United States v. Ricco Devon PrentissUnited States v. Ricco Devon Prentiss
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Tacha
ON REHEARING EN BANC
PER CURIAM.
After a divided panel vacated the defendant’s conviction for committing arson in Indian country, in violation of
A majority of this court agrees with the panel opinion’s conclusion that the Indian
As a result, we REMAND this case to the decisional panel for further proceedings. On remand, the panel will be required to determine whether the failure of the indictment to allege the Indian/non-Indian statuses of the victim and the defendant was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
Judge Baldock (joined by Chief Judge Tacha and Judges Brorby and Kelly) dissents from the majority’s conclusion that the Indian/non-Indian statuses of the victim and the defendant constitute elements of the crime of arson in Indian country. Judge Henry (joined by Judges Seymour, Ebel, and Lucero) dissents from the majority’s conclusion that the indictment’s failure to allege the status of the victim and the defendant is subject to harmless error analysis.
HENRY, joined by SEYMOUR, EBEL, LUCERO, BRISCOE, and MURPHY, Circuit Judges.
I. BACKGROUND
The relevant facts are fully set forth in the panel opinion. See Prentiss, 206 F.3d at 962-63. A federal grand jury returned an indictment charging Mr. Prentiss with committing arson in Indian country in the following terms:
On or about the 22nd and 23rd day of November, 1996, within the confines of the Tesuque Pueblo, in Santa Fe County, in the State and District of New Mexico, the Defendant, RICCO DEVON PRENTISS, did willfully and maliciously set fire and attempt to set fire to a dwelling.
In violation of18 U.S.C. § 1152 and18 U.S.C. § 81 .
Rec. vol. I, doc. 1.
Mr. Prentiss challenged his conviction on appeal by arguing that the indictment was insufficient because it failed to allege two essential elements of the offense: the Indian/non-Indian statuses of the victim and the defendant. A majority of the panel agreed, holding that “the Indian statuses of the defendant and victim are essential elements under
Judge Baldock filed a vigorous dissent. See id. at 977-80 (Baldock, J., dissenting). He assumed, without deciding, that the Indian/non-Indian statuses of the victim and the defendant are elements. Nevertheless, Judge Baldock reasoned, Mr. Prentiss had failed to establish that he was prejudiced by the indictment’s failure to allege them.
The exercise of criminal jurisdiction in Indian country affects three sovereigns: states, Indian tribes, and the federal government.
See Negonsott v. Samuels,
507 U.S. 99, 102, 113 S.Ct. 1119, 122 L.Ed.2d 457 (1993) (noting that “[c]riminal jurisdiction over offenses committed in ‘Indian country’ ‘is governed by a complex patchwork of federal, state, and tribal law’ ”) (citation omitted) (quoting
Duro v. Reina,
495 U.S. 676, 680 n. 1, 110 S.Ct. 2053, 109 L.Ed.2d 693 (1990)). As a result, identifying the statuses of the defendant and the victim is often essential in determining what court may hear the case. Thus, states may exercise jurisdiction when the defendant and the victim are both non-Indians.
See United States v. McBratney,
104 U.S. 621, 623-24, 26 L.Ed. 869 (1881) (concluding that, under the terms of its admission to the union, Colorado acquired criminal jurisdiction over non-Indians in Indian country within its borders). Tribes may exercise jurisdiction over Indians.
See
Because “Congress has . . . constitutional power to prescribe a criminal code applicable in Indian country,” United States v. Antelope, 430 U.S. 641, 648, 97 S.Ct. 1395, 51 L.Ed.2d 701 (1977), federal criminal jurisdiction is somewhat broader. Congress may establish federal crimes that may be prosecuted against citizens throughout the nation, including Indian country. Alternatively, it may create crimes that proscribe only particular conduct occurring within Indian country. See Robert N. Clinton, Criminal Jurisdiction over Indian Lands: A Journey Through a Jurisdictional Maze, 18 Ariz. L.Rev. 503, 520 (1976).
The statutes at issue here belong to the latter type. Section 81 establishes the crime of arson “within the . . . territorial jurisdiction of the United States.”
See
This section shall not extend [1] to offenses committed by one Indian against the person or property of another Indian, nor [2] to any Indian committing any offense in the Indian country who has been punished by the local law of the tribe, or [3] to any case where, by treaty stipulations, the exclusive jurisdiction over such offenses is or may be secured to the Indian tribes respectively- 1
Read in conjunction with the Supreme Court’s decision in
McBratney,
We begin our analysis by considering the victim’s status. Then, we turn to the defendant’s status. Finally, we consider the rules of statutory interpretation applicable to
A. Status of the Victim
Two Supreme Court decisions indicate that the status of the victim is an element. 3 In Lucas v. United States, 163 U.S. 612, 16 S.Ct. 1168, 41 L.Ed. 282 (1896), the government alleged in the indictment that the victim was a non-Indian and offered evidence at trial to support that allegation. The Court held that the trial judge erred by instructing the jury that it could presume that the victim was not an Indian because he was “a man who is a negro by blood.” Id. at 615-16, 16 S.Ct. 1168. It reasoned that “the status of the deceased [was] a question of fact, to be determined by the evidence” and that “[t]he burden of proof was on the government to sustain the jurisdiction of the court by evidence as to the status of the deceased, and the question should have gone to the jury as one of fact, and not of presumption.” Id. at 616-17, 16 S.Ct. 1168. In Smith v. United States, 151 U.S. 50, 14 S.Ct. 234, 38 L.Ed. 67 (1894), the Court characterized the victim’s status as “a fact which the government was bound to establish.... [I]f [the government] failed to introduce any evidence upon that point, [the] defendant was entitled to an instruction [that the court had no jurisdiction].” Id. at 55, 14 S.Ct. 234.
