Wilcoxon v. WilcoxonWilcoxon v. Wilcoxon
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Boggs
delivered the opinion of the court:
This is a writ of error sued out to bring into review the decree entered in the circuit court of Stephenson county dismissing a bill in chancery filed by the plaintiff in error against the defendants in error, on the ground the plaintiff in error had neglected and omitted to assert the alleged right sought to be litigated by the bill for
The bill was filed on the 29th day of January, 1900. The plaintiff in error and the defendants in error are the children of one Thompson Wilcoxon, deceased. In 1879 the said Thompson Wilcoxon, who was then living but at quite an advanced age, was the owner of the Wilcoxon Opera House block and the Post-office block in the city of Freeport. These properties were of the approximate value of §50,000, and were encumbered for about the sum of §25,000. On August 19, 1879, the said Thompson Wilcoxon and Cyinde Wilcoxon, his wife, entered into an article of agreement with his children, said plaintiff in error and the said defendants in error. The substance of the agreement was that the said Thompson Wilcoxon and wife leased the said Opera House block and the said Post-office block to their children for a period ending on the first day of June, 1884,—practically five years. The lease contained a covenant on the part of the lessees “to assume all the indebtedness now existing against the estate of said parties of the first part, together with such additional indebtedness as shall be incurred in the erection and completion of said Post-office block, to the extent of all the revenues arising from the rentals of said buildings (except as herein provided) during the term of this lease,” and that after retaining out of the income of the said properties a sum not exceeding §300 each per annum, the lessees, after paying the interest on the indebtedness, the taxes, insurance premiums, repairs, janitor service and other necessary expenses of managing the property, would apply the remainder of such income in the payment of the principal sum of the indebtedness against the property. The lease contained other covenants and provisions not necessary to be here stated. On the same day the plaintiff in error and the defendants in error entered into an agreement by which they formed a co-partnership for the purpose of managing the property leased from their father, in and
Before the execution of the lease said Thompson Wilcoxon had executed a will bequeathing all of his property to his wife, Cyinde. Of this it is clear the parties hereto were advised. They were all children of said Cyinde and her only heirs. Also, long prior to the execution of the lease, one Abigail Wilcoxon, an aunt of the parties hereto, had executed a will devising and bequeathing her estate, which consisted of a valuable farm of 480 acres of land, to said Thompson Wilcoxon. The parties hereto were also
On June 20, 1881, Thompson Wilcoxon, and Cyinde, his wife, executed a warranty deed conveying the Opera House and the Post-office blocks, aforesaid, to the defendants in error. The plaintiff in error insists that he did not know that his father had conveyed the said two blocks to the defendants in error, or that the codicil had been executed by his father to his will, until in 1887. He continued to serve as trustee under the co-partnership agreement until the month of March, 1888. In his bill filed herein on the 29th day of January, 1900, he avers the defendants in error, “falsely and maliciously contriving to deceive and defraud complainant, withheld from complainant any information or knowledge of the execution and delivery of said deed, and permitted, allowed and encouraged complainant to continue to act in good faith in respect
The bill in the former case was for the dissolution of the partnership and the adjustment of the partnership accounts. In actions in equity for an accounting the
The scope and purpose of the bill filed by the defendants in error against the plaintiff in error were to procure the judicial investigation and determination of the state of the accounts of the different members of that firm, and particularly of the accounts of the plaintiff in error, who, by the agreement between the co-partners, had been placed in the active management and control of the business affairs of the firm and was made the custodian of the income from the property leased by them. The relief sought to be obtained by the plaintiff in error by the present bill is entirely foreign to the scope and purpose of the bill filed by the defendants in error in the former case. The relief asked by the plaintiff in error by the present bill is that the execution and delivery of the deed from Thompson Wilcoxon conveying the Opera House block and the Post-office block to the defendants in error shall be held and decreed to be a fraud upon his rights and to operate to render null and void the articles of co-partnership, and that an accounting shall be had and taken upon the theory that said lease and articles of co-partnership are and were nullified by the alleged fraud in the matter of the making of said deed and were without legal force or effect, and that the plaintiff in error should be decreed entitled to recover compensation for his services
It was the duty of the plaintiff in error to state in his bill in the case at bar whatever he relied upon to rebut or remove the presumption of laches arising from his delay of twelve years in seeking relief. (Henry County v. Winnebago Drainage Co. 52 Ill. 299; Walker v. Ray, Ill id. 315.) He knew before the lease and articles of co-partnership were executed that his aunt Abigail had made a will
The chancellor did not err in dismissing the bill on the ground plaintiff in error was guilty of laches, and the decree is affirmed.
Becree affirmed.