Vandall v. Trinity HospitalsVandall v. Trinity Hospitals
- Reporters:
- , , , ,
- Before:
- De Walle
[¶ 1] Michael T. Vandall, M.D., appealed from a judgment dismissing his action against Trinity Hospitals (“Trinity”) and Margaret C. Nordell, M.D. for failure to state a claim upon which relief could be granted, and awarding Trinity $24,740.63 in attorneys’ fees. We hold Vandall’s complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted, and the trial court abused its discretion in awarding Trinity attorneys’ fees. We affirm the judgment dismissing Vandall’s complaint but we reverse the award of attorneys’ fees.
I
[¶ 2] Trinity hired Vandall under a Physician Services Agreement effective from December 1, 1996, through November 30, 2001. Vandall alleged that, during the course of his employment with Trinity, he learned Nordell, another Trinity physician, was engaged in a level of treatment that Vandall believed violated accepted standards of care. According to Vandall, he unsuccessfully attempted to address the problem through Trinity’s available internal procedures. Vandall alleged that, after consulting with legal counsel, he ultimately reported the matter to the North Dakota Board of Medical Examiners (“Board”), and the Board concluded Nordell’s treatment constituted gross negligence and immediately suspended her license to practice medicine in North Dakota. Vandall claimed Trinity then began a series of retaliatory actions against him, including censuring him and failing to reappoint him
[¶ 3] In January 2003, Vandall sued Trinity and Nordell, alleging Trinity undertook a series of retaliatory actions against him, because, as required by
[¶ 4] The trial court dismissed Van-dall’s complaint against Trinity and Nor-dell under
II
[¶ 5] A motion to dismiss a complaint under
III
[¶ 6] Vandall argues his complaint states a common law claim for retaliation against Trinity. He argues his common law claim is subject to a six-year statute of limitations and has not been preempted by the 180-day statute of limitations in
[¶ 7]
[¶ 8] Vandall nevertheless argues
[¶ 9] In 1993, the North Dakota Legislature enacted the whistle-blower statute now codified at
[¶ 10] Before the 1997 enactment of legislation authorizing a civil action for retaliatory discharge, this Court had discussed a limited public policy exception to the employment at-will doctrine for cases where a termination violated a specific declaration of public policy evidenced by a constitutional or a statutory provision. Lee v. Walstad, 368 N.W.2d 542, 546-47 (N.D.1985) (citing Brockmeyer v. Dun & Bradstreet, 113 Wis.2d 561, 335 N.W.2d 834, 840 (1983)). Without deciding the propriety of a public policy exception to the at-will doctrine, we held the employee in that case had not defined a clear public policy which his termination violated. Lee, at 547.
[¶ 11] Since
Lee,
we have recognized employees may bring a tort action for retaliatory discharge against an employer, if the employer’s actions contravene a clear statement of public policy in a constitutional or a statutory provision. In
Krein v. Marian Manor Nursing Home,
415 N.W.2d 793, 794-95 (N.D.1987), we held an at-will employee could sue an employer in tort for wrongful discharge .in retaliation for seeking statutorily authorized workers compensation benefits. In
Ressler v. Humane Soc.,
480 N.W.2d 429, 431-32 (N.D.1992), we held an at-will employee could sue an employer for wrongful discharge in retaliation for honoring a subpoena and for testifying truthfully at a trial. In
Jose v. Norwest Bank,
1999 ND 175, ¶21, 599 N.W.2d 293, we cited
[¶ 12] Vandall claims our decision in Anderson recognizes the coexistence of both a common law and a statutory action for retaliatory discharge. We reject Van-dall’s broad reading of Anderson. As the United States Supreme Court recently explained in Illinois v. Lidster, ■ — ■ U.S. -,-, 124 S.Ct. 885, 889, 157 L.Ed.2d 843,-(2004), general language in judicial opinions must be read in the context of the issues before a court and not in reference to circumstances different from what the court was then considering.
