Defendants Gayron M. Lytle, Gusto Records, and GML, Inc., appeal the order entered by the district court awarding Plaintiffs B.J. Thomas, Gene F. Pitney, Shirley Owens, Alston Reeves, Beverly Lee, Doris Coley Jackson, Vernon McFadden, and Hank Ballard, monetary damages in a contract action brought by Plaintiffs against Defendants for unpaid royalties following a bench trial. Plaintiffs success
The district court concluded that Plaintiffs were entitled to $1,085,325 for the foreign exploitation of their recordings. The court further found Defendants liable to Thomas for $85,848 for the domestic exploitation of one of Thomas’ albums. Defendant Lytle personally controlled the corporate defendants, GML Inc. and Gusto Records. Looking at a variety of factors, including Lytle’s improper relationship with the accountant for the corporate defendants and his use of the corporations to enter into unjustifiable financial transactions, the district court authorized Plaintiffs to pierce the corporate veil and recover from Lytle individually if they could not recover from GML and Gusto. The district court also awarded Plaintiffs $824,040.55 in attorneys’ fees and $120,965.07 in related costs and expenses.
Following a bench trial, we review the district court’s findings of fact for clear error and its conclusions of law de novo. Kline v. Tennessee Valley Auth.,
Following our extensive review of the record, all applicable law, the parties’ briefs, and oral argument by counsel, we conclude that the district court’s orders contain no reversible error as to the court’s judgment in favor of Plaintiffs.
Notes
. We recognize that a recent opinion by the New York Court of Appeals, Greenfield v. Philles Records, Inc.,
