ ~ co MP'<- \ \-~«... ~'<..~pC)nc\e_ll\- 1\f\c\ ~,~\nc.\ C.o,.n-\ ~alr~~ ~~ ~,~~~~ ~ ~crWf\\~ \\t\\ s \\.~f) t.:)~\' o(' \-\1\h~~~s Co\ti~Ll s '* \·~3 ~sa.rlA. i
,\~ ne.r\o11\f\dv£'-t s. Af'\~ ~~~ suopleP?~~
,r' • ( S\JQpierr~f\i.s t<L~1c:uc.c\ o \:h(i\\1c..\ c.\~,x o. J~b /'lt) Or-'5\AJ"' \\1\b~o\-\.~ c~~Ll-3 w~\\- c\~~l3N"\,,C\ \~S'""~~ -f\f\~~~~\~~A~Sli\1\~~ \_ ck C'OV1St \ J )
'£-"'1h\~\c\ * .-:1 S\C:,il~<f ~ _S\)~9\~nef\\ TVV\\\t~ Nt~ tt-t."\r\)ec\ w,\-~ tt-\-vr11 rr-.c..)e ~t ~ . 'nbrt- 1f ~( c~r-\·\\~d l"\J\,\ I0\3 \1\0 DOo\ u<\'\f.? so~h . '<\'ljr~ tec..\e.?\ ~\~Y1e.c:\. ~'l . ~- Low oN a..- ~~-\L\ ~1 ,.,;.
~) !"lohon ~t~Ll~:~\l:J ~AA~ \\.01) wr,\- \a3&.td.')A) supp)enenl M<f r
f')t·f'\(_)~N\001'1~ b'-- '\ ~~~\~~dt ~ ~\)\vJA~~ - E~ """'~\+- ~ [3] *8 L~ c.o"h''A~o ... 'C.. 'i h,S,\ ~ ~ ~ ( s'-t<:)wt~ \""vlv.e.s.t
-\-\tl\\ C..\es\. ~OtWI\tQ ·~ wn\ II) w- \\1.3!i'fa 'fA 1 S\Jpplef1~1'\~ Me:\ t'\ t. ~ 0 t 1\ t'\ ~\JM S )
L\,~ hJ\~ ~~~!\ cv~\' \wo '}eA.~~ ;,i't~t_ h~'t~tcll,~ \\.~'l
W\\\ ~ \~'if8d.f)f.\ \JJI\~ d~S\~tvl\ie_cj \SSU~S oc MA,\e.c\ o\:P An~ ~~ ~\XS ·rton\~~ S\(\t~ ~e}"\-o~~ s \Jppl~f'?e/\1 w~\\ ~~~o~~ ~C\cl Mef1uf"'f\f'\c:\UO"\ ~{) \\.0"1 WR'\\ \~~8'~0..'11\ Wf\~ IIAl)(( ~ ~ A'l~ ~ \~C:.\tO~cl bi (__\€._~\( S~'- ~~"',S"\ ~ .:1. ~ ~ ~ ~~~ Ot)~tN/\\ I"V\l)t~ ~·\,.\)') tV\t\ l¥l~ S·\Jppltf1~nt LVA)~ ~~RoAJ
\f\ \Jt~\f\\\0(\ o~ ~~-t.'t-1\S ~\.ll~ rA J-\ppt_\)A1-t_ fro~ ~
AS'<-
~-·")~.L\ T,\,~ Afl.c\ ~tl\n~Mt~~(CJn crt }"'~~~~ ~ecord ArL~
( 3, S \\1'1~ t~ Af'1~ ~Of ~~~ ~ )'--t~UC>I) or ( ).~H/3 ~ ld rcl \"
-
Arp\1 ~\to 1\ . {y'¥.' -s,.,n
I a.ct'l) \o dJ\\~ , ~~LJ\~P.. hA~ "~'-\~\)~d ~~ "~~~on~~ t~~Atdt~
~~\l\\o4l...'~ t~~\J\'(.~\ ~ \tl\()~1'1\\- o\ '"'~~\v~ ~ ''·CY'1 W~\\ C>\1 \\1\\~ou~ Cot p~.'S \~3 'B-tsa.'IA '~ .s 'Sv~ph~ne"'' ttA.R.o~~ .Md t1tnoY1tMcJv~ 1\f\q_ M_j M~h..l_tll..~ ~~ \\\~<:\ ~0~ ~ C<t_~\,~u.\'C. 1\<i:C)\1~.
a-.~ IV1j of:' '\'L 1\~Q\l't. w 1\3 d \) h (}\:" .('QI\1)}1 rd -M c OV t~ or (" M l.VA I .A~~~\~.
