Thompson v. . RospigliosiThompson v. . Rospigliosi
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Allen
It is further alleged in the petition:
“(6) That, owing to the large number of parties interested, and the character, condition, and location of said property, actual partition thereof cannot be had without injury to all the parties interested, and the interests of all parties require a sale of said lands, and the interests of all will be enhanced by the sale thereof.
“(7) That the Appalachian Power Company, a corporation, has offered for the tract of land and water rights described in paragraph 2 of this petition the sum of $40,000 cash, and your petitioners are advised and believe, and so allege, that the said sum is a full and fair price for the same; that the said Appalachian Power Company is ready, able, and willing to pay the said price for the said land and water rights on the delivery to it of a deed conveying a good and sufficient title in fee simple therefor.
“(8) That the owners have a prospective purchaser for the tract of land and water rights described in paragraph 3 of the petition for approximately the sum of $90,000 cash, and your petitioners are advised and believe, and so allege, that the said sum is a full and fair price for the same.”
And the petitioners pray judgment, among other things, as follows:
“(2) That, if upon investigation it shall be found by the court that the price offered by the said Appalachian Power Company for the lands and water rights described in paragraph 2 of the petition is a full and fair price, the court direct the said commissioners to sell the same to the said Appalachian Power Company for said price at private sale and execute deed therefor to said corporation upon (148) payment of said purchase money.
“(3) That if upon investigation it shall be found by the court that the price offered by such prospective customer mentioned in paragraph 8 hereof for the lands and water rights described in paragraph 3 of this petition is a full and fair price, the court direct the said commissioners to sell the same to the said purchasers for said price at private sale, and to execute a deed therefor upon payment of the said purchase price.
“(4) That the other lands be sold either at public or private sale in such manner and at such time as the court may direct.”
There are many defendants, all of whom are nonresidents, some being unknown, and some infants.
Process was served on the defendants by publication, which was complete on 23 May, 1912. Guardians ad litem were duly appointed for the parties unknown and for the infants. On 23 May, 1912, one of the guardians ad litem filed a demurrer to the petition, upon the ground that the clerk did not have jurisdiction of the matters therein alleged, and, upon the same being overruled, appealed, which appeal was heard at July Special Term of said county of Henderson. The said term convened 29 July, 1912. Prior to the meeting of the said court, the attorneys practicing therein had prepared a calendar, and
On 30 July, 1912, the Appalachian Power Company made the following offer to Justice, who had been appointed commissioner to sell, which was reported to the court, with the recommendation that it be accepted:
“The Appalachian Power Company, a corporation, hereby makes an offer of forty thousand dollars ($40,000) in cash for the tract of land and water rights described in paragraph 2 of the petition. The said Appalachian Power Company also offers ninety thousand dollars ($90,000) for the land and water rights described in paragraph 3 of the petition, the same to be paid as follows: Fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) in cash and the balance to be paid in twelve (12) months, without interest, title to be retained by the commissioner until payment in full.”
The guardians ad litem filed answers, admitting the allegations of the petition, and that the amounts offered by said power company were a fair value for the property. In addition to the personal knowledge which each of the guardians ad litem had of the value of the land and water rights and easements mentioned in the second and third paragraphs of the petition, there were at the time of filing these answers the affidavits of five persons conversant with said values, to the effect that the sums of $40,000 and $90,000 were, respectively, full and fair value for the land, water rights, and easements set forth in the second and third paragraphs of the complaint, and the court found that the guardians ad litem were entirely justified in filing answers admitting
On the afternoon of Wednesday, 31 July, a motion was made by counsel for the plaintiffs that the bids of the Appalachian Power Company be accepted, and the said motion was considered in open court, and upon considering the same and the recommendation (150) of the commissioner, together with the affidavits as to the valuations, the court found that the said offers were full and fair value, and that it was for the best interest of all concerned that the said offers should be accepted. Before accepting the same, however, the court inquired if there was any objection on the part of any one to the acceptance of said bids, and there was no objection, and thereupon the court signed the order, as appears in the record, accepting said bids, and directing the commissioner to make title upon the payment of the purchase money in accordance with said bids. Attorneys for the plaintiffs demanded that the said Appalachian Power Company immediately pay the cash payments called for in said bids, and thereupon, in accordance with the said demand, the Appalachian Power Company did on the evening of 31 July give to the commissioner drafts or checks for the amount of the bids, which said drafts or checks were paid a day or two later, and the commissioner executed and delivered to the Appalachian Power Company a deed conveying to said corporation the lands, water rights, and easements described in the second paragraph of the petition, and gave also to the said Appalachian Power Company a receipt for $15,000 cash payment for the other land.
