Thurman v. TafoyaThurman v. Tafoya
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Lohr
delivered the Opinion of the Court.
We granted certiorari to review the Colorado Court of Appeals’ opinion in
Thurman v. Tafoya,
878 P.2d 7 (Colo.App.1993), concluding that a promissory note held by Denis F. Thurman, the petitioner, and executed by Joseph A. Tafoya and Therese H. Tafoya, the respondents, was unenforceable due to the expiration of the applicable statute of limitations period. Thurman argued that
I.
We derive the following facts from the parties’ pleadings and briefs filed in the trial court. On March 20, 1986, Joseph A. Tafoya and Therese H. Tafoya (the Tafoyas) executed a promissory note payable to Denis F. Thurman in the amount of $22,380.00. The note was secured by a deed of trust on property owned by Therese Tafoya. The note provided for scheduled monthly payments in April and May of 1986 and specified that the entire principal and accrued interest would become due and payable on June 20, 1986. The Tafoyas have made no payments on the note and contest the validity of the note.
On September 25, 1987, Therese Tafoya filed for personal bankruptcy. 1 She remained under the protection of the bankruptcy court until April 18, 1988, a period of 204 days. Joseph Tafoya filed for personal bankruptcy on May 3, 1990. He remained under the protection of the bankruptcy court until December 17, 1990, a period of 228 days. During these periods, Thurman did not attempt to enforce his note or deed of trust. On December 30, 1992, approximately two years after Joseph Tafoya’s bankruptcy action ended, Thurman filed a complaint in Jefferson County District Court seeking to enforce the note and foreclose the deed of trust.
In response, the Tafoyas filed a motion to dismiss Thurman’s complaint.
See
C.R.C.P. 12(b)(5). They disputed the validity of the note and asserted that Thurman’s action was time-barred by the six year statute of limitations period prescribed by section 13-80-103.5, 6A C.R.S. (1987), and section 13-80-108(4), 6A C.R.S. (1987).
2
The Tafoyas ar
Thurman filed a response to the Tafoyas’ motion to dismiss. Thurman argued that pursuant to
In addition, Thurman filed a motion for partial summary judgment pursuant to C.R.C.P. 56 requesting resolution of the statute of limitations issue. In this motion, Thurman again argued that
In response to Thurman’s motion for partial summary judgment, the Tafoyas argued that
Based upon the parties’ submissions, the trial court issued its order. First, the court determined that the limitations period on Thurman’s action had run and was not tolled by the Tafoyas’ personal bankruptcy proceedings. The court reasoned that the bankruptcy proceedings had not adversely affected Thurman’s efforts to enforce his rights under the note. The fact that the Tafoyas were in bankruptcy for some portion of the six year period did not automatically toll the running of the statute of limitations. Second, the trial court rejected Thurman’s equitable estoppel claim. Accordingly, the court dismissed Thurman’s complaint and entered judgment for the Tafoyas. Thurman appealed the judgment to the Colorado Court of Appeals.
The court of appeals upheld the trial court’s ruling that Thurman was time-barred from enforcing the note. The court of appeals determined that the limitations period under section 13-80-103.5 expired six years after the note matured and was not tolled by
Thurman sought certiorari review by this court and we granted certiorari to address the following two issues:
Whether the court of appeals erred in holding that the Bankruptcy Code, and especially11 U.S.C. § 108(c) (1988), did not operate to toll [the] Colorado limitations period for the enforcement of notes set forth in section 13-80-103.5, 6A C.R.S. (1987).
Whether the court of appeals erred in affirming the trial court’s holding that defendants in an action to foreclose a deed of trust are not equitably estopped from raising the six-year limitations defense when they have, less than six years before the action was filed, demanded and received a subordination of said deed of trust, thereby specifically acknowledging the validity of their debt within the six-year limitation period.
We hold that
II.
When an individual files a bankruptcy petition,
Except as provided in section 524 of this title [11], if applicable nonbankruptcy law, an order entered in a nonbankruptcy proceeding, or an agreement fixes a period for commencing or continuing a civil action in a court other than a bankruptcy court on a claim against the debtor ... and such period has not expired before the date of the filing of the petition, then such period does not expire until the later of—
(1) the end of such period, including any suspension of such period occurring on or after the commencement of the case; or
(2) 30 days after notice of the termination or expiration of the stay ... with respect to such claim.
(Emphasis added).