~e.'S~(\d._-u·i\ \v-,3 t~p<tl\':ttd \_j \::,'I:C.I'\ ~U\ 0() tJO,IC\:.d ~ ~ 1..3 \~ V\o\r.•\\of"'l o~ ~\~ M\IV \~\~s·\1\\ du\H:~s .1\t.CGtch~ \6 \'i Ru't ') ;,, s- · o\: A~ D ~\\~ ~ ~r()C.. ~ ?>. ¢
wR,\ cf' M~cN\V/) -~ CCJl'\11 t)\ .. fe d\ p S
.,:: ~~ ~~{l-.. '\o~ ~~\w ~ ·~«:.\1\\D\1.... \1:,t\l\<'1 ~ . \\,\\ i ~11::1 Sl;:. J 1\:~~~e~ \ (',_t\'s tC"j'-leJ~ -\-h)\\ ~e..~ponc\en\; ~ o~c\~~'ld .\-c ~ ~G\WF\\~ \\.at) \..).)~'\\ o~ \-~\~a~:S Cor~\..\~ \~ ~ g ~a 'lA -) \\' ~ ~ DDp\enen\ eR.D..o~~- \-4 ~"-~ed ~t~roJ\q (c~~b,\- ~ ~) Mo ·~~\)PP~'-\,.~ nert1otN'Id\)tf'\S' ~ ~\~ \i Ce>\.lt\ o(' C.nMlVI'I) AppCA\13 fm te.V)tW Md chS - \"\ AccotciAnC~ W\~~- ~'1 ~V\l~s oe' A pp~l)A~ frortclvre
f'~sv\\on t? I(~ ....
'"I. ~fll\1\ ~. \\.\\ \n \c~,~~~ ~ 1..-JA\'IIeJ ... T~)l~ Couf)\f; [6]
, Q<J s~V\~ un c\er- OF\\~ 1-~ \ \~~ ~"c:_..\ ~ \n >,~ R A bou~t \J n\ or f\ l\f1 dAn ct ~ A\ f.- \-tult M~:-c"•C;Q~ A e u\ ,
. ){_"nn ~ ,b~lod't) o.. .. _ , " ·· • ·> s J a~ jt s- · ~'5,() QM.afV. on· »
. · :~ ··. ·: (e,\,\,tf\~ cr~ ~~rule\:
'I- \\~st "'i 0<-t \, 1 t~ 'lt- 1<: \ r \.1 e. A/'\ d c o \!, .P.e c. t c [0] P'f o\ >t?... A \au~:. "PP ), tA ), t-\ .:)tJ\J\Cl on \11A..1 ?>i; 9-0V) ~~ f)i\\J"j c(jpy l.f\ ·~'\ W~,\- ~ t'\,1:\n~f'l\-t~ WI-\S -\-"-~ u. '3 l n ~' \ l\qd r\"~~ecl ~ c...h n 3. 'D."n"e.\ \~I:J~ 'h"r'\x) "" \\c;,\J)~~ol) r T [1] 0>... ml\ 1
11~~~ ()(\ ~,~ ·~«- 31 .2.~\s *10 ···-~ ~'\\P'-11 ~- \\,\\ '"'"'- ,,
-~ ......... .... ··-
Mo\\OY\ MO. o\0.1:._\ ~t: :ns'IW\\-n.s ISSU.U \1\'Gd \'\ C\,n.'S \J"rn~G\- ~l\0...11.\~ COU()\/ ~,~\r'"'--~ o~o_\ s/3'/1"" Ar\~ 'S\:Jfle~ s1 ~ef\\~~ Cot\,l)j . ~· !l.cd ~~ ~,s~t'-'-\ (0\.Jr-\ "-Sv.c\~'<- 6'/4/\3 Af\d\ ·('()\\)~d \a~ ~~\,a,\-oR._ b /'l I\~ ~ "* tA\ \\ \nA~ 0f'\~ Of'\~ Cof>~ ro 1\---We_)~ -\-":_~- Co\J~l
~u.\ ~~cur-d\~ "\~ \\\~d. w l \-'-1 \\" \\.~\S C ~v 1\\ \ !:\n t.\ C:.\t.~Y,. ~0\' ~~if~r'\c\~\~ "~·~\t\t;vl\\'&, \-\\.\\ "-"~ nc\\~\e.d ~- 9-..e s porte\ ~n\ ~\' ~h\ ~ [1]
. 'E_ 't \t,~ lt ~- ~
WA.f\QW~\~
w \~ ~ \vt- (\ \(.c. '\-tp\
., l
c·_, t -.:-~··-.-.:. ,
CHRIS DANIEL
HARRIS COUNTY DISTRICT CLERK
June 7, 2013
BRIAN HILL
#0 1681 080 WYNNE UNIT
··~
-lllJN~L
To Whom It May Concern: Pursuant to Article 11.07 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, pleasy find enclosed ; copies of the documents indicated below wncerning lhe Post Conviction/Writ filed in cause number 1238827A in the 208th District Court.
0 State's Original Answer Filed
0 Affidavit
0 Court Order Dated
0 Respondent's Proposed Order Designating Issues and Order For Filing Affidavit. Respondent's Proposed Findings of Fact and Order I:2J Other
lg
Enclosure(s)- STATE'S PROPOSED ORDER DESIGNATING ISSUES ..
;, 1201 FRANKLIN • P.O. BOX 4651 • HOUSTON, TEXAS 77210-4651 • (888) 545-5577 REv: 01-02-04 PAGE I OF I
~FiLEI!f C,hris Daniel D1.strict C/ : -- er.i lvl;'\'Y 3 1 2013
Cause No. 1238827-A ~- - EX PARTE §
§ § HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS BRIAN HILL, Applicant
MOTION REQUESTING DESIGNATION OF ISSUES The State of Texas, by ai1d through its Assistant District Attorney for Harris County, requests that this Court, pursuant to TEX. CODE CRIM. PROC. art 11.07, §3(d), designate the following issues which need to be resolved:
I.; Whether the applicant was denied effective assistan~e of counsel; Service has been accomplished by mailing a true and correct copy of the foregoing instrument to the following address:
Brian Hill
#01681080
Wynne Unit
810FM2821
Huntsville, TX 77349 .
SIGNED this 3ls day ofMay, 2013.
'e urr~--- . stant District Attorney Harris County, Texas
1201 Franklin, Suite 600 Houston, Texas 77002
(713) 755-6657, (713) 755-5240 (fax) Texas Bar I.D. #24059518 *13 ,.
EX PARTE §
BRIAN HILL, HARRIS COUNTY, TEXAS Applicant
STATE'S PROPOSED ORDER DESIGNATING ISSUES Having reviewed the applicant's application for writ of habeas corpus, the Court finds that the following issues need to be resolved in the instant proceeding:
I. Whether the applicant was denied effective assistance of counsel; Therefore, pursuant to Article 11.07, §3(d), this Court will resolve the above-cited issue and then enter findings of fact.
The Clerk of the Court is ORDERED NOT to transmit at this time any documents in th~ above- styled case to the Court of Criminal Appeals until further order by this CoUrt.
By the following signature, the Court adopts State~s Proposed Order Designating Issues .
. JUN 8 4 2D1l *14 . _:.;: .:· L. ·'"' '
.. ;.. . 1} \.\AII0w~,\\(_r-, C.0(>~ o\'C'tr\Jl,t.ti -nt\-1\ C'll.lMh~A..,
\o ~\J~p\~Mti'\- W~\\ 'tlt-.~0~~ (\·'-\) \~~ M~JVH>IMd\.H'f'\J M-d t_)\t\b\\~ (\·4.) r"\1\\\t.ct ~ ~\~\t.K __ \ c_\~-~"' ~\t"t-\3. ~W'Il~\ · \\1\~~\S (c\.J~\'f , \ "'1- · \\1\f\d uJ~,\-\'U\ 'f\1\I'Y{~c\ ~\' o· t~'-'~p)M\ whc ·otr~ltV!l\\\'1 ~'~l'le_c\
te..\\.l~ n n:_c,ep\ ~o\ A~aDQ.. tvl~n~ '~Y\ :SLQf>)~ '1~-"-\ wet"\ \'1\A)t.c\ ~c ~~~~'\~ Co~11 ~~ \ ~\J\"f>\'-"1 ~f\ \1\\ W~\.\-'7 L0 \\~ l) ~RR.<J ~j / \\ J'
""/( \~~~'- \v-:~: -~X:.C0\ Of\\_j M.e.M~t"\10\)f\r) rv)~ \:_'f~l.St\-3 M~l\e.d \a ~ ~A~~,:; c(j\JA\) () t.)\--r-, \..~ c__\~t\ C)V\3. DA.n·\~\ ~ ~1.\e. ~ ( ~'-l~~d:d Ml\t\ w,\'-\ tc.t-:\)ff'\ \CC..'ltp'tj~te~ q { ~~ /t~ Ai10 t'{..~\.e.ut.c\ C\ ~~~ / \-'-\
·. l
£..'1\tt,~\\ ~ '1 Cof\tl.f'\t~ - Mc\\of'\ ~c.~~t;s'>"~ \\.~( w~,\ \';l.3~8d/A
\\ ~ 'S\Jp~'t M~f\\ ""-c:\ ~) Mel¥1o!tv\d\lf'll ~ ~ \t~~\ueci Ot ~O\\JJ·"1decl \(J Co\.H\- CnM tNt\\ A~peA\J t.l~\.\:n\-· ~ l{ (OI\\tf\\~ - L(_\~~ ~ ~,:!1,\-t:\~-' ctrd~' c.\~\K
C ~t\. ~ \J 4\lY\ ~ \\~~Q.'\~ Co\Jf\\ { ,\'f tc~"\~~\'fl5 \\.C)'? w~"\ \~'1 a a a '">Ai ,~ .s ~" r~ \e. I"!~ l't \ Md i'1 e Mll \N,Q Ul"l ~ ~" ~IJfW"~c\e~ <\-\'> C.o\)-r\ oC C_..r,MtN~t 1\\'p<A'\ ~vs_Jurv1~ \~ \'f. ~4\f(. a·~ 1\fp~ \\~\t.. ~tQC.., '/3.4 73,'5 *16 • --------~'----"-· -=6_,_\-\cl'\ to ~e,~~~~ \, \-\~~~ol.t~ C~~VtS (1\'\..o<J't) __ __ _ w~o"\' \l').D8'<a"~'l At ""a \\,s Su~p~~t'\«A~ a"'~c~~ .\a~ ~e.s~\\l~. ---~·-(-o~ ~at- U-'.1\tc\cz::c) to ~~~ C.._o~~\ o-t? G "'-n t ~.~\_A~~~ \~s-"---~ - - ·~u,t"SUA;'f'\\ ~ '~)) Cc~<L c~\.b -'hoc Ar-\- \\,of) ~e~ 3(9.\ ____ .L-A,__,(\ ot~u c\~~1,3t..>-"\-'-~-~~~~~~u ~ \/\~~ t\~Jt~im~~-·
. ~ t-~~U-~S_3_\30-~-~ ~ ~ ~ul\ ,~(!)\~ b~ "ifuct~t--.-·
-~ o\\~C\~ .1\~ ~,\~d ~ui\~~- ~\~ b0 ~'~!nc.-\_C~~s\\..Gh~lL\J~f'\-ttl .. . _(set ~ ~"'~'-"~' \- ~ 1- C:>. ~.._~)~-~"'" 1!\l:> · o '"Oe:r \-~ '\U"' !il \1\g An t\\l\-\~'\ttl: ~o.m_~_\~tl\\ ~\\ot-t'\~ C..h~'"\~s ~~w'i'\ u.>Jt-~ e'\l-v- .. _\!)____.hd(t. Q'\"' ~n·f\~\t:S ~t:o.\.00 ~1\S nc\ '":~8~~'1\c\~\o A~C~'SA~U·l'l~.
