Cal. Code Regs. tit. 23, Div. 6 Ch. 2 App. 3A

Disclosing Contributions to Restoring Ecosystem Function and Providing Social Benefits

Effective Apr 1, 2025Register 2025, No. 9State of California

Section 1. Priority Attributes and Ecosystem Tier

Appendix 3A, Section 1, Subsection 1.6 (Ecosystem Restoration Tier) requires the identification of the appropriate Ecosystem Restoration Tier for the covered action, based on the selections in Subsections 1.1 through 1.5 of Section 1.

Restoring Hydrological, Geomorphic, and Biological Processes

1.1.1 In Field 1 of Table 1-1 below, select the ecosystem type(s) that the covered action proposes to restore, if any. Select all that apply.

1.1.2 In Field 2 of Table 1-1 below, select the corresponding hydrological, geomorphic, and/or biological process(es) that the covered action proposes to restore, if any. Select all that apply.

Table 1-1 Priority Attribute 1 -- Restoring Hydrological, Geomorphic, and Biological Processes Selections

Row NumberField 1. Ecosystem TypeField 2. Hydrological, Geomorphic, and Biological Processes
1Empty Checkbox​ Tidal wetlandEmpty Checkbox​ Full tidal action and complex variable patterns of tidal inundation
Empty Checkbox​ Sediment delivery, scour, and accretion
Empty Checkbox​ Channel formation
Empty Checkbox​ Delivery of organic and nonorganic compounds which support nutrient cycling, primary productivity, plant growth, and peat formation
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth and succession, primary production, and higher trophic-level interactions
2Empty Checkbox​ Nontidal wetlandEmpty Checkbox​ Temporary or permanent inundation through natural hydrologic connections to surface and/or groundwater, but does not include managed wetlands
Empty Checkbox​ Hydric soil development through organic matter accumulation and/or terrestrial sediment delivery
Empty Checkbox​ Delivery of organic and nonorganic compounds which support nutrient cycling, primary productivity, plant growth, and peat formation
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, and higher trophic-level interactions
3Empty Checkbox​ Willow thicketEmpty Checkbox​ Temporary or seasonal floodplain inundation
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain sediment delivery, scour, and accretion which results in complex floodplain micro-topography
Empty Checkbox​ Unrestrained (natural) stream channels which allow cut-bank and point-bar formation, meander migration, and the development of shaded riverine aquatic habitats
Empty Checkbox​ Delivery of organic and nonorganic compounds which support nutrient cycling, primary productivity, plant growth, and floodplain soils
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, and higher trophic-level interactions
4Empty Checkbox​ Willow riparian scrub or shrubEmpty Checkbox​ Temporary or seasonal floodplain inundation
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain sediment delivery, scour, and accretion which results in complex floodplain micro-topography
Empty Checkbox​ Unrestrained (natural) stream channels which allow cut-bank and point-bar formation, meander migration, and the development of shaded riverine aquatic habitats
Empty Checkbox​ Delivery of organic and nonorganic compounds which support nutrient cycling, primary productivity, plant growth, and floodplain soils
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, and higher trophic-level interactions
5Empty Checkbox​ Valley foothill riparianEmpty Checkbox​ Temporary or seasonal floodplain inundation
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain sediment delivery, scour, and accretion which results in complex floodplain micro-topography
Empty Checkbox​ Unrestrained (natural) stream channels which allow cut-bank and point-bar formation, meander migration, and the development of shaded riverine aquatic habitats
Empty Checkbox​ Delivery of organic and nonorganic compounds which support nutrient cycling, primary productivity, plant growth, and floodplain soils
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, and higher trophic-level interactions
6Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool complexEmpty Checkbox​ Water inputs from precipitation, runoff, groundwater or subsurface flow that cause temporary inundation and saturation with water
Empty Checkbox​ Morphology (surface area, volume, depth, depth to hardpan) which supports hydrology, chemical processes, and native species colonization and persistence
Empty Checkbox​ Hydrology and hydrogeomorphic setting that supports appropriate wetland soil development
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, higher trophic-level interactions, and appropriate pool substrates
7Empty Checkbox​ Alkali seasonal wetland complexEmpty Checkbox​ Water inputs from precipitation, runoff, groundwater or subsurface flow that cause temporary inundation and saturation with water
Empty Checkbox​ Morphology (surface area, volume, depth, depth to hardpan) which supports hydrology, chemical processes, and native species colonization and persistence
Empty Checkbox​ Hydrology and hydrogeomorphic setting that supports appropriate wetland soil development
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, higher trophic-level interactions, and appropriate pool substrates
8Empty Checkbox​ Wet meadowEmpty Checkbox​ Water inputs from precipitation, runoff, groundwater or subsurface flow that cause temporary inundation and saturation with water
Empty Checkbox​ Morphology (surface area, volume, depth, depth to hardpan) which supports hydrology, chemical processes, and native species colonization and persistence
Empty Checkbox​ Hydrology and hydrogeomorphic setting that supports appropriate wetland soil development
Empty Checkbox​ Native vegetation recruitment, growth, succession, primary production, higher trophic-level interactions, and appropriate pool substrates
9Empty Checkbox​ Stabilized interior dune vegetationEmpty Checkbox​ Readily draining substrates
Empty Checkbox​ Wind-driven geomorphic processes
Empty Checkbox​ Movement, scour, and deposition which supports recruitment, growth, and succession of native dune scrub vegetation communities
10Empty Checkbox​ Oak woodlandEmpty Checkbox​ Fire disturbance or fire disturbance analogue (e.g., grazing) which maintains vegetation dynamics conducive to oak recruitment and other vegetation dynamics
11Empty Checkbox​ GrasslandEmpty Checkbox​ Fire disturbance or fire disturbance analogue (e.g., grazing) which maintains vegetation dynamics conducive to oak recruitment and other vegetation dynamics