In neither
Lucas
nor
Smith
was there any suggestion that the defendant had the burden of pleading the status of the victim,
Two courts of appeals have reached the same conclusion. In
Hilderbrand v. United States,
261 F.2d 354 (9th Cir.1958), the Ninth Circuit considered a defendant’s motion to vacate a judgment pursuant to
In
United States v. Torres,
733 F.2d 449 (7th Cir.1984), the Seventh Circuit addressed a defendant’s challenge to instructions that failed to inform the jury that, in order to find him guilty of conspiring to commit murder in Indian country in violation of
Hilderbrand
and
Torres
thus impose the burden of alleging the victim’s status on the government — in the indictment and at trial. Just as the older Supreme Court decisions in
Lucas
and
Smith,
neither case suggests that the defendant bears the initial burden of raising this issue. Both cases indicate that the mere allegation that the defendant has committed a crime in Indian country is not sufficient to establish federal jurisdiction under
In addition to these decisions, the policies of protecting state and tribal sovereignty support the view that the status of the victim is an element.
See McBratney,
104 U.S. at 624 (concluding that a state’s admission to the union upon equal footing with the original states provided it with criminal jurisdiction over a crime involving non-Indians);
United States v. Romero,
136 F.3d 1268, 1270 n. 2 (10th Cir.1998) (noting that the
Imposing the burden of alleging the status of the victim on the government rather than the defendant also comports with the usual practice in criminal prosecution. “[I]n ordinary criminal cases[,][the government] customarily is required to carry its burden of showing that specific events happened.”
United States v. Kaluna,
152 F.3d 1069, 1079,
reh’g granted, opinion withdrawn,
161 F.3d 1225 (9th Cir.1998). Moreover, “the government, with its ready access to official files and records, and its superior ability to locate or track down individuals, is in a better position [than the defendant] to obtain the testimony of victims of, or percipient-witnesses to, past offenses.”
Id.; see also United States v. McArthur,
108 F.3d 1350, 1355 (11th Cir.1997) (observing that “courts determining whether a statutory exception is an element of the crime or an affirmative defense often consider whether the government or the defendant is in the best position to prove facts necessary to trigger the exception”). In a crime such as arson, there may be many potential victims: landlords, tenants, and other occupants of the house. The terms of
B. The Status of the Defendant
Allocating the burden of alleging the status of the defendant presents a closer question. In both
Lucas
and
Smith
there was no dispute as to each defendant’Indian status.
See Lucas,
163 U.S. at 612, 16 S.Ct. 1168 (stating that it was proven at trial that the defendant was an Indian);
Smith,
151 U.S. at 51, 14 S.Ct. 234 (stating that the defendant admitted to being an Indian and that the only issue was whether “the undisputed testimony did not also show [the murder victim] to have been an Indian”). As a result, the Supreme Court did not discuss the burden of alleging that issue. Moreover, in contrast to the victim’s status, the government’s superior resources will not necessarily provide it with an unfair advantage in alleging or proving the relevant facts. Finally, one court of appeals has relied on the defendant’s access to information about his or her own status to conclude that “the Government need not allege the non-Indian status of the defendant in an indictment under
Nevertheless, we are not persuaded that the status of the defendant should be treated differently from the status of the victim. Most importantly, the status of the defendant may be just as significant in determining whether a federal court has jurisdiction over the crime of arson in Indian country under §§ 81 and 1152 as the status of the victim. Thus, in a case in which the government contends that the victim is a non-Indian, the status of the defendant will determine whether a federal court or a state court has jurisdiction.
See McBratney,
104 U.S. at 621-24 (holding that, under
C. Statutory Interpretation
In concluding that the status of the victim and the defendant are not elements, Judge Baldock relies exclusively on the plain language of the statute. Because
Judge Baldock’s interpretation is based on the following principle:
[A]n indictment . . . founded on a general provision defining the elements of an offense, or of a right conferred, need notnegative . . . an exception made by a proviso or other distinct clause, whether in the same section or elsewhere, and that it is incumbent on one who relies on such an exception to set it up and establish it.
McKelvey v. United States, 260 U.S. 353, 357, 43 S.Ct. 132, 67 L.Ed. 301 (1922).
In our view, this principle is insufficient to excuse the government from alleging the statuses of the victim and the defendant in the indictment. As the Eleventh Circuit observes, McKelvey’s general provision/proviso dichotomy is only one interpretative aid among several that should be applied in parsing statutes that define offenses. See McArthur, 108 F.3d at 1354 (characterizing McKelvey and another rule of construction as “merely interpretive aids” to be considered along with “other indications of legislative will evident in the statute”); United States v. Bailey, 277 F.2d 560, 562-64 (7th Cir.1960) (stating that the purpose of the statute must be considered in determining whether the government is required to allege that the defendant’s conduct does not fall within an exception). Thus, in United States v. Cook, 84 U.S. (17 Wall.) 168, 21 L.Ed. 538 (1872), the Supreme Court observed that some “exceptions” are so closely intertwined with the definition of the offense that the government must allege them in the indictment:
Where a statute defining an offence contains an exception, in the enacting clause of the statute, which is so incorporated with the language defining the offence that the ingredients of the of-fence cannot be accurately and clearly described if the exception is omitted, the rules of good pleading require that an indictment founded upon the statute must allege enough to show that the accused is not within the exception . . . as it is universally true that no indictment is sufficient if it does not accurately and clearly allege all the ingredients of which the offense is composed.
