United States v. Jean CapeceUnited States v. Jean Capece
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Lumbard
Appellant, Jean Capece, was one of 15 defendants convicted of conspiracy to violate the federal narcotic laws,
I
The gravamen of the new trial motion is an attack upon the truth of certain testimony given by Joseph Basile, the chief government witness against Capece. Basile, who was named as a member of the conspiracy but not as a defendant, testified that “on a couple of occasions” he paid for narcotics by wiring money to Joe Beck, the name by which the defendant Joseph DiPalermo, convicted along with Capece, was known to him. His testimony then continues as follows:
[By Arthur H. Christy, United States Attorney] “Q. When did you wire the money to him? Do you recall? A. On the two occasions I remember wiring money to him, on one occasion he had me wire the money to Jean Capece in care of Western Union, Grand Central Station.”
* * * * * *
“Q. Well, you said a minute ago that he had you do this. Did you have a conversation with Joe Beck about it? A. Yes, I called him on the telephone and I told him that I had a thousand dollars for him and would it be all right if I would wire it to him since I didn’t want to make a trip in the area and he told me, ‘Yes, you could wire the money to Jean Capece in care of Western Union, Grand Central Station, New York City.’ ”
-X- X X * X
“Q. Do you recall when you wired the money to Jean Capece at Joe Beck’s instructions? A. I can only recall that it was the summer of 1956. I cannot place the month.”
Neither Joseph DiPalermo nor Capece took the stand at trial to deny Basile’s testimony.
On May 20, 1960 Capece’s present counsel, her second new attorney since the trial, wrote the Western Union Company in New York City stating that he represented Capece and requested that the company search their files for a money order allegedly sent in the summer of 1956. He informed Western Union that “[t]he money order was purportedly in the sum of $1,000.00 and was allegedly sent to Jean Capece, care of Western Union, Grand Central Station. The sender was allegedly one, Joseph Di-Palermo, or Joseph Basile.”
Six days later, on May 26, Western’ Union sent the following telegram in. response:
“In connection with your letter of May 20 and subsequent personal call, our auditor has searched his files from May 1, 1956 through September 1956 but cannot locate any money order for $1,000 in favor of Jean Capece New York City from Joseph DiPalermo or Joseph Basile also of New York City either paid or unpaid.”
There is nothing before us which would’ indicate the subject matter or the date of the telephone conversation referred to in the telegram.
Whatever the value of this evidence, it is clear that Capece’s counsel was remiss in not obtaining it during the trial. There was ample time to obtain the evidence during the trial. 1 And there was every reason to try to obtain more information from Basile so that his testimony could be disproved, if possible. If Capece did not receive the money order, she knew this at the time of trial.
It is difficult to imagine, moreover, that this “new” evidence would have had any
The denial of a new trial, therefore, was quite proper. United States v. Forzano, 2 Cir., 1951, 190 F.2d 687; United States v. Walker, 2 Cir., 1952, 197 F.2d 287; United States v. Costello, 2 Cir., 1958, 255 F.2d 876; United States v. Flynn, D.C.S.D.N.Y.1955, 130 F.Supp. 412; Larrison v. United States, 7 Cir., 1928, 24 F.2d 82.
II
Judge Bicks was also correct in holding that
We affirm the orders of the district court.
Notes
. Capeee’s present counsel received a reply from Western Union six days after he sent the company a letter. Obviously her trial counsel could have obtained the same evidence long before the trial closed, for Basile testified to the money order on February 20, 1959 and the taking of evidence continued until March 20.
Capece’s counsel was also remiss in failing to inquire from where Basile had wired the money and under what name he had sent it.
. Joey Beck and Johnny the Bug were the names by which Joseph DiPalermo and John DiPietro were known to Basile.
. The other testimony given by Basile against Capece is set out fully in United States v. Aviles, 274 F.2d at page 187, where we do not even mention the money order.