1.1.3 In Table 1-1, above, each row in Field 1 lists an ecosystem type, and in the same row in Field 2 are the corresponding hydrological, geomorphic, and biological processes that a covered action could restore.

Based on the ecosystem type(s) selected in Field 1, would the proposed action restore any corresponding hydrological, geomorphic, and biological processes in Field 2?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No (continue to Section 1.2)

1.1.4 If the answer to Section 1.1.3 is “Yes,” describe how the proposed action would restore the selected hydrological, geomorphic, and biological process(es) selected in Table 1-1 above, and attach supporting documentation.

Being Large-Scale

1.2.1 In Field 1 of Table 1-2 below, select the ecosystem type(s) that the covered action proposes to restore. Select all that apply.

1.2.2 In Field 2 of Table 1-2 below, select the corresponding area where the covered action proposes to restore hydrological, geomorphic, and biological processes. For every row that is selected in Field 1, make a corresponding selection in Field 2.

Table 1-2 Priority Attribute 2 -- Being Large-Scale Selections

Row NumberField 1. Ecosystem TypeField 2. Proposed Restored Area
1Empty Checkbox​ Tidal wetlandEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 500 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 500 acres
2Empty Checkbox​ Nontidal wetland (including managed wetland)Empty Checkbox​ > or = 500 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 500 acres
3Empty Checkbox​ Willow thicketEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 200 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 200 acres
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain ratio 1 > or = 6 (large-scale) refer to table notes for methodology
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain ratio 1 < 6
4Empty Checkbox​ Willow riparian scrub or shrubEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 200 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 200 acres
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain ratio 1 > or = 6 (large-scale) refer to table notes for methodology
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain ratio 1 < 6
5Empty Checkbox​ Valley foothill riparianEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 200 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 200 acres
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain ratio 1 > or = 6 (large-scale) refer to table notes for methodology
Empty Checkbox​ Floodplain ratio 1 < 6
6Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool complexEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 40 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 40 acres
7Empty Checkbox​ Alkali seasonal wetland complexEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 40 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 40 acres
8Empty Checkbox​ Wet meadowEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 40 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 40 acres
9Empty Checkbox​ Stabilized interior dune vegetationEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 1.5 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 1.5 acres
10Empty Checkbox​ Oak woodlandEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 40 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 40 acres
11Empty Checkbox​ GrasslandEmpty Checkbox​ > or = 40 acres (large-scale)
Empty Checkbox​ < 40 acres
Notes:
a. Existing bankfull channel width (use the mean of at least six cross sections): meters
b. Protected, restored, or enhanced floodplain width: meters
c. Floodplain ratio (divide [b] by [a])

1 Method to calculate the floodplain ratio

1.2.3 In Table 1-2, above, each row in Field 1 lists an ecosystem type(s), and the corresponding row in Field 2 lists the restoration area that would be considered large-scale.

Based on the selection(s) made in Field 2, would any selected restoration area for the covered action be large-scale?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No (continue to Section 1.3)

1.2.4 If the answer to Section 1.2.3 is “Yes,” describe the area of each ecosystem type that the covered action proposes to restore, corresponding to the selections in Table 1-2 above and attach supporting documentation.

Improving Connectivity

1.3.1 In Field 1 of Table 1-3 below, select the aspect(s) of connectivity that the covered action proposes to improve. Select all that apply.

