Union Bridge Co. v. United StatesUnion Bridge Co. v. United States
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Harlan
after making the foregoing statement, delivered.the, opinion of the court.
The ‘first principal question raised by the defendant is whether the. 18th section of the River and Harbor Act of March 3d, 1899/ is in violation of the Constitution’ of the United States as delegating legislative and judicial powers
The earliest case is that of The Brig Aurora, 7 Cranch, 382, which involved the question whether Congress could make the revival of-a law (which had ceased to be in force) depend upon the existence of certain facts to be ascertained by the President and set forth in a proclamation by him. The court said: “We can. see no sufficient reason why the-legislature should- not exercise its discretion in reviving the act of March 1st, 1809, either expressly or conditionally, .as their judgment should direct. . The 19th Section of that act, declaring that it should. Continue .in force -to a certain time, and no longer, could not restrict their power of extending its operation without limitation upon the occurrence of any subsequent combination of events.” Réferring ,to this language, we said in the subsequent case of Field v. Clark, 143 U. S. 649, 683: “This certainly is a decision that it was competent for Congress to make the revival-of an act depend fipon the proclamation of the President, showing the. ascertainment by- hito of the fact that the edicts of certain nations had been so revoked ‘or modified that they did not violate the neutral commerce.of the United States. The same principle would apply in the case of the suspension of an act upon a contingency to be ascertained by the President and made known by his Proclamation.”
In
Wayman
v.
Southard,
10 Wheat. 1, 43, 45, 46, Chief Justice Marshall delivering the unanimous judgment, of the-court, said that although Congress .could not delegate to the.-courts or to -any other ‘tribunals powers strictly, and ‘exclusively legislative, and although the-line had not beén-exactly drawn that separates the im.por.tamt subjects which must be entirely
In
Field
v.
Clark,
just cited, 143 U. S. 649, 680, 683, 691, 692, the quéstion arose as to’ the constitutionality of that section of the McKinley Tariff Act of. 1890 which provided for the imposition, in a named contingency (to be determined by the President and manifested by his proclamation), of duties upon sugar, molasses and other specified articles, which the act had placed in the free list. • By that section it was declared that “with a yiew to secúre reciprocal trade with countries producing, the following articles, and for this purpose, on and after the first day, of January, eighteen hundred and‘ninety-two, whenever, and so often as the President shall be satisfied that the government of any. country producing and exporting .sugars, molasses, coffee, tea and hides, raw-,and ‘uncured, or any of such articles, imposes duties or other en-actions. upon the agricultural’ ór other products of the United States, which in view of. the free, introduction of such sugar, molasses, coffee, tea and hides into the United States he may deem to be reciprocally unequal and’ unreasonable, he shall have the power and it shall be his duty to suspend, by proclama-, tion to that efféct, the provisions of this act relating to the free introduction of such sugar, molasses, coffee, tea and hides, the production of such country, for. such time as he shall deem just, and in such case and during such suspension-duties shall be levied; collected and paid upon sugar, molasses, coffee, tea and hides, the product of or exportation from such designated, country as follows,’ namely.” Here‘follows in the act provisions indicating the particular duties to be; collected, after the .President’s proclamation, upon sugars, molasses, coffee, tea, hides, etc. It was contended in the
Field case
that the
Touching the general‘question the court said: “That Con-’ gress cannot delegate legislative power to the President is a principle universally recognized as vital to the integrity and maintenance of the system of government ordained by the Constitution. The act of October 1, 1890, in the particular under .consideration, is not inconsistent with that principle. It does’ not, in any real sense, invest the President with the power of legislation. For the purpose of . securing reciprocal trade with countries producing and exporting sugar, molasses; coffee, tea and hides, Congress itself determined that the provisions of the act of October 1, 1890; permitting the free introduction of such articles, should be suspended as to any country producing and exporting them that Imposed exactions and duties on the agricultural and other products of the United States, which the President .deemed, that-is, which he found to- be, reciprocally unequal and unreasonable: CongréSs itself prescribed, in advance, the- duties to be levied, collected and paid, on sugar, molasses, coffee, .tea or hides, produced by or exported from such designated country, while the suspension’
The latest case bearing on the general question is Buttfield v.