[¶ 13] In
Anderson,
2001 ND 125, ¶¶ 27-37, 630 N.W.2d 46, we considered a summary judgment dismissal of a retaliatory discharge claim, and we held the employee had failed to establish a genuine issue of material fact on a causal connection between the employee’s protected activity and her termination a year later. In that context, we said the elements of a claim for retaliatory discharge under both the public policy exception and the statutory claim included the existence of a causal connection between the employee’s protected action and the employer’s adverse action. However, no issue was raised in
Anderson,
or any other cases cited by Vandall, about the coexistence of a common law and statutory claim for retaliation after the authorization of a civil action for retaliatory discharge in
[¶ 14] Section 1-01-06 N.D.C.C. says “[i]n this state there is no common law in any case where the law is declared by the code,” and that language has consistently been construed to mean that statutory enactments take precedence over and govern conflicting common law doctrines.
See Northern Pac. R.R. Co. v. Herbert,
116 U.S. 642, 654, 6 S.Ct. 590, 29 L.Ed. 755 (1886);
In the Interest of M.C.H.,
2001 ND 205, ¶ 9, 637 N.W.2d 678;
Hill v. Weber,
1999 ND 74, ¶ 9, 592 N.W.2d 585;
Martin v. Rath,
1999 ND 31, ¶20, 589 N.W.2d 896;
Cermak v. Cermak,
1997 ND 187, ¶ 9, 569 N.W.2d 280;
Olson v. Souris River Telecomms. Coop, Inc.,
1997 ND 10, ¶ 13, 558 N.W.2d 333;
Burr v. Trinity Med. Ctr.,
492 N.W.2d 904, 907-10 (N.D.1992);
Nuelle v. Wells,
154 N.W.2d 364, 365-66
[¶ 15] In
Hill,
1999 ND 74, ¶ 9, 592 N.W.2d 585, we said “[w]here the provisions of the statute differ from previous case law, the statute prevails.” In
Rath,
1999 ND 31, ¶ 20, 589 N.W.2d 896, we said “[statutory principles govern over general common law if there is a conflict.” In
Burr,
492 N.W.2d at 907-10, we recognized a hierarchy which favored statutory law over common law, and we declined to apply a common law doctrine of equitable tolling to toll a malpractice statute of limitations. In
Nuelle,
154 N.W.2d at 365-66, we concluded statutory provisions in
[¶ 16] The elements of the statutory and the common law actions for retaliatory discharge are essentially the same.
See Anderson,
2001 ND 125, ¶29, 630 N.W.2d 46;
Dahlberg,
2001 ND 73, ¶ 34, 625 N.W.2d 241. However, the statutes of limitation are different. Because the language of
[¶ 17] Because of our resolution of this issue, we do not consider issues about whether Vandall became an at-will employee after two years of employment with Trinity under
IV
[¶ 18] Vandall argues his complaint states a cause of action against Nor-dell for the common law tort of wrongful initiation and continuation of administrative proceedings under Restatement (Second) of Torts § 680 (1977). Vandall’s complaint alleged Nor dell initiated a censure action against him with a letter to Trinity’s Quality Assurance Committee and Nordell filed complaints against him with the Board and with the ACOG. Vandall’s eomr plaint alleged Nordell’s complaints, with the exception of Trinity’s censure, were all terminated in his favor.
[¶ 19] We have not previously considered whether to adopt the Restatement (Second) of Torts § 680 in North Dakota, nor do we need to do so here. Assuming without deciding such an action exists in North Dakota, we conclude Vandall’s com
One who takes an active part in the initiation, continuation or procurement of civil proceedings against another before an administrative board that has power to take action adversely affecting the legally protected interests of the other, is subject to liability for any special harm caused thereby, if
(a) he acts without probable cause to believe that the charge or claim on which the proceedings are based may be well founded, and primarily for a purpose other than that of securing appropriate action by the board, and
(b) except where they are ex parte, the proceedings have terminated in favor of the person against whom they are brought.