Table 1-3 Priority Attribute 3 -- Improving Connectivity Selections

Row NumberField 1. Aspects of Connectivity
1Empty Checkbox​ Creates or reestablishes hydraulic and hydrologic connections to marsh or floodplain ecosystems
2Empty Checkbox​ Reduces distance between patches of similar ecosystem types
3Empty Checkbox​ Reduces distance between patches of different ecosystem types used by species for refuge or life history needs
4Empty Checkbox​ Protects, restores, or enhances wetland and riparian transgression/migration space
5Empty Checkbox​ Removes or remediates barriers (dams and diversions) to fish migration

1.3.2 Selecting at least one Aspect of Connectivity in Table 1-3 above indicates that the proposed action would improve connectivity. Based on the selection(s) in Table 1-3, would the covered action improve connectivity?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No (continue to Section 1.4)

1.3.3 If the answer to Section 1.3.2 is “Yes,” describe how the covered action would improve the aspect(s) of connectivity selected in Field 1 of Table 1-3 above, and attach supporting documentation.

Increasing Native Vegetation Cover

1.4.1 In Field 1 of Table 1-4 below, select the ecosystem type(s) that the covered action proposes to restore. Select all that apply.

1.4.2 In Field 2 of Table 1-4 below, select the corresponding native vegetation community or communities for which the covered action would increase cover. Select all that apply.

Table 1-4 Priority Attribute 4 -- Increasing Native Vegetation Cover Selections

Row NumberField 1. Ecosystem TypeField 2. Native Vegetation Community (VegCAMP CaCode)
1Empty Checkbox​ Tidal wetlandEmpty Checkbox​ Schoenoplectus (acutus, californicus) Alliance (52.128.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Typha (domingensis, latifolia) Alliance (52.050.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juncus effuses (soft rush marshes) Alliance (45.561.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juncus articus (Baltic and Mexican rush marshes) Alliance (45.562.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Eleocharis macrostachya Alliance (45.230.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Sarcocornia pacifica Alliance (52.215.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Distichlis spicata Alliance (41.200.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
2Empty Checkbox​ Nontidal wetland (including managed wetland)Empty Checkbox​ Schoenoplectus (acutus, californicus) Alliance (52.128.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Typha (domingensis, latifolia) Alliance (52.050.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juncus effuses (soft rush marshes) Alliance (45.561.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juncus articus (Baltic and Mexican rush marshes) Alliance (45.562.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Eleocharis macrostachya Alliance (45.230.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
3Empty Checkbox​ Willow thicketEmpty Checkbox​ Salix gooddingii Alliance (61.211.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix laevigata Alliance (61.206.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix lasiolepus Alliance (61.201.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix lucida Alliance (61.204.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix exigua Alliance (61.209.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Cornus sericea (red osier thickets) Alliance (80.100.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Rosa californica Alliance (63.907.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Acer negundo (box-elder forest) Alliance (61.440.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Sambucus nigra (blue elderberry stands) Alliance (63.410.01)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
4Empty Checkbox​ Willow riparian scrub or shrubEmpty Checkbox​ Salix gooddingii Alliance (61.211.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix laevigata Alliance (61.206.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix lasiolepus Alliance (61.201.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix lucida Alliance (61.204.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix exigua Alliance (61.209.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Cornus sericea (red osier thickets) Alliance (80.100.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Rosa californica Alliance (63.907.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Acer negundo (box-elder forest) Alliance (61.440.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Cephalanthus occidentalis (button willow thickets) Alliance (63.300.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
5Empty Checkbox​ Valley foothill riparianEmpty Checkbox​ Quercus agrifolia Alliance (71.060.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus lobata Alliance (71.040.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus (agrifolia, douglasii, garryana, kelloggii, lobata, wislizeni) Alliance (71.100.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus wislizeni Alliance (71.080.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juglans hindsii and hybrids special stands Alliance (61.810.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix gooddingii Alliance (61.211.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix laevigata Alliance (61.205.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix lasiolepis Alliance (61.201.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix lucida Alliance (61.204.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Salix exigua Alliance (61.209.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Acer negundo (box-elder forest) Alliance (61.440.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Cornus sericea (red osier thickets) Alliance (80.100.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Rosa californica Alliance (63.907.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Platanus racemosa Alliance (61.310.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Populus fremontii Alliance (61.130.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Cephalanthus occidentalis (button willow thickets) Alliance (63.300.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
6Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool complexEmpty Checkbox​ Lasthenia fremontii -- Downingia bicornuta (Fremont's goldfields -- Downingia vernal pools) Alliance (42.007.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Eryngium aristulatum Alliance (42.004.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
7Empty Checkbox​ Alkali seasonal wetland complexEmpty Checkbox​ Cressa truxillensis -- Distichlis spicata (alkali weed -- saltgrass playas and sinks) Alliance (46.100.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Lasthenia fremontii -- Distichlis spicata (Fremont's goldfields -- saltgrass alkaline vernal pools) Alliance (44.119.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Allenrolfea occidentalis (iodine bush scrub) Alliance (36.120.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Sporobolus airoides (alkali sacaton grassland) Alliance (52.060.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Leymus cinereus -- Leymus triticoides (creeping rye grass turfs) Alliance (41.080.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Frankenia salina (alkali heath marsh) Alliance (52.500.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
8Empty Checkbox​ Wet meadowEmpty Checkbox​ Lasthenia californica -- Plantago erecta -- Vulpia microstachys (California goldfields -- dwarf plantain -- six-weeks fescue flower fields) Alliance (44.108.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Leymus cinereus -- Leymus triticoides (creeping rye grass turfs) Alliance (41.080.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Ambrosia psilostachya (western ragweed meadows) Alliance (33.065.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Lotus purshianus (Spanish clover fields) Provisional Herbaceous Alliance (52.230.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juncus effusus (soft rush marshes) Alliance (45.561.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Juncus articus (Baltic and Mexican rush marshes) Alliance (45.562.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
9Empty Checkbox​ Stabilized interior dune vegetationEmpty Checkbox​ Lupinus albifrons (silver bush lupine scrub) Alliance (32.081.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Baccharis pilularis (coyote brush scrub) Alliance (32.060.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Lotus scoparius (deer weed scrub) Alliance (52.240.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
10Empty Checkbox​ Oak woodlandEmpty Checkbox​ Quercus agrifolia Alliance (71.060.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus lobata Alliance (71.040.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus (agrifolia, douglasii, garryana, kelloggii, lobata, wislizeni) Alliance (71.100.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus wislizeni Alliance (71.080.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Quercus douglasii Alliance (71.020.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other
11Empty Checkbox​ GrasslandEmpty Checkbox​ Lasthenia californica -- Plantago erecta -- Vulpia microstachys (California goldfields -- Dwarf plantain -- six-weeks fescue flower fields) Alliance (44.108.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Leymus cinereus -- Leymus triticoides (creeping rye grass turfs) Alliance (41.080.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Nassella pulchra Alliance (41.150.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Eschscholzia californica (California poppy fields) Alliance (43.200.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Amsinckia (fiddleneck fields) Alliance (42.110.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Plagiobothrys nothofulvus (popcorn flower fields) Alliance (43.300.00)
Empty Checkbox​ Other