Stranahan,
192 U. S. 470, 486. That case involved the” constitutionality of the act of Congress of March 2, 1897, 29 Stat. 604, c. 358, relating to the “importations of impure rind unwholesome tea.”’ The act provided for the appointment by
It would seem too clear to admit of serious doubt that the statute under which the Secretary of War proceeded is in entire harmony with the principles announced in former cases. In no substantial, just sense does it confer upon that officer as the head of an Executive Department powers strictly legislative or judicial in their nature, or which must be exclusively exercised by Congress’ or by the .courts. It has long been the policy of the Government to remove such unreasonable’ obstructions to the free navigation ’ of the waterways of the United States as were caused by bridges maintained over them. That such an object was of common interest and within the competency of Congress, under its power to regulate commerce, everyone must admit; for commerce comprehends navigation, and therefore, to free navigation from unreasonable obstructions is a legitímate exertion of that power.
Gibbons
v.
Ogden,
9 Wheat. 1, 189, 190. As appropriate to the object
To this may be added the consideration that Congress, by the act -of .1899, did not invest the Secretary of War with any power in these matters that could reasonably be characterized as arbitrary. He cannot act in reference to any’ bridge.alleged to -be an unreasonable obstruction to free navigation without first giving the parties an opportunity to be héard. He cannot require any1 bridge of that character to be altered,’ even f.or the purpose of rendering navigation through or under it’ reasonably free, easy and unobstructed, without giving previous notice to the persons or corporations owning or controlling the bridge, specifying the changes recommended-by. the Chief of Engineers, and allowing a reasonable time in which to make them; If, at the end .of ,such time, the required alterations ’ have not been made, then the Secretary is ^required to bring‘. the matter to the attention of the United States ‘District Attorney in order that criminal proceedings may be’ instituted to enforce the act of Congress. In the present case all the provisions of the statute were complied with. The parties concerned were duly notified and were fully heard. Nor is’ there any reason to say that the Secretary of War was not entirely justified, if not compelled^ by the evidence in finding
We are. of. opinion that the act . in question is> not unconstitutional as conferring upon the Secretary of War powers of such nature that they, could not be delegated to him- by Congress.
The next principal contention of1 the Bridge Company is-that the act of 1899 is unconstitutional, in that it -makes no provision, and the United States has not offered, to compensate it’ for the sum that will necessarily be expended in order .to make the alterations or changes required by the order of the Secretary of War.’ In other words, the defendant insists, that what, the. United States requires to- be done in respect^ of defendant‘s bridge is a taking of private property for public use, which the Government is forbidden by the Constitution to do without making just compensation to, or without making provision to justly compensate, the owner. Stating the question-‘in another way, the contention is, in,effect, that even.if the United States did not expressly assent to the construction of this” bridge as it is, and even if the bridge has become ah unreasonable, obstruction to the free navigation of the waterway in question-, the exertion of the power of the United States .to regulate commerce among the States is subject to the fundamental condition that it cannot require the defendant, whose bridge ‘was lawfully constructed, to make -any alterations however necessary to- .secure free ‘navigation, without paying or‘securing‘to it compensation for the‘reasonable cost of such alterations,.
,The propositions are combatted by the Government, which contends that^the alterations or changes’ required- to secure navigation against an unreasonable obstruction -is not a
taking
of private property for public use within the meaning of. the Constitution, and that the cost of ,such alterations or changes are to.be deemed incidental only to the exercise of an undoubted function of the United States, when exerting, through Congress, its power to regulate commerce among the States,
It would seem - clear ‘that this issue has likewise been determined by the principles announced in the previous cases of this court. Let us see whether such be the fact.
A leading case upon this subject is Gibson v. United States, 166 U. S. 269, 271 et seq. Congress, by the River and Harbor Acts of 1884 and 1886, 23 Stat. 133,147, 24 Stat. 316, 327, authorized and directed the improvement of the Ohio River, and made appropriations - to effect ‘that object. Under the authority of the Secretary of War, and the Engineer’ Corps of the Army, a dike was constructed in that river for the purpose of concentrating the water-flow in the main channel of the river, near Neville Island. The dike began at a certain point on the .island. Its construction substantially destroyed the landing on and in front of a farm, owned by Mrs. Gibson, on that island — preventing, during most of the year, free egress, and ingress from and to such farm to the .main or navigable channel of the river. At the time of the construction of-the dike that farm was in a high state of cultivation, well improved with a dwelling house, barn and outbuildings. It had a frontage of a thousand feet on the main navigable channel, and the owner had a landing there which was used in the shipping of products from and supplies to her farm, and was the only one from which such products and supplies could be shipped. Before the construction of the dike the farm, by reason of the use to which it was put, was worth six hundred dollars per acre. The obstruction caused by the dike reduced its value to one hundred and fifty-or, two hundred dollars per acre, resulting in damages to the owner in excess of three thousand dollars. Suit was brought against the United States in the Court of Claims to recover such damages‘.’ That court found as a conclusion of law that the owner was not entitled tó recover.
