N.Y. Comp. Codes R. & Regs. tit. 10, § 112.5
(17) Pest shall mean:
(40) Well head protection zone shall mean the ±119.0 acre parcel owned by the supplier of water (identified as tax parcel #6865-265185) located at the confluence of the Shaw Brook and the Mill Brook which contains the public water supply facilities and the well cone of depression. This zone shall also be known as Zone I as delineated on the map, dated April 1992 and filed with the New York State Commissioner of Health and with the village clerk of the village of Millbrook, and included as subdivision (j) of this section.
(c) General provisions.
(4) Spills. Within any of the herein defined protection zones, any person who is the owner of, or in actual or constructive possession or control of a hazardous material, petroleum, or radioactive material, or any agent or employee thereof, or any person in a contractual relationship therewith, who is responsible for, or has knowledge of any spill, as defined in subdivision (b) of this section, of any hazardous material, petroleum, or radioactive material to the ground surface or any water body, shall notify the supplier of water, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and the Dutchess County Department of Health. All spills shall be reported to the supplier of water, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and the Dutchess County Department of Health within two hours of such spill, or when knowledge of such spill is obtained.
(d) Specific regulations: Zone I.
(5) The area shall be posted prohibiting trespass for any purpose except as permitted in paragraph (2) of this subdivision.
(e) Specific regulations: Zone II.
(1) Wastewater treatment works:
(3) Septage and sludge:
(6) Hazardous material:
(8) Fertilizer and manure use:
(9) Pesticide and herbicide use:
(10) Petroleum storage:
(11) Stockpiles:
(13) Construction and closure of wells:
(15) Sediment generation:
(ii) land disturbing activities which may result in deterioration of the quality or quantity of the public water supply source, including general construction, highway construction, access road construction and maintenance are prohibited except where measures have been put in place to prevent erosion and sediment production.
(f) Specific regulations: Zone III.
(1) Wastewater treatment works:
(3) Septage and sludge:
(8) Fertilizer and manure use:
(9) Pesticide, including herbicide, use:
(10) Petroleum storage:
(11) Stockpiles:
(13) Construction and closure of wells:
(15) Sediment generation:
(ii) land disturbing activities which may result in the deterioration of the quality or quantity of the public water supply source including general construction, highway construction, access road construction and maintenance are prohibited except where measures have been put in place to minimize erosion and sediment production.
(g) Inspections.
The officials of the village of Millbrook, or any persons charged with the maintenance or supervision of the public water supply system by its officers or their duly appointed representative, shall make regular and thorough inspections of the identified protection zones to ascertain compliance with the rules and regulations set forth in this section. It shall be the duty of the aforesaid officials to cause copies of any rules and regulations violated to be served upon the persons violating the same, together with notices of such violations. If such persons served do not immediately comply with the rules and regulations, it shall be the further duty of the aforesaid officials to promptly notify the Commissioner of Health or his designee of such violations. The aforesaid shall report to the State Commissioner of Health in writing annually, prior to the 30th day of January, the results of the regular inspections made during the preceding year. The report shall state the number of inspections which were made, the number of violations abated and the general conditions of the protection zones at the time of the last inspection.
(h) Variances.
(2) An application for a variance must:
(4) Decision of the commissioner:
(iv) in granting a variance or a conditioned variance, the commissioner may require financial security, impose time limitations or limit transfer of the approval.
(i) Remedies for violation.
Remedies for violation of these rules and regulations shall be those specified by sections 1102 and 1103 of the Public Health Law.
(j) Village of Millbrook - Water Supply Protection Zone Map, April 1992.
(k) Millbrook Watershed Inventory and Census, Revised 1992.
Village of Millbrook
Summary Report
Millbrook Watershed Inventory and Census
(Revised 1992)
In order to assess the impact to regulated parties of the proposed watershed rules and regulations, an inventory of the existing land uses within the Millbrook public water supply watershed was conducted by the village. The land use inventory was then compared with the prohibited activities as described in the proposed watershed rules and regulations. The land use inventory was compiled using:
6. Recent subdivision and site plan maps on file with the Town of Washington Planning Board.
Land Use Inventory:
As identified through the land use inventory, land uses within the Millbrook public water supply watershed are:
Mabbettsville Hamlet
A veterinarian; bowling alley; proposed retail nursery/landscape operation; ice cream stand; automobile dealership with repair facility; automobile repair shop; professional offices; retail delicatessen; antique shop; apartment building; municipal park with swimming (pond); power equipment dealership building (vacant); and single family dwellings. Outside of the Mabbettsville Hamlet
Large areas of vacant land either currently used or once used as pasture or cultivation of crops for food or livestock; large lot (greater than 5 acres) single family residences; horse and cattle farms with single family and accessory apartments, barns and outbuildings; tool manufacturer; apartment building; private school; municipal landfill; and private hunting preserve.
ANALYSIS:
The comparison of land uses within the Millbrook public water supply watershed with the proposed watershed rules and regulations indicates that adoption and implementation of the proposed rules and regulations will not have a detrimental economic impact on landowners within the watershed and will not result in the significant loss of the economic value of any existing residential, commercial or municipal land uses This conclusion is based on the following:
• In Zone I, any use of the well head protection area other than as a public water supply and for non-intrusive recreation activities such as hunting, fishing, picnicking, nature study and hiking is prohibited.
The village of Millbrook owns in fee simple absolute the 119 acre site on which the public water supply infiltration galleries and wells are located. This entire 119 acre parcel is designated Zone I and is under the exclusive control of the village of Millbrook. No economic impact to the use and ownership of the Zone I area is anticipated.