Id. at 173-74 (emphasis added). That principle may apply even when the exception is set forth in a subsequent clause or section of the statute. Id. at 174-75 (noting that an exception may be “clothed in such language . . . to define the offence [ ] that it would be impossible to frame the actual statutory charge in the form of an indictment with accuracy, and the required certainty, without an allegation showing that the accused was not within the exception contained in the subsequent clause, section, or statute”); see also McArthur, 108 F.3d at 1353 (discussing McKelvey and stating that “[a] second, but related, rule is that where one can omit the exception from the statute without doing violence to the definition of the offense, the exception is more likely an affirmative defense”); Nicoli v. Briggs, 83 F.2d 375, 379 (10th Cir.1936) (stating that Cook holds “that if it is impossible to frame the statutory charge without negativing the exception, then it should be negatived” and that Cook, “read as whole, does not appear to be at variance with the later case of McKelvey ”) (emphasis added); United States v. Kelly, 63 F.Supp. 977, 978 (N.D.Ind.1945) (rejecting “a mechanical test” that relies exclusively on whether an “exception” is set forth in an enacting clause or a proviso).
The interpretive principle set forth in
Cook
applies to
Accordingly, Supreme Court authority, decisions of other circuits, policies underlying
III.
We next consider the issue of whether the indictment’s failure to allege the Indian/non-Indian statuses of Defendant and his victim deprived the district court of subject matter jurisdiction, or instead, is subject to harmless error review. Relying on United States v. Brown, 995 F.2d 1493 (10th Cir.1993), and United States v. Smith, 553 F.2d 1239 (10th Cir.1977), Defendant argues that “the failure of the indictment to allege all the essential elements of the offense . . . is a jurisdictional defect requiring dismissal, despite citation of the underlying statute in the indictment.” Brown, 995 F.2d at 1505. According to Defendant, “the absence of prejudice to the defendant does not cure what is necessarily a substantive, jurisdictional defect in the indictment.” Smith, 553 F.2d at 1242.
Bound by prior precedent, a divided panel of this Court agreed, holding that “the complete omission of an essential element of the crime [from the indictment] . . . is a fundamental jurisdictional defect that is not subject to harmless error analysis.” Prentiss, 206 F.3d at 975. This was so, the panel reasoned, because absent an indictment that alleged each essential element of the crime, the Court could not be certain the grand jury made the probable cause findings necessary to sustain the indictment. Id. at 976; see also United States v. Peterman, 841 F.2d 1474, 1477 (10th Cir.1988).
Upon en banc consideration, we now vacate that portion of our panel opinion which declined to review for harmless error the omission of an essential element from the indictment. Id. at 974-77. Contrary to our prior precedents, we hold that the failure of an indictment to allege an essential element of a crime does not deprive a district court of subject matter jurisdiction; rather, such failure is subject to harmless error review. To the extent that this Court’s prior decisions, including Brown and Smith, hold otherwise, we overrule them.
A.
In
Madsen v. United States,
165 F.2d 507 (10th Cir.1947), we established that under the new form of pleading, an “indictment must allege the essential elements of the offense but mere forms of averment may be disregarded.”
Id.
at 509. Since then, we have repeatedly recognized that to ensure compliance with the Fifth Amendment’s grand jury guarantee,
That a court may not adjudicate a criminal prosecution without subject matter jurisdiction is beyond doubt. Courts’ recurring reference to the elements of a crime as “jurisdictional” to justify dismissal of an indictment which fails to allege an element, however, is misplaced.
E.g., United States v. Tran,
234 F.3d 798, 805-810 (2d Cir.2000);
United States v. Spinner,
180 F.3d 514, 515-17 (3d Cir.1999). An indictment’s failure to allege an element of a crime “is not jurisdictional in the sense that it affects a court’s subject matter jurisdiction,
i.e.,
a court’s constitutional or statutory power to adjudicate a case.... ”
United States v. Martin,
147 F.3d 529, 532 (7th Cir.1998). As Judge Easterbrook aptly explained: “Subject matter jurisdiction in every federal criminal prosecution comes from
Elements of the crime of arson in Indian country under
The indictment in this case sought to charge Defendant with the federal crime of arson in Indian country.
See
B.
Because an indictment’s failure to allege an essential element of a crime is
[Ajfter a verdict . . . every intendment must be indulged in support of the indictment . . . and such a verdict . . . cures mere technical defects unless it is apparent they have resulted in prejudice to the defendant. Prejudice to the defendant is, of course, a controlling consideration in determining whether an indictment . . . is sufficient.
Clay v. United States, 326 F.2d 196, 198 (10th Cir.1963) (emphasis added).
In both Brown, 995 F.2d at 1504, and Smith, 553 F.2d at 1240-42, however, we declined to consider whether defendants suffered any prejudice as a result of the defective indictments. Instead, we effectively, though not expressly, treated an indictment’s failure to allege an essential element of a crime as structural error subject to automatic reversal. Structural error occurs in only a “very limited class of cases,” Johnson v. United States, 520 U.S. 461, 461-468, 117 S.Ct. 1544, 137 L.Ed.2d 718 (1997) (emphasis added), and “necessarily render[s] a trial fundamentally unfair.” Rose v. Clark, 478 U.S. 570, 577, 106 S.Ct. 3101, 92 L.Ed.2d 460 (1986). This is because structural errors “deprive defendants of ‘basic protections’ without which ‘a criminal trial cannot reliably serve its function as a vehicle for determination of guilt or innocence.’ ” Neder v. United States, 527 U.S. 1, 8-9, 119 S.Ct. 1827, 144 L.Ed.2d 35 (1999) (quoting Rose, 478 U.S. at 577-78, 106 S.Ct. 3101).