' ' . "!.>,-\-liS"'"-"" \we.r.\~_t<).Q"\"'3 S.\"1C~ ~oc o-.d.e- .ou\~y~J-"\'~ '<'.te... ·
(~ ·. _ _ · \;S.SUt.~ of;; \~~~-e-~\\~~ ~\S~!\!:)C'_:_LO~ t~~~ .\.0.1\~ g,\\)ID 1\1:\0 ~ · · . _.; -~0 ~\-ndl~_o\'\>~c.\~-l-~\ft'\uetde't-,3. \-at~~~\\)~. \M~ \s:~\J\t>, ot-
_t.o~x\u:~~\Of'\~- ~~~~~g_a ~1\d~ S\<'\C:t.. . tv\~_ti)_t-\~ hA~ ll)~\\}_v\-._. _· __ _ S\1\\\~c\ \.~ ~~~ ~og--\'-\ a,~~nt_\-_C.S)\.)1\ ' No o~e\e_'""s b~ t\1~ ~tJ\-\ -·.
_Co\J-.n_k ~~~~0~ \""<c::... \~S\.J\~ o\\f\(;w~_c_:\_\.u_S._ A33)~\~n~~ orv C<?UI)~~·--
1\C..tott\t~ \~ c.. c._\> At\ \\.o~ 3e'- 3Lctj 60~ 'oeen ·ru~~ --~~o _ _ _:__:t"--'\ ~At~\ \lm 1r2 "'\0\ C\.1\V•\s s;to<'\ \t-\11;\ 1\\\=rt~,L__\-w\e'l. V, 1-<)-.rr\ W. _
Ot-d~.r \c '"~~~\u((. ~".t~ \9..~\..\~ A\ 'rw-tQ. \.~tlt-\>o~. ~ ·P·utc\~ oP. __ ____.·~'--'-'-A~ or- ~onc\u~\WlS. \v..u~ 'S~~ ~e\.~ \,1-~L &\~~-~ \t'\.J\\ C:-t}~-.·
~ ;' bt-\IVI b .. \~,\\ 1 _~ou.\~_1~~-~ .tt:~Ut)lt. ~~ Wt-\.\ A~~lr~V)A. M~-- 1\ ~ ~u H\ c. ~~~~~~eJ ~o ~\ ( t u =-\:~ """'\ tl .. ~ L'teA ~,1\"o•c.h. ~-J"-t. J ~'L • . W\~ ~e..~~~\et:.\eue~J-~ te,~s;:)\\)~d .~~0./-~ .'tot-wt-.~~~-. ~· .~l\:1 -.- . -- ·: · · -- ..
---~0\)\-\~ ~\\l"l\.1\Jt\\ :A_~~c.M~.. ______ (_c.~~~'-el\\~ ~ Sa-0\c..~·-··~~\s-- Q~~ J·-----,--- *17 s:i\ ·~~ ~t-\-~ Wht· \~~ 'fi'~'i) 1\ ,. . ·'t_~ ~~\~ ~t"\1\fl ~v\\ ~\~tf"U: ... \ ccv.t\ l\ '\j):S •l 71. 'c \'> \\ J\~ t\ \ Co\;.Y\.\y ) } • . S\~-l~>-~ '\.(..i'I\S.
. ()t'<:\.u· ~_\"\o\nS,}Q ·~ ~:t-st~~~~~\~1\l,e.=~-'--~.--· _c_~'"'~\\:~U\,oV")): tJ.}~\\"· \~3,%~i'l" AA~ \,\j S'~'-eM~·\_~R~cR~ \,~
t-~\\)~ ~to~~~~~ -\o_ \-~~ Cc~-o-P ~1MlM!f\ A-MtFb __ --~'~u~ ~ .\~'1A~ Co-·~~t- Cn~-~~~~~_p~ ~·~·e.~ ~L~) __ · __ _ ·~--
~· : ' *18 . t{u~'lt \~~t-8'~'1A ,!"!:~ ~~~-}~ct- \-l, ~\~\rt~\- ~~- 'X ' v:s 'X oP ~A-t't'l~ c~~'f. . .S-\ A~ o\'. \~A~ • ")<• _______ ___,l.