[¶ 20] Vandall alleged Nordell initiated Trinity’s censure action with a letter to Trinity’s Quality Assurance Committee, but Vandall’s complaint alleged he was censured by Trinity. Vandall’s complaint does not and cannot allege Nordell’s letter to Trinity’s Quality Assurance Committee resulted in the termination of that proceeding in his favor because Trinity did censure him. Therefore his allegations regarding that letter fail to state a claim upon which relief can be granted under Restatement (Second) of Torts § 680. Moreover, Vandall has not marshaled an argument in this Court about his allegation that Nordell filed two complaints with the ACOG. We have said a party waives an issue by not providing supporting argument. McMorrow v. State, 2003 ND 134, ¶ 12, 667 N.W.2d 577 (citing Olander Contracting, Co. v. Gail Wachter Invs., 2002 ND 65, ¶ 27, 643 N.W.2d 29). We conclude Vandall has waived any argument about Nordell’s complaints with the ACOG.
[¶ 21] We move to consideration of Vandall’s argument about Nordell’s two complaints to the Board, which he alleges were terminated in his favor and were made for revenge and without justification and probable cause.
[¶ 22] Courts that have considered the application of Restatement (Second) of Torts § 680 generally have recognized it does not apply to a complaint made to an administrative agency that has an independent investigative panel charged with investigating and determining whether the complaint warrants further action, because the agency, not the complainant, issues legal process and initiates, continues, or procures the administrative proceeding. See Hogen v. Valley Hosp., 147 Cal.App.3d 119, 195 Cal.Rptr. 5, 7-8 (1983); Stanwyck v. Home, 146 Cal.App.3d 450, 194 Cal. Rptr. 228, 233-34 (1983); Lindenman v. Umscheid, 255 Kan. 610, 875 P.2d 964, 979 (1994); Davis v. Board of Educ., 963 S.W.2d 679, 685-87 (Mo.Ct.App.1998).
[¶ 23] In Davis, 963 S.W.2d at 686, the Missouri Court of Appeals explained the principle of initiating, continuing, or procuring an administrative proceeding:
What constitutes initiation, institution or instigation of charges in an agency setting depends on how charges are brought to the agency for adjudication. In those cases where the agency provides a means for persons to file complaints which automatically trigger agency action on those complaints, the person is held to have instigated the action.
Thus, where the defendants on their own initiative submitted affidavits to licensing officials with the intent to secure the revocation or non-renewal of plaintiffs private detective’s license and the licensing authorities refused to renewthe license on the basis of the affidavits, the court held that instigation was sufficient. Mel vin[ v. Pence], 130 F.2d [423] at 427 [(1942)].
Where a defendant filed written verified charges of misconduct with a Real Estate Licensing Board which required the Board to hold a hearing, the defendant “instituted” the administrative action. Carver[ v. Lykes], [262 N.C. 345,-]137 S.E.2d [139] at 145^6 [(1964)]. The defendant’s motive is not relevant. Id. at 146. Likewise, where a document is filed with an agency which document initiates a contested proceeding, a defendant has instigated an action. Hillside Associates[ v. Stravato], 642 A.2d [664] at 670 [(1994)] (filing an appeal of plaintiffs building permit with a zoning board). In Kauffman[ v. A.H. Robins, Co], 448 S.W.2d [400] at 403-04 [(1969)], the Tennessee Supreme Court held that the defendant drug company had instituted an agency Board of Pharmacy proceeding where it filed a complaint in which it stated that it stood ready to attempt to prove that plaintiff violated certain pharmacy laws. As a result of the complaint, plaintiff was cited to appear before the State Board of Pharmacy for a hearing. Id. at 401.
On the other hand, when an agency official has sole authority to initiate the action, persons who have provided information to that official are not held to have initiated or taken an “active part” in initiating the action. The general rule is that an individual who merely provides facts concerning the conduct of another to an officer possessing the authority to issue charges is not liable for malicious prosecution. See e.g., Linden-man, 875 P.2d at 979. In Lindenman the Kansas Supreme Court held that a county board of health employee who inspected a day care center and filed a report with the board did not initiate the board’s ex parte suspension of the day care center’s license and cannot be considered an “active part” of the board’s subsequent revocation action against the day care center. Id. The board filed the revocation action when the day care center refused to stipulate to the accuracy of the inspection report, a condition for lifting the suspension. Id. at 969. Likewise, in Werner v. Hearst Publications, Inc., 65 Cal.App.2d 667, 151 P.2d 308, 312 (1944), individuals who sent a letter to an investigator for a state bar association complaining about an attorney did not institute the show cause proceeding against the attorney, where the local bar association committee made an independent investigation and one of its members signed the complaint initiating the proceeding. This holding was reaffirmed in Stanwyck v. Horne, 146 Cal. App.3d 450, 194 Cal.Rptr. 228, 234 (1983).