Thurman argues that
To resolve this case, we must rely on well settled principles of statutory construction. The primary goal in interpreting statutes is to give effect to the intent of the legislature. To do so, courts interpret statutory terms in accordance with their plain and ordinary meaning. Bertrand v. Board of County Comm’rs, 872 P.2d 223, 228 (Colo.1994); Scoggins v. Unigard Ins. Co., 869 P.2d 202, 205 (Colo.1994). In addition, a statute should be read and considered as a whole in order to give consistent, harmonious, and sensible effect to all of its parts. McCarty v. People, 874 P.2d 394, 398 (Colo.1994); People v. Andrews, 871 P.2d 1199, 1201 (Colo.1994). If the statute is ambiguous, courts may consider prior enactments of the statute as well as the statute’s legislative history as indicative of legislative intent. General Elec. Co. v. Niemet, 866 P.2d 1361, 1364 (Colo.1994); City of Ouray v. Olin, 761 P.2d 784, 788 (Colo.1988). Moreover, courts must consider the underlying purpose or policy of the statutory enactments when determining the legislative intent. Gambler’s Express Inc. v. Public Utilities Comm’n, 868 P.2d 405, 410 (Colo.1994); Matter of Estate of Royal, 826 P.2d 1236, 1238 (Colo.1992).
By its terms,
Both the Second Circuit Court of Appeals and the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals support our conclusion that the plain language of
This interpretation of
Because we find the meaning of
Moreover, the legislative history of
The House amendment adoptssection 108(c)(1) of the Senate amendment which expressly includes any special suspensions of statutes of limitation periods on collection outside bankruptcy when assets are under the authority of a court. For example, Section 6503(b) of the Internal Revenue Code suspends collection of tax liabilities while the debtor’s assets are in the control or custody of a court, and for 6 months thereafter.
124 Cong.Rec.H. 11089 (daily ed. Sept. 28, 1978),
reprinted in
1978 U.S.C.C.A.N. 5787, 6488. This statement clearly refers to special suspension statutes of limitations that exist outside the Bankruptcy Code. It then specifically refers to section 6503(b) of the Internal Revenue Code as an example.
See supra
note 6. The statement does not indicate that
Finally, policy concerns support our interpretation of
In addition, creditors are not unduly burdened by an interpretation of
Thurman relies on two United States circuit court of appeals cases,
In re Morton,
866 F.2d 561 (2d Cir.1989),
8
and
In re Hunters Run Ltd. Partnership,
875 F.2d 1425 (9th Cir.1989), as support for his contention that
Thus, a more narrow reading of
Morton
and
Hunters Run
supports our conclusion that
In summary, we hold that
Pursuant to section 13-80-103.5, Thurman had until June 20, 1992, to enforce his note. The Tafoyas’ bankruptcy actions ended in December of 1990. The statute of limitations for enforcement of the note did not expire while the Tafoyas were under the protection of the bankruptcy court. Therefore,
III.
We now consider Thurman’s claim that the Tafoyas should be equitably estopped from raising the statute of limitations as a defense. Thurman argues that the Tafoyas acknowledged the validity of the note when they asked Thurman to subordinate his lien on Therese Tafoya’s property to the lien of another encumbrance. According to Thurman, this request equitably estops the Tafoyas from disputing the validity of the note and raising a statute of limitations defense.
Application of the doctrine of equitable estoppel may prevent the assertion of a statute of limitations defense. Klamm Shell v. Berg, 165 Colo. 540, 441 P.2d 10 (1968). To invoke the doctrine of equitable estoppel, a party who relies to his detriment on an affirmative promise must show that the promisor may have reasonably expected to induce action or forbearance of a material character. Ralston Oil and Gas Co. v. July Corp., 719 P.2d 334, 340 (Colo.App.1985); Mountain Stone Co. v. H.W. Hammond Co., 39 Colo.App. 58, 61, 564 P.2d 958, 960 (1977). Moreover, the claimant must show that reasonable reliance on these assertions discouraged the claimant from bringing suit within the applicable time period. See Strader v. Beneficial Finance Co., 191 Colo. 206, 211-12, 551 P.2d 720, 724 (1976) (where a party contributes to the running of the statute of limitations, the doctrine of equitable estoppel will prevent raising that defense). A party, however, may not rely on the mere noncommittal acts of another in order to establish equitable estoppel. Mountainwood Condominium Homeoumers Ass’n v. Cal-Colorado, 765 P.2d 1066, 1069 (Colo.App.1988) (plaintiffs reliance on non-committal acts does not establish equitable estoppel); Lee v. City and County of Denver, 29 Colo.App. 256, 261, 482 P.2d 389, 392 (1971) (plaintiff not entitled to rely on non-committal contacts with insurance company, thus, equitable es-toppel was not relevant to action).
