Thomas v. WorthingtonThomas v. Worthington
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Trout
This is an appeal from the district court’s denial of a Motion to Determine Judgment Unenforceable and a Motion for Ex Parte Order Quashing Immediate Income Withholding Order filed by the appellant, Robert Worthington (Robert).
I.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Kathy Worthington Thomas (Kathy) and Robert were divorced by decree of divorce entered on November 9, 1982. Robert was ordered to pay child support to Kathy for the couple’s two children. On March 21, 1988, child support payments were terminated because the children were living with their father. Despite termination of the current child support payments, Robert owed back child support which had accrued during the time period between November 9, 1982 and March 21,1988.
Kathy obtained a money judgment against Robert for child support on May 11, 1989. On July 6, 1989, the magistrate judge in the underlying divorce case entered an order fixing the principal and interest on the child support arrearages. A subsequent nunc pro tunc order entered on May 31,1996, granted Robert credit for certain payments and fixed the interest rate to accrue on the unpaid arrearages at eighteen percent per annum. Neither party appealed the magistrate’s order.
On January 13, 1995, Kathy filed a complaint alleging an unpaid principal of child support of $19,093.88 with accrued interest of $10,927.32 and requesting a judgment in that amount. Robert then challenged the manner in which interest had been calculated on the principal and whether the payments were to be applied toward interest or principal first. After a trial on the issues, the district judge held the magistrate’s ruling on the rate of interest would not be disturbed and that payments should be credited first toward interest, with any remainder credited toward the principal sum owing. The district judge then entered judgment on July 10, 1997, awarding Kathy $9,876.71 together with interest thereon at the rate of eighteen percent per annum until paid. A writ of execution was ordered to issue for execution of the judgment and on November 5, 1997, an Immediate Income Withholding Order For Child Support issued. In the interim, as of January 1997, both children had reached the age of twenty-three.
On November 14,1997, Robert filed a Motion to Determine Judgment Unenforceable asserting that
After a hearing and briefing by the parties, the district judge held that under former
II.
ANALYSIS
A. Kathy’s complaint was not an “action or proceeding” to collect child support under
The principal issue on appeal is whether a complaint filed to renew a judgment for back child support sufficiently commences an action or proceeding to collect child support arrearages under
Robert argues that under
In this case, the district judge improperly interpreted
In order to avoid the operation of the statute of limitations,
Legislative history also supports our determination that Kathy’s complaint was not an “action or proceeding” under
In sum, we hold that the district judge incorrectly interpreted
B. Because Kathy is not the prevailing party, she is not entitled to attorney fees on appeal.
Kathy argues that because Robert failed to support his minor children and because Robert consistently challenged Kathy’s attempts to enforce the judgments against Robert, she is entitled to attorney fees. Kathy asserts her right to attorney fees under I.C. § § 12-121 and 32-704.
An award of attorney fees under
Kathy also argues that she is entitled to attorney fees pursuant to
The court may from time to time after considering the financial resources of both parties and the factors set forth in section 32-705, Idaho Code, order a party to pay a reasonable amount for the cost to the other party of maintaining or defending any-proceeding under this act and for attorney’s fees____
Although a request for attorney fees and costs may be made in an original application to this Court, it is our policy to leave to the trial court “the making and enforcing of all orders necessary to provide the wife with the means of prosecuting or defending on appeal . . . and to exercise [our] original jurisdiction only upon a showing that such action is necessary to the exercise of [our] appellate jurisdiction.”
Wilson v. Wilson,
131 Idaho 533, 537, 960 P.2d 1262, 1266 (1998) (quoting
Brashear v. Brashear,
71 Idaho 158, 165, 228 P.2d 243, 247 (1951)). Accordingly, because Kathy did not seek an order from the district judge requiring Robert to pay her attorney fees on appeal, we will not award Kathy attorney fees unless such an award is necessary to the exercise of our appellate jurisdiction. In this case, Kathy has been able to defend Robert’s appeal up to this point. We thus find that an award of attorney fees on appeal is not necessary to the exercise of our appellate jurisdiction. Therefore, we will not award attorney fees to Kathy under
III.
CONCLUSION
The district court’s order denying Robert’s Motion to Determine Judgment Unenforceable and Motion for Ex Parte Order Quashing Immediate Income Withholding Order is reversed. Costs on appeal are awarded to Robert. No fees to either party on appeal.
Justices SILAK, SCHROEDER, WALTERS and KIDWELL, concur.
Notes
. In 1995, the legislature amended
We note that in making its decision, the district judge appears to have incorrectly applied the amended statute to the action. The district judge cited and relied upon the amended statute in making its decision that Kathy’s complaint tolled the statute of limitations and allowed her to then execute on her subsequent judgment. However, because the 1995 amendment did not change the portion of the statute at issue in this case, the district judge’s error does not effect the Court‘s analysis on appeal.
. The 1995 amendment added the following to the end of the statute, “[a]n action or proceeding under this section shall include, but is not limited to, execution on the judgment, order to show cause, garnishment, income withholding, income tax offset or lottery prize offset.”