Uken v. SloatUken v. Sloat
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Henderson
PARTIES
Appellant Leo Uken brought suit in Hyde County against eight appellees, all school patrons of the Hyde County School District, namely: Orland Sloat, Lyla Sloat, Melvin Boschee, Florence Boschee, John Ryan, Delores Ryan, Mrs. Jan Marks, and Richard Kusser.
ACTION
Appellant commenced an action seeking damages for alleged defamation by libel and slander. Appellees Melvin and Florence Boschee filed a joint motion for summary judgment and the remaining appel-lees filed a similar joint motion. Depositions were taken of all appellees and also of appellant. After receiving memorandum briefs from both parties and conducting a hearing, the trial court entered summary judgments in favor of all appellees. Appellant appeals from these judgments. We affirm.
FACTS
Appellant, who was at the time superintendent of schools for the Hyde County School District, contends he was defamed stemming from events during January of 1978. Prior to that time, a number of parents with children enrolled in the Hyde County School system had received complaints, both first and second hand, from teachers and administrators regarding, the operation of the school system and appellant’s role in that operation.
In preparation for discussing their concerns with the school board on January 9, 1978, the “committee of eight” made sufficient copies of the document to distribute to concerned parents attending the meeting, as well as members of the school board. A copy was made for appellant, who was excluded from the executive session. All ap-pellees took their copies with them after the meeting had finished and, according to ap-pellee Orland Sloat, no copies were left lying around.
Immediately after the executive session of January 9, 1978, a general discussion took place between a group of parents and teachers. The teachers were present in the school building because of their concern with the school’s operation and appellant‘s role therein. Appellee Lyla Sloat deposed that she had no recollection of any discussion with the teachers as to the specific concerns stated in the aforementioned document.
Appellant maintains that sometime during the evening, copies of the document were either shown or given to several teachers who were at the school. Also, appellant deposed that both principals of the school, along with the school business manager, received copies of the document. Appellant claims that after the school board meeting, copies of the document were left lying around the school and that he personally picked up three of the copies. The circumstances of the situation prompted appellant to believe that the document or its contents achieved widespread circulation among the public. Appellant claims that the statements in the document were false and defamatory and damaged him professionally and personally.
Appellant concedes that the documents given to the school board during the executive session were privileged. He claims, however, that the communication by appel-lees Orland and Lyla Sloat to the other appellees, the discussion held at the Sloat residence on January 8,1978, and receipt of the documents by the school principals, teachers, and business manager were publications of defamatory material which were not privileged.
ISSUE
Was the trial court’s order of summary judgment warranted under this set of facts as applied toSDCL 20-11-5 ?
DECISION
In reviewing the trial court’s order granting summary judgment, we premise our decision on the principle that affirmance of such a judgment is proper if there exists any basis which would support the trial court’s ruling. Maryland Casualty Company v. Delzer, 283 N.W.2d 244 (S.D.1979).
Second, we must determine if the communication by appellees was made with malice. If so, appellees’ qualified privilege under
We hold that appellees’ communication was between interested individuals and made without malice. It would be preposterous to foreclose parents from discussing school affairs that vitally affect the welfare of their children. Therefore, we find appel-lees’ communication privileged under
The judgments are affirmed.
All the Justices concur.