Thurman has not presented any evidence that indicates the Tafoyas induced him to refrain from filing suit. Thurman mainly argues that the request for subordination of the lien, in and of itself, was an acknowledgment of the validity of lien. The subordination agreement, however, does not contain any express acknowledgement of the lien’s validity; nor does Thurman allege that he signed the subordination agreement in exchange for an acknowledgement of the validity of the note and deed of trust.
Moreover, the Tafoyas have presented un-eontradicted evidence that they continually have protested the validity of the promissory note. As of the date of the filing of the present action, the Tafoyas had never made a payment on the note despite the fact that the note called for monthly payments of $205.15 in April and May of 1986 and payment in full on June 30, 1986. In addition, the Tafoyas’
Thurman has not presented any evidence supporting his claim that the Tafoyas induced him to refrain from enforcing the promissory note. The subordination agreement, in and of itself, does not represent the kind of affirmative act necessary to establish a claim of equitable estoppel. Therefore, we affirm the decision of the court of appeals holding that the Tafoyas are not equitably estopped from raising the statute of limitations as a defense.
IV.
In summary, we conclude that Thurman’s action against the Tafoyas is time-barred. Under the circumstances of this case,
Notes
.
See generally
. Section 13-80-103.5 states in pertinent part:
(1) The following actions shall be commenced within six years after the cause of action accrues, and not thereafter:
(a) All actions to recover a liquidated debt or an unliquidated, determinable amount of money due to the person bringing the action, all actions for the enforcement of rights set forth in any instrument securing the payment of or evidencing any debt, and all actions of replevin to recover the possession of personal property encumbered under any instrument securing any debt;....
Under § 13-80-108(4), “[a] cause of action for debt, obligation, money owed, or performance shall be considered to accrue on the date such debt, obligation, money owed, or performance becomes due.”
.
. Thurman also argued that a statute of limitations defense is not a proper ground for a motion to dismiss; rather, the expiration of a statute of limitations period should be pled as an affirmative defense. The trial court and the court of appeals both rejected this argument. We did not grant certiorari on this issue and do not address it.
. In defining the verb “toll,” Black‘s Law Dictio-naiy states: “To suspend or stop temporarily as the statute of limitations is tolled during the defendant’s absence from the jurisdiction and during the plaintiff‘s minority.” Black’s Law Dictionary 1488 (6th ed. 1990). Thurman uses the word toll in the context of
.
The period of limitations on collection after assessment prescribed in section 6502 shall be suspended for the period the assets of the taxpayer are in the control or custody of the court in any proceeding before any court of the United States or of any State or of the District of Columbia, and for 6 months thereafter.
This provision, in conjunction with
.
The operation of any statute of limitations of the United States or of any State, affecting the debts of a bankrupt provable under this title, shall be suspended during the period from the date of the filing of the petition in bankruptcy (1) until the expiration of thirty days after the date of the entry of an order denying his discharge; or (2) if he has waived or lost his right to a discharge, then until the expiration of thirty days after the filing of such waiver or loss of such right or, in the case of a corporation, if no application for a discharge is filed within the period of six months after the adjudication, then until the expiration of thirty days after the end of such period; or (3) until thirty days after the dismissal of the bankruptcy proceedings, whichever may occur first.
(Emphasis added) (repealed by Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1978, Pub.L. No. 95-598, Title I, § 101, 92 Stat. 2682 (codified at 11 U.S.C.)).
. The holding in Morton has been limited by Aslanidis, 7 F.3d at 1073-74. In Aslanidis, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals held that Morton did not suspend the running of the statute of limitations period; rather, Morton merely found that the statute of limitations for enforcement of a judgment lien could not expire during the pendency of a bankruptcy stay. Id.
. Thurman also relies on
Garbe Iron Works, Inc. v. Priester,
99 Ill.2d 84, 75 Ill.Dec. 428, 457 N.E.2d 422 (1983), and
Major Lumber v. G & B Remodeling,
817 S.W.2d 474 (Mo.Ct.App.1991), as support for his position. In these cases, the courts held that when a party files bankruptcy, the amount of time a lien claimant has to file suit is extended by the number of days the automatic stay is in effect.
Garbe,
75 Ill.Dec. at 430, 457 N.E.2d at 424 (extending limitations period for 133 days, amount of time debtor was under protection of bankruptcy stay);
Major Lumber,
817 S.W.2d at 478 (extending six month statute of limitations for period of time debtor is under protection of bankruptcy stay). For the reasons stated above, we reject the holding in these cases and rely on the cases holding that
. Thurman does not argue that Colorado law suspends statute of limitations periods while a debtor is under bankruptcy court protection; thus,