Nevertheless, most recently in Neder, the Supreme Court recognized that “most” constitutional errors can be harmless: “ ‘If the defendant had counsel and was tried by an impartial adjudicator, there is a strong presumption that any other constitutional errors that may have occurred are subject to harmless-error analysis.’ ” Id. at 8, 119 S.Ct. 1827 (quoting Rose, 478 U.S. at 579, 106 S.Ct. 3101) (emphasis added). Such a presumption is proper because “ ‘[rjeversal of error, regardless of its effect on the judgment, encourages litigants to abuse the judicial process and bestirs the public to ridicule it.’” Johnson, 520 U.S. at 470, 117 S.Ct. 1544 (1997) (quoting R. Traynor, The Riddle of Harmless Error 50 (1970)). Importantly, the harmless error doctrine “ ‘recognizes the principle that the central purpose of a criminal trial is to decide the factual question of the defendant’s guilt or innocence, and promotes public respect for the criminal process by focusing on the underlying fairness of the trial.’ ” Neder, 527 U.S. at 18, 119 S.Ct. 1827 (internal ellipses omitted) (quoting Delaware v. Van Arsdall, 475 U.S. 673, 681, 106 S.Ct. 1431, 89 L.Ed.2d 674 (1986)).
To date, the Supreme Court has classified only two types of grand jury related errors as structural, both involving discrimination in the selection of grand jurors.
Vasquez v. Hillery,
474 U.S. 254, 260-64, 106 S.Ct. 617, 88 L.Ed.2d 598 (1986) (racial discrimination);
Ballard v. United States,
329 U.S. 187, 193, 67 S.Ct. 261, 91 L.Ed. 181 (1946) (sex discrimination). Otherwise, the Court has “see[n] no reason not to apply [harmless error analy
Furthermore, despite the Fifth Amendment’s requirement that the Government prove each and every element of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt, In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358, 364, 90 S.Ct, 1068, 25 L.Ed.2d 368 (1970), and the Sixth Amendment’s requirement that a jury, rather than a judge, reach the requisite finding of guilty, Sullivan v. Louisiana, 508 U.S. 275, 277, 113 S.Ct. 2078, 124 L.Ed.2d 182 (1993), the Court in Neder held that the failure to instruct the jury on every element of an offense “does not necessarily render a criminal trial fundamentally unfair or an unreliable vehicle for determining guilt or innocence.” Neder, 527 U.S. at 9, 119 S.Ct. 1827 (emphasis in original). To us, a defendant’s right to have a petit jury find each element of the charged offense beyond a reasonable doubt is no less important than a defendant’s right to have each element of the same offense presented to the grand jury. If denial of the former right is subject to harmless error analysis, we believe denial of the latter right must be as well. See United States v. Mojica-Baez, 229 F.3d 292 (1st Cir.2000), ce rt. denied, — U.S. —, 121 S.Ct. 2215, 150 L.Ed.2d 209 (2001) (“[W]e see no reason why harmless error review should not apply to the failure to include an element in an indictment that otherwise provided the defendants with fair notice of the charges against them.”). 11
We conclude that the Government’s failure to allege in the indictment the Indian/non-Indian statuses of Defendant and his victim is not “so intrinsically harmful as to require automatic reversal . . . without regard to . . . [its] effect on the outcome” of the case.
Neder,
527 U.S. at 7, 119 S.Ct. 1827. Rather, to determine whether the omission of these elements from the indictment requires reversal, this Court must apply a harmless error analysis first established in
Chapman v. California,
386 U.S. 18, 24, 87 S.Ct. 824, 17 L.Ed.2d 705 (1967), and recently reaffirm
Accordingly, this cause is returned to the original appellate panel for application of harmless error review to the indictment’s failure to allege the Indian/non-Indian statuses of Defendant and his victim, and, if necessary, resolution of the remaining issues Defendant raises on appeal.
SO ORDERED.
BALDOCK, Circuit Judge, joined by TACHA, Chief Judge, and BRORBY, and PAUL KELLY, Jr., Circuit Judges, dissenting as to Part II.
The Court construes the “Indian versus Indian” exception contained in the second paragraph of the Indian Country Crimes Act,
I.
The federal arson statute,
The second and only remaining paragraph of
This section shall not extend [1] to offenses committed by one Indian against the person or property of another Indian, nor [2] to any Indian committing any offense in the Indian country who has been punished by the local law of the tribe, or [3] to any case where, by treaty stipulations, the exclusive jurisdiction over such offenses is or may be secured to the Indian tribes respectively-
Id.
A fourth, judicially-created proviso excepts from
II.
The Court concludes that the first proviso of
To be sure,
To reach a contrary result, the Court relies on two nineteenth century Supreme Court decisions,
Smith v. United States,
151 U.S. 50, 54-55, 14 S.Ct. 234, 38 L.Ed. 67 (1894);
Lucas v. United States,
163 U.S. 612, 616-17, 16 S.Ct. 1168, 41 L.Ed. 282 (1896), which stand for the proposition that the Government has the burden of proving the Indian/non-Indian statuses of a defendant and victim under
The Court’s frail attempt to explain within the confines of a remote footnote why it might construe these latter two provisos differently than the first stands the language and structure of
Since at least 1882, the Supreme Court has recognized that where provisos or exceptions appear in a distinct clause of a criminal statute, the Government need not allege in an indictment that a defendant does not come within the provisos or exceptions to the statute. United States v. Britton, 107 U.S. 655, 670, 2 S.Ct. 512, 27 L.Ed. 520 (1882). In McKelvey v. United States, 260 U.S. 353, 357, 43 S.Ct. 132, 67 L.Ed. 301 (1922), the Court emphasized the point:
By repeated decisions it has come to be a settled rule . . . that an indictment or other pleading founded on a general provision defining the elements of an offense, or of a right conferred, need not negative the matter of an exception made by a proviso or other distinct clause, whether in the same section or elsewhere, and that it is incumbent on one who relies on such an exception to set it up and establish it.