_ __ ___ Ctx"Q,~\~ oft' ~~\'\:)\c_~· ~ t"\c\:l~~~ ~L~~~-.~-----'--- --~~1\\,~c~s. CC;)~f\.lS \\.C') w:~t\ \J- \9..~S'B~'I ~ ~~Sl S'v~~\e . .-~n~l-: ___ _ __ _ e.~li\:.=..;_~:.=-o~~ b<!. 't-~So\\)~cl Ard tt:)'r ~o'l~A..~e...cl. ~· CouA·o£.>_G~\.M~\_ __ _ _____,A'--'- ~~\s. ~\J~l~l\f'l\- ~ Coa~ J2 Cl-\~ ~'"'o~. s.ec.; At\-. -~). __ · __ \\c~ _____o_'.L __ ,_~'t'~""' h. \\1\\ ~\)(L. ~~ -~ot~ ~ ~ s tl-u\t~-\:,~_W\ \n.d_A_\~.-- _ _Mct eot\~~\ c.~-P-~-~ ~'L ~o'~~()~ Vt~\.'u~(UVl_· -=-~~~-~~~"---.---- ·. ro\\.wi.~ ,ctcn~s3<c\t
- - . -· t)~ve-Pt-A-~~a~e-f\ . _
_ · _··-~ ~ - ~ ~\~\t\L\ A\:\~~7----------
C/o \\1\~~'~ Co\lv-A-1_\)\~\nt.-\ A~~c..1\ O~<c"':- _________ _ \~<:>\ \=t"~"\'U) S\;nt~ bO<!J • ·
· t-\o'-!'Skol'l :t_'1::_:_1_0-=0-=-()...._:__ ___ ________ __ __ ~--- ~,,,~ c?\.Y1;\i-------
'~a, tt-M~\\(\ \,~ \~ n~c>-t
____________ ·._~_:__e_sQ~'-A-.\)u\1\:j 3ubn\<~,; · ~JU.B.rtV -2t )){~. \-d-0-\S \\1\'£\ \) . \ \ \\;\ ~ \:\.8");0~ ------------~-----~----- • ____________ __:_ _ __ ----,_t_.\_;_:_\ l.::__~:__o-=--:_f\.c._ ... '-_:_\- . . .. \ 'o '\'I) v 'i""'' 't (0
- ---'---~-----------
___ _ _,_r\-=--=~---=-=--·-'1--t._\\ ~ )~~.1\8 I 'l ~~3 *19 \ \ g ~ ~ 0 , \'d- ~ ~:'?~'") 1\ A f'\ d >: "PP\ e M ~" t ' . ' ~~\~~~iii'~ Y\~l')otA~c\vf1~ \\\~d. \l·~Q\}\' o%tR: \"''\""'\ ·
.'~~-~~·:.~k,-~o\'1. O<'\ \\.OI \JJ\,\ \·)..~¥~~'11\. \~ef'\ ..... 1 1;-t; -::"'-.-..• w.· ~~"' [0] -'/~ [0] ~;l;' ~ ~.;r 1-t.l. ' I • ';~~ <;;~~{>\e.l)m\ \IJ"'\ '>~:S.\1:\J"d. o{\1 S~p\eM~<:s • . {' . -. . . . .... . ' . . : . . i ~(, 1 ).? \L\; X" \ o\i\\ 1\ hA,·~ 's~<:r'l A \1'1os;\ \ W\J 'ItA 1- S W\ c<:c ' '\~ ~ \ "->SIJI\::>, . \.0'<:_ \ 'S~'-.1 ~ d_ t ~'-'.~<!.. '1 d..C)\;, Of\ )\\ e c). · Cl~ Ml \\. "wt.\\ \~~\S8().'fA ~(\d ,\ s.. · .. S\J~p\et'7eA\ ·"£~~0~~ .. '1:. w~~\cJ: .
\,\\'(\a H:.c\ \J\e:J,\ _ ~ \\ c:>'l w t, \ ~'- ~Otwt~.~d.ed, •\0 , \\, ~ . ··. "\c:tl\~ co-_j~\ o\ (I'WII~~\ A~pU\\~ '-ctotc\l~ \<6_~· .. ~,~:~ . · . . . '1 ~. L\ ts) .. "'\ P~\ "'~ 3 o r) - -t~ ~ d \%\'\- ~'j ·"-·<:C~<\'Ct:>\. : cf' /';G).fJ,\' ~)'a-ry - --- .
