United States of America, Plaintiff-Appellee--Cross-Appellant v. Jack Griffin, Appeal of Merrill Moores, Cross-AppelleeUnited States of America, Plaintiff-Appellee--Cross-Appellant v. Jack Griffin, Appeal of Merrill Moores, Cross-Appellee
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Easterbrook
The foreclosure of a mortgage has produced a difficult problem in the interpretation of
I
Carmel Bank had a note for $28,000 plus $9,292 in interest arrears secured by a first mortgage on some property, and the United States had a note for $115,000 plus $15,359 interest arrears secured by a second mortgage. The annual rates of interest were 18% on Carmel Bank’s note and 10% on the government’s. The United States sought to foreclose its mortgage, and the affected parties worked out a consent decree. The owner admitted the debts and nonpayment; the United States admitted Carmel Bank’s prior interest; everyone agreed to the sale of the property to satisfy the debts, the sale to take place free of any equity of redemption. The buyer would get good title, and the United States would have a judgment against the owner for any deficiency.
It was necessary to identify the rate of interest that would apply to the debt between the date the judgment was entered and the date of the foreclosure sale (and the date the United States collected any deficiency). Under
The statute creates a potential problem for people negotiating a consent decree. Unless the negotiations conclude with startling dispatch, at least one auction of treasury bills will intervene between the beginning of the negotiations and the entry of the judgment. One expedient is to leave blanks in the decree to be filled in on the day of judgment. That happened here. The decree called for the fund generated by the sale to be disbursed as follows (after provisions for taxes and costs):
b. To the payment of $37,291.89 to Carmel Bank and Trust Company, with future interest accruing at the rate of $13.81 per day from May 1, 1983, up to the date on which the decree is entered, plus interest thereafter of —%, according to law, plus attorneys’ fees in the amount of $3,000.00;
c. To the payment of $130,358.50 to plaintiff, with future interest accruing at the rate of 10% per annum from May 1, 1983, up to the date on which the decree is entered, plus interest thereafter of_% per annum, according to law, plus costs, disbursements, and expenses.
Each paragraph set out the contractual rate Of interest ($13.81 per day on the bank’s debt is 18% per year) running from May 1 until entry of judgment, followed by a blank to be filled in “according to law.” One might suppose that the law” in question was
The decree was entered on May 25, 1983. On that date the rate of interest required by
Immediately before the sale in January 1985, Merrill Moores, an attorney, bought Carmel Bank’s interest in the judgment. Moores then purchased the property at the sale for $115,001, exactly $1 more than the United States bid. Moores paid the sum to the Marshal, but as the owner of the bank’s interest in the judgment Moores is entitled to cash back. The question is how much. The difference is substantial. The debt to the bank was $37,637 on May 25, 1983, when the judgment was entered. With interest compounded yearly at 18%, the entitlement will be worth about $58,600 by February 1, 1986, while if the rate is 8.72% the entitlement will be worth about $47,100.
The United States wants to receive as much of the $115,001 as possible, and it asked the district court to change the 18% rate in paragraph (b) to the legal rate of 8.72%. The court complied. Moores then asked the court to restore the original rate. The court reaffirmed its decision in a thoughtful opinion. The district judge agreed with Moores that the party seeking an alteration of a judgment under
II
The consent decree called for a single number, the rate “according to law”, to be inserted in each of two blanks. Different numbers ended up in these blanks — the contractual rate in one and the rate “according to law” in the other. It is therefore apparent on the face of the document that something went wrong.
1
We do not know who wrote the numbers in the blanks or when; we know only that a mistake was made. Our question is whether this blunder is best characterized as a “clerical mistake” that may be corrected under
The polar cases are clear. If the parties had actually bargained for a rate of 18%, believing it to be authorized by law, they could not use
Kenner,
which allowed a district court to establish a rate of interest several years after the entry of judgment, is close but not dispositive. In
Kenner,
as here, the judgment called for the legal rate of interest; in
Kenner
the judgment was silent on what that rate might be, while this judgment said “18%”. But the only reasons why the use of an incorrect number might matter are reliance and an actual agreement to employ the wrong number. The bank did not rely to its detriment on the error, and the consent judgment does not embody an actual agreement on anything other than the rate of interest determined “according to law.” (We address in Part III whether Moores has an independent claim of reliance.) The amendment of the judgment to replace “18%” with “8.72%” therefore carries out the principal function of
If the flaw lies in the translation of the original meaning to the judgment, then
The distinction between changes that implement the original meaning and changes that alter the original meaning to correct a legal or factual error explains the divergent cases applying
The appearance of conflict among these cases is an illusion. In
Scola
the judge had discretion over interest, so that a failure to award interest in the judgment reflected a legal and factual decision rather than an oversight. In
Hoffman
the parties agreed on an award of interest. It later turned out that their agreement was based on a mistake of law; still the judgment implemented the original meaning, so that it was necessary to seek another source of authority to correct the mistake. In
Warner
the district court awarded interest at 6%, meaning to do just this; when the court discovered that the law required the .award to be 8%, it had to search for authority outside
By contrast, in
Stovall
the judgment specified 6% interest, “the legal rate,” without stating whether interest would be compounded. The court held that
In this case the parties agreed to use the legal rate of interest and left blanks for the insertion of that rate. Correction of the judgment restores the original meaning. Whoever typed “18%” in one blank was sleepwalking. The change to the correct figure of 8.72% may unsettle expectations, but many alterations of judgments under
Ill
Moores stresses that he is a stranger to all of this. He bought the bank’s interest in the judgment, perhaps for a price that reflected an assumption that interest was running at 18% rather than 8.72%. Moores insists that the loss from the mistaken interest rate should fall on the United States, because it could have protected itself while he could not. We must decide whether Moores’ status as a purchaser of the judgment affects the operation of
The tension between the protection of expectations and the pursuit of accuracy is not unique to judgments. In commercial law parties often sell or assign interests in notes and other contracts. The venerable rule governing such transactions is that the purchaser of a negotiable instrument for value and without notice of any defect acquires the instrument free of claims and defenses that would apply to the transfer- or. See § 3-305 of the Uniform Commercial Code; Farnsworth, Contracts 783 (1982). Someone who signs a negotiable obligation knows that claims may be transferred to a holder in due course, and this prospect may influence the price. The difficulty of asserting defenses against a holder in due course may make the transaction less attractive to the maker of the note, but it also increases the liquidity of the obligation as the other party sees things, and so may lead it to offer a better deal.
