United States v. ShrakeUnited States v. Shrake
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Easterbrook
A jury convicted Jason Shrake of possessing images of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct and of transmitting them in interstate commerce.
The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act, Pub.L. 109-248, 120 Stat. 587 (July 27, 2006), added
(m) Prohibition on reproduction of child pornography.
(1) In any criminal proceeding, any property or material that constitutes child pornography (as defined by section 2256 of this title) shall remain in the care, custody, and control of either the Government or the court.
(2) (A) NotwithstandingRule 16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure , acourt shall deny, in any criminal proceeding, any request by the defendant to copy, photograph, duplicate, or otherwise reproduce any property or material that constitutes child pornography (as defined by section 2256 of this title), so long as the Government makes the property or material reasonably available to the defendant.
(B) For the purposes of subparagraph (A), property or material shall be deemed to be reasonably available to the defendant if the Government provides ample opportunity for inspection, viewing, and examination at a Government facility of the property or material by the defendant, his or her attorney, and any individual the defendant may seek to qualify to furnish expert testimony at trial.
The computer on which Shrake kept pictures and video files was seized by federal agents.
Shrake’s challenges to
Consider the argument that
Shrake’s other constitutional objections to the Adam Walsh Act fail for the same reason: confrontation and cross-examination rights do not concern pretrial discovery; allowing a prosecutor to determine (subject to judicial review) which materials are outside the scope of pretrial discovery is no more problematic for
Only one aspect of the statute’s implementation gives us pause. Although the district court denied Shrake’s motion for an exact copy of the hard disk for his expert’s use, the prosecution provided such a copy to its own expert. When Shrake learned about this differential access, he asked the district court to foreclose testimony by the prosecution’s expert; the judge denied this motion. In this court the United States defends this decision by arguing, first, that an expert for the prosecution is part of “the Government” as
We very much doubt that, if the expert hired by the United States had an auto accident while driving with the duplicate hard disk, the United States would accept liability under the Federal Tort Claims Act. The expert was a private consultant; there is a substantial difference between “the Government” and people who provide services to the United States under contract. The United States itself recently drew this distinction in
Daniels v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co.,
484 F.3d 884 (7th Cir.2007), when arguing that a consultant during a federal investigation is
not
a federal employee or otherwise part of “the Government.” The prosecutor has not tried to reconcile the position taken here with the one taken in
Daniels.
Wardius v. Oregon,
412 U.S. 470, 93 S.Ct. 2208, 37 L.Ed.2d 82 (1973), holds that rules about pretrial discovery in criminal prosecutions must apply to prosecutors as well as to defendants. Access provided to private experts retained by the prosecution must be provided to private experts retained by the defense. The district court did not abuse its discretion, however, in denying Shrake’s pretrial motion to prevent the prosecution’s expert from testifying. The appropriate relief — which defense counsel never sought — would have been access on equal terms. Doubtless the court also had discretion to prevent the prosecution’s expert from testifying — or at least to prevent her from testifying to matters that she investigated using forensic tools that were not available to the defense expert, who had to examine the disk in the prosecutor’s office. Violations of discovery rules (or for that matter the Rules of Evidence) regularly are enforced by excluding evidence; the prosecutor’s view that exclusion is never permissible would prevent district judges from ensuring compliance with
On to the sentence, which at 330 months is exceedingly long. Shrake did not molest any of the children in the video files or produce them himself. And he does not have a criminal record. Yet the sentence is within a properly constructed range under the Sentencing Guidelines. The district judge calculated Shrake’s offense level at 40, which for a first offender supplies a range of 292 to 365 months; the judge sentenced Shrake in the middle of that range, and on appeal such a sentence enjoys a presumption of reasonableness. See Rita v. United States, — U.S. —, 127 S.Ct. 2456, 168 L.Ed.2d 203 (2007); United States v. Mykytiuk, 415 F.3d 606, 608 (7th Cir.2005). After Gall v. United States, — U.S. -, 128 S.Ct. 586, 169 L.Ed.2d 445 (2007), stressed the extent of a district judge’s discretion in sentencing, and the limits of appellate review, it is difficult to see how a mid-Guideline sentence could be upset unless the judge refuses to entertain the defendant’s arguments or resorts to an irrational extra-statutory consideration.
What Shrake principally argues is that other people convicted of violating § 2252(a) have received lower sentences, engaged in conduct worse than his, or both, so that
The base offense level for distributing child pornography is 22. U.S.S.G. § 2G2.2(a)(2). The district court added two levels because the material depicted a prepubescent minor, § 2G2.2(b)(2), five because Shrake distributed the material in exchange for other images, § 2G2.2(b)(3)(B), four because the material contains depictions of sadistic or masochistic conduct, § 2G2.2(b)(4), two because Shrake used a computer, § 2G2.2(b)(6), and five because his relevant conduct included 600 or more images, § 2G2.2(b)(7)(D). Every -video counts as 75 images, see § 2G2.2 Application Note
The sentences to which Shrake points as comparisons are not wholly comparable. Take, for example, United States v. Barevich, 445 F.3d 956 (7th Cir.2006). Bare-vich was sentenced to 76 months after being convicted of violating the same statute as Shrake. Barevich had more images and more videos — but then five levels is the maximum enhancement for quantity under § 2G2.2(b)(7)(D). Barevich’s final offense level was 27, in part because he did not receive all of the enhancements that applied to Shrake and in part because he pleaded guilty and got a three-level deduction for accepting responsibility. His Guideline range was 87 to 108 months; Shrake does not say that this was unduly low. The district judge gave a sentence below the range, and the prosecutor did not challenge that decision; one judge’s disposition toward lenience is not binding on another judge.
Or take United States v. Griffith, 344 F.3d 714 (7th Cir.2003). Griffith was sentenced before November 1, 2004, when the base offense level for distributing child porn jumped from 17 to 22. He received all of the enhancements that Shrake did, taking him to level 35, which was reduced to 32 because Griffith pleaded guilty. That left Griffith with a range of 168 to 210 months, and the judge went outside it to give him a 262-month sentence. Shrake maintains that Griffith should have received a sentence higher than his own, because Griffith had two prior convictions for sexual crimes, but § 3553(a)(6) does not require district judges to nullify changes in the Guidelines. The disparity between Griffith and Shrake is not “unwarranted” when it rests on (a) an increase in the base offense level after Griffith’s sentence, plus (b) a reduction for acceptance of responsibility that applies to Griffith but not Shrake. Defendants who lacked these benefits have received sentences higher than Shrake’s. See United States v. Ohlinger, 377 F.3d 785 (7th Cir.2004) (360 months, the statutory maximum).
More generally, it is pointless for a defendant whose own sentence is within the Guidelines to raise this ground. As we observed in
United States v. Boscarino,
437 F.3d 634, 638 (7th Cir.2006): “Sentencing disparities are at their ebb when the Guidelines are followed, for the ranges are themselves designed to treat similar offenders similarly. That was the main goal of the Sentencing Reform Act. The more out-of-range sentences that judges impose ..., the more disparity there will be. A sentence within a properly ascertained range therefore cannot be treated as unreasonable by reference to § 3553(a)(6).” See also, e.g.,
United States v. Babul,
476 F.3d 498 (7th Cir.2007);
United States v. Gamar-Gonzalez,
469 F.3d 1109 (7th Cir.2006). Shrake received a very stiff sentence, but it is not “unreasonable” under the Supreme Court’s approach to appellate review after
United States v. Booker,
543
AFFIRMED