Zimmerman v. EdenZimmerman v. Eden
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Groner
This is an appeal from an order of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia entered February 14,1930, denying a motion to reinstate a voluntary petition in bankruptcy dismissed for want of prosecution by an order entered August 15,1929.
The record shows that on the 11th of July, 1929, appellant filed a voluntary petition in bankruptcy in forma pauperis and was on that day adjudicated bankrupt. The petition was referred to the referee in bankruptcy, and on the 15th of July notice was duly sent to the bankrupt to provide or deposit indemnity for expenses to be incurred by the referee in giving and publishing notice of the first creditors’ meeting. Similar notice was again mailed the bankrupt on the 19th of July, and, on the 15th of August, the bankrupt being still in default, his recalcitrancy was duly reported to the court with a recommendation from the referee that the petition be dismissed for want of prosecution, and on that day an order accordingly was passed by the Supreme Court of the District, sitting as a bankruptcy court. Six months later the bankrupt appeared by counsel and moved the court to reinstate the petition as of the date of the adjudication, and thereupon tendered the amount necessary to cover the expenses. This motion the court denied, and this appeal is taken from that order.
Section 18g of the Bankruptcy Law (
“It is furthermore clear that the provisions of sections 58a and 59g of the Bankruptcy Act, as amended by sections 9% and 10 of the Act of June 25, 1910, c. 412, 36 Stat. 838 [11 USCA §§ 94(a) , 95(g)], that no application for the dismissal of a voluntary or involuntary petition shall be entertained until ten days notice has been sent to creditors of the proposed dismissal, when read together, relate only to dismissals upon application of a party in interest, and do not apply to the dismissal of a voluntary petition, upon the initiation of the court, and for the protection of its officers from the continuance of merely futile proceedings, on account of the bankrupt’s own failure to take the preliminary steps necessary to bring the creditors before the court.”
This we think is a clear and correct state*451ment of the law, for if it were otherwise a voluntary bankrupt might file his petition, secure an adjudication, draw to himself all the protection the law affords, and, by refusing to provide the costs of advertising and holding a creditors’ meeting, postpone that necessary preliminary step until after the time limitation for filing proofs of claim had expired — an obvious absurdity. This of course may not be done.
The order of the lower court denying the petition for reinstatement is therefore affirmed, with costs.
Affirmed.