On 6 August, 1912, H. L. Borland, purporting to be the agent of Kuhn & Kuhn, made an offer in their behalf in open court to pay $145,000 for said property, which said offer was amended on 9 August, 1912, by offering $145,000 for a good title to said property. At the same time he made the offer to pay $145,000 for a good title to said property as the agent of Kuhn & Kuhn, the said Borland filed an application in his own behalf to have the decree confirming the sale to the power company set aside, and that he be made a party, alleging that he owned an interest in said lands. The claim of the said Borland to own an interest in said lands is based on three deeds, all of which were executed to him after said July special term began, one being of date 31 July, 1912, and the consideration therefor being $100, one of date 31 July, 1912, the consideration being $1 and other valuable
E. B. Goelet, being duly sworn, says: That he is a notary public residing at Saluda, in Polk County, and that on 1 August, 1912, he was called upon by some person, whose name he does not recollect, but who, he understood, resided in New York, to go to the residence of John and Martha Paris in Henderson County, to take the acknowledgment of certain papers, but, upon arriving, that the parties declined to sign the papers; that on the next day the same person requested him to go back to the same place, and that then the said John Paris and wife, Martha Paris, and Bessie Owens, their daughter, and her husband, Andrew Owens, all signed the paper and acknowledged it before him; that the paper was an instrument quitclaiming to one Borland all their rights in said lands in Henderson County bordering on the waters of Green River and Camp Creek; that the said parties who signed the deed stated that they had no papers to show any rights in the land, but thought they had some claim through Noah R. Paris; that all of them were illiterate people, and requested affiant to sign their names to said instrument while they held the pen; that the person at whose request he went out to take the acknowledgment stated that he desired the papers for use in the court in Hendersonville, then in session; that no money was paid at all, but an agreement was entered into to the effect that, if the paper was used, some $50 or $100 was to be paid, and in the event it was not used, nothing was to be paid; that affiant met the said Martha Paris in Saluda on yesterday morning, 9th inst., and she asked him if he had seen any of the parties, and stated that she had not yet received any money for the papers. E. B. GOELET.
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this the 10th day of August, 1912. C. M. PACE, C. S.C.
(152) S. J. Justice, being duly sworn, says: That he is now, and has been for a number of years, the local agent representing the owners of what are known as the Speculation Company lands, in Henderson, Polk, and other counties, and that he has in his possession the documents and papers of said estate, extending over a long period of time; that these lands are the same ones mentioned in the complaint in this action, having been originally owned by Isaac Bronson and Goold Hoyt; that among the papers in his possession is a contract signed by William
Sworn to and subscribed before me, this 10th day of August, 1912. C. M. PACE, C. S.C.
The interest of all parties in the land who are nonresidents, and are not personally represented, does not exceed 25 per cent of the whole. Upon the hearing of said motions of said Borland, in behalf of (153) himself and Kuhn & Kuhn, counsel for plaintiffs requested the court not to set aside the sale to the Appalachian Power Company, for the reason that they considered the sale was fair and just, and that the best interests of their clients would be subserved by letting the sale stand. Counsel for the Appalachian Power Company stated to the court that the offer made by the power company would be withdrawn, unless the same was accepted at that term of the court.
After considering all these matters, it was determined by the court that, even if the court had power to set aside the sale to the Appalachian Power Company, it was for the best interests of all parties that the sale should not be set aside. After hearing the said motions, the court made and entered the two orders thereon which appear in the record, and to the denial of the said several motions, and each of
We conclude, therefore, that the section of the Revisal referred to (
We have, then, before us a proceeding properly instituted, process duly served, an offer to buy, which has been accepted and performed, a decree of confirmation of the sale, regularly entered by a court of competent jurisdiction, and a deed executed pursuant to the decree, and we are asked by one not a party to reverse the ruling of the judge of the Superior Court refusing to set aside the decree, upon the ground of an advance bid of 10 per cent. There is authority for the position that after confirmation the biddings will never be reopened, except in case of fraud (Attorney-General v. Navigation Co., 86 N.C. 412), but as the decree of confirmation and the motion to set aside were at the same term of court, and as orders and decrees are usually within the control of the court during the term, we will consider the question as if the motion to confirm and a motion to accept an advance bid of 10 per cent had been made at the same time. It is undoubtedly true that an offer to increase the bid 10 per cent is a sufficient reason for ordering a resale, and that it is usual to accept such an offer, and the refusal of the court to do so should be exercised with extreme caution and only after careful investigation; but the offer is addressed to the discretion of the court, which means, according to Chief Justice Marshall, when presiding at the trial of Aaron Burr, that it is addressed “not to the inclination of the court, but to its judgment, which is to be guided by sound legal principles.” In Trull v. Rice, 92 N.C. 572, the proceeding was for a sale of land for partition. The land was sold under an order
This case has been approved on this point in Uzzle v. Weil, 151 N.C. 132; Copping v. Manufacturing Co., 153 N.C. 330; and in Tayloe v. Carrow, 156 N.C. 8, the present Chief Justice saying in the first of those cases, which was a sale in foreclosure proceedings: “The brief of counsel for appellant is based on the ground that the court had the power to set aside the sale, and should have done so, upon the advance bid of 40 per cent. But conceding that, notwithstanding the increase in the value of land since 1895, it would have been just to the purchaser to now reopen the sale, the action of the court in refusing to do so is not reviewable. Trull v. Rice, 92 N.C. 572.” And in the second, which was a proceeding in partition: “This action of the judge in setting aside the report and ordering a sale is not reviewable unless there is an error of law committed. In Simmons v. Foscue, 81 N.C. 86, the Court said: ‘Of the force and effect of the evidence in inducing the exercise of that reasonable discretion reposed by law in the judge when called on to confirm the action of the commissioners, he alone must determine, and if no error in law was committed, we cannot reverse his decision.’ This has been cited and approved. Trull v. Rice, 92 N.C. 572.”
(157) It follows, therefore, that his Honor exercised a discretion vested in him by the law when he refused to accept the advance bid, associated as it was with other unfavorable circumstances, and
The application of Borland to be made a party was properly denied upon the facts presented, and any rights he has are preserved in the order entered.
Affirmed.