Note: VegCAMP is the California component of the National Vegetation Classification system, maintained by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife in collaboration with other agencies and organizations.

1.4.3 Refer to both Table 1-2 and Table 1-4 for this section. On what share of the aggregate area(s) selected in Field 2 of Table 1-2 would the covered action increase the cover of the native vegetation community or communities selected in Field 2 of Table 1-4?

Empty Checkbox​ At least 75% of the aggregate area (increases native vegetation cover)

Empty Checkbox​ Less than 75% of the aggregate area

1.4.4 Based on the selection in Section 1.4.3 above, would the covered action increase native vegetation cover?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No (continue to Section 1.5)

1.4.5 Describe how the covered action would increase cover of the native vegetation communities selected in Table 1-4, across the area selected in Section 1.4.3, and attach supporting documentation. If the selection(s) in Table 1-4 include “Other,” identify and describe those native vegetation communities here.

Contributing to the Recovery of Special-Status Species

1.5.1 In Field 1 of Table 1-5 below, select the ecosystem type(s) that the covered action proposes to restore. Select all that apply.

1.5.2 In Field 2 of Table 1-5 below, select the corresponding special-status species whose recovery would be contributed to by the proposed action. Select all that apply.

Table 1-5 Priority Attribute 5 -- Contributing to the Recovery of Special-Status Species Selections

