Witte v. Cooke Tractor Co.Witte v. Cooke Tractor Co.
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Houser, Bennick, Anderson, Ruddy (per curiam)
This is an action in equity to rescind a contract for the purchase of a movable crane, for cancellation of the note and mortgage given in part payment therefor, and for refund of installments paid thereon, based upon breach of warranty.
Frank L. Witte, an excavating material and hauling contractor, sued Cooke Tractor Company, a corporate distributor and dealer in excavating equipment and machinery, alleging in his petition that plaintiff consulted with defendant regarding the purchase of suitable equipment for use in excavating work and explained the use to be made of the equipment; that defendant advised plaintiff to purchase a Wayne Crane and attachments and “represented to plaintiff that such equipment would adequately do the work for which it was intended: excavation of earth on various contracting jobs.” The petition further alleged the purchase of the equipment, the giving of a promissory note and chattel mortgage thereon for the unpaid purchase price, the payment of $5,916.32 on the note; that a balance of $11,968.60 is due on the note; that the equipment did not and could not adequately do the work for which it was purchased but continually broke down, requiring repairs, replacements and rebuilding, causing plaintiff loss of time, damage and expense; that defendant was notified of the failure of the equipment and although defendant attempted to make repairs the equipment has never operated in a reasonable and satisfactory manner and has not been able to do the work which was in the contemplation of the parties at the time the equipment was purchased; and that plaintiff formally rescinded, and offered to return the equipment. Plaintiff sought an injunction to restrain defendant from repossessing
Defendant filed a general denial. The parties entered into a stipulation whereby plaintiff turned over the equipment to defendant and defendant delivered the note and mortgage to plaintiff for cancellation, plaintiff to have no further liability thereon, with the provision that the stipulation should not prejudice or affect the rights or liabilities of the parties respecting the matter in controversy except that if the court should order rescission of the contract then plaintiff should be under no obligation to return the equipment and no order of cancellation of the mortgage and note should be necessary. The trial chancellor after hearing all of the evidence found the issues for plaintiff and against defendant and awarded plaintiff, the purchaser, the sum of $5,916.32. From that decree the Cooke Tractor Company has appealed to this court.
Plaintiff informed Ernest Cooke, defendant‘s manager, and John Wilsdon, defendant‘s salesman, that he was in the wrecking and excavating business, and was in the market to buy a machine; that he needed equipment that would really go out and do the type of work necessary; that in his type of work with competition, etc. he always figured a capacity of around 600 cubic yards a day on a ½ yard crane; that he needed a machine that would dig from 560 to 600 yards a day, which in terms of truckloads would be from 125 to 150 truckloads, working on an 8-hour schedule. Plaintiff spoke to Wilsdon several times about his particular needs and uses for a crane and impressed upon him that he needed a crane capable of doing “a lot of excavating work.” Wilsdon recommended the Wayne crane. He was told that plaintiff was doing all kinds of excavating and cleaning up work as well as digging basements. Wilsdon was out on several jobs plaintiff was working on and saw the operations. While plaintiff had previously had experience with Lima, Bay State and North-West Cranes, plaintiff informed Wilsdon that he knew nothing about a Wayne Crane and had never seen one of them. Wilsdon prevailed on plaintiff to go to defendant‘s place of business to look at the crane. Wilsdon told plaintiff that the Wayne Crane was “faster than anything on the market, and that it would outdig and outperform any machine that was in use in and around St. Louis. * * *.” Cooke informed plaintiff that “this Wayne Crane was tops with any one of them, this equipment, that it would outdig any other crane, so far as speed was concerned * * that it would outdig any machine, that it would dig 150 loads or better a day * * * that it would outperform any 1/2 yard machine that was on the market * * * that it had the speed and it had the stability to outperform any machine on the market,” and that it had all the qualifications needed to do the work and was faster and better and easier to handle than anything plaintiff had been using; that it would “run rings around” anything else on the market. Defendant company supplied Wilsdon with literature concerning the crane and instructed him to use the literature as the basis of fact in dealing with prospective purchasers and that the