Accord United States v. Santos-Riviera,
183 F.3d 367, 370-71 (5th Cir.1999) (relying on the above rule of criminal statutory construction to hold that neither the citizenship status of the offender nor victim was an essential element of hostage taking under
Furthermore, unlike the Court, I find no basis in
The clear language and structure of
HENRY, joined by SEYMOUR, EBEL, and LUCERO, Circuit Judges, dissenting, as to Part III.
Overruling our prior decisions in
United States v. Brown,
995 F.2d 1493, 1505 (10th Cir.1993) and
United States v. Smith,
553 F.2d 1239, 1242 (10th Cir.1977), the majority concludes that an indictment’s failure to allege the essential elements of an offense — a violation of the Fifth Amendment — may constitute harmless error. Because
Brown
and
Smith
properly apply Supreme Court precedent, I would not overrule them. Instead, I would follow the rule that “the failure of the indictment to allege all the essential elements of an offense . . . is a jurisdictional defect requiring dismissal.”
Brown,
995 F.2d at 1505. As the indictment in this case failed to allege an essential element of a
Brown and Smith are controlled by Stirone v. United States 361 U.S. 212, 216, 80 S.Ct. 270, 4 L.Ed.2d 252 (1960). There, the Supreme Court vacated a conviction based upon an allegation not charged in the indictment. The Court applied the principle that “after an indictment has been returned its charges may not be broadened through amendment except by the grand jury itself.” Id. at 215-16, 80 S.Ct. 270. It reasoned as follows:
If it lies within the province of a court to change the charging part of an indictment to suit its own notions of what it ought to have been, or what the grand jury would probably have made it if their attention had been called to suggested changes, the great importance which the common law attaches to an indictment by a grand jury, as a prerequisite to a prisoner’s trial for a crime, and without which the constitution says ‘no person shall be held to answer,’ may be frittered away until its value is almost destroyed.
[A]fter the indictment [is] changed it [i]s no longer the indictment of the grand jury who presented it. Any other doctrine would place the rights of the citizen, which were intended to be protected by the constitutional provision, at the mercy or control of the court or prosecuting attorney.”
Unlike the majority of this court, the Stirone Court did not authorize a reviewing court to examine the evidence presented at trial to determine whether the indictment’s omission of an essential element constituted harmless error. In my view Stirone establishes that, absent an indictment that sets forth each element, a reviewing court cannot be assured that the grand jury made the finding required by the Fifth Amendment: that there is probable cause that the defendant committed the charged offense. 17
Notably, when a defendant does not challenge its sufficiency in the district court proceedings, an indictment must be reviewed under a more deferential standard.
See Brown,
995 F.2d at 1505. However, even under that standard, the indictment must still contain “words of similar import” to the element in question.
Id.
(quoting
United States v. Vogt,
910 F.2d 1184, 1201 (4th Cir.1990)). Am indietment’s mere citation of a statute is not an adequate substitute for “words of similar import to the element in question.”
Brown,
995 F.2d at 1505 (internal quotation marks omitted);
see also United States v. Cabrera-Teran,
168 F.3d 141, 146 (5th Cir.1999) (“[A] statutory citation, standing alone, cannot substitute for including an element of the crime in an indictment.”);
United States v. Forbes,
16 F.3d 1294, 1297 (1st Cir.1994) (stating that “[a] statutory citation, standing alone, cannot substitute for setting forth the elements of a crime” but that “it may reinforce other references in the indictment so as to render it valid”);
United States v. Hernandez,
980 F.2d 868, 871 (2d Cir.1992) (per curiam) (“We are aware that a citation to a statutory section alone is not sufficient to cure a defective indictment that fails to allege all the elements of an offense....”);
United States v. Zangger,
848 F.2d 923, 925 (8th Cir.1988) (“If an essential element of the charge has been omitted from the indictment, the omission is not cured by the bare citation of the charging statute.”)
United States v. Pupo,
841 F.2d 1235, 1239 (4th Cir.1988); (“An indictment that must rely on a statutory
In the instant case, in concluding that the indictment’s failure to allege an essential element of an
In Neder, the Court distinguished cases that “defy harmless-error review” because they contain “a ‘defect affecting the framework within which the trial proceeds’” from cases that involve “ ‘simply an error in the trial process itself.’ ” Id. at 8, 119 S.Ct. 1827 (quoting Arizona v. Fulminante, 499 U.S. 279, 310, 111 S.Ct. 1246, 113 L.Ed.2d 302 (1991)). It placed the failure to submit an element of an offense to the petit jury in the latter category, concluding that such failure could be reviewed for harmless error.
In support of this harmless error approach, the Court invoked decisions concerning errors in jury instructions and noted that these decisions reviewed the evidence presented at trial in order to assess the prejudicial effect of the instructional error. See id. at 9, 119 S.Ct. 1827 (stating that “[w]e have often applied harmless-error analysis to cases involving improper instructions” and citing case). The Court justified this approach, in part, by noting the procedural protections afforded to the defendant at trial. See id. (“[The defendant] was tried before an impartial judge, under the correct standard of proof and with the assistance of counsel; a fairly selected, impartial jury was instructed to consider all of the evidence and argument in respect to [his] defense against the tax charges.”).