Row NumberField 1. Ecosystem TypeField 2. Special-Status Species
1Empty Checkbox​ Tidal wetlandEmpty Checkbox​ California least tern (Sterna antillarum browni)
Empty Checkbox​ Ridgway's rail (Rallus obsoletus)
Empty Checkbox​ California black rail (Laterallus jamaicensis coturniculus)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun song sparrow (Melospiza melodia)
Empty Checkbox​ Tricolored blackbird (Agelaius tricolor)
Empty Checkbox​ White-tailed kite (Elanus leucurus)
Empty Checkbox​ Salt marsh harvest mouse (Reithrodontomys raviventris)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun shrew (Sorex ornatus sinuosus)
Empty Checkbox​ California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Western pond turtle (Actinemys marmorata)
Empty Checkbox​ Giant garter snake (Thamnophis gigas)
Empty Checkbox​ Green sturgeon (Acipenser medirostris)
Empty Checkbox​ Delta smelt (Hypomesus transpacificus)
Empty Checkbox​ Longfin smelt (Spirinchus thaleichthys)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley fall/late fall-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley spring-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Sacramento River winter-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
Empty Checkbox​ Delta mudwort (Limosella subulata)
Empty Checkbox​ Mason's lilaeopsis (Lilaeopsis masonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Slough thistle (Cirsium crassicaule)
Empty Checkbox​ Delta tule pea (Lathyrus jepsonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun thistle (Cirsium hydrophilum var. hydrophilum)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun marsh aster (Symphyotrichum lentum)
Empty Checkbox​ Soft bird's beak (Choropyron molle ssp. molle)
Empty Checkbox​ Side flowering skullcap (Scutellaria lateriflora)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
2Empty Checkbox​ Nontidal wetland (including managed wetland)Empty Checkbox​ California least tern (Sterna antillarum browni)
Empty Checkbox​ Ridgway's rail (Rallus obsoletus)
Empty Checkbox​ California black rail (Laterallus jamaicensis coturniculus)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun song sparrow (Melospiza melodia)
Empty Checkbox​ Tricolored blackbird (Agelaius tricolor)
Empty Checkbox​ White-tailed kite (Elanus leucurus)
Empty Checkbox​ Salt marsh harvest mouse (Reithrodontomys raviventris)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun shrew (Sorex ornatus sinuosus)
Empty Checkbox​ California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Western pond turtle (Actinemys marmorata)
Empty Checkbox​ Giant garter snake (Thamnophis gigas)
Empty Checkbox​ Delta mudwort (Limosella subulata)
Empty Checkbox​ Mason's lilaeopsis (Lilaeopsis masonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Slough thistle (Cirsium crassicaule)
Empty Checkbox​ Delta tule pea (Lathyrus jepsonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun thistle (Cirsium hydrophilum var. hydrophilum)
Empty Checkbox​ Suisun marsh aster (Symphyotrichum lentum)
Empty Checkbox​ Soft bird's beak (Choropyron molle ssp. molle)
Empty Checkbox​ Side flowering skullcap (Scutellaria lateriflora)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
3Empty Checkbox​ Willow thicketEmpty Checkbox​ Least Bell's vireo (Vireo bellii pusillus)
Empty Checkbox​ Western yellow-billed cuckoo (Coccyzus americanus)
Empty Checkbox​ Yellow-breasted chat (Icteria virens)
Empty Checkbox​ Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsoni)
Empty Checkbox​ San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica)
Empty Checkbox​ Riparian woodrat (Neotoma fuscipes riparia)
Empty Checkbox​ Riparian brush rabbit (Sylvilagus bachmani)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley fall/late fall-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley spring-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Sacramento River winter-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
Empty Checkbox​ Valley elderberry longhorn beetle (Desmocerus californicus dimorphus)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
4Empty Checkbox​ Willow riparian scrub or shrubEmpty Checkbox​ Least Bell's vireo (Vireo bellii pusillus)
Empty Checkbox​ Western yellow-billed cuckoo (Coccyzus americanus)
Empty Checkbox​ Yellow-breasted chat (Icteria virens)
Empty Checkbox​ Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsoni)
Empty Checkbox​ San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica)
Empty Checkbox​ Riparian woodrat (Neotoma fuscipes riparia)
Empty Checkbox​ Riparian brush rabbit (Sylvilagus bachmani)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley fall/late fall-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley spring-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Sacramento River winter-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
