Tschetschot v. Commissioner of Internal RevenueTschetschot v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Armen
Held: W’s net gambling losses are not exempt from the limitations of
Held, further: We leave for the parties to determine as part of their computations under Rule 155, Tax Court Rules of Practice and Procedure, whether there was a substantial understatement for the taxable year in issue; if so, Ps are liable for the accuracy-related penalty.
J. Anthony Hoefer, for respondent.
MEMORANDUM FINDINGS OF FACT AND OPINION
ARMEN, Special Trial Judge: Respondent determined a deficiency in petitioners’ Federal income tax for the taxable year 2000 of $10,071, as well as an accuracy-related penalty for a substantial understatement of income tax of $2,014. The grounds for the deficiency were the limitations of
FINDINGS OF FACT
At the time the petition was filed, petitioners resided in Cedar Rapids, Iowa.
Mrs. Tschetschot is a database project engineer. She was also a professional tournament poker player in 2000.2 Mr. Tschetschot is not a professional gambler but occasionally plays slot machines and blackjack while accompanying his wife on her poker tournament trips.
Tournament poker is somewhat different from “live-action” poker. A poker tournament consists of a series of individual events hosted by a casino, and it can last anywhere from several days to 2 weeks. Unlike live-action poker, tournament participants cannot exit the game by cashing out partway through the tournament; tournaments are played until there is one player left with all of the chips.
All tournaments have a “buy-in“, or entrance fee, that is paid by the tournament participants to the tournament organizer. A portion of this amount is an administrative fee kept by the casino hosting the event, and the remainder goes directly into the prize fund “pot” that will ultimately be paid out to the
Mrs. Tschetschot claimed a net loss of $29,933 from her “professional gambler” activity in 2000 on her Schedule C, Profit or Loss From Business. Mr. Tschetschot claimed a net loss of $9,000 from his “professional gambler” activity in 2000 on his Schedule C.
Respondent determined a deficiency of $10,071 based on the view that the deductions claimed by petitioners related to their gambling activities were not appropriately Schedule C deductions, but rather deductions allowable on Schedule A, Itemized Deductions, but only to the extent of petitioners’ winnings. Respondent also determined an accuracy-related penalty under
At trial, petitioners conceded the issue as to Mr. Tschetschot but disputed the determination as to Mrs. Tschetschot. Respondent conceded Mrs. Tschetschot’s status as a professional, as well as the corresponding treatment of certain expenses related to her professional gambling activity.
OPINION
I. Tournament Poker5
Central to petitioners’ contention is the thesis that tournament poker, unlike other types of poker, is not a wagering activity.
The term “wagering” has different meanings depending on the context in which the term is used. More often than not, and as it is used in the Internal Revenue Code, the term is synonymous with “gambling“.6
When a term is not defined, we must apply the term’s “plain, obvious, and rational meaning.” Liddle v. Commissioner, 103 T.C. 285, 293 n.4 (1994), affd. 65 F.3d 329 (3d Cir. 1995); see also Boyd v. United States, 762 F.2d 1369, 1373 (9th Cir. 1985). According to the dictionary, a “wager” is defined as “something risked or staked on an uncertain event” or “a bet“. Random House College Dictionary (1968). Similarly, “to wager” is
After a careful review of the record, it is clear that while there are differences between tournament poker and other types of poker,8 none rise to the level of meaningful, substantive
A. Tournament Poker as a Sporting Event
Petitioners argue that tournament poker is conducted in much the same way as other professional sporting tournaments. Participants pay an entry fee and compete to win prizes through their good fortune and superior skill. But simply because a sport or activity is played or conducted in a tournament setting does not transform the underlying activity into something different.9
Tournament poker play, much like live-action poker, necessitates the use of the word “bet” or “wager” even to describe how the game is played. Petitioners argue that the usage of the word “bet” in this context is insignificant. The Court sees it differently.
Betting is so intrinsic to poker that it is nearly impossible to avoid using a word that implies gambling in any way
Petitioners agree that the first poker tournaments held were, in fact, “wagering events“. For example, in those early games, “Each participant put up $10,000 and received $10,000 in chips.” The fact that the chips being used to place bets in tournament poker today only bear some fractional relationship to the dollar values of the prizes and/or entry fees does not change the basic nature of the game as a wagering activity.
B. Professional Tournament Poker as a Business
Petitioners also raise an equal protection argument and argue that there is no valid reason to treat tournament poker differently, for tax purposes, from tournament golf or tennis. Petitioners argue that the benefits of being able to offset “exaggerated income” from very successful years by losses sustained in less successful years should be available to professional tournament poker players as much as they are to other professions.
Congress made a policy decision to treat businesses based on wagering activities differently. In the absence of Congressional
[A] classification that differentiates the business of gambling from other business has “a rational basis, and when subjected to judicial scrutiny, it must be presumed to rest on that basis if there is any conceivable state of facts which would support it.” * * *
Valenti v. Commissioner, supra (quoting Carmichael v. Southern Coal & Coke Co., 301 U.S. 495 (1937)).
II. Substantial Understatement of Tax
With respect to a taxpayer’s liability for any penalty,
In view of respondent’s concession that Mrs. Tschetschot’s expenses are deductible, it is unclear whether there exists a
III. Conclusion
The moral climate surrounding gambling has changed since the tax provisions concerning wagering were enacted many years ago. Not only has tournament poker become a nationally televised event, but casinos or lotteries can be found in many States. Further, the ability for the Internal Revenue Service to accurately track money being lost and won has improved, and some of the substantiation concerns, particularly for professionals, no longer exist. That said, the Tax Court is not free to rewrite the Internal Revenue Code and regulations. We are bound by the law as it currently exists, and we are without the ability to speculate on what it should be. Accordingly, we hold that tournament poker is a wagering activity subject to the limitations of
Decision will be entered
under Rule 155.