The Chief Justice of this court, delivering its unanimous judgment, said: “All navigable waters are under -the con
The
Gibson case
was referred to with approval
in Scranton
v.
Wheeler,
179 U. S. 141, 153, 162. The latter case involved the question whether the owner of land on the St. Mary’s Biver in Michigan was entitled, under the Constitution .of the United States,’ to be compensated for the .injury or damage done him, as a riparian owner, by certain work done in that river under the authority of the United States. The controlling question was whether the prohibition in the Constitution of the United States of the taking of private property for public use without just compensation has any application to the case of an owner of land bordering on a public navigable river whose access from his land to navigability is permanently lost by reason of the construction of a. pier resting on submerged lands in front of his upland, and which pier was erected by the United States for the purpose only of improving the navigation of such river. After observing that when that which is done amounts, within the meaning of the Constitution, to a taking of private property for public use, and that Congress may not, in the exercise of its power to regulate commerce, override the provision for just compensation when private property is so taken, the court entered
In
New Orleans Gas Light Co.
v.
Drainage Comm.,
197 U. S. 453, 461, 462, it appeared that, under contract with the City of New- Orleans, and at its. own- .expense, the Gas Light Company had lawfully laid its pipes at certain places in the. public ways and streets of that city. Subsequently, the Drainage Commission of‘New Orleans -adopted a pían for the drainage of the .city, which -made it necessary to change the location in’ some places of the mains , and pipes theretofore laid by the Gas Light Company. That’ company, contended that to-require such changes was-a taking of its property for public Use for. which it. was .entitléd, under the Constitution, to compensation. That view was rejected by this court. We said: “The gas company ‘did not acquire any specific location in the streets; it was content with the geñeral right to use. them,, and when it located its pipes itf was at the risk that they might be, at some’ future time, disturbed, when the State might require fer a necessary public use that changes in location be made. , •. . .The need of occupation of the
In
C., B. & Q. R. R. Co.
v.
Drainage Com’rs,
200 U. S. 561,
The latest- adjudication by -this court was in
West Chicago
Do the principles announced in the above cases require us to hold, in the present case,-that the making of the alterations of .its bridge specified’ in the order of the Secretary of War will, be a taking of the property of the- Bridge Company for public use? We- think not. Unless there be a taking, within thmeaning of- the Constitution,- no obligation arises upon .the United States to make compensation for the cost to be incurred in making such’ alterations. , The damage that will, accrue to the Bridge Company,-.as the.result of compliance
Independent of the gfounds upon which we thus place our decision, it is appropriate to observe that the conclusion reached finds Support in the charter of the Bridge Company and in the law of Pennsylvania as declared by its highest court. The charter of the company, as we. have seen, expressly warned the company that its bridge must not obstruct navigation — that is, in legal effect, navigation as it then was, or might be, at any subsequent time. In
Dugan
v.
Bridge Company,
27 Pa. St. 303, 309, 311, we have the case of a bridge company on which was conferred the franchise to erect and maintain a toll-bridge across Monongahela River,- coupled, however, with the condition that such bridge should not .be erected “in such manner as to injure, stop, or interrupt the. navigation of’ such river by boats, rafts or other vessels.” The Supreme Court .of Pennsylvania interpreted these words as méaning that “the bridge was to be so built as not to injure,stop or interrupt the navigation, either then or now, whether in its infancy or full growth.” The same general question arose in
C., B. & Q. Railway
Co. v.
Drainage Comm’rs,
above cited. This court held that the.adjudged cases “negative the
These are all the matters which require notice at our hands; and perceiving rio error” of law on the record, the judgment must be affirmed.
It is so ordered.
Mr. Justice Brewer and,Mr. Justice Peckham dissent. Mr. Justice Moody did not participate in the consideration or decision of the case.