In contrast to the error in
Neder,
the error at issue in this case — an indictment’s failure to allege an essential element of an offense — is better characterized as “a defect affecting the framework within which the trial proceeds”; it is not “simply an error in the trial process itself.” As a result, there is not an established body of case law that has undertaken the kind of harmless error review that the majority
In my view, the majority reads too much into the Supreme Court’s statement that structural errors occur in only a “very limited class of cases,” Johnson v. United States, 520 U.S. 461, 468, 117 S.Ct. 1544, 137 L.Ed.2d 718 (1997), and the fact that the Court has used the term “structural error” to describe only two types of grand jury errors. See Maj. op. at 983 (citing Vasquez v. Hillery, 474 U.S. 254, 264, 106 S.Ct. 617, 88 L.Ed.2d 598 (1986) and Ballard v. United States, 329 U.S. 187, 193, 67 S.Ct. 261, 91 L.Ed. 181 (1946)). The universe of errors is not completely described by the terms “structural” and “non-structural.” See Freytag v. Commissioner, 501 U.S. 868, 896, 111 S.Ct. 2631, 115 L.Ed.2d 764 (1991) (Scalia, J., concurring in part and concurring in the judgment) (stating that a judgment must be set aside when an error “whether structural or not . . . deprived the federal court of its requisite subject-matter jurisdiction”). Thus, without using the term “structural error,” courts have held that an indictment’s failure to allege the essential elements of an offense “cannot be cured by absence of prejudice to the defendant,” Tran, 234 F.3d at 809; is “not amenable to harmless error review,” Spruill, 118 F.3d at 227; and is “reversible error per se,” Keller, 916 F.2d at 636.
This circuit’s decisions prohibiting the constructive amendment of indictments provide additional support for this view. For example, in United States v. Phillips, 869 F.2d 1361, 1364 (10th Cir.1988), we noted that “[e]ver since Ex Parte Bain, 121 U.S. 1, 7 S.Ct. 781, 30 L.Ed. 849 (1887) was decided . . . it has been the rule that after an indictment has been returned its charges may not be broadened through amendment except by the grand jury itself’ (internal quotation marks omitted). We also stated that “[a]ny such amendment effected by the court’s instructions would constitute plain error and be reversible per se.” Id. (emphasis added). See also United States v. Davis, 55 F.3d 517, 521 (10th Cir.1995) (“A variance that expands the indictment is considered a constructive amendment and is per se reversible error.”) (emphasis added); United States v. Mills, 29 F.3d 545, 548 (10th Cir.1994) (“A constructive amendment that broadens an indictment is reversible error per se, because only the grand jury can amend an indictment.”) (emphasis added). By directing the panel to review the record to determine whether there is evidence to support elements missing from the indictment, the majority authorizes on appeal what these cases forbid at trial: the broadening of the indictment by an entity other than the grand jury.
Moreover, two other circuits have refused to follow the majority’s sweeping interpretation of
Heder. See United States v. Tran,
234 F.3d 798, 809 n. 2 (2d Cir.2000) (stating that the panel opinion in
Prentiss
“convincingly reasoned that
Ned-er
was inapplicable to the failure of an indictment to state an offense” and “add[ing] that
Neder
concerned a constitutional error in the trial process, not an error that deprived the court of subject matter jurisdiction, which is never subject to harmless error review”);
United States v. Du Bo,
186 F.3d 1177, 1180 (9th Cir.1999) (“Until the Court applies
Neder’s
In my view,
Mechanik
is similarly inapplicable. In that case, the Supreme Court examined the government’s violation of
In summary, neither
Neder,
nor
Me-chanik,
nor the weight of the evidence at trial deprives a defendant of the Fifth Amendment right to have a grand jury frame a charge by finding probable cause as to each essential element of the offense. Here, as the panel opinion held, the indictment against Mr. Prentiss contains no allegations of the status of either the victim or the defendant, facts that a majority of this court has found to constitute essential elements of the crime of arson within Indian country under
Notes
. Section 1152 is referred to as the Indian Country Crimes Act, the General Crimes Act, see Felix S. Cohen’s Handbook of Federal Indian Law at 287 n. 50 (Rennard Strickland et al. ed.,1982) [hereinafter Cohen], and the Federal Enclave Act. See United States v. Brisk, 171 F.3d 514, 519 (7th Cir.1999). Its history is set forth in United States v. Cowboy, 694 F.2d 1228, 1232-33 (10th Cir.1982); see also Cohen, supra, at 287-300.
. An affirmative defense may impose various burdens on the defendant: (1) the burden of pleading (“the burden of introducing [a] defense for consideration”), Paul H. Robinson, 1 Criminal Law Defenses § 3(a), at 12 (1984); (2) the burden of production (the burden of “adducing] sufficient evidence to . . . support . . . the presence of [a] defense”), id. § 3(b), at 15; or (3) the burden of persuasion (the burden of “convincing] the tribunal of the existence of the facts” supporting the defense). Id. § 5(a), at 41.
. Both cases were decided under a prior version of § 1152. At that time, the provision excluding Indian Indian crimes, crimes punished by tribal law, and crimes assigned to the tribe by treaty was set forth in a separate section. See Cowboy, 694 F.2d at 1233 (discussing R.S. §§ 2145 and 2146, enacted in 1873 and amended in 1875). The language setting forth these jurisdiction limitations is nearly identical to the language used in the current version of § 1152.
. The Ninth Circuit added, however, that “[o]nce the defendant properly raises the issue of his Indian status, then the ultimate burden of proof remains, of course, upon the Government.” Hester, 719 F.2d at 1043.