Empty Checkbox​ Valley elderberry longhorn beetle (Desmocerus californicus dimorphus)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
5Empty Checkbox​ Valley foothill riparianEmpty Checkbox​ Least Bell's vireo (Vireo bellii pusillus)
Empty Checkbox​ Western yellow-billed cuckoo (Coccyzus americanus)
Empty Checkbox​ Yellow-breasted chat (Icteria virens)
Empty Checkbox​ Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsoni)
Empty Checkbox​ San Joaquin kit fox (Vulpes macrotis mutica)
Empty Checkbox​ Riparian woodrat (Neotoma fuscipes riparia)
Empty Checkbox​ Riparian brush rabbit (Sylvilagus bachmani)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley fall/late fall-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Central Valley spring-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Chinook salmon (Sacramento River winter-run) (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha)
Empty Checkbox​ Steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss)
Empty Checkbox​ Valley elderberry longhorn beetle (Desmocerus californicus dimorphus)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
6Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool complexEmpty Checkbox​ Greater sandhill crane (Grus canadensis)
Empty Checkbox​ California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii)
Empty Checkbox​ California tiger salamander (Ambystoma californiense)
Empty Checkbox​ Giant garter snake (Thamnophis gigas)
Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool tadpole shrimp (Lepidurus packardi)
Empty Checkbox​ Longhorn fairy shrimp (Branchinecta longiantenna)
Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool fairy shrimp (Branchinecta lynchi)
Empty Checkbox​ Mid-valley fairy shrimp (Branchinecta mesovallensis)
Empty Checkbox​ Conservancy fairy shrimp (Branchinecta conservatio)
Empty Checkbox​ California linderiella (Linderiella occidentalis)
Empty Checkbox​ Legenere (Legenere limosa)
Empty Checkbox​ Boggs Lake hedge-hyssop (Gratiola heterosepala)
Empty Checkbox​ Dwarf downingia (Downingia pusilla)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
7Empty Checkbox​ Alkali seasonal wetland complexEmpty Checkbox​ Greater sandhill crane (Grus canadensis)
Empty Checkbox​ California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii)
Empty Checkbox​ California tiger salamander (Ambystoma californiense)
Empty Checkbox​ Giant garter snake (Thamnophis gigas)
Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool tadpole shrimp (Lepidurus packardi)
Empty Checkbox​ Longhorn fairy shrimp (Branchinecta longiantenna)
Empty Checkbox​ Vernal pool fairy shrimp (Branchinecta lynchi)
Empty Checkbox​ Mid-valley fairy shrimp (Branchinecta mesovallensis)
Empty Checkbox​ Conservancy fairy shrimp (Branchinecta conservatio)
Empty Checkbox​ California linderiella (Linderiella occidentalis)
Empty Checkbox​ Legenere (Legenere limosa)
Empty Checkbox​ Boggs Lake hedge-hyssop (Gratiola heterosepala)
Empty Checkbox​ Dwarf downingia (Downingia pusilla)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
8Empty Checkbox​ Wet meadowEmpty Checkbox​ Carquinez goldenbush (Isocoma arguta)
Empty Checkbox​ Alkali milkvetch (Astragalus tener)
Empty Checkbox​ Heckard's peppergrass (Lepidium latipes var. heckardii)
Empty Checkbox​ Brittlescale (Atriplex depressa)
Empty Checkbox​ Heartscale (Atriplex cordulata var. cordulata)
Empty Checkbox​ Delta button celery (Eryngium racemosum)
Empty Checkbox​ San Joaquin spearscale (Atriplex joaquiniana)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
9Empty Checkbox​ Stabilized interior dune vegetationEmpty Checkbox​ Lange's metalmark butterfly (Apodemia mormo langei)
Empty Checkbox​ Antioch Dunes evening primrose (Oenothera deltoides howellii)
Empty Checkbox​ Contra Costa wallflower (Erysimum capitatum)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
10Empty Checkbox​ Oak woodlandEmpty Checkbox​ Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsonii)
Empty Checkbox​ California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii)
Empty Checkbox​ California tiger salamander (Ambystoma califonriense)
Empty Checkbox​ Western pond turtle (Actinemys marmorata)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species
11Empty Checkbox​ GrasslandEmpty Checkbox​ Greater sandhill crane (Grus canadensis)
Empty Checkbox​ White-tailed kite (Elanus leucurus)
Empty Checkbox​ Yellow-breasted chat (Icteria virens)
Empty Checkbox​ Swainson's hawk (Buteo swainsonii)
Empty Checkbox​ Western burrowing owl (Athene cunicularia)
Empty Checkbox​ California red-legged frog (Rana draytonii)
Empty Checkbox​ California tiger salamander (Ambystoma californiense)
Empty Checkbox​ Western pond turtle (Actinemys marmorata)
Empty Checkbox​ Giant garter snake (Thamnophis gigas)
Empty Checkbox​ Other special-status species

