United States v. KroutUnited States v. Krout
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Jolly
Doug Krout was convicted,
in absentia,
on a charge of possession of more than fifty kilograms of marijuana with intent to distribute, in violation of
I
While driving through a border patrol checkpoint on April 21, 1992, Krout aroused the suspicions of border patrol agents and then fled. A high-speed chase ensued that ended with Krout wrecking his car. After a short chase on foot, Krout was arrested. During a search of his car, the border patrol found about eighty-three kilograms of marijuana in the trunk.
The next month, a grand jury returned a one-count indictment charging Krout with possession of more than fifty kilograms of marijuana with intent to distribute, in violation of
Over a year later, on August 21, 1993, Krout resurfaced when he was arrested in Houston on an unrelated criminal matter. He was sentenced, and the judgment against him was entered, on March 29, 1994.
We now consider whether the district court either erred in proceeding to try him in his absence, 2 or in refusing to grant a mistrial in connection with the dismissal of a juror. We will discuss each of these matters in turn.
A
Codifying existing caselaw,
As an initial matter, we must consider an issue of first impression in this circuit: when, for purposes of
Relying upon double jeopardy cases and contending that “[tjhere is no rational distinction between double jeopardy and the right to be present at trial in deciding when the trial begins,” Krout asserts, however, that the trial did not commence until the jury was sworn.
We disagree with Krout’s view of when trial begins under
We find the reasoning of our sibling circuits to be persuasive on this issue and hold that, for the purposes of
B
With the “commencement of trial” issue resolved, we must now address Krout’s argument that the district court erred when it resumed trial without him because he did not knowingly and voluntarily waive his right to be present. He argues that because there is no evidence that he knew that the trial could proceed without him, or that he had the right to be present throughout his trial, or that this right could be waived, the trial court erred when it carried on proceedings without him. We think that although the district court properly engaged in the balancing test of determining whether to proceed in the absence of the defendant,
5
that question is irrelevant now because under the circumstances before us it is clear that pursuant to the very language of
C
Finally, Krout contends that the district court erred when it refused to grant his motion for a mistrial because of the dismissal of a juror by a magistrate judge, and his replacement with a duly empaneled alternate juror by the district judge, when trial resumed.
Concededly, this case presents somewhat unusual circumstances. Sometime between jury selection and resuming the trial, a magistrate judge excused a juror without notifying the parties. In denying Krout’s motion for a mistrial, the district court stated “I wish we had been consulted before [the juror] had been released, but I don’t believe that — since we have three alternates, I don’t believe that’s grounds for a mistrial.” Krout contends that he had no opportunity to challenge the magistrate judge’s decision and that he believed that the juror was favorable to his cause.
Krout does not explain precisely in what respect the district court’s decision constitutes an abuse of discretion that would require a reversal of his conviction. Instead, he simply restates the facts, and quotes the district court’s ruling. He also implies that, because the juror was excused by a magistrate judge that was acting without authority, the district court abused its discretion in denying his motion for a mistrial. Then, Krout says, in addition to abusing its discretion, the district court violated
We find that Krout has failed to show bias or prejudice in the court’s decision, or that the decision prejudiced his case. “Every [juror] replacement involves a change in the jury’s composition. How much weight should be given this factor is a matter for the sound discretion of the trial judge.” Rodriguez, 573 F.2d at 333. Krout does not assert any grounds for impugning the motives of the court, nor does he contend that the resulting jury was deficient. Instead, he simply states a “belief’ that the excused juror was favorable to his case. Moreover, Krout had the opportunity to challenge the qualifications of alternate jurors when they were selected. Thus, he has failed to show bias or prejudice, and, accordingly, the district court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to grant a mistrial.
II
To sum up, we find that, for the purposes of
AFFIRMED.
Notes
. On July 6, 1992, a pretrial services officer tried to contact Krout to inform him that the resumption of his trial had been moved up to July 7, but was unable to reach him. The officer spoke to Krout‘s sister, who informed the officer that Krout did not know of the July 7 trial date but would appear on July 9.
On July 7, a different district court judge called the case for proceedings to resume. Krout did not appear. Krout’s attorney advised the court that he had been unable to reach his client to inform him of the July 7 date, and that Krout did not return any telephone messages left by his attorney. Because Krout was absent, the court reset the case to the original July 9 date.
. Krout also argues that the district court violated his constitutional rights, specifically his Fifth Amendment due process right and his Sixth Amendment right to confront witnesses, when it proceeded to trial without him. To the extent that Krout’s arguments have substance, they are co-existent with the validity of his waiver under
. In George, the defendant was present for jury selection, then failed to appear when trial resumed ten days later. George, 680 F.2d at 14. The defendant did, however, eventually return to court. The district court, nevertheless, had resumed its proceedings without him. The jury convicted him of the offenses with which he was charged, and on appeal he made some of the same arguments that Krout is presenting today. Id. at 14-15.
. We note that this interpretation is consistent with the Supreme Court’s reasoning in
Crosby v. United States,
- U.S. -, 113 S.Ct. 748, 122 L.Ed.2d 25 (1993), that looked to the plain language of
. In deciding whether to continue a trial in the absence of the defendant, the court “must at the time make a record inquiry to attempt to ascertain the explanation for the absence of the accused and ... balanc[e] the likelihood that the trial could soon take place with the defendant‘s presence against the undue convenience or prejudice occasioned by a slight delay or a rescheduling of the trial.”
United States v. Beltran-Nunez,
716 F.2d 287, 291 (5th Cir.1983). In the instant case, the district court postponed the trial for two days, and after the case was called a second time the court immediately conducted a