. As noted in the panel opinion, the Indian Major Crimes Act,
. The indictment in Hester contained a crucial allegation that the indictment in this case omits: “that the victim was an Indian.” Hester, 719 F.2d at 1042. Moreover, Hester does not discuss the Ninth Circuit’s earlier decision in Hilderbrand. Thus, even after Hester, it appears that an indictment that “did not allege that appellant or the victim of the accused was an Indian .... fail[s] to state that any basis for federal jurisdiction exist[s].” Hilderbrand, 261 F.2d at 357 (emphasis added).
. Interestingly, the prosecutor in this case was also unable to describe the basis for federal jurisdiction without referring to Indian and non-Indian status. When asked before opening statements why the case was not prosecuted in tribal court, she responded, “Mr. Prentiss is not an Indian, nor does the state have jurisdiction because the harmed party is Domingo Vigil, a member of the pueblo who owns the house, so the federal government has the duty to prosecute the case.” Rec. vol. Ill, at 123. Thus, the government did not adopt Judge Baldock’s view that the federal court had jurisdiction merely because the crime occurred in Indian country.
. The government also argues that, in characterizing the statuses of the victim and the defendant, we should consider the other limitations on federal jurisdiction set forth in the second paragraph of § 1152 — that federal jurisdiction does not extend to “any Indian committing any offense in the Indian country who has been punished by the local law of the tribe” or “to any case where, by treaty stipulations, the exclusive jurisdiction over such offenses is or may be secured to the Indian tribes respectively.”
We are not persuaded by this argument. Although this case does not require us to construe these other jurisdictional limitations, we note that in determining whether a provision of a statute constitutes an element or an affirmative defense, courts have considered a variety of factors, including: (1) the breadth or narrowness of the provision; (2) whether “one can omit the exception from the statute without doing violence to the definition of the offense”; (3) the legislative history; and (4) “whether the defendant or the government is better situated to adduce evidence tending to prove or disprove the applicability of the exception.” McArthur, 108 F.3d at 1353.
Consideration of these factors may lead to different conclusions regarding each of the limitations set forth in the second paragraph of
Additionally, the history of
. Section 3231 provides in relevant part: “The district courts of the United States shall have original jurisdiction, exclusive of the courts of the States, of all offenses against the laws of the United States.”
. Mechanik explained Vasquez and Ballard on the basis that “discrimination in the selection of grand jurors is so pernicious, and other remedies so impractical, that the remedy of automatic reversal was necessary as a prophylactic means of deterring grand jury discrimination in the future....” 475 U.S. at 71 n. 1, 106 S.Ct. 938.
. Unlike the dissent, we do not believe
Stirone v. United States,
361 U.S. 212, 80 S.Ct. 270, 4 L.Ed.2d 252 (1960), dictates a contrary result in this instance. In
Stirone,
the indictment adequately charged Defendant with extortion through transporting sand in interstate commerce in violation of the Hobbs Act.
See also Apprendi v. Mew Jersey,
530 U.S. 466, 120 S.Ct. 2348, 147 L.Ed.2d 435 (2000). Based upon the evidence and improper jury instructions at trial, however, the jury may have convicted defendant of a different Hobbs Act violation, i.e., extortion through transporting steel in interstate commerce. The court held that defendant could not “be tried on charges that are not made in the indictment.”
Stirone,
361 U.S. at 217, 80 S.Ct. 270. In contrast, the indictment in this case, although it failed to expressly set forth all the elements of the crime, sought to charge Defendant with the sole crime for which the jury convicted him, i.e., setting fire to a dwelling within the confines of the Tesuque pueblo in violation of
. Because
.
. Federal crimes “are solely creatures of statute.” Staples v. United States, 511 U.S. 600, 604, 114 S.Ct. 1793, 128 L.Ed.2d 608 (1994). Subject to constitutional limitations not implicated here, Congress, not a federal appellate court, is authorized to define the elements of a federal criminal offense. Whalen v. United States, 445 U.S. 684, 689 & n. 3, 100 S.Ct. 1432, 63 L.Ed.2d 715 (1980). “[W]ithin our federal constitutional framework the legislative power . . . to define criminal offenses . . . resides wholly with the Congress.” Id. As part of its responsibility to define the elements of federal crimes, Congress has sole authority to define the limits of the lower federal courts’ criminal jurisdiction over those crimes.
The judicial power of the United States is . . . dependent for its distribution and organization, and for the modes of its exercise, entirely upon the action of Congress, who possess the sole power of investing [inferior federal courts] with jurisdiction either limited, concurrent, or exclusive, and of withholding from them in the exact degree and character which to Congress may seem proper for the public good.
Palmore v. United States, 411 U.S. 389, 401, 93 S.Ct. 1670, 36 L.Ed.2d 342 (1973).
. In
Hester,
defendant was charged with sexually-related crimes against Indian children on the Navajo Reservation. On appeal, defendant challenged the indictment’s failure to allege an essential jurisdictional element of the crime under
We accordingly hold that the Government need not allege the non-Indian status of the defendant in an indictment under§ 1152 , nor does it have the burden of going forward on that issue. Once the defendant properly raises the issue of his Indian status, then the ultimate burden of proof remains, of course, upon the Government.
Hester, 719 F.2d at 1043.
. See also United States v. Torres, 733 F.2d 449 (7th Cir.1984). The sufficiency of the indictment was not at issue in Torres. Rather, the court held the district court erred when it failed to instruct the jury the Government had the burden of proving as a “jurisdictional requisite” that the crime occurred between an Indian and non-Indian in Indian country. Torres, 733 F.2d at 454, 457-58. The court ultimately concluded that the error was harmless.
. Stirone‘s reasoning has been applied by many circuits. See, e.g., United States v. Tran, 234 F.3d 798, 809 (2d Cir.2000) (citing Stirone and concluding that, because an indictment‘s failure to allege an essential element is a jurisdictional defect, “it cannot be cured by the absence of prejudice to the defendant”); Jones v. Smith, 231 F.3d 1227, 1232 (9th Cir.2000) (“As the Supreme Court indicated in Stirone . . ., where a defendant is convicted of a crime and where a grand jury never charges the defendant with an essential element of that crime, a constructive amendment of the indictment has occurred, and reversal is warranted.”); United States v. Spruill, 118 F.3d 221, 227 (4th Cir.1997) (“It is well established . . . that failure to recite an essential element of the offense in the indictment is not amenable to harmless error review.”); United States v. Nunez, 180 F.3d 227, 230 (5th Cir.1999) (stating that “[w]e have consistently followed Stirone and have reversed convictions where the jury might have convicted [a] defendant on new elements to the offense not charged by the grand jury”) (internal quotation marks omitted). United States v. Keller, 916 F.2d 628, 634, 636 (11th Cir.1990) (noting that “an amendment [to the indictment] occurs when the essential elements of the offense contained in the indictment are altered to broaden the possible bases for conviction beyond what is contained in the indictment” and that this constitutes “reversible error per se”). But see United States v. Mojica-Baez, 229 F.3d 292, 309-11 (1st Cir.2000) (disagreeing with the panel opinion in Prentiss and concluding that an indictment‘s failure to allege an essential element was subject to plain error review), cert. denied, — U.S. —, 121 S.Ct. 2215, 150 L.Ed.2d 209 (2001).
. In James, the Ninth Circuit acknowledged that “[t]he indictment should have contained allegations that [the defendant] was an Indian and that the victim was an Indian.” 980 F.2d at 1317. However, applying the liberal standard for assessing post-verdict challenges to indictments, it concluded that the error was harmless. In reaching that conclusion, the court stated that “the defendant must have been given adequate knowledge of the missing elements in order to satisfy the due process requirement: otherwise, reference to a statute in an indictment will not cure the defect in an indictment.” Id. It noted that the government had satisfied this requirement by providing the defendant with a copy of the grand jury proceedings, which included testimony that both the defendant and the victim were Indians.
James’s conclusion that the provision of a grand jury transcript may substitute for allegations in an indictment is inconsistent with our holding in Brown, and I would decline to follow it. I also note that there is no indication in the record before us that the government provided Mr. Prentiss with “adequate knowledge of the missing elements,” as it did in James. Id.
. The Second Circuit has criticized the reasoning of Mojica-Baez. See Tran, 234 F.3d at 809 n. 2 (“To the extent that Mojica-Baez can be read to conclude that this type of error [i.e., the failure of an indictment to state an essential element of the offense] is not jurisdictional, we reject that conclusion here.”). Its holding has also been questioned by a district court within the First Circuit. See United States v. Wilkes, 130 F.Supp.2d 222, 237-38 (D.Mass.2001) (applying Mojica-Baez as circuit precedent but stating that “in effect, the First Circuit did precisely what Stirone proscribed when it speculated [as to what the grand jury would have done]” and stating that, “[u]nder Mojica-Baez, . . ., the prosecutor can do an end-run around the grand jury and cure crucial omissions just by notifying the defendant”).
I also note that, in finding the deficiency in the indictment to be harmless, the First Circuit relied on the fact that the indictment was proper at the time it was returned and became deficient only because Supreme Court and circuit precedent subsequently changed. See Mojica-Baez, 229 F.3d at 310 (“It is one thing to vacate a conviction or sentence where the prosecutor failed to indict in accordance with the current state of the law. It is quite another thing to vacate a conviction or sentence based on an indictment that was entirely proper at the time.”). The circumstances are different here.
. I also agree with Judge Richard Arnold‘s recent assessment of Neder:
The Supreme Court [in Neder\ has held that it is not always reversible error to fail to submit to a jury an essential element of a criminal charge. If, for example, no reasonable jury could have found against the prosecution with respect to this element, the error can be treated as harmless. The same thing, however, cannot be said of the other part of the . . . principle . . . that every element of a crime must be charged in an indictment (if the crime is federal). As far as I am aware, no case has ever held that the omission of an element of a crime from an indictment can be harmless error. In such cases, we do not ask whether a jury would have found that element on the evidence submitted to it, or, indeed, whether the grand jury would have returned an indictment including that element if it had been asked to do so. Rather, an indictment that omits an element of a crime is structurally deficient and provides no lawful basis for bringing anyone to trial. Failure to include an essential element in a federal indictment warrants relief even if the government later proves the omitted element at trial.
United States v. Moss, 252 F.3d 993, 1004 (8th Cir.2001) (Arnold, J. dissenting) (emphasis added).
. The Supreme Court’s decision in Apprendi v. New Jersey, 530 U.S. 466, 120 S.Ct. 2348, 147 L.Ed.2d 435 (2000), underscores the importance of the indictment’s factual allegations. The Court there held that “any fact that increases the penalty for a crime beyond the prescribed statutory maximum must be submitted to a jury, and proved beyond a reasonable doubt.” 120 S.Ct. at 2362-63. The Court suggested that the relevant facts must also be included in the indictment. Applying Apprendi, we held in United States v. Jones, 235 F.3d 1231, 1236 (10th Cir.2000), that an allegation that increases the penalty for an offense over the statutory maximum must be alleged in the indictment. In concluding that the evidence at trial may correct deficiencies in the indictment, the majority is at odds with these decisions too.
. I acknowledge that, under the liberal standard for assessing post-verdict challenges, the same conclusion would not necessarily follow if the indictment had alleged the status of either the defendant or the victim. For example, if the indictment cited