United States v. BurchUnited States v. Burch
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Baldock, Ebel, Murphy
Submitted on the briefs:
Steve A. Burch, pro se.
Before BALDOCK, EBEL, and MURPHY, Circuit Judges.
Defendant-appellant Steve A. Burch appeals the district court‘s denial of his application for a writ of habeas corpus, which was construed as a motion to vacate, set aside or correct his sentence pursuant to
Defendant is an enrolled member of the Southern Ute Indian Tribe. On August 4, 1993, defendant was indicted by a federal grand jury for the crime of manslaughter, in connection with the death of an infant which occurred in the Meadowbrook Trailer Park, space #39, in Ignacio, Colorado. The town of Ignacio is located entirely within the boundaries of the Southern Ute Indian Reservation. After a jury trial, defendant was convicted and sentenced to seventy-nine months’ incarceration. His conviction was affirmed by this court in United States v. Burch, No. 94-1293, 1995 WL 94653 (10th Cir. Feb. 28, 1995) (unpublished order and judgment).
In July 1997, defendant filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus, pursuant to
On appeal, defendant argues that the State had exclusive jurisdiction over the offense because it occurred in Ignacio, Colorado, and therefore the United States lacked jurisdiction to try him under the Indian Major Crimes Act. The government argues that (1) notwithstanding the provisions of Public Law 98-290, the fact that the offense was committed by an Indian in Indian country gave the United States exclusive jurisdiction pursuant to the Indian Major Crimes Act; (2) Colorado never took the steps necessary to assume jurisdiction over Indians in Indian country pursuant to
Challenges to a district court‘s subject matter jurisdiction may be raised at any time, including in a § 2255 motion for collateral review of a federal conviction. See United States v. Cuch, 79 F.3d 987, 990 (10th Cir. 1996). Subject matter may not be conferred on a federal court by stipulation, estoppel, or waiver. See Insurance Corp. of Ireland, Ltd. v. Compagnie des Bauxites de Guinee, 456 U.S. 694, 702 (1982). We review jurisdictional issues de novo. See Cuch, 79 F.3d at 990.
Criminal jurisdiction over offenses committed in Indian country,
The Indian Major Crimes Act was enacted in 1885 to establish exclusive federal jurisdiction over certain enumerated felonies committed by [a]ny Indian . . . against the person or property of another Indian or other person . . . within the Indian country.
In 1953, Congress enacted Public Law 280, ch. 505, 67 Stat. 588 (1953), which conferred upon certain states, known as the mandatory states, criminal jurisdiction over offenses committed by or against Indians in identified portions of Indian country. See
In May 1984, six weeks after the Luna decision, Congress enacted Public Law 98-290, which represented a negotiated agreement between [t]he Southern Ute Indian Tribe and the State of Colorado, together with the involved local governments. 130 Cong. Rec. 10,290 (1984). Section 5 of the law provides
The State of Colorado shall exercise criminal and civil jurisdiction within the boundaries of the town of Ignacio, Colorado, and any other municipality which may be incorporated under the laws of Colorado within the Southern Ute Indian Reservation, as if such State had assumed jurisdiction pursuant to the Act of August 15, 1953 (67 Stat. 588), as amended by the Act of April 11, 1968 (82 Stat. 79).
Pub. L. No. 98-290, § 5, 98 Stat. at 202. The question in this case, then, is whether Public Law 98-290 removed from the United States jurisdiction over Indian Major Crimes Act offenses committed in the town of Ignacio.
In construing Public Law 98-290, [o]ur task is to give effect to the will of Congress. Negonsott, 507 U.S. at 104 (quotation omitted). Based on both the language of Public Law 98-290 and its legislative history, we conclude that Congress intended to bestow upon the State of Colorado exclusive jurisdiction over the offenses described in the Indian Major Crimes Act, if committed within the boundaries of the town of Ignacio.
Public Law 98-290 provides that Colorado‘s exercise of jurisdiction should be as if the state had assumed jurisdiction pursuant to Public Law 280, as amended. Public Law 280, in turn, grants the named states exclusive jurisdiction over offenses occurring in identified portions of Indian country, expressly stating that the Indian Major Crimes Act does not apply to those areas. See Pub. L. No. 280, § 2, 67 Stat. at 589 (codified
This conclusion is buttressed by statements made both in the House and Senate Reports and in introducing the bill on the House floor. The House Report for Public Law 98-290 states
H.R. 4176 would eliminate . . . uncertainty by confirming the boundaries of the reservation and by clarifying the criminal jurisdiction of the Federal Government, the State government, and the tribe. Under the terms of the bill, the United States and the tribe would retain their existing criminal and civil jurisdiction over Indians anywhere within the boundaries of the reservation except within the limits of any municipality incorporated under the laws of the State of Colorado, in which case, the State would exercise criminal and civil jurisdiction over all persons, Indian and non-Indian, as if it had assumed such jurisdiction pursuant to the provision of Public Law 83-280.
H.R. Rep. No. 98-716, at 2 (1984) (emphasis added). The Senate Report states
Within the town of Ignacio, which lies within the reservation, the State and town shall have jurisdiction as if jurisdiction had been assumed under Public Law 83-280. Within the remainder of the reservation, the tribal and Federal law shall be applicable to Indians who are members of a federally recognized Indian tribe anywhere within the boundaries of the reservation.
S. Rep. No. 98-404, at 1 (1984) (emphasis added). In describing the bill to the House of Representatives, Congressman Young reiterated that the United States and the tribe would retain their existing criminal and civil jurisdiction over Indians anywhere within the boundaries of the reservation except within the limits of incorporated municipalities where State jurisdiction would be exercised over all parties. 130 Cong. Rec. 10,290 (1984) (emphasis added).
The Supreme Court‘s decision in Negonsott, 507 U.S. at 105, holding that the federal courts retained jurisdiction to prosecute Indians under the Indian Major Crimes Act even after criminal jurisdiction had been granted to the State of Kansas, does not require a contrary result. There, the Court was construing the effect of the Kansas Act, codified at
Further, because Congress directly granted to Colorado jurisdiction over the town of Ignacio, the State was not required to take further action to assume jurisdiction. State jurisdiction over offenses committed by or against Indians in Indian country may be obtained in one of two ways: (1) by a direct congressional grant; or (2) by a state‘s assumption of optional jurisdiction pursuant to Public Law 280. See Ross v. Neff, 905 F.2d 1349, 1352 (10th Cir. 1990).
A direct congressional grant of jurisdiction over Indian country does not require any further action to vest the state with jurisdiction unless state law itself prevents the state from exercising such jurisdiction. See, e.g., Yakima Indian Nation, 439 U.S. at 471-72 (explaining that direct jurisdictional grant to mandatory states effected an immediate cession of
Here, Colorado‘s admission into the Union invested it with criminal jurisdiction over its citizens throughout the whole of the territory within its limits, including the Ute Reservation. United States v. McBratney, 104 U.S. 621, 624 (1881). No Colorado statute or constitutional provision precludes it from exercising jurisdiction over Indians in Indian country. See, e.g., Arizona v. San Carlos Apache Tribe, 463 U.S. 545, 561-62 (1983) (noting absence of jurisdictional disclaimers in Colorado Enabling Act, in contrast to most western states). Thus, upon enactment of Public Law 98-290, Congress removed any federal bar to Colorado‘s exercise of its criminal jurisdiction over offenses committed by or against Indians within the town of Ignacio, and the State was not required to take further action to invest itself with such jurisdiction. The cases cited by the government, requiring positive state action to obtain jurisdiction over offenses committed by or against Indians in Indian country, address assumptions of optional jurisdiction under Public Law 280, and do not apply here. See United States v. Baker, 894 F.2d 1144, 1146 (10th Cir. 1990); United States v. Burnett, 777 F.2d 593, 597 (10th Cir. 1985); Luna, 683 P.2d at 364. Based on the foregoing, we conclude that when the offense underlying defendant‘s conviction occurred, the United States no longer had Indian Major Crimes Act jurisdiction over offenses committed in the town of Ignacio.
We turn, then, to the government‘s third argument in support of its jurisdiction. The government argues that the designation Ignacio, Colorado, was simply a mailing address, and that the offense actually occurred outside the boundaries of the incorporated town. In support of its argument, the government has submitted an affidavit by the Assessor of the County of La Plata certifying that the Meadowbrook Trailer Park is located outside the boundaries of the town of Ignacio, with attached photocopies of a tax record and a portion of a map. The government has asked us to take judicial notice that the offense occurred outside the boundaries of the town of Ignacio, and that, therefore, the United States had jurisdiction over the offense pursuant to the Indian Major Crimes Act.
Judicial notice may be taken at any time, including on appeal. See Mills v. Denver Tramway Corp., 155 F.2d 808, 812 (10th Cir. 1946) (holding appellate court has discretion to take judicial notice for the first time). A fact may be judicially noticed if it is not subject to reasonable dispute because it is either (1) generally known within the territorial jurisdiction of the trial court or (2) capable of accurate and ready determination by resort to sources whose accuracy cannot reasonably be questioned.
Whether an offense occurred within particular geographical boundaries is an appropriate subject for judicial notice. See Government of the Canal Zone v. Burjan, 596 F.2d 690, 693-95 (5th Cir. 1979) (taking judicial notice of government maps to determine whether charged offenses occurred within boundaries of Canal Zone); United States v. Lossiah, 537 F.2d 1250, 1251 (4th Cir. 1976) (approving trial court‘s taking of judicial notice that town was within Cherokee Indian Reservation); see also United States v. Stands, 105 F.3d 1565, 1575 (8th Cir.) ([G]iven a particular piece of land, it is for the court, not the jury, to determine whether that land is in Indian country.), cert. denied, 118 S. Ct. 120 (1997). The sources provided to the court in this case, however, do not permit us to take such notice.
Although official government maps are generally an acceptable source for taking judicial notice, see Government of the Canal Zone, 596 F.2d at 694, we have not been provided such a map. Instead, we have been provided a photocopy of a portion of a map of some place, with a handwritten identification of the place as the City of Ignacio, a hand drawn city boundary, and a handwritten notation that the subject property is outside the city limits. This is not a source whose accuracy cannot reasonably be questioned. Further, because the map, without the notations, does not show the boundaries of the town of Ignacio or the location of the Meadowbrook Trailer Park, the facts sought to be noted are not readily determinable from the map.
Moreover, given the record allegations that the offense was committed in Ignacio, Colorado, the county assessor‘s hearsay affidavit cannot be considered a source whose accuracy is beyond reasonable question. See, e.g., 21 Charles A. Wright & Kenneth W. Graham, Jr., Federal Practice and Procedure, § 5108, at 514 (1977) (noting that a person cannot be source of indisputable accuracy under Rule 201(b)(2)); Association Against Discrimination in Employment, Inc. v. City of Bridgeport, 647 F.2d 256, 277-78 (2d Cir. 1981) (holding photocopies of employment roster and affidavit explaining significance of pages were not sources of information whose accuracy could not be questioned, and could not support judicial notice of city‘s use of federal funds); Groundhog v. Keeler, 442 F.2d 674, 681 (10th Cir. 1971) (noting, in dicta, inappropriateness of taking judicial notice of affidavit contents to contradict allegations in complaint).
To determine whether the United States had jurisdiction to charge and try defendant, this case must be remanded for further proceedings. The district court is instructed to determine whether the offense for which defendant was convicted occurred inside or outside the boundaries of the town of Ignacio. If the court intends to determine this issue by judicial notice, defendant must be given an opportunity to be heard pursuant to
The government‘s motion to supplement the record is denied. The judgment of the United States District Court for the District of Colorado is VACATED, and the case is REMANDED for further proceedings.