N.Y. Comp. Codes R. & Regs. tit. 15, § 79.10
(c) By March 1st of each calendar year, every inspection station owner must return to the department all unused inspection certificates from the previous year. Refunds or credits will be allowed for such unused or defective certificates of inspection upon receipt of an application in a form prescribed by the commissioner and surrender of the certificates. A sticker returned as defective must have a legible serial number. Stickers voided or damaged by an act of the inspection station or inspector are not eligible for credit, except that stickers intentionally voided to prevent issuance may be eligible for credit at the department's discretion. Stickers may also be eligible for credit in the following cases: