Vaughn v. FitzgeraldVaughn v. Fitzgerald
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Simmons
It appears from the record that James Fitzgerald, of the county of Wilcox, died seized and possessed of a certain tract of land in that county. In 1889 his widow applied to the ordinary for a year’s support out of the estate of her deceased husband. Commissioners were appointed by the ordinary to set apart and assign to her a year’s support. They made their return to the ordinary, setting apart certain personalty and “also 65 acres of land of lot No. 37 in the 8th district of Wilcox county, price $5.00 per acre, being the west side.” It does not appear that any objections were ever made to the return of the commissioners, but the return was, through the mistake or negligence of the ordinary, not recorded as required by law. The evidence tends to show that, upon the return of the commissioners, the widow took possession of the land thus set apart to her. She resided thereon for a short time, and then removed to the house of one of her sons, Cicero Fitzgerald, on *518the same farm, and there remained until she died. After her death this son claimed the land which had been set apart to the widow. He died, leaving one minor child. Yaughn, the present plaintiff in error, was appointed guardian of this child. J. M. Fitzgerald, the administrator of the widow of James Fitzgerald, brought suit against Yaughn to recover the land for the purpose of distribution (there being several heirs), and for mesne profits. On the trial of the case the administrator tendered in evidence the report of the commissioners setting apart this land to the widow as a year’s support, and an order of the ordinary, granted nine years after the making of the return, ordering that the return be recorded nunc pro tunc. The administrator also showed chain of title into the deceased husband of his intestate, and proved possession by such husband in his lifetime. Yaughn, the guardian, disclaimed any title in himself individually, but resisted the suit on the ground that the land was the property of his ward. He introduced in evidence a deed from one Dóster to Cicero Fitzgerald, the father of his ward, dated in 1888 and prior to the setting apart of. the year’s support. He also introduced evidence tending to show that Cicero Fitzgerald went into possession under this deed, and remained in possession up to the time of his death, and that since that time Yaughn had been in possession as guardian. This evidence was explained or rebutted by the plaintiff by testimony tending to show that the possession of Cicero Fitzgerald was permissive, and also that the deed from Doster had been made to Charles Fitzgerald, and had been changed, after its execution, so as to substitute the .name of Cicero for that of Charles as grantee. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff, and Yaughn moved for a new trial. His motion was overruled, and he excepted.
Judgment affirmed.
All concurring, except Fish, J., absent.