United States v. E. Gordon Dickie, M.D.United States v. E. Gordon Dickie, M.D.
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Schroeder
The defendant appeals from an order of the district court pursuant to
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The defendant was convicted on numerous counts involving the unlawful prescription and distribution of controlled substances, Medicaid fraud, and mail fraud. The defendant’s convictions were affirmed by this court on March 7, 1983. Subsequently the government moved the district court to correct the language contained on the defendant‘s Judgment and Commitment Order to conform to the aggregate amount of fines originally intended by the sentencing court.
The district court originally imposed fines on the defendant’s seven Medicaid
As to Counts 49 to 55 [alleging Medicaid fraud], on each of those counts, you be fined the sum of $5,000;
And in Counts 56 to 61 [mail fraud], on each of those counts, you be fined the sum of $1,000; the fines payable in 30 days.
As the transcript and subsequent filings reveal, the attorneys for both sides proceeded under the assumption that the aggregate amount of fines imposed totaled $41,000, that is, $5,000 on each of the defendant’s seven Medicaid convictions, and $1,000 on each of the defendant’s six mail fraud counts. In denying the defendant’s
The defendant’s interpretation of the Judgment and Commitment Order is that it imposes an aggregate sum of $6,000 in fines, that is, $5,000 on the Medicaid fraud counts “consecutive to” the $1,000 imposed on the mail fraud counts. The defendant contends that the Judgment and Commitment Order, so construed, contains no clerical error sufficient to invoke
STANDARD OF REVIEW
This circuit has yet to articulate the appropriate standard of review governing the grant or denial of a
Because the sentencing court is in a unique position to know the actual terms of the sentence it intended to impose, some measure of deference should be accorded a sentencing court’s personal observations on this matter. Nevertheless,
ANALYSIS
A review of the sentencing transcript reinforces the conclusion that the district court intended to impose fines “on each of [the defendant’s Medicaid fraud and mail fraud] counts.” Although the
The fact that both the court and counsel construed the oral pronouncement as imposing a separate fine on each count in all proceedings prior to the filing of the present
In conclusion, we cannot say that the district court’s finding of a clerical error in the Order of Judgment and Commitment was clearly erroneous. Accordingly, we AFFIRM.
Notes
. Of course, inadvertent judicial mistakes in imposing sentence may be subject to correction under