-\'o\ · \.\. o~ bSe a\J~ C.\)\ ~\.l-~ \~~ _c);,~\n ~\ c ~\J\~ -~ ~\\ · :· \:-. · ·.:; . - - \' o' \.N 1'\~ d \.'v\ 'f.. w ~~ \ '\ ec o' C:\ \ '.l \~ ~ \"'~ Cx::,"'\' C.'r'i ~< Nr;: ; ~~kD d\:\\11c_\"'~ ;ec,e.~cd eY\tJJSIOr\ .. ~{\}Y\~ 1 3 .
lf'l +'n~ \eH ':> ~u\c~ ()0 ( (1\Jt:\ ?,Q\4, l'dl,lOI\ ; ~\>\~~ o\' .· .. Ay~e\ll\~(-~tl)~~d~t~: ~~~·~>~~·~(s)l\~c\ 'l~~-S, •.. · (~~1~. ~~~~~ lt~l} ......_, . ·. ·. . · . . :·,., .· ' . .. ' . . ·.·· . . . • , . f.\,\\{)~·-"~~ .· ·"".M"~~' ~-~)oN· ·o\' ¥\A,k:·e~··s .. : ~~c~t-a, ~~G.'~- , -~ ~. ~ ~-r·· · ··N"d·
.. .. . \ ' 1 Me_ ~r>, f'lt ·'<.\'C) i e Si> \0\ II) I)~ o\'('_\ A I iTl S ~,;,er ~~IS t d [1] 1; J\pp \1 Cf,~l ok / !l,C)\Ll. 1: WOU'd \,)\~' ~C) . . .
~u\e_ ')~.5- s~~- e_~ec:.\n)t. )(\~ ~ ·.• .. . . ) . ' . . . ,. re~u<~st,:~ ,\4~t~"l'S. Ccv~'~1) ~~~~, ... \ C\t.Q..\. (Y'IttS \:)M.1e.\ .. ( f\6l ~\_C)::J . . . . ' ' .· . }i
. . . . ~ ... -.:-~~_.: .. ";· __ ,~-~---V-3'·-r .... o·.;.~ ·.. ... __ .. ·. :_. f;.:/.,"~)\=-:·!_ .··-.... ••...
~.~~ [1] fC~~t1_:'\ ~ i:- ~·: ... ;!~-~~·· -.-\' i~ \ .'.' . ' . . # . . . . . - • • _ • '
/'. . . (c ~f>tw t\~Q •. <:'\~ '"" \)~~ '' \\ 0 ~ ~ 'w~,\):.-6 f' \-\Noe.~q'2, . •' ~· I
) \'J..::)83'~'1 ~ 1\~d · ,\ ~ ~u<?~\~J·'~ei~\: e·R,R~R.~ NJd t'1errnaii\/)~\J(YtS .
:--.~. ~.() \~~- ~ .. ~~-'l1\~ ,(c0~.\-(\\,. (t\~·l~f\\:-·)\~~tl\\~: 1\CCOt0'-05· · · .. . . .. . ,·.. . . . . . . . . . . ' '~ . .. . '·.
.~.'>J \ e':!i'0 ~:\>1\:C~ · o\' )\\)~~~ Q,OG~d0 \ t_ ; :>., '-\{5) Afl cl.· .
,
· · 'l :,, s . (w~,\ \,\ed, lf\. Ro~~~, ~ouf\ \ . •. ·. ... . . . .. l\~~~ ~our~, ..
. • . . ,. . - \ 1 J \ . . • •• [1] .... .!· . :., ..... . . .
·. S.~"'c e.t\.':01 . . .. . . . ·. . , .. · · ·.. • .··· .· ·. ·. . ·. :) .. (~~l j t5 . . ·.~;A}J.}.IY\) /J._ .. , .~ ..... ·: - r _ · . _ _ ·... . . . ) (· n () .., ,· } . \ l?~~\f\~ 13.· \\,\\·.·~\{o~\68'0 .::.··,_ - . . . · " .. ,.\:" ·. . J:\\,~· \)f\,1' .. ~-- "·. :·vtc~tt:· ~tr\·: ··cv~o---,, . . · .. \~:~c\\'Jt\\e\\ex/\S· 11·~l,2> ·. . . ..
·· .. /