1.5.3 In Table 1-5 above, each row in Field 1 lists ecosystem type(s), and the corresponding row in Field 2 lists the special-status species for which a covered action could contribute to their recovery.

Based on the selection(s) made in Field 2, would the covered action contribute to the recovery of special-status species?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No (continue to Section 1.6)

1.5.4 If the answer to Section 1.5.3 is “Yes,” describe how the covered action would contribute to the recovery of the special-status species corresponding to the selections in Table 1-5 above, and attach supporting documentation. If the selection(s) in Table 1-5 include “Other,” identify and describe those special-status species in the area provided below.

Ecosystem Restoration Tier

1.6.1 Field 1 of Table 1-6.1, below, lists Priority Attributes 1 through 5. The corresponding row in Field 2 of Table 1-6.1 lists the selection in this Appendix 3A made in Sections 1.1 through 1.5, above, on whether the covered action would have the applicable Priority Attribute.

Complete Field 3 of Table 1-6.1, by copying the responses from the corresponding sections in Sections 1.1. through 1.5 of this Appendix 3A form, as indicated in Field 2.

Table 1-6.1 Summary of Responses

Row NumberField 1. Priority AttributeField 2. Section NumberField 3. Response to Section
1Restoring Hydrological, Geomorphic, and Biological Processes1.1.3Empty Checkbox​ Yes
Empty Checkbox​ No
2Being Large-Scale1.2.3Empty Checkbox​ Yes
Empty Checkbox​ No
3Improving Connectivity1.3.2Empty Checkbox​ Yes
Empty Checkbox​ No
4Increasing Native Vegetation1.4.4Empty Checkbox​ Yes
Empty Checkbox​ No
5Contributing to the Recovery of Special-Status Species1.5.3Empty Checkbox​ Yes
Empty Checkbox​ No

1.6.2 Add the number of “Yes” responses in Table 1-6.1 Field 3, and then select the corresponding number in Field 1 of Table 1-6.2, below. The corresponding value in Field 2 of Table 1-6.2 is the covered action's ecosystem restoration tier.

Table 1-6.2 Calculated Ecosystem Restoration Tier

Row NumberField 1. Number of “Yes” Responses in Table 1-6.1, Field 3, Rows 1 through 5Field 2. Ecosystem Restoration Tier
1Empty Checkbox​ 1Empty Checkbox​ Tier 5
2Empty Checkbox​ 2Empty Checkbox​ Tier 4
3Empty Checkbox​ 3Empty Checkbox​ Tier 3
4Empty Checkbox​ 4Empty Checkbox​ Tier 2
5Empty Checkbox​ 5Empty Checkbox​ Tier 1

Section 2. Social Benefits and Delta as Place

Social Benefits

Appendix 3A, Section 2, Subsections 2.1 through 2.4 (Social Benefits) require the identification of the social benefits that would be provided by the covered action, and the disclosure of supporting information, in each of the following four categories:

2.1 Cultural Benefits

2.2 Recreational Benefits

2.3 Agricultural Benefits

2.4 Natural Resource Benefits

Cultural Benefits

2.1.1 In Field 1 of Table 2-1 below, select the types of cultural benefits that the covered action would provide. Select all that apply.

2.1.2 In Field 2 of Table 2-1 below, select the specific cultural benefits that the covered action would provide. Select all that apply.

Table 2-1 Cultural Benefits Selections

Row NumberField 1. Types of Cultural BenefitsField 2. Specific Cultural Benefits
1Empty Checkbox​ Ecocultural resourcesEmpty Checkbox​ Supports long-term resilience of tribal ecocultural resource species
Empty Checkbox​ Engages tribes in a way that respects sovereignty and protects or enhances access to natural resources
Empty Checkbox​ Provides education on ecocultural resources through interpretive signage, facilities, or funding for interpretive personnel/events
Empty Checkbox​ Supports responsible ecotourism, agritourism, sportfishing, hunting, or other cultural activities
Empty Checkbox​ Involves the public in stewardship of ecocultural resources during project implementation or monitoring
2Empty Checkbox​ Human health and well-beingEmpty Checkbox​ Improves air quality, water quality, or environmental quality in a manner that is expected to protect or enhance human health and well-being
Empty Checkbox​ Provides public access to lands for exercise, relaxation, and/or appreciation of natural beauty
3Empty Checkbox​ Environmental justiceEmpty Checkbox​ Redresses existing environmental inequities by targeting action and resources for disadvantaged and disproportionately impacted communities
Empty Checkbox​ Engaged and co-planned with disadvantaged communities
Empty Checkbox​ Improves access for safe subsistence fishing
Empty Checkbox​ Improves environmental conditions (e.g., air quality or water quality) for at-risk groups

2.1.3 Based on the types of cultural benefits selected in Field 1 of Table 2-1, and the specific cultural benefits selected in Field 2, would implementation of the covered action result in cultural benefits?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No

2.1.4 If the answer to Section 2.1.3 is “Yes,” describe how the covered action would provide the types of cultural benefits and specific cultural benefits selected in Table 2-1, and then attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with tribes, local communities, or experts.

2.1.5 If the answer to Section 2.1.3 is “No,” but the proposed action would provide cultural benefits not listed in the table above, describe the cultural benefits that the action would provide, and attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with tribes, local communities, or experts.