Purchasers of non-negotiable obligations, by contrast, take them subject to all defenses — no matter how late these defenses may arise, and no matter how much they may unsettle expectations. The contracting parties can act with greater assurance in the sense that their original bargain will survive subsequent transfers. The obligor’s expectations are not affected by subsequent transactions it cannot control. If an event later unsettles the contract, the buyer of the contract right will not receive what it expected (the performance of the obligor) but must settle for its remedies against the party from which it acquired the rights.
This approach is imperfect, as are all rough compromises, but a court ought not invent some new accommodation when the judgment of time so strongly favors drawing a line based on negotiability. Moores therefore acquired his interest subject to every uncertainty Carmel Bank itself faced. A judgment is not a negotiable instrument within the meaning of the Uniform Commercial Code. See UCC § 3-104. We therefore treat Moores as if he were Carmel Bank, and Moores in return may have a right of action against the bank. 2
Moores might have sought a different sanctuary. A foreclosure sale is designed to settle all outstanding rights and to convey a‘clear title for a known price. A variety of legal doctrines therefore inhibit attempts to revisit events that took place before the sale. See
Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. v. Meyer,
781 F.2d 1260, 1263-66 (7th Cir. 1986). Moores did not argue in the district court that the foreclosure sale cut off the government’s right to seek relief under
IV
The error in the rate of interest was not the only mistake in this case. Although all people with interests in the real estate should be notified of foreclosure proceedings, see
The failure of notice did not affect the lien. It passed through the sale as a top priority charge against the property. But Indianapolis would prefer to collect its $5,000 from the fund in court rather than keep its lien, and Moores would prefer to take the property free of liens rather than stand second in line. The record does not reflect whether Moores knew about the Barrett Law Assessment when he bid at the sale, but shortly after the sale he notified the Comptroller of Indianapolis, who appeared and asked the court for cash from the fund. The district court granted the application, and the United States filed an appeal, arguing that Indianapolis did not formally move to intervene and anyway that the motion came too late.
The City’s motion was not styled one for intervention, but a court is entitled to disregard labels and treat pleadings for what they are. This was a request for intervention, as it could be nothing else. The request came late, and
The City acted promptly after it received notice of the foreclosure. The City’s intervention harmed the United States in the trivial sense that the Treasury is $5,000 poorer after the intervention than it was before. But the United States was supposed to notify the City back in 1983; had it done this, the City would have appeared to claim its $5,000. A belated intervention could have injured the United States only if all bidders at the sale had known about the assessment. Knowledgeable bidders would have subtracted $5,000 from their valuations, knowing that the City would own that much of the property by virtue of its lien. If the bidders had cut their price by $5,000 and the court nonetheless had paid the City from the fund, this would have transferred $5,000 from the United States to the successful bidder.
3
The United
Just as Moores must look to the bank to settle accounts that have been disturbed by the alteration of the judgment, so the United States must look to. whoever performed the title search that failed to turn up the City’s lien. Because the United States has not demonstrated prejudice, the City is entitled to its cash. The United States gets the benefit of the adjustment of interest, Moores gets clear title, and the judgment is
Affirmed
Notes
. Moores contended at oral argument that the parties may have bargained for the 18% contract rate, so that the mistake lies in the description “according to law.” But if the parties bargained for the contract rate, why did they leave a blank to be filled in later? The contract rate was known from the start. Moores also properly concedes that
. This, too, is a subject of contract. Moores may have purchased the bank’s interest without recourse. The record does not contain the contract between Moores and the bank, although Moores could have supplied that contract (and any other information he wished) with his motion to restore the 18% rate. Indeed, for all we know Moores and the bank recognized the defect in the 18% rate and contracted based on differing views of the probability that a court would change the rate. Whether they did or not, the matter is wholly between them and does not affect the rights of the United States.
. An illustration shows how. Suppose a parcel is worth $100,000, is subject to a $5,000 Barrett Law Assessment, and has a $30,000 first mortgage that will be paid from the fund created by the sale. The residual interest of the United States is worth $65,000. Bidders aware of the Barrett Law Assessment would not offer more than $95,000, because that is all the equity available for purchase. This works out all right if the Barrett Law Assessment passes through the sale: the bidder pays $95,000 for $100,000 worth of property saddled with a $5,000 lien; the first mortgagee gets $30,000; the City keeps its lien; and the United States gets $65,000. If the City intervenes after the sale, however, the United States loses and the bidder gains: the bidder pays $95,000 for clear title to property worth $100,000; the first mortgagee gets $30,-000; the City gets $5,000; and the United States realizes $60,000 on its equity of $65,000.