[¶ 24] In
Stanwyck,
194 CaLRptr. at 233-34, the California Court of Appeals discussed the initiation of proceedings in the context of a complaint to the state bar association about a lawyer’s conduct. The court concluded the state bar association’s rules required it to conduct an independent investigation and determine whether to proceed on the complaint, and the state bar association, not the complainant, therefore initiated, continued, or procured disciplinary proceedings against the attorney.
Id.
at 234. The court recognized a strong public policy dictated allowing a person to make a complaint to the state bar association without fear of a subsequent action for malicious prosecution.
Id.
at 234-36. In
Hogen,
195 Cal.Rptr. at 8, the California Court of Appeals extended the rationale of
Stanwyck
to complaints to the Board of Medical Quality Assurance, noting the mechanism for handling those complaints
[¶ 25] Under
[¶ 26] Although Vandall claims the corollary of the “good faith” language in those provisions is that the Legislature presumed the lack of good faith would establish the basis for an action, he has not marshaled an argument to support that claim. See Trade ‘N Post, L.L.C. v. World Duty Free Americas, Inc., 2001 ND 116, ¶ 2, 628 N.W.2d 707 (holding no implied private right of action for damages under Unfair Discrimination Law or Unfair Trade Practices Law). The good faith exception to civil liability recognizes the public policy of encouraging persons to come forward with complaints about medical professionals without fear of defending a malicious prosecution action. The good faith exception does not necessarily establish an independent action for bad faith, and that language is not germane to whether Nordell initiated, continued, or procured an administrative proceeding within the meaning of Restatement (Second) of Torts § 680.
[¶27] Under the statutory scheme in
V
[¶ 28] Vandall argues his complaint states a cause of action against Trinity and Nordell for intentional infliction of emotional distress.
[¶ 29] In
Muchow v. Lindblad,
435 N.W.2d 918, 923-25 (N.D.1989), we said a claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress under Restatement (Second) of Torts § 46 (1965) consists of extreme and outrageous conduct that is intentional or reckless and causes severe emotional distress. In discussing the degree of extreme and outrageous conduct necessary for intentional infliction of emo
[¶ 30] We conclude Vandall’s claims against Trinity do not allege conduct that is so outrageous in character and so extreme in degree as to go beyond all possible bounds of decency and to be regarded as atrocious and utterly intolerable in a civilized community. To the extent Van-dall raises a similar claim against Nordell, we also conclude those claims do not rise to the level of extreme and outrageous conduct. We therefore conclude Vandall’s complaint fails to state a claim for intentional infliction of emotional distress against Nordell and Trinity.
VI
[¶ 31] Vandall argues the trial court erred in awarding Trinity attorneys’ fees. He argues he did not sue Trinity under
[¶ 32] Attorney fees are not allowed to a successful litigant unless expressly authorized by statute.
In re Estate of Lutz,
2000 ND 226, ¶ 33, 620 N.W.2d 589.
[¶ 33] In awarding Trinity attorneys’ fees, the court recognized its “authority for the awarding an unspecified amount of reasonable attorney fees in
VII
[¶ 34] We affirm the judgment dismissing Vandall’s complaint and reverse the award of attorneys’ fees.
[¶ 35] DALE V. SANDSTROM, WILLIAM A. NEUMANN, MARY MUEHLEN MARING, and WILLIAM F. HODNY, S.J., concur. [¶ 36] The Honorable WILLIAM F. HODNY, Surrogate Judge, sitting in place of EAPSNER, J., disqualified.