Recreational Benefits

2.2.1 In Field 1 of Table 2-2 below, select the specific recreational benefits that the covered action would provide. Select all that apply.

Table 2-2 Recreational Benefits Selections

Row NumberField 1. Specific Recreational Benefits
1Empty Checkbox​ Provides opportunities for land-based recreational activities such as hiking and wildlife observation
2Empty Checkbox​ Provides opportunities for water-based recreational activities such as nonmotorized and motorized boating
3Empty Checkbox​ Connects users to the Great California Delta Trail System
4Empty Checkbox​ Includes public facilities such as restrooms
5Empty Checkbox​ Contributes to species populations in a way that benefits recreational fishing (e.g., salmon, sturgeon), nature study, and wildlife observation (e.g., birdwatching)
6Empty Checkbox​ Enhances public access to recreation (e.g., provides parking) while mitigating traffic impacts on neighboring agricultural and private lands

2.2.2 Based on the specific recreational benefits selected in Field 1 of Table 2-2, would implementation of the covered action result in recreational benefits?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No

2.2.3 If the answer to Section 2.2.2 is “Yes,” describe how the covered action would provide the specific recreational benefits selected in Table 2-2, and then attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

2.2.4 If the answer to Section 2.2.2 is “No,” but the proposed action would provide recreational benefits not listed in the table above, describe the recreational benefits that the proposed action would provide, and attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

Agricultural Benefits

2.3.1 In Field 1 of Table 2-3 below, select the specific agricultural benefits that the covered action would provide. Select all that apply.

Table 2-3 Agricultural Benefits Selections

Row NumberField 1. Specific Agricultural Benefits
1Empty Checkbox​ Protects or enhances ecological systems supportive of agriculture such as supporting pollination or natural pest control
2Empty Checkbox​ Conserves or improves soils in a manner that benefits agricultural land use
3Empty Checkbox​ Restores natural processes and communities that would reduce flood risk to neighboring agricultural lands
4Empty Checkbox​ Improves local water quality
5Empty Checkbox​ Recharges groundwater, increasing the water supply available in an aquifer, in locations that do not have high water tables
6Empty Checkbox​ Prevents increases in subsurface water levels, in locations with high water tables that interfere with agricultural activities

2.3.2 Based on the specific agricultural benefits selected in Field 1 of Table 2-3, would implementation of the proposed action result in agricultural benefits?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No

2.3.3 If the answer to Section 2.3.2 is “Yes,” describe how the covered action would provide the specific agricultural benefits selected in Table 2-3, and then attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

2.3.4 If the answer to Section 2.3.2 is “No,” but the covered action would provide agricultural benefits not listed in the table above, describe the agricultural benefits that the action would provide, and attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

Natural Resource Benefits

2.4.1 In Field 1 of Table 2-4 below, select the specific natural resource benefits that the covered action would provide. Select all that apply.

Table 2-4 Natural Resource Benefits Selections

Row NumberField 1. Specific Natural Resource Benefits
1Empty Checkbox​ Reduces flood risk by reducing peak water elevations
2Empty Checkbox​ Reduces flood risk by reducing operations and maintenance requirements on flood control works
3Empty Checkbox​ Reduces flood risk by reversing subsidence
4Empty Checkbox​ Reduces carbon emissions by reversing subsidence
5Empty Checkbox​ Mitigates climate change by sequestering carbon or other greenhouse gases
6Empty Checkbox​ Reduces heat island effects
7Empty Checkbox​ Increases native species habitat
8Empty Checkbox​ Enhances biodiversity of native species

2.4.2 Based on the specific natural resource benefits selected in Field 1 of Table 2-4, would implementation of the covered action result in natural resource benefits?

Empty Checkbox​ Yes

Empty Checkbox​ No

2.4.3 If the answer to Section 2.4.2 is “Yes,” describe how the covered action would provide the specific natural resource benefits selected in Table 2-4, and then attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

2.4.4 If the answer to Section 2.4.2 is “No,” but the proposed action would provide natural resource benefits not listed in the table above, describe the natural resource benefits that the action would provide, and attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

Delta as Place

2.4.5 If the answers to Section 2.1.3, Section 2.2.2, Section 2.3.2, and Section 2.4.2 are “No,” explain how the proposed action would protect and enhance the unique cultural, recreational, natural resource, and agricultural values of the Delta as an evolving place (California Water Code section 85054), and then attach supporting documentation. Cite any relevant literature or consultations with local communities or experts.

History

1. New appendix filed 2-27-2025; operative 4-1-2025 (Register 2025, No. 9).

Log InSign Up