The first reason of demurrer specified is plainly insufficient; the second reason calls for more consideration.
Section 4140 of the General Statutes, by which "any railroad, or any of its appurtenances," is included with "any building, or any of its appurtenances" (§ 4135), as subject to the provisions of the mechanic's lien law, was first enacted in 1871. Public Acts of 1871, p. 722, Chap. *Page 293
137. The State in 1836 adopted the policy of subjecting, under specified regulations, any building whose value was enhanced by the service of mechanics rendered in its construction, to a lien securing the payment of services so rendered. At that time a "railroad," that is, a structure resting upon land and adapted to facilitate the movement of passengers or freight, was substantially unused; prior to 1871 the building and use of such structures had become common, mainly under the control of corporations called steam railroads, and to some extent of corporations called horse-railroads. A rapid increase in the building and use of such structures for various purposes was probable. To give to mechanics the same security for the payment of their services, when those services were rendered in the construction of this structure called a railroad, that the existing law gave them when those services were rendered in the construction of other structures called dwelling-houses, or other buildings, was the evident purpose of the Act of 1871. In the Revision of 1866, p. 549, "An Act Relating to Liens" provides as follows: "Every dwelling-house, or other building, in the construction, erection or repairs of which, or of any of its appurtenances, any person shall have a claim for materials furnished, or services rendered, exceeding the sum of twenty-five dollars, shall, with the land on which the same may stand, be subject to the payment of such claim; and the said claim shall be a lien on such land and building and appurtenances." The Act of 1871 is "An Act in addition to an Act Relating to Liens." The addition made is thus stated: "Every railroad in the construction, grading, or building of which, or any of its appurtenances, any person shall have a claim for materials furnished, or services rendered, by virtue of any contract made with or approved by the corporation owning or managing said railroad, shall with its real estate, right of way, material, equipment, rolling stock, and franchise, be subject to the payment of such claim; and the said claim shall be a lien on the said railroad and its said property and appurtenances, and the manner of filing, perfecting *Page 294
and foreclosing said lien, shall be in accordance with the provisions of title thirty-eight, of the revised statutes of 1866, and all the provisions of said act are hereby extended and made applicable to railroads and persons furnishing services and materials as above specified." The practical effect of this Act is to alter the original Act so that it provides that "every dwelling-house, other building, or railroad, in the construction," etc., shall be subject to a lien; and the alteration is put into the form of an additional section so as to provide more readily for the necessary difference in detail when the structure, in the construction of which the services are rendered, is a railroad. The law relating to liens as thus amended in 1871 is incorporated, without substantial change in the particulars now material, in the Revision of 1875, Title 18, Chap. 7, §§
There is error, the judgment of the Court of Common Pleas is reversed and the cause remanded for further proceedings according to law.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.