representations in the literature were to be passed on to the prospects as facts. Typical statements concerning the Wayne Crane appearing in the descriptive literature follow: “Does more jobs easier, faster; digs rapidly; moves more dirt per hour; dumps cleaner; lower cost per yard; does basement excavation faster; does more work; saves time; moves dirt quicker because of its speed and ease of operation; more speed; more mobility; keeps trucks rolling; saves man hours, demurrage and gets things done; Wayne Crane efficiency does it better; greater mobility that means more work in less time; moves more material.” Wilsdon made two or three trips thereafter to plaintiff‘s office. Plaintiff expressed the desire to see a Wayne Crane in operation, and Wilsdon took him to East St. Louis to see one, but it was idle at the time they arrived. He conceded that he “didn‘t just buy the equipment right off the bat” but “spent some time in reviewing it over” in his own mind over a period of ten days or
There was voluminous evidence indicating that the crane and equipment did not satisfactorily perform the work for which it was intended. Plaintiff had trouble with the hydraulic cylinder, the friction brake bands, the clutch, the teeth on the shovel, the shovel stick cable, oil leaks, the steering apparatus, the generator bracket, the pump, and the boom hoist lever. It would heat up when run normally. There were numerous breakdowns, frequent necessity for repairs, failure to get production with the crane, failure of the crane to perform properly, failure to pick up full shovels of earth, failure to hold cinders in the bucket. The number of loads per day ran far short of normal. The shovel would pick up only half or quarter bucket loads at a time. It was slow in operation, slow in the hoist. One operator said that for shoveling and hard digging it was “not so hot.” Another said that it could not be used as a shovel; that “it wouldn‘t do the digging; we couldn‘t load with it.” A job that should take six or eight hours would require two days to finish. Many hours and days were lost while the machine was being repaired. It was necessary to rent other cranes in order to complete jobs undertaken with the equipment. The best production plaintiff ever experienced with the crane was 100 truckloads in eight hours, under ideal conditions. On some days they got as few as eight loads in eight hours. Other half yard cranes will dig and load from 400 to 600 cubic yards (110 to 125 truckloads) in an average day‘s work of eight hours. Operators would become disgusted on account of the necessary repairs and would quit. The machine, when used as a shovel, would not stay in position but would push itself backwards, i. e. instead of the bucket going up when the power was applied, the machine would slide back away from the embankment. If the machine was stabilized to prevent it from moving backwards, it would bend the shovel stick. The machine was not built strong enough, and was unable to lift enough, or to “take the beating they would have to take under the conditions of excavating.” The shovel attachment never did work successfully.
Defendant‘s witnesses denied the making of the oral representations, denied any complaints on the part of plaintiff until April 16, 1948, denied that defendant had urged plaintiff to keep the machine and have it repaired and that it would eventually perform satisfactorily, and contended that the Wayne is a very good crane which compares favorably with other half yard cranes on the market.
During the course of the trial the purchase order signed by plaintiff, which contained a statement “It is understood that the machinery is sold by the dealer with the standard warranty of the manufacturer. This is the only warranty either expressed, implied or statutory, upon which the machinery is sold,” (Defendant‘s Exhibit No. 1) was identified by plaintiff, Cooke and Wilsdon. Defendant offered the exhibit during plaintiff‘s case. It was not admitted then and was reoffered by defendant at the close of plaintiff‘s case but the court ruled it out. The standard warranty of the manufacturer was as follows: “The equipment to be free from defects in material and workmanship under normal use and service.”
On this appeal defendant contends that there was no express warranty. It is argued that the statements that the Wayne Crane was “faster” and would “outdig and
The sufficiency of the petition to allege an express warranty has not been challenged, indeed, defendant concedes that “the plaintiff‘s petition pleads an oral express warranty.” While not a classic example of the pleader‘s art, the petition, not having been attacked by motion in the pleading stage, is sufficient after judgment as the statement of a claim upon which relief could be granted on the theory of express warranty. If, therefore, the proof was sufficient to sustain an oral express warranty, we need not determine whether this is also a case of implied warranty.
We have concluded that plaintiff‘s evidence makes out a case of oral express warranty that the crane would load 150 truckloads or better per day authorizing recovery under the general allegations of express warranty contained in the petition. A statement that a machine is of a certain capacity may constitute a warranty to that effect. 77 C. J. S., Sales, § 330(2), page 1194; Cosgrove v. Bennett, 32 Minn. 371, 20 N.W. 359, where the contract provided that a roller machine have “`capacity of one hundred barrels per twenty-four hours‘“; Chamberlain Co. v. Allis-Chalmers Mfg. Co., 51 Cal.App.2d 520, 125 P.2d 113, where the representation was that a pumice sifter would grade two tons per hour of dry pumice at 98½% efficiency; Sauerman & Ball v. Simmons, 74 Ark. 563, 86 S.W. 429, where the statement was made that a pump would lift water 35 feet on a straight lift. The statement that the crane would dig and load 150 truckloads or better a day was a positive affirmation or representation of a fact and not a mere expression of opinion, and meant that the crane was capable of loading the stipulated number of trucks in an ordinary 8-hour day, when properly used and handled. See Tower v. Pauley, 76 Mo.App. 287; Cosgrove v. Bennett, supra. Plaintiff used crane operators whose experience ranged from 17 to 37 years, and who were shown to be careful and efficient. Even under the most favorable circumstances the machine was not capable of loading more than 100 truckloads per day. The average production was considerably less. That the machine utterly failed to measure up to the express warranty was proved by overwhelming evidence.
For its next point defendant claims that plaintiff did not sustain the burden of proving the express representation that the Wayne Crane would load 150 truckloads or better a day, pointing to the fact that the statement was asserted only by plaintiff, whereas it was denied by three of defendant‘s witnesses, including the president of the company. We have considered and weighed the evidence on both sides of this issue and conclude that the express warranty was made.
Defendant asserts, however, that plaintiff‘s failure to rescind and tender back the crane within a reasonable length of time bars rescission of the contract. It is true that one who seeks to rescind a sales contract must do so within a reasonable time after the discovery of the grounds for rescission. Stone v. Kies, Mo. App., 227 S.W.2d 85. In the case at bar plaintiff discovered that the crane was not suitable or adaptable for his uses and purposes within about sixty days after the date of purchase. The contract was not rescinded and the crane tendered back until some eight months after the discovery and approximately ten months after the purchase was made. We find, however, that
In Aeolian Co. of Missouri v. Boyd, Mo. App., 65 S.W.2d 111, we said, loc. cit. 114:
“The rule that a purchaser must rescind promptly upon discovering the misrepresentations of the seller does not apply where the delay in rescission is occasioned by the action of the seller in requesting and inducing the
purchaser to continue to try to use the article pending replacements or adjustments. (Citing cases.)”
And see McCartney v. Taylor Aircraft Co., Mo.App., 140 S.W.2d 95, loc. cit. 98, where the court said with respect to the purchaser of a defective airplane:
“* * * his action in not rescinding promptly will not constitute a waiver of his right to thereafter rely upon a rescission, where the seller, either expressly or by implication from his acts and conduct, induces the purchaser to continue to use the property pending a correction of the defects. In this situation the seller cannot invoke the rule that the purchaser has waived his right to rely upon a rescission.”
In Dubinsky v. Lindburg Cadillac Co., Mo. App., 250 S.W.2d 830, loc. cit. 832, we said:
“If the purchaser is persuaded by the seller to keep the automobile for a while to give it proper trial or to permit the seller to correct the defect and it is not made to come up to the warranty he may still return the same and recover the purchase price.”
See also 77 A.L.R. loc. cit. 1186.
On the evidence in this case we cannot convict the trial court of error in failing to hold that rescission was barred. We do not believe that plaintiff at any time accepted the crane in its then condition as in compliance with the contract. See Goodwin Mfg. Co. v. Arthur Fritsch Foundry & Machine Co., 115 Mo.App. 382, loc. cit. 389, 89 S.W. 911.
It is next urged that the court erred in refusing to admit in evidence Defendant‘s Exhibit No. 1, the written purchase order signed by plaintiff, which contained a provision limiting the liability of the dealer to the standard warranty of the manufacturer, and which would have excluded all other warranties, express or implied. Plaintiff‘s principal objection to the offer of the exhibit was that defendant should have pleaded the written warranty as an affirmative defense. We are obliged to sustain the ruling of the trial court in this connection for the reason that
Defendant claims that since an offer was made to prove the purchase order and the terms of the manufacturer‘s warranty, that evidence is now before this court and should be considered in the review of this case. An appellate court, however, reviews the case on the record made in the trial court, and can consider only the evidence which was admissible under the pleadings as they were made up in the trial court. The evidence not having been admissible for the trial court‘s consideration, under the pleadings, it is not permissible for us to consider it.
Nothwithstanding that a breach of the warranty was plainly shown, it was elicited on cross-examination of plaintiff that the machine actually operated on 133 different days for a total of 972 out of a a possible 1,064 working hours and that plaintiff had considerable income from its use and operation. Can a purchaser of goods have rescission and restitution of that part of the purchase price which he has paid where the goods are not totally and entirely unfit and worthless? The rule is that there may not be a rescission for a partial failure of consideration unless it is substantial and material, 77 C.J.S., Sales, § 97, page 788; 78 C.J.S., Sales, § 491, page 159, or, as stated by Corbin on Contracts, Vol. 5, § 1119, when the contract has been broken by the seller in a manner so substantial that the buyer may rightfully return the goods after having accepted them, and regard the breach as “total“. This involves “weighing the breach” to determine whether it is substantial or comparatively immaterial, “by determining the extent of harm caused by it to the buyer and the degree to which it frustrates his purpose in buying * * *.” In the case at bar the crane was substantially and materially unfit to do the work and accomplish the purpose for which it was warranted and purchased, and the fact that it was not wholly worthless or totally unfit does not prevent rescission.
It is also urged that plaintiff has sustained no loss; that he enjoyed the valuable use of the crane and that the purchase price paid should be “offset” by the amount of the value of such use, which defendant asserts was approximately $10,000. Wholly aside from the question of the right to assert a setoff or recoupment of this nature, which we do not now determine, there could be no such allowance in any event in this case because defendant did not file any pleading in which it sought an allowance for the rental value of the crane or for the value of its use. Defendant filed nothing but a general denial and cannot now claim the right to setoff or recoupment in the nature of a counterclaim. In order to do so it must have been pleaded under the compulsory counterclaim statute,
Defendant contends that in any event plaintiff‘s recovery is limited to the cost of the shovel attachment ($1,227) and that plaintiff cannot recover the amounts paid on the whole consideration for all of the equipment. (The total purchase price was $16,910.94.) The crane consisted of an engine and cab mounted on rubber tires, together with several attachments each of which was adapted to a different type of work, e. g. trench hoe, dragline, clamshell, shovel, etc. Each attachment was priced separately but there was only one contract for the total amount of the crane and attachments. Since the evidence does not demonstrate breach of warranty as to the trench hoe, dragline and clamshell attachments, defendant contends that plaintiff could not rescind as to them. This contention is overruled. The crane and all of its component parts for its different operations were purchased at one time and delivered in one shipment. The contract arose out of one transaction. The attachments were not separately purchased. It was an entire contract, and not severable or apportionable. It was not one to be performed in installments. The attachment most useful and needed for plaintiff‘s purposes was the shovel attachment. As to the crane in use as a shovel a breach of warranty was fully disclosed. The shovel attachment was useless without the boom and crane engine and controls. Under the circumstances of this case there could not have been a partial rescission. Syme-Eagle & Co. v. Joplin Grocer Co., 206 Mo.App. 357, 229 S.W. 246; Herrington v. Julius Seidel Lumber Co., 209 Mo.App. 73, 236 S. W. 898. And see Palmer v. Reeves & Co., 139 Mo.App. 473, 122 S.W. 1119, in which it was held that a contract for the sale of a clover huller, feeder and stacker is not divisible but entire.
Finally, defendant claims that the failure of the trial court to make requested findings of fact and conclusions of law as required by
Finding no error in the record, the Commissioner recommends that the judgment of the circuit court be affirmed.
PER CURIAM.
The foregoing opinion of HOUSER, C., is adopted as the opinion of the Court.
The judgment of the circuit court is, accordingly, affirmed.
BENNICK, C. J., and ANDERSON and RUDDY, JJ., concur.