145 Iowa 110 | Iowa | 1909
The plaintiffs are the three daughters of James Doran, .Sr., now deceased. They and their only brother, James Doran, Jr., constitute the only heirs at law of James Doran, Sr. In 1859 James Doran, Sr., became the owner of the certain eighty acres of land involved in this controversy. In November, 1861, he executed a deed therefor to his brother, Patrick Doran, defendant herein, for a recited consideration of $231. James Doran, Sr., however, continued in the occupancy of the land and did so continue down to the time of his death, October, 3, 1904. The brothers, James and Patrick, were on intimate terms throughout their lives till a few months prior to the death of James, and had various business transactions together. Their methods of business with each other appear to have been loose and indefinite, and the evidence does not disclose any of the details of the transactions between them. In May, 1904, James Doran, Sr., brought an action against his brother Patrick to quiet his title in the eighty acres in question, and based his claim of title upon adverse possession. The defendant Patrick filed an answer and a cross-bill, asking- that his title thereto be quieted against the plaintiff. While the pleadings were in this state, and before the trial of the case, the plaintiff died. E'or some time before his death James Doran, Sr., had been in ill
The record is voluminous, and we have gone over the evidence with much care. The principal questions involved are fact questions, and a detailed discussion of them will serve no useful purpose.
The decree of the trial court was right, and it is affirmed.