N.Y. Comp. Codes R. & Regs. tit. 9, § 572.20
(c) A timely renewal request shall be reviewed as follows:
(3) Requests for renewal of permits which have previously been renewed shall be referred to the regulatory programs committee for initial review pursuant to section 572.12 of these regulations. In such a case, the agency may, following committee review, renew the permit, renew the permit with modifications, notify the project sponsor of its intent to hold a public hearing on the request, or deny the request without prejudice to submission of an application for a new permit.
(d)
(2) For the purpose of determining if a subdivision (or portion thereof) was in existence within the period stipulated in the permit, the agency will consider, among other factors occurring within the period: