United States v. Brian Douglas ZickertUnited States v. Brian Douglas Zickert
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Tjoflat
This is an appeal from a sentence imposed on a plea of guilty in a federal criminal drug importation case from the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida. The primary complaint of the appellant, Brian Zickert, concerns the district court’s noncompliance with
We conclude that this omission by the district court violated Zickert’s right to know the consequences of his plea. Therefore, we reverse the district court’s order denying Zickert’s motion to withdraw his plea and remand with instructions to allow him to plead anew. 1
I.
Zickert and two co-defendants were arrested in July of 1988 for attempting to smuggle cocaine into the United States. The government sought indictments in both the Southern District of Florida and the Middle District of Florida on separate offenses related to the venture.
Zickert was indicted first in the Southern District of Florida. He negotiated a plea agreement with the government, and was sentenced to a term of five years in prison. His five year sentence reflected a reduction under
Zickert was next indicted in the Middle District of Florida on a second offense related to the smuggling attempt, and entered into a second plea agreement with the government on that offense on July 11, 1989.
3
In summary, this agreement stated that the government would (1) recommend that any sentence imposed in the Middle District run concurrently with Zickert’s sentence in the Southern District; (2) furnish the court with reasons acceptable for imposing a sentence outside the Sentencing Guidelines; (3) advise the court of Zickert’s cooperation; and (4) recommend that the
The district court accepted Zickert’s guilty plea at a rearraignment hearing on July 11, 1989. The following dialogue took place at that hearing:
THE COURT: You know there have been discussions between the U.S. Attorneys and attorney for the government [sic] that have resulted in plea agreements in these cases. The plea agreement appears in the Court file. I hand it to you and ask you to examine it and to tell me whether this is the agreement into which you have entered with the government . . . [Is that the agreement into which you have entered], Mr. Zic-kert?
DEFENDANT ZICKERT: Yes, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Mr. Zickert, do you understand that those portions of the plea agreement referred to as recommendations which may be made by the United States attorney to the Court under certain conditions are strictly and purely that, recommendations. That this Court does not commit itself to follow those recommendations or agree to be bound by them in any way. You understand that?
DEFENDANT ZICKERT: Yes, Your Honor.
The district court then accepted Zickert’s guilty plea. The court never told Zickert that he would not be permitted to withdraw his plea if the government’s recommendations were not followed.
The district court accepted the plea agreement at Zickert’s sentencing hearing on March 22, 1990. The court noted that the government’s list of reasons for departing from the Sentencing Guidelines provided a sufficient factual basis for a downward departure of four levels. Based upon the revised offense level, the court imposed a sentence of fifteen years and nine months to be served concurrently with the five year sentence from the Southern District of Florida. It refused to reduce the sentence to match the reduction allowed under
Dissatisfied with the longer sentence pronounced by the Middle District of Florida, Zickert filed (1) a motion for rehearing; (2) a motion to withdraw guilty plea; and (3) a petition to vacate, set aside or correct sentence pursuant to the provisions of
II.
The parties agree the district court erred when it failed to inform Zickert, in keeping with
There are three primary objectives of
The record before us clearly indicates that the first and second purposes of
The plea agreement signed by Zickert and the government specifically states: “If the Court rejects the provisions of the agreement . . . [it] will afford the defendant an opportunity to withdraw his plea of guilty prior to sentencing.” That sentence could be read to mean that the court would have to reject the
whole
agreement before having to advise Zickert that he could not withdraw his plea. However, the sentence refers to the court’s rejection of the
provisions
of the agreement. We adopt this interpretation as being both the most logical construction and the one most compatible with the spirit of
Based upon the explicit direction contained in
Zickert had the right to know all of the direct consequences of his plea, including its permanence. We conclude that the district court’s deviation from Rule ll(e)(2)’s formal requirements deprived him of this knowledge, thereby affecting his substantial rights under
III.
The government maintains that the district court’s error is harmless under the totality of circumstances because the court specifically told Zickert that it would not be bound by the agreement. We do not agree. As we stated earlier, the plea agreement
The government also argues that the district court’s omission is harmless error because Zickert never indicated to the court prior to sentencing that he believed that he could withdraw his plea. The government relies upon United States v. Thibodeaux, 811 F.2d 847 (5th Cir.), cert. denied, Thibodeaux v. United States, 483 U.S. 1008, 107 S.Ct. 3236, 97 L.Ed.2d 741 (1987). Thibo-deaux is distinguishable from this case. In Thibodeaux, the court relied upon the record to determine that the defendant made no attempt at arraignment to indicate that he believed he would be able to withdraw his plea. However, the plea agreement in that case did not include the specific provision concerning withdrawal of the plea as did the present agreement. As previously stated, we find that the record before us provides a “realistic likelihood that [Zickert] labored under the misapprehension that his plea could be withdrawn” if the recommended sentence was not imposed. Thibodeaux, 811 F.2d at 848 (quoting United States v. de la Puente, 755 F.2d 313, 315 (3rd Cir.), cert. denied, 474 U.S. 1005, 106 S.Ct. 524, 88 L.Ed.2d 456 (1985)).
IV.
Zickert contended on brief that the district court rejected the plea agreement when it did not impose the government’s recommended sentence. If his argument were correct, then the district court would have been required to give him the opportunity to withdraw his plea under
Zickert misreads
Zickert also petitioned the district court for relief under
For the foregoing reasons, we VACATE Zickert’s sentence, REVERSE the denial of his motion to withdraw his plea, and REMAND for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.
Notes
. The rearraignment hearing at which the district court deviated from
.
. The July 11, 1989 agreement provided:
1. With regard to the above-captioned case:
(a) Defendant will enter a voluntary plea of guilty to Count Twelve of the Superseding Indictment....
******
(c) The appropriate disposition of this case is a sentence in which the sentence to be imposed in this case runs concurrent with defendant’s sentence in the Southern District of Florida....
******
(e) At the time of sentencing in the Middle District of Florida, the government . . . will file a motion which will list reasons why the Court may impose a sentence outside the range established by the applicable guidelines.
(f) If subsequent to his entry of a plea of guilty . . . the defendant cooperates truthfully, fully and completely with the government, the government shall bring the nature, extent and timing of his cooperation to the attention of the sentencing court....
(g) If the court in the Southern District of Florida reduces the defendant’s sentence pursuant toFed.R.Crim.P. 35 to a sentence of less than that imposed in the present case, the United States agrees to recommend that the court in this district reduce the defendant‘s sentence to no more than that imposed in the Southern District of Florida.
2. It is understood by the parties that the Court is neither a party to nor bound by this agreement. The Court may accept or reject the agreement . . . If the Court rejects the provisions of the agreement contained in Paragraph 1, (a)-(g), the Court will afford the defendant an opportunity to withdraw his plea of guilty prior to sentencing.
.
. Under