• In Zone II and Zone III, wastewater treatment works must be properly designed installed and maintained.
On-site wastewater treatment, storage and disposal for the individual residential, commercial and municipal land uses within the watershed are provided through individual septic systems. No economic impact to residential, commercial or municipal land uses in Zone II and Zone III as a result of the design, installation and maintenance requirement for wastewater treatment works is anticipated.
• In Zone II, storage of septage, sludge or human excreta are prohibited. The exception is for storage and disposal of septage, sludge or human excreta associated with a properly functioning wastewater treatment work.
No commercial or private sites for storage of septage, sludge or human excreta, other than storage and disposal of wastewater associates with the proper operation of individual wastewater treatment works, were identified by the land use inventory. On-site storage of septage, sludge and human excreta via individual wastewater treatment works for residential, commercial or municipal land uses are permitted within Zone II. No economic impact to residential, commercial or municipal land uses as a result of the prohibition on storage or disposal of septage, sludge or human excreta is anticipated.
• In Zone II, solid waste management facilities are prohibited. The exception is for disposal areas located within the property boundaries of a single family residence or farm used for disposal of solid waste generated by that single family or farm, and a recycling facility having an on-site capacity not exceeding 450 tons per month.
The proposed definition of “solid waste management facility” is taken directly from the rules and regulations promulgated by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation regarding solid waste disposal facilities and landfills. (See 6 NYCRR 360 et seq.). Included in the Part 360 regulations are specific exemptions to the regulations (6 NYCRR 360-1.7(b)) for certain waste disposal and resource separation activities. The proposed Zone II exception to the watershed rules and regulations for disposal areas located within the property boundary of a single family residence or farm, and for recycling facilities having a limited on-site storage capacity, are consistent with the Part 360 regulations and exemptions to the regulations.
Only one solid waste management facility within the Zone II boundary, the town of Washington landfill, was identified. The town landfill would be directly affected by adoption and implementation of the proposed watershed rules and regulations. Implementation of the rules and regulations would require closure of the landfill resulting in loss of the use of municipal property and potential hardship on town residents to find alternative waste disposal sites. However, the town of Washington is currently under a consent order to study the closure of the landfill and is actively moving toward preparation of a closure plan. Because the town was undertaken to close the existing landfill and provide for post closure monitoring, the prohibition on solid waste management facilities within Zone II will have no additional adverse economic effect on, town residents or the town of Washington.
• In Zones II, disposal of hazardous material is prohibited.
The proposed rules will not prohibit the storage and use of hazardous material as part of a business process but will prohibit disposal of such material anywhere in the Zone II boundary. No operational sites for commercial or private disposal of hazardous material within Zone II were identified by the land use inventory. Although the inventory identified an automobile dealership located in Mabbettsville as a listed generator of hazardous material, the dealership is required, pursuant to Environmental Conservation Law, to provide for disposal of hazardous material in a permitted hazardous waste disposal facility. There are no permitted hazardous waste disposal facilities located anywhere in the Millbrook public water supply watershed. Thus, the prohibition on disposal of hazardous material in Zone II will have no additional adverse economic effect on existing residential, commercial or municipal land uses.
• In Zone II, open storage of fertilizer for non-farm and non-residential use is prohibited.
No operational open air sites for storage or chemical fertilizer for commercial use were identified by the land use inventory. It should be noted, however, that this prohibition does not prohibit the use of chemical fertilizer but instead regulates the manner in which it is stored. The prohibition, therefore, could impose some minor cost on a landowner to comply with the regulation, but would otherwise limit the lawful use of property.
• In Zone II, disposal of pesticides, including herbicides, is prohibited.
No operational sites for disposal of containers of unused pesticides and herbicides were identified by the land use inventory. Similar to the restriction on open air storage of chemical fertilizers, this prohibition does not limit or prevent the use of pesticides or herbicides but regulates the manner of their disposal. Environmental Conservation Law requires unused or waste pesticides or herbicides be disposed of in a permitted solid waste management facility or a permitted hazardous waste disposal facility as appropriate.
• In Zone II and Zone III, disposal of water used for make-up water or for washing of equipment used in conjunction with pesticides and herbicides is prohibited.
This regulation would prohibit the prospective disposal of water used for make-up water or water used to wash equipment used in conjunction with pesticides and herbicides except pursuant to a NYSDEC authorization.
TOWN OF WASHINGTON
WATER RESOURCES SURVEY
JUNE 1988
The following survey is designed to help the Town of Washington plan measures to protect the surface and ground water resources of the Mill Brook, the Shaw Brook, and associated tributaries.
Name __________ Address _________
____________ ____________
Tax Map #_________
1. Describe the current use of the property.
Single family _______ Multi-Family (number)_____
Commercial (type) ______ Retail (type)_______
Offices (type) _______ Vacant or Forested (type) ___
Agriculture (type) ______ Other (type)________
(a) Application.
The rules and regulations set forth in this section duly made and enacted in accordance with the provisions of sections 1100-1107 of the Public Health Law shall apply to the source of the public water supply of the village of Millbrook. Said water supply is located approximately one mile east of the village along NYS Route 44 on land identified as Dutchess County Office of Real Property Tax number 6865-265185. The location of boundaries designated for the protection zones, which comprise the Millbrook public water supply watershed, are described on the watershed protection zone map, dated April 1992 and filed with the New York State Commissioner of Health, Albany, NY, and with the village clerk of the village of Millbrook, Dutchess County, NY, and included as subdivision (j) of this section.
(b) Definitions.