Waddell v. BrownWaddell v. Brown
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Ivers
Arvel J. Waddell appeals a September 26, 1991, decision of the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (BVA or Board) denying an earlier effective date for the award of service connection for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and denying an increased disability rating for PTSD (currently rated 10% disabling). Arvel J. Waddell, BVA 91-28418 (Sep. 26, 1991). The Secretary of Veterans Affairs (Secretary) has filed a motion for partial summary affirmance with regard to the issue of an earlier effective date, and for partial remand with regard to the issues of an increased disability rating for PTSD and a permanent and total disability (PT) rating for pension purposes. The Court has jurisdiction of the case pursuant to
I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
Appellant served on active duty in the United States Army from March 2, 1966, to March 1, 1968. R. at 1. On October 28, 1985, he applied to a Veterans’ Administration (now Department of Veterans Affairs) (VA) regional office (RO) for service connection for PTSD and several other conditions. R. at 60. On February 25,1986, the RO denied service connection for PTSD (R. at 64) and sent appellant a letter notifying him of the denial of service connection and of the denial of a PT rating for pension purposes on March 5, 1986 (R. at 65). On September 23, 1986, appellant filed a Notice of Disagreement (NOD) (R. at 66), and the RO sent a Statement of the Case (SOC) on October 21, 1986 (R. at 68). Appellant did not file any other documents regarding this determination until November 1989.
On November 28, 1989, appellant sought to reopen his claim for service connection and filed a new claim for a PT rating for pension purposes. R. at 73; see Abernathy v. Principi, 3 Vet.App. 461, 464 (1992) (claim for PT rating for pension purposes is new claim and is not subject to “new and material” evidence requirement for reopened claims). In the resubmitted claim, he indicated that “Social Security verification” would be forthcoming. Ibid. On October 5, 1990, the RO granted service connection for PTSD with an effective date of November 30, 1988, and denied a PT rating for pension purposes. R. at 110. On a March 7, 1991, VA Form 1-9 (Appeal to BVA), appellant indicated that he had “been unable to retain or obtain gainful employment” and that he was receiving Social Security Administration (SSA) disability benefits. R. at 129. On September 26, 1991, the BVA denied an effective date earlier than November 30, 1988, for appellant’s service-connected PTSD and denied an increased disability rating for PTSD, but did not address his claim for a PT rating for pension purposes. Waddell, BVA 91 — 28418, at 8.
II. ANALYSIS
In his brief, appellant argues that the effective date of award of service connection for PTSD should be the date of his 1985 original claim because he has “continually prosecuted” that claim since then. Br. at 1. However, appellant has not “continually prosecuted” that claim. The RO notified appellant of the denial of that claim in March 1986 (R. at 65) and sent an SOC in October 1986 (R. at 68). Appellant did not file a substantive appeal to the Board within 60 days of the date that the RO mailed the SOC or within one year after the date that the RO mailed notifica*456tion of the denial. See
Pursuant to
With regard to the claim for an increased disability rating for the service-connected PTSD, the Board breached its duty to assist appellant by not conducting an examination to determine to what degree appellant’s functional impairment was attributable to PTSD. See
In order to explain the relationship between these [psychiatric] disorders, and pursuant to its statutory duty . . . to assist claimants who have presented well-grounded claims, the Board should have ordered . . . under38 C.F.R. § 3.327 (1991), a thorough, fully informed, and comprehensive medical examination to (1) reconcile the diagnoses; (2) evaluate the veteran for purposes of determining the existence of each of the impairments noted in the record; (3) determine the degree of disability, in terms of ordinary conditions of life, imposed by each impairment, if possible, and its relation to service; and (4) determine the extent to which each impairment contributes to the veteran’s employability or unemployability. [Citations omitted.]
In this case, the BVA stated: “Notwithstanding that the veteran is socially isolated and has manifested extensive psychiatric pathology, the 10 percent evaluation now assigned appropriately reflects that degree of functional impairment attributable to service-connected [PTSD].” Waddell, BVA 91-24818, at 7. Various VA and private physicians have diagnosed appellant as having several disorders concurrently, including PTSD, intermittent explosive disorder, avoidant personality disorder, anxiety disorder, depressive disorder, schizoid personality disorder, and antisocial personality disorder. R. at 94, 101, 108, 119, 121. None of these neuropsychiatric examinations fully describes the degree of disability attributable to each psychiatric disorder. Absent such an examination, the Board’s evaluation cannot be a fully informed one. On remand, the Board must *457conduct a thorough examination to determine the degree of appellant’s functional impairment attributable to PTSD.
The Board also failed to adjudicate a claim for non-service-connected pension under
The Board also breached its duty to assist by not seeking to obtain records of SSA disability determinations. The SSA determinations are relevant to a determination of whether appellant is able to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation under
III. CONCLUSION
The Court notes that appellant in this appeal has presented the issue of an earlier effective date for the award of service connection. The Court further notes, after a careful review of the record, that the date of award, cited by the RO and the BVA as November 30, 1988, does not appear to be in keeping with the facts set forth in the record. Therefore, on remand, the BVA may wish to examine, inter alia, the effective date of award as stated in its decision.
Accordingly, upon consideration of the record, appellee’s motion for partial summary affirmance and for partial remand, and appellant’s brief, the Court AFFIRMS in part and VACATES in part the Septem*458ber 26, 1991, decision of the BVA, and REMANDS the matter for readjudication consistent with this opinion.